To VR or not to VR; that is the question

9 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
18 Jun 2016 11:55pm
I've just been offered voluntary redundancy, and am crunching the numbers to decide if I will take it. I need to decide by Wednesday.

I've set up a reasonably detailed financial model in Excel, but there are two parameters that I'd like people's opinion on. I am in my late 40's, so my superannuation will be sitting untouched for at least 10+ years.

What range of values would you assume for:

1. Average superannuation rate of return over the longer term (10 to 20 years)?
2. Average CPI over the longer term (10 to 20 years)?

I'm just as interested in the difference between the values as I am about the actual values.

I've been assuming an investment rate of return 1% or 2% higher than inflation, (eg. 3% CPI and 4% super return, or 3% CPI and 5% super return) which I think is pretty conservative, although even changing between those two makes a very significant difference.

Not after any 'financial planning' advice. I know all the relevant rules, just curious about what range of numbers people think are realistic for 1 & 2 above.

The assumptions I make on those two numbers are going to determine how much longer my wife is going to need to keep working.
busterwa
busterwa
3782 posts
3782 posts
18 Jun 2016 10:31pm
Don't take it hold in there along as you can, There just thinning out dead wood ! If they were that keen on getting rid of you you'd get promoted to management!
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
19 Jun 2016 2:00am

Probably a good time to think about setting up a self managed super fund. More control and more options. The government buggers with the superannuation rules regularly no matter which party is in vogue.

If your money is not making 7% minimum nett, it is in the wrong place.

As far as the job goes, that is really a personal decision.

Question 1. Your super fund should be delivering minimum 10% p/a long term depending what your spread is. Mine is a "balanced portfolio" ie medium risk, medium return. However super funds rely on shares too much I believe and as we all know, shares are very volatile.

Question 2. CPI is what it is. Calculate on 4% p/a.

If you are looking for placement of money, these guys are worth a look. www.cromwell.com.au/

I have money with them which is in an unlisted property trust which is neither capital nor return guaranteed however from day one I have been receiving 8.5% p/a returns paid monthly, tax deferred and has grown to 8.75% returns and the capital value has grown to $1.20 on the $1.00 invested. The tenant in the building is the Queensland Government and the Queensland Government and Federal Government are broke. Go figure.

The whole of life is risk. You just need to calculate the risk
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
19 Jun 2016 10:25am
Thanks for the link Cisco. I'd been thinking of getting a direct stake in commercial property, but never got around to doing the research.

Afraid most of my super will be locked into deferred benefit government super that I can't roll into a SMSF (until I'm 58), but at least I can do something with the VR money.

Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
19 Jun 2016 6:36pm
busterwa said..
Don't take it hold in there along as you can, There just thinning out dead wood ! If they were that keen on getting rid of you you'd get promoted to management!


Good in theory, but sometimes its not a good choice. When I took my VR I was paid out at 4 w$ [Av Gross] / per Y of service (max 25 year limit) the next wave got 3 w$ [Av Gross] Y (max 25 y) then the 3 round got 3 w$ [base rate and not yearly gross as were previously used] So Im glad I left when I did.

When you are calculating your Super remember that you may NOT be putting into super for quite a few years, either you may take a while to find a job, or being self employed with very little super input.
GPA
GPA
WA
2529 posts
GPA GPA
WA, 2529 posts
19 Jun 2016 5:56pm
FYI - Just as a cautionary tale, I know two very good employees that I had worked with for 15yrs and could highly recommend... both took redundancy in Oct/Nov and neither have been able to find fulltime work. One is in IT, the other Admin.

The other thing I have noticed is that salaries are down...

G.

Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
19 Jun 2016 7:48pm
GPA said..
FYI - Just as a cautionary tale, I know two very good employees that I had worked with for 15yrs and could highly recommend... both took redundancy in Oct/Nov and neither have been able to find fulltime work. One is in IT, the other Admin.

The other thing I have noticed is that salaries are down...

G.



Have to agree I took my VR 13 years ago and have not found 'full time' work in the traditional sense in that time (and I do search lots), I do now have a reasonable income made up from about 3-4 casual jobs.
Do I regret it? .... NO, the VR gave me 100 weeks pay + 2x lots of [unused] long service leave payments. Some of the other people that took the VR from the same company have struggled.
Buster fin
Buster fin
WA
2599 posts
WA, 2599 posts
19 Jun 2016 6:22pm
GPA said..
FYI - Just as a cautionary tale, I know two very good employees that I had worked with for 15yrs and could highly recommend... both took redundancy in Oct/Nov and neither have been able to find fulltime work. One is in IT, the other Admin.

The other thing I have noticed is that salaries are down...

G.


Indeed. It"s a particularly bad time to be unemployed. Nor looking for tenants to fill residential/commercial/industrial leases.
West Aus in particular is about to take a beating.
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
19 Jun 2016 9:33pm
I'm not planning on getting another job. All my calculations are based on me retiring now. My wife is a teacher, and she'll keep working for a few years. That's why I'm curious about interest rate assumptions, because I'm wondering how much my super is going to worth when I hit 60 after leaving it sitting earning interest for a decade or so.
Carantoc
Carantoc
WA
7285 posts
WA, 7285 posts
19 Jun 2016 7:38pm
Not sure if it helps but I have an idea for a macro for an excel financial model for early retirement.

It is based on something like :

Cell A1 : Text "Maui"
Cell A2 : Text "buy ticket to"
Cell A3 : Text "one-way"

Cell A4 : =Cell A2 + Cell A1 + Cell A3
Skid
Skid
QLD
1499 posts
QLD, 1499 posts
19 Jun 2016 9:39pm
Harrow, have you factored in your part time sales assistant work?
Beaglebuddy
Beaglebuddy
1595 posts
1595 posts
20 Jun 2016 4:46am
It seems you never end up with as good an interest rate as you had planned when initially making these calculations. Commercial real estate seems sound but... brick and mortar businesses are disappearing in favor of internet mail order businesses such as Amazon. In the US we just had a huge sporting goods chain go under, Sports Authority, 463 stores closing.
If you stay on could you expect a better redundancy offer in the future? or do the people who jump on this first get the best deal?
deanrobi
deanrobi
VIC
641 posts
VIC, 641 posts
20 Jun 2016 12:46pm
As mentioned above work on 10% interest on your super, that seems to be the average over the past 10 years, I believe some funds are achieving 12% this year. Having the defined benifit pension is a plus, unless there is a change after the election, consider the benefits of 'transition to retirement' there maybe room in there to assist you but I assume from you post that your preservation age is not for a while yet
Slashrockson
Slashrockson
NSW
126 posts
NSW, 126 posts
20 Jun 2016 6:54pm
Retired under 50!! Take it you lucky bastard.
kiteboy dave
kiteboy dave
QLD
6525 posts
QLD, 6525 posts
20 Jun 2016 9:31pm
Yes, VR

Haggar
Haggar
QLD
1670 posts
QLD, 1670 posts
21 Jun 2016 8:42am
Harrow, if you want to retire now make sure you have lots of things you want to do. Im a bit older than you and VR has been on the cards here for a while. If I did get VR I would stil plan to work again, but on my terms under a contractor arrangement. I know you said you dont want it but If you havnt already done so you should get some retirement planning, work out what income you want in retirement and for how long, your plan needs to support this with contingency. Whatever you do, make sure you enjoy it and stay busy
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
21 Jun 2016 1:13pm
This is an interesting read for early retirement: www.mrmoneymustache.com/

As per cisco's comment, I'd expect super to be closer to 10%, mine has been consistently around that (except probably 2008 and maybe 2011).
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
26 Jun 2016 11:32am
The plug has been pulled.

If I can't pull of a decent planing gybe in the next summer or two, I'll have no excuses left.
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
26 Jun 2016 10:13am
Bend your knees (a lot!) and lean forward. Keep you carve wide and come out pointing a little downwind
Cambodge
Cambodge
VIC
851 posts
VIC, 851 posts
26 Jun 2016 1:31pm
Pugwash said...
Bend your knees (a lot!) and lean forward. Keep you carve wide and come out pointing a little downwind


And it's a 90deg turn, not 180.
Mr Milk
Mr Milk
NSW
3139 posts
NSW, 3139 posts
26 Jun 2016 6:08pm
You are about to find out that it is hardly ever windy and you have to do more housework
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15105 posts
WA, 15105 posts
26 Jun 2016 5:39pm
Harrow said..
The plug has been pulled.

If I can't pull of a decent planing gybe in the next summer or two, I'll have no excuses left.


I think you should go to WA to look for work for a few weeks in summer... just in case.


cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
27 Jun 2016 12:10am

Mention the term "Voluntary Redundancy" in ten years time and people will say "Huh, what is that??"
Haggar
Haggar
QLD
1670 posts
QLD, 1670 posts
27 Jun 2016 10:47am
Enjoy Harrow!
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
27 Jun 2016 4:04pm
cisco said..

Mention the term "Voluntary Redundancy" in ten years time and people will say "Huh, what is that??"


Yeah, my industry is attempting to slash the existing agreement, and replace VR provisions with a forced redundancy based on the fair work minimum standard 3 months payout. I got out just in time.

Now need to figure out what to cook for dinner. Any recipe ideas? Soon I'll be tearing pages out of copies of Women's Weekly borrowed from my mother-in-law .
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply