Helium inflation

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
27 Dec 2009 11:41pm
Help me solve a query. If you fill a rigid non expandable vessel with helium instead of air, at what pressure does it begin to lose buoyancy?
swoosh
swoosh
QLD
1929 posts
QLD, 1929 posts
27 Dec 2009 10:59pm
around 7x atmospheric.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
28 Dec 2009 12:22am
Thanks, and a pressure gauge would read?
swoosh
swoosh
QLD
1929 posts
QLD, 1929 posts
27 Dec 2009 11:29pm
gauge pressure would be 620kPa / 90psi
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
27 Dec 2009 9:43pm
Thinking about filling up your kite?
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
28 Dec 2009 1:29am
Thanks a stack.

No we were discussing surfboard and board design. I bought some wood strip kayak plans from laughing loon and was discussing making a surfboard first as the kayak is a pretty big job and I do not want to cock it up. Thy look really great and can buy them off the shelf for around $8k the plans cost me about $300 bucks. The secret is in the finishing and fibreglassing and I want something to practice on before I bite the bullet.

Wooden surfboards built on the same lines look great but they give away weight. If you used the same principles but used aircraft ply you would achieve the same strength. Because the ply is glassed on both sides it forms a very rigid board. That was when we got around to talking about pressurizing it, which you could do quite easily. It would be as tight as a drum and in comparison to a filled board almost indestructible. It would need varnishing once a year to avoid bleaching the veneers because fiberglass is not uv resistant.

Then someone mentioned helium!

NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
28 Dec 2009 1:23am
So you want to inflate it with helium to give it structural strength and stiffness?
Hydrogen is much lighter.
shark
shark
WA
361 posts
WA, 361 posts
29 Dec 2009 11:04am
Japie-its a good theorie but but slightly flawed, depending on your purpose..

You are blurring "weight" and "mass".

Think of it like a brick that weighs 10 kg here at sea level. It takes a certain amount of energy to start and stop it moving (kinetic energy).

Take that brick into space, it weighs nothing but the mass is still the same. Still takes the same energy to stop/start it moving etc.

Hence if your 25 kg surfboard that is too heavy to turn easily and will crack your skull if it hits you, will still be exactly the same if you fill it with helium and it only weighs 5 kg.
However it will be more buoyant, if that is your sole purpose.
Richiefish
Richiefish
QLD
5612 posts
QLD, 5612 posts
29 Dec 2009 1:24pm
add a small rocket motor and a bic lighter ?
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
29 Dec 2009 2:36pm
The idea of pressurising it was purely to do away with the necessity of having supporting ribs which all wooden surfboards of any length require to prevent the wood strips from bowing under weight. We figured that if it was going to be pressurised if we used helium it may give it that extra little bit of weight advantage.

Have a look at some of the photos on this site and you will see what I mean. The boards look great but you would not want to have to carry them too far.

mooncussersurfboards.blogspot.com/

This is the Laughing Loon site:http://www.laughingloon.com/canoe.kayak.html

The finished boats look really great and by all accounts have superior performance as well.
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
29 Dec 2009 12:06pm
The board and the kayak are awesome, amazing craftsmanship
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14965 posts
QLD, 14965 posts
29 Dec 2009 2:18pm
what happens if the gas heats up and expands causing a blow out?
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
29 Dec 2009 2:57pm
Just how much difference in weight would there be between a board (say 70 litres ?) filled with air at 10 psi and one filled with hydrogen at 10 psi?
swoosh
swoosh
QLD
1929 posts
QLD, 1929 posts
29 Dec 2009 4:24pm
less then 70g. would be almost half a kilo at 90psi thou.

however you will struggle to contain the gas at that pressure, your structure would have to be very rigid to contain the pressure and also your bottom shape would flex a lot unless rigid enough, i.e. it might go from convex to concave bottom shapes which is probably not what you want. I'd say it would be much heavier then a rib supported structure by the time you resolve the rigidity issues.

There is probably a sweet spot strength wise that you could find by balancing skin thickness, rib thickness and distance between the ribs. In the links, I'd say that you probably want ribs lighter and more closely spaced then those examples.

shear tip
shear tip
NSW
1125 posts
NSW, 1125 posts
29 Dec 2009 5:47pm
Gestalt said...

what happens if the gas heats up and expands causing a blow out?


There'd have to be a vent plug to prevent that. Then all your mates could take turns on the plug and you could all be Alvin the Chipmunk.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
29 Dec 2009 7:34pm
The Kayaks are built over a frame which is removed before the deck is glassed to the hull. The deck and the hull are glassed inside and out which results in a very rigid structure.

The board I want to build will be glassed inside and out. Given that the internal space is small in comparison to a kayak I am hoping that it will require little pressure to give it rigidity. Too much and it definitely poses a risk changing the shape and possibly splitting.

Heat is a problem with glassed timber. Dark timber left in the sun will heat up and give off gas which causes de-lamination . It the board were under pressure and if left in the sun the internal pressure would increase. The secret would be to pressurize to maximise rigidity but allow for further expansion through heat without the structure splitting.

saltiest1
saltiest1
NSW
2575 posts
NSW, 2575 posts
30 Dec 2009 1:04am
just do it and see what happens. ill watch from the side lines
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
29 Dec 2009 10:38pm
I don't think that heat would bump up the pressure inside by much... it's proportional to absolute temperature, so going from 0 to 40 deg C is around 13% increase in pressure. The skin will expand as well, reducing the increase in pressure.

Helium is a small molecule though, it escapes through balloons in a couple of days so I'd think your main worry would be the pressure decreasing over time. If you made the bladder thick enough to contain the helium then it might have trouble conforming to the shape.

I'd love to see the final product though!
shark
shark
WA
361 posts
WA, 361 posts
29 Dec 2009 11:47pm
even 10 psi inside a wooden structure would be "difficult" to contain.
Rough off the top of head calculation of 10 psi.

1 meter by 1 meter is roughly 40 inches by 40 inches.
That is 1600 square inches. Which is 16000 pounds which is 7000 kilos per square meter of pressure pushing outwards. 3 medium passenger cars.

How are you going to fibreglass the inside fully? A Kayak you could reach inside of but a surfboard?
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
30 Dec 2009 2:49am
I think you are right Nebbian. Helium is difficult to contain. My idea was to make the board maintenance free as far as possible and to seal off the valve. Buoyancy was a pay off.

We had had more than a few mind alterers before the subject of helium came up and then visions of people air surfing followed!

Rigidity looks like it will be achieved by air pressure. Realistically all we want to achieve is a center core that does not yield to foot pressure on land. I cannot see that being much over 30psi bearing in mind that this is a double glassed .5mm veneer deck glued to a rail.

I am not a surfer myself but am close to it. The turn over of traditional boards is what makes them environmentally unfriendly and expensive. Every time my young bloke buys one he goes to bed with and within a short space of time it ends up in the recyclers. It is because they have a soft core. And he is a bit rough!

Rigidity in the kayaks is achieved through hull shape. Hopefully we can achieve this with a board that is pressurized. I like to think that you could strike it with a round hammer without risk of inflicting damage you would expect in a soft core.

As far as weight give away is concerned I have not worked it out yet. Over and above the glass and resin use in a traditional board it's weight give away will be an extra layer of glass and resin on the inside, tip and stern filled with resin say 100gms plus the whole surface area with a sandwich of .5mm aero ply. Add a couple of grams for a decent valve and two coats of varnish!

Watch this space!
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
30 Dec 2009 9:42am
Can I have a surf on it?
saltiest1
saltiest1
NSW
2575 posts
NSW, 2575 posts
30 Dec 2009 9:59pm
rigid boards are a totally different feel to standard pu boards. some people like it. personally i like a little feed back into my feet.
Gorgo
Gorgo
VIC
5124 posts
VIC, 5124 posts
31 Dec 2009 4:53pm
www.avisosurf.com/

These are hollow carbon fibre boards. Apparently you can make minor changes in the shape by opening the vent plug then heating or cooling the board then seal it up again.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
31 Dec 2009 9:10pm
Thanks Gorgo I watched the video. If you were a serious surfer you would have to consider one, they would last for ever.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
31 Dec 2009 9:18pm
Shark, fiberglassing inside would be done virtually the same way as in the kayaks. The inside glass layer over the join between the deck and the hull is squeegeed with a small roller on an extension pole. In the case of the board I would use a foam brush cut down to get wet out from the back end. In the kayaks the bow and stern are filled with resin. They stand them up on end in a bucket of ice to reduce the risk of heat damaging the veneers while the resin is curing.
Glitch
Glitch
QLD
292 posts
QLD, 292 posts
2 Jan 2010 1:35pm
It is possible to do a light weight board out of wood. The best way would be like you said jappie, to do a wood sandwich ad using balsa. they can also be done the traditional way built up over an internal frame. http://www.grainsurf.com/forum has some very good wood boards. For a good light weight board have a look at 5' 8" Balsa Fish , also there are some threads by woodyads on light weight wooden boards.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
2 Jan 2010 9:40pm
Thanks a stack for that Glitch. There's some really good ideas on there.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply