Forums > Windsurfing General

Drone wanted that can film Windsurfing with Go Pro

Reply
Created by gmitton > 9 months ago, 2 Apr 2014
gmitton
SA, 1426 posts
2 Apr 2014 6:03PM
Thumbs Up

Saw this: www.harveynorman.com.au/cameras-phones-gps/cameras/action-cameras/dji-phantom-quadcopter-drone-for-gopro.html

but believe it is for low winds. Can anyone recommend anything that could be used in 30 knots with a Go Pro?

evlPanda
NSW, 9202 posts
2 Apr 2014 7:04PM
Thumbs Up

I had a friend attempt to film me sailing from a drone. Alas there wasn't enough wind, the gimbal thingy mucked up and all he got was an upside-down shot of the beach, and now he's moved to Melbourne.

Was about 15 knots and he said it was handling it easily. Mind you his is military spec. and cost about $3K. Thing'll fly itself home in an emergency.
I don't know about the Harvey Norman one. see below.

I don't know what they're using in this one, but it sure isn't 20 knots as they are claiming. Looks like 15 tops.



According to this page: http://www.dji.com/product/phantom/spec
The one you listed has a Maximum Flight Velocity of 10m/second.

That's 36km/h, or about 18 knots. With a reasonable margin of safety you'd be maxed out in 16 knots of wind.

Makes me wonder if quad-copters just aren't fast enough. Normal rc chopper can do easy 100km/h, but is a lot trickier to fly.

...one pilot for flying, one pilot for filming? It's ridiculous but a whole lot cheaper than a real helicopter.

(also rc choppers in general are dangerous - not for public beaches)

Reflex Films
WA, 1437 posts
2 Apr 2014 4:05PM
Thumbs Up

A DJI s1000 or S800 will do the trick - prepare to be shocked at the price tag though! You need a gimbal for the camera and good radio gear too.

Got 10 g spare?



jn1
2454 posts
2 Apr 2014 4:31PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
gmitton said..
Can anyone recommend anything that could be used in 30 knots with a Go Pro?

We'll have to call you "Stanley Mittonbrick" . Sounds like a great idea to film aerial video. The only thing I recommend is jumping on a UAV site and talking to operators and see what they have to say about your idea.

sailquik
VIC, 6074 posts
2 Apr 2014 7:46PM
Thumbs Up

I seem to remember some video footage take of Sail Rocket from a radio controlled model plane. I may have seen the same type of thing from Luderitz.

Found it:

SeanAUS120
QLD, 721 posts
2 Apr 2014 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
evlPanda said..





This is shot with a DJI Phantom 2 Vision. You can buy these for <$600 AUD out of Asia. Pretty cheap. You can fly them in 20 knots it's seems. Ricardo Campello has one in Maui he said he could fly in 30 knots but the footage is a bit shaky... photos work ok though at that windspeed he said.

This one looks like it has the gimble, which adds a few hundred dollars ...

I wonder if overhead 'drone' footage is going to become the new 7-minute headcam gopro videos ... fill up this forum again. haha!

Get one now before they change the laws and you aren't allowed to fly them on public land ever again.


jh2703
NSW, 1222 posts
2 Apr 2014 10:10PM
Thumbs Up

The dji phantom is good up to 15 knots but after that it fights too much and drains the battery quickly. You'll need to invest in something a bit more solid then the phantom to get good windsurf action. That said the phantom is excellent for getting scenery and lifestyle shots with smooth results, Easier then setting up dolly shots. Ricardo, Just like me has crashed his and from what I read so have most others. I don't think the transmitter they used in the phantom 1 were all that good, They are greatly affected by wi-fi signals which cause them to do funny things...Even the wi-fi from the GoPro itself can cause interference. I believe this has since been fixed with the phantom 2. Mine has crashed twice for what would appear to be no reason at all, They just fly off on occasion. It survived the first crash into the ocean but the second one was into the ground which destroyed it. Strangely though the GoPro survived both crashes even though it wasn't in a housing? I think these will be banned before long.....So I'm buying another before it happens.

Try these guys, They have ready to fly quads available if you don't want to build one yourself helipal.com

firiebob
WA, 3131 posts
2 Apr 2014 7:56PM
Thumbs Up

I believe there is a firmware up date to fix the wifi flyaways, if the DJI gets the same signal for 10sec it'll stop, wait and if same same will go into fly home mode. There is a video explaining it, I got a DJI for 500 delivered with extra battery, lots of fun, needs a gimble for GoPro and I ordered a cheapie for $80 recommended by a few forums, could be poop but I'll play with it and see but not home for another 2 weeks.

As I said lots of fun, like everything, new version is better, longer flight times etc. My flight times are ok but I never do anything sus without a fresh battery. I'm away but when I get back I'll do the firmware update and cross fingers no bugger offs

jh2703
NSW, 1222 posts
2 Apr 2014 11:33PM
Thumbs Up

Mine crashed after the firmware update....Beware!

If it's working leave it as is......My 2 cents

jh2703
NSW, 1222 posts
2 Apr 2014 11:39PM
Thumbs Up

In case you haven't seen it here's one of my first test flight with the phantom 1 & Using a gimbal and Hero3+



gmitton
SA, 1426 posts
3 Apr 2014 9:48AM
Thumbs Up

Thanks for all this advice. The Phantom 2 has a better battery, but based on the detail on this forum it sounds like it is still a major stretch. Will investigate and report back for benefit of others...

westozwind
WA, 1379 posts
3 Apr 2014 8:55AM
Thumbs Up

This is another option, but don't believe the quoted fly time. It's a bit like gear manufacturers claims for their 2014 gear that is soooo much better than the 2013 stuff.
http://www.hobbyking.com/hobbyking/store/__48164__Walkera_QR_X350_FPV_GPS_Quadcopter_w_DEVO_F7_5_8Ghz_Video_TX_and_GoPro_Adapter_Mount_Mode2_RTF_.html
Also, 15-18 knots will be tops for this unit as well.
I'm going down the build your own path. Far more frustrating, but cheaper/bigger bang for buck.
The "brain" is the key. It's allows you to move between quad, hex and octo copter configurations.
Battery's, motors, props et all are way more customisable than ready to fly.
There are open source models that do more than just return to home, but can fly a pre programmed flight path using GPS and an altimeter.
Octo's seem to be slightly better for high wind and give you a bit more fail safe.
Go the DJI or Walkera if you are not technically minded, even getting the order right for all the parts is a nightmare, and you will be ordering more stuff I guarantee.
The season is over, and autumn is a great time to learn to fly.
Don't buy from Hardly Normal. A quick search will get you a far better deal.

aus301
QLD, 2039 posts
3 Apr 2014 1:50PM
Thumbs Up

I don't know anything about these things, but I know one of the guys on the Goldy is using one of these www.quadh2o.com/

They are waterproof, so if they take a dip or land on water all good. I'm pretty sure he started with a cheaper one that went missing on a slightly windy day.

here is some footage from it...

KA360
NSW, 801 posts
3 Apr 2014 4:36PM
Thumbs Up

sboardcrazy
NSW, 7925 posts
3 Apr 2014 6:15PM
Thumbs Up

What an unreal place! Unfortunately my internet is too slow to play it without stopping regularly.

robhow2
NSW, 56 posts
3 Apr 2014 6:56PM
Thumbs Up

This professional solution may be more to your liking ? Will lift DSLR cameras for top video quality as well.

firiebob
WA, 3131 posts
3 Apr 2014 9:42PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
jh2703 said..

If it's working leave it as is......My 2 cents


Thanks, will do

Harrow
NSW, 4520 posts
6 Apr 2014 9:03AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
evlPanda said.. Normal rc chopper can do easy 100km/h, but is a lot trickier to fly.

...one pilot for flying, one pilot for filming? It's ridiculous but a whole lot cheaper than a real helicopter.

(also rc choppers in general are dangerous - not for public beaches)

You can get stabilisation systems for RC heli's that have a mode that let's you 'drive' them around like a car at a constant altitude.

But, as you say, they are dangerous, and the size you need to carry a decent camera can easily kill someone if it crashes.

SeanAUS120
QLD, 721 posts
7 Apr 2014 2:27PM
Thumbs Up

How long have we got until all drones are illegal to fly in AUS do you reckon?

www.news.com.au/national/western-australia/casa-probe-launched-after-camera-drone-knocks-down-runner/news-story/8ce201d1792d2561008d6184e0aece7e

westozwind
WA, 1379 posts
7 Apr 2014 1:04PM
Thumbs Up

Hacked...
au.news.yahoo.com/triathlete-injured-in-drone-incident-22435997.html
It's a convenient excuse...

Harrow
NSW, 4520 posts
7 Apr 2014 3:50PM
Thumbs Up


Not very long if people keep trying to pull stupid stunts like this.

Flying a remote control quadcopter over a crowded sports event is simply irresponsible and selfish. There is always a real possibility that something will go wrong, and if you are above a whole lot of people there is going to be a high chance of injurying someone.

Chris6791
WA, 3271 posts
7 Apr 2014 2:38PM
Thumbs Up

westozwind said..

Hacked...
au.news.yahoo.com/triathlete-injured-in-drone-incident-22435997.html
It's a convenient excuse...


Hacked, then says she fell over and hit her head simply because it crashed near her. Geez, man up, apologise and send her some flowers or something. Coming up with BS excuses just makes him look childish.

aus301
QLD, 2039 posts
9 Apr 2014 9:51AM
Thumbs Up


dring44
WA, 38 posts
9 Apr 2014 12:25PM
Thumbs Up

I wonder how hard they are to build yourself, I recall seeing a video on how to do it somewhere.

sideskirt
328 posts
9 Apr 2014 5:09PM
Thumbs Up

This vid from Maui is excellent.

K Dog
VIC, 1847 posts
9 Apr 2014 10:15PM
Thumbs Up

Great video aus301. Awesome viewing perspective.

KA360
NSW, 801 posts
12 Apr 2014 4:31PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
K Dog said..

Great video aus301. Awesome viewing perspective.


If you can't afford a drone ,here is an alternative viewing perspective - using a stick !

joe windsurf
1480 posts
12 Apr 2014 7:54PM
Thumbs Up

previous entry -- "This video is private"

KA360
NSW, 801 posts
12 Apr 2014 10:07PM
Thumbs Up

^^^ sorry ,now fixed.
BTW It's flow style king, Caesar Finies doing a one handed Bob.

mrrt
WA, 72 posts
5 May 2014 2:17PM
Thumbs Up

Looks like the new DJI Phantom Vision + might be the new king of affordable, user-friendly drones. The included gimbal-mounted camera makes all the difference.

With GPS and compass-based position keeping and map-based waypoint plotting using an iPad app and a built-in 3D gimbal and near-GoPro camera quality (can also attach a GoPro instead) for giving butter-smooth HD video and photography, it looks just the thing for US$1,300 complete.

www.dji.com/phantom-2-vision-plus



- built-in GPS
- automatically flys back to home position if goes out of range
- pre-plot route on a map on iPad app and it automatically flys the route by itself
- Use your iPhone, iPad or Android device to fly the copter (FPV) and control camera seeing what the camera sees
- gyro-stabilised HD camera for perfectly smooth 1080P video (near GoPro quality)
- 14 megapixel still photos
- 56 kmph speed
- 700m range (upgradeable)
- 1,000+ feet altitude
- 25 minutes flight time per battery charge
- High wind performance - good for Windsurfing footage!
- resistant to light rain
- Can be waterproofed too for those unfortunate dunkings:
www.dslrpros.com/Blog/tabid/148/post/dslrpros-watersafe-liquipel-solution/language/en-US/Default.aspx



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"Drone wanted that can film Windsurfing with Go Pro" started by gmitton