Active Topics |  Search

Login or Register
Forums > SUP > Board Talk & Reviews > Naish Mana vs Fanatic AllWave for beginner
Author Naish Mana vs Fanatic AllWave for beginner
Page: of 1
SA
1 Posts
Posted 12/10/2011, 11:10 am        Report
I'm looking at getting a SUP to mainly ride in small waves and am looking at either a 9'5" Mana or 9'6" AllWave (or maybe wait for the Starboard 9'5" Widepoint) . I weigh about 80 kg. Has anyone tried these boards back to back?
WA
354 Posts
Site Sponsor!
Visit Website
Posted 12/10/2011, 11:34 am        Report
Hi Tooko, I haven't ridden the Mana but can tell you that the 9'6" Allwave is too big for you. The 9'6" is 174 litres volume and 32inches wide. If you have some experience you could get away with the 8'10" Allwave at 31" wide and 146 litres. Otherwise the 9'2" Allwave at 160 litres and 31.5" wide will be perfect for easy paddling and small waves. DM
NSW
201 Posts
Posted 12/10/2011, 3:10 pm        Report
tooko said...
I'm looking at getting a SUP to mainly ride in small waves and am looking at either a 9'5" Mana or 9'6" AllWave (or maybe wait for the Starboard 9'5" Widepoint) . I weigh about 80 kg. Has anyone tried these boards back to back?
Hi Tooko, i own the 10' Mana, I demoed the Allwave 9'2" on the weekend it is a very stable board. IMO as stable as the 10' Mana Im 100kg, so at your weight i wouldn't go any bigger than the 9'2" Allwave
TAS
2768 Posts
Posted 12/10/2011, 4:50 pm        Report
I have surfed the Mana - I don't think anyone has ridden the 9.5 Starboard that isn't a team rider yet, but I intend to in the near future and I have not ridden the Fanatic but know people who have, and based on what I know and have seen all three boards are too big for you (volume wise). It sounds like you are perhaps looking at these boards due to their width because you are a novice sup surfer, but even if you are you do not need anywhere near this much volume at 80kgs. In the starboard range anything from a 9 x 30 Converse to a 9.8 x 30 Element will suit you perfectly and are fantastic boards. I don't know much about Fanatics but I think there are boards from 9.2 to 10ft that will also be suitable for you. In the Naish range I don't think there are as many comfortable options as that offered by Starboard and Fanatic unless you do look at a mana, but in my opinion the starby and fanatic are much more fun boards and better performing than the mana's.
NSW
478 Posts
Posted 12/10/2011, 6:14 pm        Report
i have to agree with BB those boards are rather large volume vise for you, there good boards for what you want them for but your a little on the light size for when you get more experienced and want to use it for more than small waves, you coud easily do the 8'10 or the 9'2 allwave which would be good for surfing but also stable, even the 9'5 mana has alot of volume where you could go down to the 9 footer, if your looking for something more stable go for something with a wider roundish nose and wider tail not great for advanced surfing but good for what your looking for, try and steer away from boards like the hokua and prowave sorta boards that are for more advanced surfing and not really suited for beginners, you'll hear this from lots of people just try and demo as many different boards as you can until you find one you like, and then try and get a good deal on one or try and pick up a good second hand one if you can as it will save you a few bucks, that you can put towards your next board, trust me there will be another one Jarryd
NSW
1542 Posts
Posted 16/10/2011, 6:58 pm        Report
I'm 90kg and relatively inexperienced SUPer and I have an 8'10'' Fanatic Allwave, I find it has very good stability for my my weight. I think the width makes it easier to stay balanced. However, If you want something that paddles better in flat water and still competent in small waves then the SB lement 9' 6" is a great board.
VIC
1049 Posts
Posted 16/10/2011, 8:37 pm        Report
At your weight the 8'10" Widepoint or the Allwave would be your logical choices. The width is the critical thing for stability. Dependent on your ability you might even want to demo the 9'2" Prowave which is actually 30 inches wide and around 130 litres ( See other Allwave V Prowave thread). It really depends on your ability. Larger volume also makes a board easier to paddle in flat water for fitness but equals corkiness if you are too light. If you ride off the back foot and push hard that probably won't be a problem. Cheers Leroy
14 Posts
Posted 19/10/2011, 7:46 am        Report
That's a no brainer- Mana 9'5.
ACT
1102 Posts
Posted 19/10/2011, 11:13 am        Report
I would go the Fanatic, just cause they are cool. For a beginner go long and wide. its the same maxim as all other board sports. I still only use my 11-2 Drive I love the glide of a longer board. I have smaller but I just don't enjoy them, plus I one putting a sail on the Drive and going for a windSUP.
Western Samoa
1 Posts
Posted 19/10/2011, 3:31 pm        Report
I have lived and surfed Hawaii for 20 years, 3 years SUP experience, mostly small surf now, but did some downwind with my son on narrow tandem boards not made for SUP. I weigh 200 pounds and swam better in college than I surf but I love to surf like it is nobody's business. I own among a dozen long boards and like my 10'5" Waverider, cheap SUP, light composite built like a foam body board which I do down wind and can shred in up to 3' here on Maui. With the soft construction I never hurt my boys on it and it has blown off my SUV and hit the teen. I am currently looking for wave specific SUP, under 9'6" so I can lock it in my SUV to have with me all the time and not get ripped off. Today I picked up a Naish, Hokua 9'6" demo and caught the North shore bumping 3' after picking up the boys at school. Wind was low and the swell was from one direction but I fell in many times trying to take off though I paddled out the the break no trouble. As well I tried the Mana 9' yesterday and caught plenty 1-2'ers for a couple hours or so. Both paddle OK thru chop. They take late drops best. At 200 pounds they are both slow at 135L/140L and the 29"ish width was a challange in side chop. It was fun catching waves but I usually don't fall unless I am too far inside on a big break and just get hammered. It may be I just need to dial in the board I buy but I am still not convinced to buy. I started demoing with Naish because they offered to deduct up to $100 in demos toward a purchase of last years used demo, w/ prices of $500-700. New is twice that. I did previously demo two 9'6" Kazuma production boards with a quad fin set up. 1st tried the 30" wide and did better on the 31" but both decks were awash like my friend's 9'1"X33" custom Kazuma. I just can't catch waves trudging so slow sinking a very stable board. I may need to try the 9'6" Nalu in the morning to determine if I need more volume. The 2012 Hokua 9'6" is 150+L with a sqwash tail but Starboard has the Element 9'8', Hero 9', and wide point 8'11" 153L boards that I will have to try too. Naish Mana 9'5" is 190L but caries alot of mass for an 80KG rider. Should mention, I am of the opinion that a 2+1 fin set up with a standard center fin box could help stabilize a start up rider. I bet either Naish could use a big fin until I get dialed in. I started SUP on an old "SoftTop" 12' tandem, with long board rocker, only 26" wide. I put a big Windsurf fin on it to help stabilize it and we rode fine, even caught 3' swell on down wind regularly over 4 miles. I am looking forward to more writers coments on their experience with different brands. I will close saying that Naish has the absolute best hand-hold. I was able to pull them out of the surf from horizontal with one hand because of the curl inside. Much safer in shore break than kicking the board up on its side with a heel. Good luck with your choice. Let us know what you rent and buy!
QLD
1581 Posts
Posted 19/10/2011, 9:19 pm        Report
Minor hijack. For a beginner who is 73kg, would a Fanatic Allwave 8'10 be too big? Just want it for small waves and flat water. Probably use it to get some friends and family on the water too.
WA
354 Posts
Site Sponsor!
Visit Website
Posted 19/10/2011, 9:58 pm        Report
Hi Swoosh, The Fanatic Allwave is a great little board for surfing, no doubt, and it won't be too big for you depending upon the surf you're trying to ride. A lot of what you are asking for would depend upon the weight of the family and friends you are talking about. If they are heavier than you and have no experience, the 8'10 will be a handful in anything other than smooth flat water. Also kinda depends on the kind of waves you are looking at riding; full or hollow and how big. If you want to do a bit of flat water paddling for your fam and friends as well as some small waves, perhaps a Fanatic Fly HRS 10' or 10' 6" may be better suited. The Fly will do flat water much better than the Allwave and will still surf well in smaller waves. Just a thought! DM
WA
59 Posts
Posted 26/10/2011, 1:00 pm        Report
My experience is that the 9'2" Allwave and 9'5" Mana are near enough to the same feeling board so either of these are a great starting option. Definitely reckon the 9'6" is overkill for you. Agree with DM on the fly 10' for more glide.
QLD
69 Posts
Posted 29/10/2011, 8:56 pm        Report
I have surfed a long board for a lot of years and have paddled a 14' glide for past 18 months, decided to purchase something for surf,went with a 9'6" allwave figgerd wife could use it in flat water as well. I'm rapped with it so stabble and handles great. I'm 85kg.
VIC
1049 Posts
Posted 30/10/2011, 6:56 pm        Report
Yesterday I took the 9'6" Allwave for a surf. I mean surf. This board is like a large fish. I will ne buying ASAP. I shut up some smartarse longboarders very quickly. It was as stable as the PSH paddler and I could hot dog it at will. I wish somebody had of been filming as I reckon I could have edited out my bloopers and made myself look awfully better than I am. It has dawned on me that all surfers/suppers are different. I will bggordering the 9'2" as I'm sure it will still be more than enough volume. It's half the weight of the paddler and amazingly manouverable. When I slipped my toes on the nose and nearly did a 360 at 53 and surfing this board for the first time,well I knew that I would have to buy one. Sorry Phil but I was having such a good time at Raffs, that I missed out on the SOUL do. See you at the Bassup thing next week isnt it? My computer is not working so I am posting on the mobile. It's just that I'm so excited by the board. It might not suit everyone but in the 2 ft waves this board was mindblowing. Thanks Matt at RPS you made my weekend. Now I just have to work out how to pay for it!
United States
22 Posts
Posted 1/11/2011, 9:13 am        Report
Leroy - thanks for the review. I was debating between the Allwave, Mana and the PSH Hull Paddy. Glad to hear it is significantly lighter than the PSH. Sounds like the Allwave is a board that is beginer freindly and also suitable for the more advanced crowd. Would love to hear more feedback about the Allwave!
QLD
30 Posts
Posted 4/11/2011, 7:54 am        Report
I've had the Mana 9.5 about twelve months and have just got the Allwave 8.10 about 3 weeks ago. I'm also 80kgs. First of all you can probably forget the allwave 9.6, be too much of a barge for you. The Mana has great glide and surfs really well for its size, I think it's the plan shape and rocker. It has great stability. The Allwave is surpringly loose to surf off the tail, probably the result of the tail kick and swallow tail. It's looser than the Mana in the surf. Not as great to paddle though, still ok though, just more effort than the Mana to move along. To be expected from the increase in rocker and decrease in size. The Allwave is also really stable, not As stable as the Mana, but pretty stable. I've been paddling/surfing the Allwave for thee weeks and jumped back on the Mana and I must admit it did feel pretty big and bulky. I wouldnt go back regularly. Which is best for you? Couldn't make the call. The Mana is easier, the Allwave looser in the surf. Maybe the Allwave 9.2 could be a consideration, but that might be too big after a while. Demo, demo!
NSW
201 Posts
Posted 4/11/2011, 4:40 pm        Report
I agree with Dexy, i am 100kg's and have owned a 10 MANA for over 12 months I have demoed the 9'2"Allwave and it is very stable and surfs well, but it's not a big step from the 10 MANA IMO you would be looking for another board in a few months.
VIC
1049 Posts
Posted 5/11/2011, 8:12 pm        Report
If you are under 80 kg, there is no way you would want anything more than the 8'10" Fanatic Allwave or Starby Widepoint. You might even want to Demo the Starby 8'.5" Pocket Rocket dependant on ability. My friend Matt rides one at 95 kg, but he is a good surfer and rips in good conditions, but beware the howling crosshore. It really is does depend on your level of ability.
QLD
235 Posts
Site Sponsor!
Visit Website
Posted 9/11/2011, 10:43 am        Report
Hey Tooko If your after a board that will be mainly used for riding small waves... I'd be leaning towards the AllWave, simply because you can ride it in a few sizes smaller than most other boards due to its volume. At 80kg you wouldn't want to go any biggest than the 9'2" with 160L, it has heaps of volume. If you can stand on the 8'10" that would would be the go. Your only dropping 14L from the 9'2" to the 8'10", so not a huge difference. The Mana is also a sick board, however the all-wave with the double concave and V shaped hull is a little bit more suited to specific wave riding. The Mana would be a much better crossover board. Marcel
 
Page: of 1
Forums > SUP > Board Talk & Reviews > Naish Mana vs Fanatic AllWave for beginner
^^^ Return to top of page ^^^