Forums > Land Yacht Sailing Construction

Wheels for a mini

Reply
Created by kiwiboy > 9 months ago, 3 Oct 2011
kiwiboy
12 posts
3 Oct 2011 3:37PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Everyone

I am new here and shortly plan to start building a LLF Mini. I am currently doing a engineering apprenticeship in Wellington NZ, so have availability to all the steel and equipment I will need.

For the front wheel I am going to use a children's bike wheel and fork to save costs. Now for my question. I know there has been much discussion on What wheels to use for the rear but other then the ones on the original LLF mini thread not many answers. I have been given prices for 3 brands of plastic wheel, Kings, Richmond and Fallshaw. I Understand the Fallshaw wheels are very good but also a lot more expensive. Anybody used Kings or Richmonds?

Thanks
Steve

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
3 Oct 2011 7:10PM
Thumbs Up

Lets put it this way... how much is a pair of Fallshaws?

or

How much is a pair of the others (and when they don't work as well and you get dissatisfied) then buy a pair of Fallshaws?

Cheaper to do it right from the start.... I have seen it happen several times.

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
3 Oct 2011 7:56PM
Thumbs Up

Check with Hiko and Clemco, they have sourced wheels in NZ. Ive seen some richmond wheels an youd get better wheels from a tipper. often the rubbish wheels are the same price , or more expensive than the fallshaws. in fact I recall they were cheaper in NZ

cisco
QLD, 12312 posts
3 Oct 2011 11:54PM
Thumbs Up

Fallshaw for sure on the fore shore.

ADlandyachts
QLD, 62 posts
4 Oct 2011 5:43AM
Thumbs Up



I am in Hamilton. Check out the wheels on my mini. $140.00 incl gst. (set of three)
wheels, tyres, tubes and sealed bearings. (for front and rear wheels)






Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
4 Oct 2011 8:16AM
Thumbs Up

I often wonder about trying to skimp a few $ on the wheels the difference between ones that work and ones that may not, yet will spend more on the main sheet and pulley system than the wheels.

If someone was into running would they go to a forum and pose the question "Are Dunlop Volley shoes suitable for running marathons" ?.....

Is there a perception of the sport of Land Sailing that the craft are built for the lowest possible cost or built from recycled bits and perhaps not a serious sport?


Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
4 Oct 2011 10:12AM
Thumbs Up

Yeah! Gizmo, Fallshaw's may well be a Known quantity and high quality but looking at those ones I'd be willing to take the punt, They certainly look the part and I do really like the Front Rim and I doubt that it will crack up in a hurry. On Schrodinger's Cat I am currently using Cheap Chinese Junk which aren't quite round but they will do for now. I may well find out more about those wheels and bring them from K1W1 land if I can con the mate into getting them for me.
Ron

Gizmo
SA, 2865 posts
4 Oct 2011 10:31AM
Thumbs Up

My point exactly... If you hadn't used cheap Chinese wheels in the first place you wouldn't be looking for a replacement set.
Buy one good set rather than 2 sets (one bad one good)

cisco
QLD, 12312 posts
4 Oct 2011 12:46PM
Thumbs Up

ADlandyachts said...







I have one of these wheels that Paul put on the front of Nappy Rush.

If you leave it sitting in the sun too long the pressure will pop the tyre off the rim making a loud noise that will cause the dog to race for cover under the bed.

Hiko
1229 posts
4 Oct 2011 1:02PM
Thumbs Up




These are the wheels I use on my minis they were sold to me when I asked for Fallshaw wheels but they are not marked as such so not sure
They cost $56 NZ each Wheel, 2 ply ribbed tyre, tube and 2x 6204 2rs bearings
I have had no problems with them to date

kiwiboy
12 posts
4 Oct 2011 5:22PM
Thumbs Up

Hi everyone

Thanks for your reply's. ADlandyachts, what brand are your wheels? you had any problems?

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
4 Oct 2011 8:15PM
Thumbs Up

cisco said...

ADlandyachts said...







I have one of these wheels that Paul put on the front of Nappy Rush.

If you leave it sitting in the sun too long the pressure will pop the tyre off the rim making a loud noise that will cause the dog to race for cover under the bed.



yes this is the rim I trialed , the rim is not deep enough to prevent the tyre from rolling sideways, It was great as a front wheel , very light etc, but was unusable on the rear. When I tried to buy more I realized I had upset somebody as I had assumed they were a fallshaw( they had a fallshaw looking part no), but the fallshaw distributer was selling them on the side., havent seen anymore on the shelves

aus715
VIC, 58 posts
6 Oct 2011 8:49PM
Thumbs Up

Spotted this on FleaBay recently.



These look reasonable and seem to have a sealed bearing in the hub.

Bunnings also now stocks a run-flat tubeless (?) or solid tyre on its newest barrows. Not sold separately at this stage. The plastic wheel rim itself seems much larger in diameter and the tyre more 'low profile'. Still meets the same total running diameter as before though.



landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
7 Oct 2011 7:29AM
Thumbs Up

something to look out for is rimms with that domed shape in the middle. you need to stick a finger in and check if there is a separatetube passing through the centre. if not , and the rim is cheapthin construction then the whole show will warp without much load on it. given that the tyre will be really cheap 2ply . this wheel could really slow you down. how much each are they

aus715
VIC, 58 posts
7 Oct 2011 9:18PM
Thumbs Up

Hi Landyacht,

Good points. Good to be back too, reading the pages again...

$49, wheel and tyre as you see it. No compression inner tube, as you suggest. Can't see them being 'bad' but certainly better than the cheapie B' variety reds. The guy had 10. Not sure the bearings are all that 'precise' either. Rolled a few barrow wheels at B that had the same looking bearings and they were still quite grainy and noisy. Not sloppy though.

Can't help thinking that the metal wheel is so much heavier than the placcy version.

Rotating mass, inertia etc, not unimportant?

Can't seem to find the Falshaw snowflake design placcy wheels in Melbourne...frustrating.

Any ideas?

aus715
VIC, 58 posts
10 Oct 2011 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

Ta Ron!

Dandenong has to be...ooh, at least...10km from 'Blacky'.

Will give them a ring tomorrow.

(Too reliant on internet search engine inadequacies, obviously, but the important thing is that you came through for me!!!)

Thanks again.

Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
10 Oct 2011 8:52PM
Thumbs Up

Well A715, I used a search engine.. try Dogpile.com personaly I wouldn't use anything else Google and the rest are just pirates as far as I am concerned.
Ron

aus715
VIC, 58 posts
11 Oct 2011 10:25PM
Thumbs Up

The boys from 'Dandy' really came through. You can buy the rims for $20 each, separate 6024 precision bearings, the ribbed 4 ply tyres and matching high quality tubes all for around $150 for a pair, assembled by them. Pretty decent deal I think and the right setup for the job.
Should see them early next week I think. Can't wait.

sn
WA, 2775 posts
12 Oct 2011 12:43AM
Thumbs Up

aus715 said...
around $150 for a pair,


I do hope thats a typo cause that sounds a bit scary for a pair of wheels!

(especially since I read fallshaws are now selling at $36? per complete wheel- and I think that includes decent bearings too- but that might need confirming)

aus715
VIC, 58 posts
12 Oct 2011 11:26PM
Thumbs Up

Confirm then, and save me some money. I have not agreed to purchase as yet. The rib tyres were 40each with tubes, 4 ply, not 2 ply. Seems they were from a different supplier and had to bring them in.
I might just go for the chunky tyre then.

Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
13 Oct 2011 9:47PM
Thumbs Up

You guys want to keep one thing in mind when buying any product "Cheap is as Cheap Does" Right? Sure get the best deal you can on a given product but don't compare Oranges and Apples, you'll only do yourself in the eye.

I priced a 480/800 X 8 4Ply down here and they wanted $56 for it. How will it compare with an $18 Barrow wheel. Hold and Feel them both like you were examining certain items of your anatomy compare their weight and what they feel like In the case of tires I would suggest the heavier and harder would be more suitable. Not so with the other bits
Ron

sn
WA, 2775 posts
13 Oct 2011 7:13PM
Thumbs Up

AUS715..here you go,

construction section,

wheel shaft thread,

The Western Australian distributor of Fallshaw products (EASYROLL Materials Handling) posted that they have the wheels at $36.00 a piece.

It looks like I missread the bit about the bearings though.

grlynch
QLD, 208 posts
13 Oct 2011 9:33PM
Thumbs Up

Out of curiosity, has anyone tried the polyurethane solid tyres?

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
13 Oct 2011 8:33PM
Thumbs Up

aus715 said...

The boys from 'Dandy' really came through. You can buy the rims for $20 each, separate 6024 precision bearings, the ribbed 4 ply tyres and matching high quality tubes all for around $150 for a pair, assembled by them. Pretty decent deal I think and the right setup for the job.
Should see them early next week I think. Can't wait.

I think your getting either diddled or somebody is getting mixed up.
the wheels should come with the tyre /tube alreadythe tyre description is KNO
the only thing they have to change is the bearing set up from the crappy wheelbarrow bearing to the precision 6204or 6004.
this isnt supposed to affect the price.
we have been paying just over $60 with freight to kal, Easyroll came good with thier $36 offer. I dont know how you will go be interstate, but try sending a PM and find out.
$150 for a pair is a bad price

aus715
VIC, 58 posts
14 Oct 2011 11:19PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks Gents.

Don't forget this price included the Rib tyre. These don't come with the stock FS wheel. Bearing upgrade is only $7.

$20 for the red centre rim, the 4 ply rib tyre is the expensive bit at $40. Seems FS don't actually stock that tyre, they have to get it in.

I agree it is a little steep compared to what many have said they can find...but is it actually the same stuff, as Ron alludes to.

Not bought as yet though.

Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
15 Oct 2011 12:20AM
Thumbs Up

Ah Ha! Grynch,

The Wheels you are talking about would be quite a bit heavier and that would increase the Spin inertia when you get them up to speed and I should imagine slow turning ability as well. Wheels like that are also designed for low speed therefore I should imaging that Balance isn't a construction priority.

Ron

aus715
VIC, 58 posts
15 Oct 2011 7:59PM
Thumbs Up

The FS wheels with the chunky block tyre is much cheaper, of course.

So how important is the rib tyre?

Bear in mind that these wheels will end up on a bigger 'boat' down the track.

I figure I haven't spent anything yet, so the total bill so far is OK.

Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
15 Oct 2011 8:24PM
Thumbs Up

Well the Chunky will definitely pick up a bunch of soil/sand/water and fire it about to get in your eyes and hinder vision, even Rib tread will do it but not as bad. No doubt on soft surfaces Chunky will give better grip which can be a plus or minus depending on the situation. Any tires will do but some are better than others, some last longer as well depending on the Rubber Formula all depressions you have to make for yourself.
Ron

sn
WA, 2775 posts
15 Oct 2011 10:31PM
Thumbs Up

last time I bought rib tyres, they came from Mullins Wheels, around $15 or $16 each for rib tyre + tube.

its been a while since I had to buy any though- they dont wear much running on grass.

just make sure when you buy them that the tubes are the right size- 2 of mine came with 3" x 8" tubes by mistake.

stephen

Nikrum
TAS, 1972 posts
16 Oct 2011 8:42PM
Thumbs Up

Lads,
It is an idea to check out some of your Farm Machinery Shops, they may Stock a 4.80/800 x8 x 4ply that is way tougher than normal tires though quality comes at a price as well.
Ron

landyacht
WA, 5921 posts
16 Oct 2011 9:38PM
Thumbs Up

aus715 said...

Thanks Gents.

Don't forget this price included the Rib tyre. These don't come with the stock FS wheel. Bearing upgrade is only $7.

$20 for the red centre rim, the 4 ply rib tyre is the expensive bit at $40. Seems FS don't actually stock that tyre, they have to get it in.

I agree it is a little steep compared to what many have said they can find...but is it actually the same stuff, as Ron alludes to.

Not bought as yet though.



i suspect the ribbed tyre you are going to get is a great heavy, almost road tyre. the standard fallshaw KNO tyre is fine. I use them on my class5 as they are only a bit heavier than the lightweight4ply ribbed.but are taller,and take alot more wear.
see if there is a MULLINS WHEELS in Vic,. they sell a reasonably priced light 4plyfor less than $20 with a tube



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Land Yacht Sailing Construction


"Wheels for a mini" started by kiwiboy