The refugee show on SBS tonight

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
28 Jun 2011 12:11pm
Anyone see " go back to where you came from". The wash-up is on tonight.
evlPanda
evlPanda
NSW
9207 posts
NSW, 9207 posts
28 Jun 2011 1:03pm
I only caught the last one, thought it was on every week for three weeks. Pretty heavy stuff taking them all the way back like that.

Before anyone says anything they intentionally chose people with strong viewpoints like that or it wouldn't be as interesting, would it? The producers weren't having a go at bogans, like some senthitive people in the media are saying. (sheesh). It was nice to see them open their minds a bit/travel.
adolf
adolf
1862 posts
1862 posts
28 Jun 2011 6:07pm
Yeah, I watched the whole thing.

Interesting how they did it. Kind of like a survivor format - not what I was expecting. It was watchable and entertaining, but by the end of it, I felt none the wiser.

Sure, you have sympathy for the refugees plight, but the program was very one sided and didn't tackle hard questions - ie: we know we got to take some of them, but how and where do we draw the line. You also knew at the start that the people/contestants would change their hard line views (they were kind of forced to)

Overall, my thoughts were that this was a propaganda film and yet another example of taxpayers money going down the drain.

I'll watch the wash up.
petermac33
petermac33
WA
6415 posts
WA, 6415 posts
28 Jun 2011 6:44pm
brought to you by the ministry of propaganda.
faito anto
faito anto
VIC
181 posts
VIC, 181 posts
28 Jun 2011 8:46pm
I watched all 3 episodes, and thought it was excellent TV - locally made Tprogramming at its best.

It was pretty disturbing to see that ex-army guy from Adelaide rounding up refugees while on that raid. In another time, another place, he might have been a Nazi collaborator war criminal.

Wineman
Wineman
NSW
1412 posts
NSW, 1412 posts
28 Jun 2011 9:20pm

Thought provoking. Entertaining (it is TV!).... so far
You don't rate a mystery thriller before the end, so I'll wait til end.

I don't think they ever set out to give answers, but to generate discussion of the topic from a different perspective.
dusta
dusta
WA
2940 posts
WA, 2940 posts
29 Jun 2011 12:37pm
the wrap up last night was excellent
Ados
Ados
WA
421 posts
WA, 421 posts
29 Jun 2011 1:40pm
Anything that raises the profile of this issue above the politics is good in my books. The old 'walk a mile in another man's shoes' is still a good way to view things and a measure of a thinking, moral and compassionate human being.
Little Jon
Little Jon
NSW
2115 posts
NSW, 2115 posts
29 Jun 2011 10:44pm
rednecks at their best
patsken
patsken
WA
717 posts
WA, 717 posts
30 Jun 2011 11:45am
Pretty interesting and thought provoking show but ultimately apathy will continue.

I don't think the Malaysian segment would have won too much support for the governments so called "Malaysian Solution". It seemed to me that quite a bit of restraint (or editing) was being exercised by the Malay authorities during the raid - for the cameras possibly!

Tony Abbott's love child made the most of his advertorial opportunities
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
30 Jun 2011 2:52pm
patsken said...

Pretty interesting and thought provoking show but ultimately apathy will continue.

I don't think the Malaysian segment would have won too much support for the governments so called "Malaysian Solution". It seemed to me that quite a bit of restraint (or editing) was being exercised by the Malay authorities during the raid - for the cameras possibly!

Tony Abbott's love child made the most of his advertorial opportunities


Yeah that young liberal guy and his "keep right" T-shirts. He was the real eye opener for me in the whole show. And then in the wash up show the other night he was talking about his belief in the "liberal philosophy" (HA!) and how that informs his ideas about social justice and freedom of choice !!!!!(Jesus ****ing Christ)
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply