Desal Plant Marcoola -Protest Against the Vandals

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Hivolts
Hivolts
QLD
3 posts
QLD, 3 posts
19 Jan 2010 9:17pm
Back in November Captain Bigh decided that a desla plant would be built at Marcoola . Communities against desalanation an be found at the web site below .

A few of you raised concerns about this Desal plant .

Keep in mind Desal plants use enormous amounts of energy to produce fresh water. The Salt resdue must go some where and the no Brainers have decide out to sea it must go .Good Bye to the marine world as we know it. Good bye to beautiful beaches . Hello to Dumb Politicians

Captain Bligh then plans to Pump the water to Bne and as we sailors know water is very heavy so she is going to use more power . She wants to destroy national parks by cutting Pipe lines through the forest .

http://cadi.org.au/

We need your support to stop this nonsence which has been largely bought about by poor planning and project deferral .

If you could hit web site and down load a form and scan back to cadi , all of us sea lovers will thank you.

Fair winds Hivolts
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
19 Jan 2010 7:54pm
How to speed up the demise of the planet, (1) set up a desal plant.

Oh thats it, by by.

How many of these things already exist?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
19 Jan 2010 9:23pm
We've got one here, and it's supposed to be wind farm powered. A 2nd is in the pipeline.
pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
19 Jan 2010 10:23pm
Almost all your fresh water presently comes from a large desalination plant.
It is very inefficient.
Most of the water it produces is never used for anything to benefit anyone or anything.
Almost all the salt from this desal plant is just dumped into the sea.
The rest of it is dumped over the countryside salting up the land.
It's powered by a nuclear reactor.

It's been happening for millions of years and no one is doing anything about it.

Seriously now,
I think desal plants are the only real answer to our water problem.
I also think that they are about the only worthwhile use for wind farm energy simply because the end product, i.e water, can be effectively and cheaply stored for use for a long time after the wind stops blowing.
An excellent example of this is the wind powered desal plant at Coral Bay in Nth West WA.
When the wind blows we get power to run the town. Whatever is left over runs the desal plant. The water is stored in big concrete storage tanks.
When the wind stops blowing the water is still available. There appears to be enough storage for about 3 months or more. Certainly enough to last until the wind blows again.

It's probably one of the very few uses where wind power makes sense.

The other power source that would make it an excellent option is nuclear fusion.
Unfortunately we don't have any due to short sighted decisions taken over the last 40 years.
Hopefully it will come one day.
In the meantime we could make do with nuclear fission reactors. Not perfect but far better than burning oil, coal, anything at all really.

My advice is, don't protest.
You are just choking off the best long term option for guaranteed water security.




elmo
elmo
WA
8894 posts
WA, 8894 posts
19 Jan 2010 11:06pm
Desal or recycled water
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
20 Jan 2010 12:04am
pweedas said...

The other power source that would make it an excellent option is nuclear fusion.
Unfortunately we don't have any due to short sighted decisions taken over the last 40 years.
Hopefully it will come one day.



Pweedas ftw!

Fusion is the answer to all our energy needs... once we have that then we can get a hydrogen economy going, bye bye greenhouse gases.

As for saline solution being a problem in the ocean... where do you think that the fresh water we've desalinated ends up? Back in the ocean of course, diluting the saline solution back to where it was before. There's no way humans could possibly affect the salinity of the ocean, even if they tried. Really hard. On a global scale, this is, wait for it, a drop in the ocean BOOM BOOM!
j murray
j murray
SA
947 posts
SA, 947 posts
20 Jan 2010 9:19am
I tend to favor Pweedas .......but i;m sitting on the fence

Paradox
Paradox
QLD
1326 posts
QLD, 1326 posts
20 Jan 2010 10:40am
Hivolts said...



.....The Salt resdue must go some where and the no Brainers have decide out to sea it must go .Good Bye to the marine world as we know it. Good bye to beautiful beaches . Hello to Dumb Politicians



This is one of the key arguments against it? Or maybe just a badly thought out pitch to try to get members of a water sports forum to jump on your bandwagon? Do you really believe that putting the salt back in the ocean will do anything? By that argument you could suggest that heavy rain over the ocean will kill our saline reliant marine life! fortunately most seabreeze members are a bit more informed than your average "Dumb Politician" ......or environmental activist it seems!

I still can't work out the impact on beautiful beaches either...maybe some localised disruption when they bury the pipes, but that would be short lived.

Never let minor annoyances like reality and facts stand in a way of a good drum beating though.....

The only issue I have with desal plants is the amount of power they draw and therefore how much the water is going to cost - bring on the nuke plants Pweedas and Nebs, I agree they are the only long term sustainable option and there is too much missinformation and emotion surrounding them - generally stirred up by ill informed drum beating.....

shark
shark
WA
361 posts
WA, 361 posts
20 Jan 2010 11:05am
only alternative is recycling water but-you guys over there already canned that idea. Even though it happens all over europe etc, people in Oz are too precious to consider it.

Headlines-"sewage to be pumped through your taps!" eeewww we dont want that. Lets protest everything. Desal plants do use a lot of energy-but many people cant get their head around the fact that pumping water long distances such as Ord to Perth takes MORE energy than to desalinate it.

PWEEDAS, CB is a great example, do you live up there?
raynef2005
raynef2005
QLD
161 posts
QLD, 161 posts
20 Jan 2010 2:58pm
Hivolts said...

Back in November Captain Bigh decided that a desla plant would be built at Marcoola . Communities against desalanation an be found at the web site below .

A few of you raised concerns about this Desal plant .

Keep in mind Desal plants use enormous amounts of energy to produce fresh water. The Salt resdue must go some where and the no Brainers have decide out to sea it must go .Good Bye to the marine world as we know it. Good bye to beautiful beaches . Hello to Dumb Politicians

Captain Bligh then plans to Pump the water to Bne and as we sailors know water is very heavy so she is going to use more power . She wants to destroy national parks by cutting Pipe lines through the forest .

http://cadi.org.au/

We need your support to stop this nonsence which has been largely bought about by poor planning and project deferral .

If you could hit web site and down load a form and scan back to cadi , all of us sea lovers will thank you.

Fair winds Hivolts


Yeah and the reason these desal plants are going ahead is because that dam that SEQ much needed and that Bligh was in great support of was barred. (It was going to inconvenience a few hundred locals.)
Knight Kiter
Knight Kiter
19 posts
19 posts
20 Jan 2010 1:07pm
Hivolts said...


Keep in mind Desal plants use enormous amounts of energy to produce fresh water. The Salt resdue must go some where and the no Brainers have decide out to sea it must go .Good Bye to the marine world as we know it. Good bye to beautiful beaches . Hello to Dumb Politicians


salt in the ocean?!?! stop this madness now.

moran.
pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
20 Jan 2010 1:19pm
shark said...

PWEEDAS, CB is a great example, do you live up there?


No.
But it is on my annual pilgrimage route up north each winter.
I always stop in there for a few days on the way up and back again.

Up until two years ago, the only water available for anything except drinking was salty artesian water.
Fresh water was in short supply.
If you filled up your water bottles at the caravan parks without paying you were charged with theft. There were signs up to warn you.

What ammounts to three large fans stuck up on a hill outside the townsite supply power and heaps of fresh water for all.
Backup power is still by diesel generators which is not good but it is the standard option for small towns in Noth West WA.

pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
20 Jan 2010 1:21pm
j murray said...

I tend to favor Pweedas .......but i;m sitting on the fence




Old chinese saying;
"Man who sit on fence get hit by traffic going both ways."

{edit} Hang on. On consulting an old chinese person, saying is;
"Man who sit on fence get splinters in bum."

Hmm,.. Neither sound very attractive.
ginger pom
ginger pom
VIC
1746 posts
VIC, 1746 posts
20 Jan 2010 7:57pm
elmo said...

Desal or recycled water


yes, in the UK they solved the problem with desal
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
20 Jan 2010 7:00pm
Nuclear fusion has been just 20 years away for the past 60 years.
I wouldn't count on it.
Maybe we should get FlySurfer to stop tinkering with that time machine and get him on to cold fusion
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
20 Jan 2010 5:18pm
NotWal said...

Nuclear fusion has been just 20 years away for the past 60 years.
I wouldn't count on it.
Maybe we should get FlySurfer to stop tinkering with that time machine and get him on to cold fusion


I think he is finished and onto a methlab, cold fusion wasnt making enough money
busterwa
busterwa
3782 posts
3782 posts
21 Jan 2010 12:51pm
A desalination plant is the way to go.
People must understand that we cant keep on pulling water out the ground and dropping the water table.
This has been prevalent in my area lately.
What we are seeing because of the lower water table levels the natural bush slowly dying back. The bush land is not as green as it used to be.All the trees which have tapped into the watertabble are no longer getting water.
If the water table drops we effectively cut water to all the native bush land and it will eventually die.
The government is aware of this and that's why they have started to look at desalination.
If we look at the bigger picture on desal plants we would understand that they are one of the best options for water refinement.
Unfortunately if it is an expensive process the cost will be past up amongst the consumer.
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
21 Jan 2010 4:19pm
Lowering of the water table is not a problem on the east coast. The main issue is its basically impossible to build new dams for metropolitan water supplies but the population keeps increasing. Coupled to that is the illogical way in which water is sold in Sydney at least. My water bill normally comes out at $125 a quarter. Thats $120 connection fee and $5 for the water.

We would actually try and save water if we had a lower connection fee and reasonable charge for water use. This pricing system is not promoting conservation of water.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply