If you are even thinking about an Allwave, check this thread out:
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Stand-Up-Paddle/Review/allwave-96-or-92/?SearchTerms=allwaveAnd make sure you watch Paul's video on the 8'10.
I think you would like the 9'2 for stability, especially coming down from a bigger board. i saw a relatively inexperienced guy out in slight chop the other day, doing everything wrong - but not falling off much. And it seemed to paddle quite fast for its shape. They look a bit corky to me - but you may not mind that - and they look really loose. Seems like a high percentage of the guys who get an allwave seem to come on here and post how happy they are.
I'm on a Hokua 9'5 and loving it. It's loose enough for me (86kg and an experienced surfer). But I can see the appeal of the fanatic boards.
Good luck!