RRS

8 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
EC31
EC31
NSW
490 posts
NSW, 490 posts
20 Jun 2017 6:00pm
A topic for racing folk.
On Friday, I had the situation of running downwind off the start line on starboard, with another boat to leeward, overlapped and close enough to enjoy some banter. As we approached a line of moored boats (obstruction), I made mention of my need to gybe to avoid the obstruction, he agreed and gybed and so did I. All as per the rules.

After the race, we had a rules quiz. And they did almost the same as my scenario above. Except they changed the windward boat to be on port. Picture below. Does a port tacker enjoy the same rights as a starboard tacker when it comes to a 'continuing' obstruction?


Jode5
Jode5
QLD
853 posts
QLD, 853 posts
20 Jun 2017 6:22pm
Yes he is entitled to water.
FreeRadical
FreeRadical
WA
855 posts
WA, 855 posts
20 Jun 2017 4:39pm
You can't just barge in though:

19.2

(c) While boats are passing a continuing obstruction, if a boat that was clear astern and required to keep clear becomes overlapped between the other boat and the obstruction and, at the moment the overlap begins, there is not room for her to pass between them, she is not entitled to room under rule 19.2(b). While the boats remain overlapped, she shall keep clear and rules 10 and 11 do not apply.
EC31
EC31
NSW
490 posts
NSW, 490 posts
20 Jun 2017 7:18pm
Does the rule change if both are close hauled to windward, one on port is skirting obstruction (the wind is coming from obstruction side) and starboard tacker is coming towards boats?
Rule 20.1 seems to suggest that port tacker can only hail if both are on the same tack.
FreeRadical
FreeRadical
WA
855 posts
WA, 855 posts
20 Jun 2017 5:23pm
That would just be normal port-starboard rule. The guy on port would need to bear away.
rumblefish
rumblefish
TAS
824 posts
TAS, 824 posts
21 Jun 2017 9:23am
It also depends on the situations.
In the pic above you could argue that the port tacker could of seen the obstruction a long way off and had opportunity to head up and take the stern of the stb tacker.
Jode5
Jode5
QLD
853 posts
QLD, 853 posts
21 Jun 2017 7:35pm
I think you will find that no boat that has right of way can force another boat into peril. Remember col regs also come into play here, a car can not run another car off the road and neither can a boat. If there is an accident the insurance company will look at col regs before racing rules. You must give the boat water. If you think the boat had an opportunity to avoid the obstruction or obstructed you, it is up to you to protest not force an accident. Under the rules all boats are to avoid a collision. I have been racing and CRO for many regattas for many years and I am sure if I sat down with the rule book long enough I would come up with all the rules that relate.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply