Battery's again!

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
southace
southace
SA
4803 posts
SA, 4803 posts
1 Jul 2015 8:25pm
Can someone please confirm that 200 amphr battery's will have the same lifespan as a 100 amphr battery?

I'm looking at some Cat 200 amphr battery's that have partial filled gel in them they are $980 each as to the 100amphr which are $220 each?
sirgallivant
sirgallivant
NSW
1531 posts
NSW, 1531 posts
1 Jul 2015 8:58pm
Ouch! You are going to be savaged for this!
Again.

MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2711 posts
NSW, 2711 posts
1 Jul 2015 10:12pm
I hate electrics and am no good at sorting electric string, but even so I can't see why the life of a battery would vary with its capacity.
southace
southace
SA
4803 posts
SA, 4803 posts
1 Jul 2015 9:52pm
So I should buy two 100 amphr battery's and parallel them to make 200amphr and will cost me $440 rather than the $980 for the 200 and same lifespan? It's hard to get my head around that!
LooseChange
LooseChange
NSW
2140 posts
NSW, 2140 posts
1 Jul 2015 10:26pm
MorningBird said..
I hate electrics and am no good at sorting electric string, but even so I can't see why the life of a battery would vary with its capacity.


The life of a battery can be influenced by the demands placed on it, therefore it could be argued that a lower capacity battery is working harder than one of a higher capacity.
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
1 Jul 2015 10:28pm

Maybe think along a different line. How good are the warranties on the respective batteries??
southace
southace
SA
4803 posts
SA, 4803 posts
1 Jul 2015 10:04pm
Most warranties are no more than one to two years I believe CISCO unless you can find better!
MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2711 posts
NSW, 2711 posts
1 Jul 2015 10:52pm
I bought two 105 amp hour AGM batteries in Feb 2010. They are still going strong. A 40 watt panel keeps them charged up. They don't get a hard life but have been run down below 50% on occasion.
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
1 Jul 2015 11:24pm
southace said..
Most warranties are no more than one to two years I believe CISCO unless you can find better!


Yes, that is what I am saying. Most times a more expensive so called marine battery will only have a one year warranty just the same as a cheaper truck and tractor battery.

I had Marshall (made by Exide) standard truck and tractor batteries with one year warranties in my charter yacht that were still quite healthy after five years because I looked after them well.
RiffRaff
RiffRaff
WA
265 posts
WA, 265 posts
2 Jul 2015 3:03pm
I have 3 x 120Ah batteries which run Fridge, Freezer, Auto helm, Navigation equipment etc. This is not enough to get me through a night with all running so I think I will be adding at least one more 120Ah.
If the 200Ah and the 100Ah are exactly the same spec other than capacity and if space and weight is not an issue then it is a no brainer that the 100Ah are the way to go.
UncleBob
UncleBob
NSW
1311 posts
NSW, 1311 posts
2 Jul 2015 7:33pm
I have just been through the same exersize and bought two 110 ah batteries for $370.00. Standard lead acid designed as a dual purpose cranking and deep cycle battery. Couldn't get 6 volt replacements of the same size as the old ones so went for 12 volt that are exactly the same size to fit the box.
Charriot
Charriot
QLD
880 posts
QLD, 880 posts
2 Jul 2015 8:04pm
my two cents
let me make up unprofessional guess
price is no related to quality, capacity, nothing electrical just the quantity of sales
Yara
Yara
NSW
1322 posts
NSW, 1322 posts
2 Jul 2015 8:22pm
Only problem with two smaller batteries is that for optimum life you should charge and discharge them separately. If they are in parallel then one is always trying to charge the other. This is nature, one leg is always shorter, one breast....
Charriot
Charriot
QLD
880 posts
QLD, 880 posts
2 Jul 2015 10:07pm
not true
very good to charge them parallel
even better discharged parallel
when there is No charge or discharge ....disconnect parallel
scruzin
scruzin
SA
564 posts
SA, 564 posts
4 Jul 2015 10:38am
Parallel charging is advisable only when the batteries are all the same type, since charging characteristics varies by battery type and mixing battery types can result in undercharging or overcharging. In my case, I went with identical dual-purpose batteries for house and starter batteries so all can be charged simultaneously. Dual-purpose batteries also have the advantage of tolerating deep discharges that would wreck most pure starter batteries, and (I'm told) typically last longer as a result.
Charriot
Charriot
QLD
880 posts
QLD, 880 posts
4 Jul 2015 8:42pm


Yes there is no limitation charging batteries parallel, as long as they all have the same chemistry.
unequal capacity or the same capacity with unequal discharge ...does not matter at all

they all have the same voltage but different rate of charging,
smaller or less discharge batterys are top up faster and all available current goes larger bat.

They nicely equalise, because they both on equal voltage...there is no flow between them.
On discharge ....the same process.

Problem with losing the capacity starts, when all is switched off, but bat. are still interconnected.
..it is quite simple....isn't it.....

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply