"at home with Julia"

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
8 Sep 2011 5:17pm
Anyone see it? any reviews?
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
8 Sep 2011 3:22pm
I would rather masterbate with a cheesegrater
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
8 Sep 2011 3:24pm
Didn't intend on watching it but did so by accident.

Thought it would be utter sh!te and was only partially correct.

Was a lot better than I thought it would be (but hardly outstanding) and certainly not the worst comedy I have seen lately.

Myeh.. 5/10.
chrispychru
chrispychru
QLD
7932 posts
QLD, 7932 posts
8 Sep 2011 5:37pm
pretty good. not hard too take the piss out of juulia with a nose like a witch and talks like a educated bogan,she should have been called mercedes gillard
CMC
CMC
QLD
3954 posts
CMC CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
8 Sep 2011 5:58pm
doggie said...

I would rather masterbate with a cheesegrater


Slightly amusing, mostly painful. Oooowww. You quoting my favourite movie character Doggie?

SomeOtherGuy
SomeOtherGuy
NSW
807 posts
NSW, 807 posts
8 Sep 2011 5:59pm
Too much information doggie!
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
8 Sep 2011 4:03pm
I loved it. Thought it was hilarious. Paul Keating, Bob Katter, oh, and Bill Shorten, the dog

Oh, and Tom, poor ol' Tom. And, the kids out the front of the lodge. Brilliant.
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
8 Sep 2011 4:11pm
CMC said...

doggie said...

I would rather masterbate with a cheesegrater


Slightly amusing, mostly painful. Oooowww. You quoting my favourite movie character Doggie?




Ford Fairlane (.Y.)
subasurf
subasurf
WA
2154 posts
WA, 2154 posts
8 Sep 2011 7:49pm
doggie said...

I would rather masterbate with a cheesegrater


You mean you already don't?
SandS
SandS
VIC
5904 posts
VIC, 5904 posts
8 Sep 2011 10:27pm

I liked the independents , dictating the terms at the dinner table , getting Tim to make the coffee just the way they wanted!!

the show as a whole .... just a bit of a giggle

landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
8 Sep 2011 8:43pm
glad to see something that doesnt rely on swearing,you needed to listen and look for the subtleties? in the actions.
look forward to next week.
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
9 Sep 2011 12:00am
I cringed, start to finish. A steaming rancid pile of cack. "Hey dad" had better acting and "Houseboat horror" had a better script. More annoying than "the Librarians"......one star.
adolf
adolf
1862 posts
1862 posts
8 Sep 2011 10:35pm
I comb my hair Wednesday night and didn't have time to catch up with the TV - was it any good?
kyteryder
kyteryder
NSW
692 posts
NSW, 692 posts
9 Sep 2011 8:36am
Date night seems totally wrong now.
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
9 Sep 2011 11:28am
It wasn't a bad show. A bit of satire can be funny. Julia did not come too bad out of it. The three amigos are the ones who probably dislike it more than anyone else along with ALP MPs.

Why be an ALP MP? Your opinion or voice doesn't matter. Meanwhile the independents can tell Julia what time they are coming round for dinner.
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
9 Sep 2011 10:19am
log man said...

I cringed, start to finish. A steaming rancid pile of cack. "Hey dad" had better acting and "Houseboat horror" had a better script. More annoying than "the Librarians"......one star.


Sheeessshhh loggy...

We know you love the labs. Based on the comment above, can we assume you work as a librarian

I think the librarians is brilliant. Frances O'Brien is soooo close to reality...
frant
frant
VIC
1230 posts
VIC, 1230 posts
9 Sep 2011 12:31pm
I thought it was hilarious, best show I have seen in a long time. I just loved the way "acting" Julia mimicked "real" Julias big bum waddle.
I reckon it will lift the current PM's approval rating as you can't help feeling great sympathy for her inability to organise her nookie time with Tom. or is that Tim!
Four and a half stars from me.
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
9 Sep 2011 7:24pm
frant said...

I thought it was hilarious, best show I have seen in a long time. I just loved the way "acting" Julia mimicked "real" Julias big bum waddle.
I reckon it will lift the current PM's approval rating as you can't help feeling great sympathy for her inability to organise her nookie time with Tom. or is that Tim!
Four and a half stars from me.


Geez you guys are easily pleased, shows like this need to develop characters not characitures. Characters come from good writing and sensitive actors. Is it "the Office? is it "wilfred"? is it "Arrested development"?. No its Hey dad with funny voices. Australian produces need to realize that audiences judge Australian shows against the best the world has got not just what this country produces. Yeah and its not because of my undying love for all things commy that i hate this show. If the show was about the little rodent I would still hate it .
chrispychru
chrispychru
QLD
7932 posts
QLD, 7932 posts
9 Sep 2011 7:37pm
log man said...

frant said...

I thought it was hilarious, best show I have seen in a long time. I just loved the way "acting" Julia mimicked "real" Julias big bum waddle.
I reckon it will lift the current PM's approval rating as you can't help feeling great sympathy for her inability to organise her nookie time with Tom. or is that Tim!
Four and a half stars from me.


Geez you guys are easily pleased, shows like this need to develop characters not characitures. Characters come from good writing and sensitive actors. Is it "the Office? is it "wilfred"? is it "Arrested development"?. No its Hey dad with funny voices. Australian produces need to realize that audiences judge Australian shows against the best the world has got not just what this country produces. Yeah and its not because of my undying love for all things commy that i hate this show. If the show was about the little rodent I would still hate it .

geez mate go bat one off and lighten up
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
9 Sep 2011 8:08pm
^^^So, one size fits all... All tv will be... Yawn! How beige. How labs. Good one loggy
chrispychru
chrispychru
QLD
7932 posts
QLD, 7932 posts
9 Sep 2011 10:46pm
Pugwash said...

^^^So, one size fits all... All tv will be... Yawn! How beige. How labs. Good one loggy


its a tv show for gods sake,if your life is that boring where you get upset about high quality viewing,i suggest you should bat one of just to clear some mind space or something better to do than watch tv
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
9 Sep 2011 11:37pm
Ermmmmmm... Yeah... Ok... That was for Loggy bru. Oh yeah, and all those things...
chrispychru
chrispychru
QLD
7932 posts
QLD, 7932 posts
10 Sep 2011 7:20am
Pugwash said...

Ermmmmmm... Yeah... Ok... That was for Loggy bru. Oh yeah, and all those things...


landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
10 Sep 2011 9:36am
Mobydisc said...

It wasn't a bad show. A bit of satire can be funny. Julia did not come too bad out of it. The three amigos are the ones who probably dislike it more than anyone else along with ALP MPs.

Why be an ALP MP? Your opinion or voice doesn't matter. Meanwhile the independents can tell Julia what time they are coming round for dinner.


OMG ya took it seriously.
Im glad to see we are able to start having a laugh at the pollies again, seems a good sign and omen

log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
10 Sep 2011 12:30pm
chrispychru said...

log man said...

frant said...

I thought it was hilarious, best show I have seen in a long time. I just loved the way "acting" Julia mimicked "real" Julias big bum waddle.
I reckon it will lift the current PM's approval rating as you can't help feeling great sympathy for her inability to organise her nookie time with Tom. or is that Tim!
Four and a half stars from me.


Geez you guys are easily pleased, shows like this need to develop characters not characitures. Characters come from good writing and sensitive actors. Is it "the Office? is it "wilfred"? is it "Arrested development"?. No its Hey dad with funny voices. Australian produces need to realize that audiences judge Australian shows against the best the world has got not just what this country produces. Yeah and its not because of my undying love for all things commy that i hate this show. If the show was about the little rodent I would still hate it .

geez mate go bat one off and lighten up


Ahhhh,........... that feels a lot better chrispy. Thanks was good advice. If in doubt bat one off ......... I'm a bit tired now.
chrispychru
chrispychru
QLD
7932 posts
QLD, 7932 posts
12 Sep 2011 8:02pm
log man said...

chrispychru said...

log man said...

frant said...

I thought it was hilarious, best show I have seen in a long time. I just loved the way "acting" Julia mimicked "real" Julias big bum waddle.
I reckon it will lift the current PM's approval rating as you can't help feeling great sympathy for her inability to organise her nookie time with Tom. or is that Tim!
Four and a half stars from me.


Geez you guys are easily pleased, shows like this need to develop characters not characitures. Characters come from good writing and sensitive actors. Is it "the Office? is it "wilfred"? is it "Arrested development"?. No its Hey dad with funny voices. Australian produces need to realize that audiences judge Australian shows against the best the world has got not just what this country produces. Yeah and its not because of my undying love for all things commy that i hate this show. If the show was about the little rodent I would still hate it .

geez mate go bat one off and lighten up


Ahhhh,........... that feels a lot better chrispy. Thanks was good advice. If in doubt bat one off ......... I'm a bit tired now.


works for me mate
Poodle
Poodle
WA
868 posts
WA, 868 posts
18 Sep 2011 4:53pm
I finally caught the first two episodes online. I ranged from rolling on the floor laughing, to cringing at how accurately it portrays the incompetent federal govt we are lumbered with.

Funniest show since early Kath & Kim :-)

Poods
frant
frant
VIC
1230 posts
VIC, 1230 posts
22 Sep 2011 8:25am
Poodle said...

I finally caught the first two episodes online. I ranged from rolling on the floor laughing, to cringing at how accurately it portrays the incompetent federal govt we are lumbered with.

Funniest show since early Kath & Kim :-)

Poods


I caught episode #3 last night. Thought it was again pretty good.

WRG to the "flag" incident we know Bill Clinton did it in the oval office with all and sundry. Going back a few years one of the Lab. ministers Evans? got sprung as well. If past and current Prime Ministers don't make use of the perks in the office then they really don't deserve to be P.M. of our beloved country. And Logman you wont have any idea of what is going on because surely you didn't stoop to watch it again.
Carantoc
Carantoc
WA
7288 posts
WA, 7288 posts
22 Sep 2011 9:07am
I watched for the first time last night.

Funnier than I thought, but I don't believe that tripe should be put out by the ABC.

It is a character assasination, not a comedy show.

Political satire should be about the statements people make, the contridictions in their policies and the decisions they take. It should not be about their personality or character.

Last night's episode ending scene was a sad and lonely Julia crying on the floor of her kitchen, brought about by her own personality. It leaves an impression in the mind of the viewer as to the nature of the person, that is not necessarily true but sure to influence the polical opinion.

By having a show that has one politican as its lead is disproportionate and politically one sided. Spitting Image and Dawes and ... (Brian whats he called) have 3 minute sketches equal over the political spectrum. 'At home with' has 30 second cameos from others and 30 minutes of character assasination of one person.

Don't get me wrong, I think Julia is a useless PM, but I don't think my tax money should be spent making this sort of 'entertainment'. I am sure many manical dictators have represented the character and personality of their opponents in a less sordid way.

It apears to me to come down to the fact that the ABC and the shows writers are too dumb to work out the difference between Kath and Kim style soap opera fiction and political satire.

They should stick to low brow, pop culture, bland entertainment of the poorest quality for the dumbest masses and stay away from anything that requires intelligence to broadcast. But I guess then it would be called 'today tonight with Julia'
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
22 Sep 2011 1:15pm
The problem with the show and most Aussie comedies is we've seen the best from around the world and it doesn't cut it to just cut it to say it's ours and therefore lets barrack for it. We've seen "yes minister" and "Fawlty towers" so we know what great comedy writing is, we've seen "arrested development" and "the Allan Partridge show , so we know what good characters are like. So there's the bar, it gets raised now and then and when shows miss the mark they should cop it. As for the PM being a tabboo subject, naahh, give it to her, both barrels, only the gun is a pop gun.
Carantoc
Carantoc
WA
7288 posts
WA, 7288 posts
22 Sep 2011 12:52pm
No problem giving to the PM, or any other politician, criticism is an important part of a democracy and humour and satire is an important part of life.

But there is a line somewhere between deriving humour from a persons own character, beliefs, religion, sexual orientation, ability etc. as opposed to their actions in public office.

For sure ridicule and satarise Julia. But mocking her for her decision not to marry, just seems character assassination of a biased polical type. If, for example, she publically and politically criticised couples living together out of wedlock (as say the church does) and then lives out of wedlock herself, then for sure lay it into her.

But for the ABC, a publically funded a-political organisation that has one-sided legal protections for what it says and does, portraying her as a lonely and sad figure sobbing on her kitchen floor for failing to manage a relationship, just doesn't seem right to me.

Funny maybe, but not right.

Let's have a comedy show mocking disabled children's dreams and aspirations. Some may also find it funny, but it is not necessarily right. - oh wait the ABC put that out as well.

But yes, even ignoring the above, compared to say Spitting Image or Clark and Dawes I though it was very poor quality writing and producing.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply