Vikings or Game of Thrones ?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Ted the Kiwi
Ted the Kiwi
NSW
14256 posts
NSW, 14256 posts
23 Jun 2014 10:03am
Just finished watching Season 2 of Vikings and I have to hand it to them over GoT. I find the story lines more enjoyable (probably the more realistic historical nature of them and the fact that they have been blended with historical events), interesting religious beliefs, political issues within the villages themselves, the shear lunacy of some of the story lines and their attitude to s*x. I reckon its a ripper of a TV Series. I love the emphasis on a good death - so that you can go to val-hella. The blood eagle was just an epic episode.

I rate Lagertha over Daenerys Targaryen. Dragons are so pffffft - I prefer a shieldmadien any day of the week.



dusta
dusta
WA
2940 posts
WA, 2940 posts
23 Jun 2014 9:42am
totally agree with you . I don't see what the big deal is about GOT
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
23 Jun 2014 11:59am
A few of the reasons why I enjoy GoT, both the books and the TV show. Firstly I like the idea of magic, dragons and all that supernatural stuff was around. That sort of stuff died out hundreds of years ago so all that matters today is cold steel and gold. However those old things are coming back. Its great how Ned Stark died at the end of the first book/season, ie the main character is gone, especially as he did have a way to live but was too inflexible to see it. Plenty of other reasons why I like GOT too. I actually like the books more.

I've seen Vikings and enjoy it too for the reasons mentioned. Its interesting to see how the pagan Germanic religion interacts with Christianity. Its also interesting to consider the English that the Vikings plunder were basically the same as the Vikings a couple of hundred years before.

kiteboy dave
kiteboy dave
QLD
6525 posts
QLD, 6525 posts
23 Jun 2014 4:07pm
Tough call. Have to give it to GoT. Much bigger storyline, I mean very ambitious, it takes 2-3 eps just to get round the characters and catch up with what they're doing. Vikings ultimately has less going on, less room for story to develop. (huddle/plan in winter, raid/fight each other in summer, England/farming being the wildcard/expansion). But the bigger story with GoT can be it's undoing - hard to stay on top of who's who unless you binge watch it. Defo one that you can watch again from S1E01 and pick up heaps.

stuk
stuk
NSW
894 posts
NSW, 894 posts
23 Jun 2014 6:24pm
Really enjoyed both. But I think I give it to GOT. I'm a Tolkien fan, I first read The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings about 35 years ago. I'd have to rate George Martin and his work up there alongside Tolkien. Just the sheer volume of his work (each book is over 800 pages) writing about a world,culture,political system,magic system etc etc that he invented in his own mind is simply amazing. Whilst the writers of Vikings had a well researched history to base their stories about. But both are fantastic shows.

The same but different I can't wait for the next Star Wars movie to be released, its currently in production for release in 2015. Then it'll be a case of watch all the existing movies in the correct order to catch up on the storyline again.
Tux
Tux
VIC
3829 posts
Tux Tux
VIC, 3829 posts
24 Jun 2014 8:57am
GOT for the storylines...Vikings for the sword fights...gotta agree about the shield maidens...is it just me of has Rhagnars second wife Princess whats her name got more odd looking the longer series went on? When he meet her she was smoking now I reckon she looks like some weird alien hybrid....I like the fact that Rhagnar tried to go for the threeway when the princess rocked up!!
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
24 Jun 2014 12:46pm
GOT has better dragons..

Smithy
Smithy
VIC
859 posts
VIC, 859 posts
24 Jun 2014 7:05pm
Gotta love Ragnar's face in bed at the end of the last episode of the season, got his 2 wives and now king...
actiomax
actiomax
NSW
1576 posts
NSW, 1576 posts
25 Jun 2014 6:40pm
Got to agree one day I want that smile
Its vikings for me .
Ted the Kiwi
Ted the Kiwi
NSW
14256 posts
NSW, 14256 posts
25 Jun 2014 7:19pm
Tux said...
GOT for the storylines...Vikings for the sword fights...gotta agree about the shield maidens...is it just me of has Rhagnars second wife Princess whats her name got more odd looking the longer series went on? When he meet her she was smoking now I reckon she looks like some weird alien hybrid....



Maybe she is just ageing - they have been away a fair bit in recent years That offer of a threesome was hilarious !
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply