How much power do kites generate?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
elliot
elliot
NSW
22 posts
NSW, 22 posts
15 Oct 2006 11:28pm
Does anyone know?

I guess if a kite at zenith can loft someone who weighs a couple of hundred pounds, then that's about how much power they generate at that point in the wind window, but how much would they generate in the power zone?

Obviously it's going to vary massively between kites and wind speeds, the speed of the kite through the window, and where it is in the window. But some sort of table would be good, like this kite generates X kg when moving between 11 and 1 o'clock at 30 kph in 20 knots of wind at z degrees of elevation blah blah etc.

Must be nearly impossible to measure in the field, but can't they work this stuff out from computer models?

Probably asking a little much I suppose...

I must be a stats freak
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
15 Oct 2006 11:44pm
There would be a lot of factors at play. For example, when a kite is in the powerzone, it relates to how faster its travelling at the time, how much sail is exposed to the wind, how thick the leading edge is, etc.
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
15 Oct 2006 11:52pm
a lot!
lemming
lemming
WA
75 posts
WA, 75 posts
15 Oct 2006 10:33pm
Haha - quality.

Loving the technical gargon, reasoning and finaly result.

Cut to the chase - "A lot"

nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
16 Oct 2006 5:57am
Put a spring balance on your chicken loop and find out!

Just to nitpick, I think you mean force, not power.
echostorm
echostorm
QLD
1245 posts
QLD, 1245 posts
16 Oct 2006 8:29am
good question. there would have to be a computer model to simulate it, maybe someone can design one for us ;). All I know is when I get ripped up in the air and slammed back on the water (unintentionally) then its a hell of a lot stronger then a human could ever be! I have heard stories of a kite causing the front of a car to bounce in little hops. I cannot valify this story however if anyone was there or has seen similar feats of power first hand it would be good to hear them.
elliot
elliot
NSW
22 posts
NSW, 22 posts
16 Oct 2006 8:38am
I would've thought they use computer models to design the kites, which surely would calculate the forces at play anyway as part of the process.

Maybe they just draw them, and go 'yeah, that looks cool - do a yellow one' and then hope it flies better than last year's.
echostorm
echostorm
QLD
1245 posts
QLD, 1245 posts
16 Oct 2006 8:43am
They figured out aerodynamics of planes decades ago without computer models and those theories still hold current. But red ones definantly help make the kites fly faster.
uvblue
uvblue
QLD
23 posts
QLD, 23 posts
16 Oct 2006 1:02pm
Try this simulator: www.flysim.com/kitesim/kitesim_features.html

It has a nice force gauge feature
GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
16 Oct 2006 2:40pm
quote:
Originally posted by echostorm

They figured out aerodynamics of planes decades ago without computer models and those theories still hold current. But red ones definantly help make the kites fly faster.



that's gold! and I definately agree...
LEWISS
LEWISS
NSW
335 posts
NSW, 335 posts
16 Oct 2006 7:44pm
think about it like this: a couple of days ago I went wakeboarding behind a mates 3.5m tinny... I edged out to the one side, not to hard, but nearly flipped the boat because it got pulled sideways at speed. When kiting in desend wind, the kite pulls you fine, with out struggle, depending on size. MUST have heaps of power!!
jan
jan
WA
1119 posts
jan jan
WA, 1119 posts
16 Oct 2006 6:38pm
quote:
Originally posted by uvblue

Try this simulator: www.flysim.com/kitesim/kitesim_features.html

It has a nice force gauge feature



I don't think the force gauge is anything near accurate.

If you think about it, a kite doesn't exert a force stronger than gravity, otherwise we would be paragliding all the time ;)
kitecrazzzy
kitecrazzzy
WA
2184 posts
WA, 2184 posts
16 Oct 2006 6:58pm
less than the breaking strain of your front lines combined and more than you weigh. so about y do you want to know its not like it changes anything.
elliot
elliot
NSW
22 posts
NSW, 22 posts
16 Oct 2006 9:27pm
Curiosity, plain & simple...
kkiter
kkiter
NSW
452 posts
NSW, 452 posts
16 Oct 2006 9:30pm
Static Kite in 20Kn of wind with:
Lift co-efficient of 1.5 (angle of attack at 5 deg)
Air density of 1.3 kg/m3
Surface area 12m2
Lift force = 278 pound force

Just an example. Depends on wing profile, air density, CL etc.
Defiitely enough power to defy gravity. I'm sure I've been lifted off the water at some stage.
jan
jan
WA
1119 posts
jan jan
WA, 1119 posts
16 Oct 2006 7:50pm
you can change direction to upward, but this doesn't defy gravity ;)...
Soonee
Soonee
VIC
147 posts
VIC, 147 posts
16 Oct 2006 10:13pm
Enough to power a small lituanian city I'd say
echostorm
echostorm
QLD
1245 posts
QLD, 1245 posts
16 Oct 2006 10:34pm
quote:
Originally posted by Soonee

Enough to power a small lituanian city I'd say



hahahahahaha... or enough to feed the starving.
hosko
hosko
WA
393 posts
WA, 393 posts
16 Oct 2006 8:38pm
quote:
Originally posted by kkiter

Static Kite in 20Kn of wind with:
Lift co-efficient of 1.5 (angle of attack at 5 deg)
Air density of 1.3 kg/m3
Surface area 12m2
Lift force = 278 pound force

Just an example. Depends on wing profile, air density, CL etc.
Defiitely enough power to defy gravity. I'm sure I've been lifted off the water at some stage.


how can you get a force in pounds when your units are all kg an metres. doesn't make dimensional sense.
Fitzy
Fitzy
QLD
617 posts
QLD, 617 posts
16 Oct 2006 11:49pm
About 20 to 40 Horse Power depending on windspeed and kite size.

Fitzy Gold Coast OZ
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
16 Oct 2006 10:12pm
They used to use just two horses to rip people apart.
silviu
silviu
VIC
663 posts
VIC, 663 posts
17 Oct 2006 2:10am
I remembre reading sometrhing in Peter Lynn Kites website. they commission a student to research the force of their kites. They published the paper in their website.
The student used, the old ARC's, tied to a car which was moving at different speeds, simulating the wind.
stamp
stamp
QLD
2800 posts
QLD, 2800 posts
18 Oct 2006 11:02pm
...enough to destroy careers, break up relationships, make you broke, and give an incredible rush of adrenaline and freedom
elliot
elliot
NSW
22 posts
NSW, 22 posts
19 Oct 2006 12:25pm
Well, my job is boring, I'm single, and I'm nearly always broke anyway, so... bring it on
hosko
hosko
WA
393 posts
WA, 393 posts
19 Oct 2006 12:53pm
well here goes an example:
say a kiter of 90kg does a jump which carries him 10metres into the air and say this occurs in 2.5 seconds from point of liftoff to 10 metre height then we can work outt he average power generated by the kite over this jump.
firstly --> Potential Energy = mgh
= 90 x 9.81 x 10
= 8829 J
=8.829kJ

and --> Power = Energy/time
= 8.829/2.5
= 3.53kW

So 3.53 kW during this jump. that is quite alot of power and i'd say this sort of jump is achievable.

an initial indication anyway.....

(also for the old school people 3.53kW = 4.73hp)
elliot
elliot
NSW
22 posts
NSW, 22 posts
19 Oct 2006 6:26pm
Ok, thanks. So, how much would one generate in the power zone?

What's the speed record? about 40 knots? I guess we'd need to know what the drag coefficient of a kiteboard is with about 90Kg on it. But then you'd have to be edging, wouldn't you, which would create more drag.

Or was the record set on a down-winder?

Should I just drop this & do something else?

Votes please:
1) yeah, drop it ffs, this thread has been dragging on far too long, stop clogging up the forum
2) no, even I want to know now, you bastard. I didn't care before but now I can't stop thinking about it
3) what's kiteboarding?
4) kim beazley
hosko
hosko
WA
393 posts
WA, 393 posts
19 Oct 2006 4:39pm
5
echostorm
echostorm
QLD
1245 posts
QLD, 1245 posts
19 Oct 2006 6:52pm
Ill vote 5 too.
jan
jan
WA
1119 posts
jan jan
WA, 1119 posts
19 Oct 2006 4:58pm
quote:
Originally posted by elliot
Ok, thanks. So, how much would one generate in the power zone?



Not to be a nazi, but you need to be a little careful with your terms.

At a guess what you really want to ask is how much FORCE is provided by the kite at a given instant when it is in the "power zone".

(ie how much "pull" will the kite have)

At another guess, it is probably not much different from the magnitude of force that lifts a kiter during a jump, so you could (roughly) use hosko's example to calculate this too, hosko can do the math :).

Of course the numbers you will end up with are not particularly useful to compare with anything :)
elliot
elliot
NSW
22 posts
NSW, 22 posts
19 Oct 2006 7:32pm
Yes, nebbian kindly pointed out my terminal error earlier in this thread.

But, surely the force generated in the power zone is a lot greater than that which is generated when a kiter is jumping, because (from what I've read) the kite is moving overhead when a kiter jumps, whereas the power zone is down near the horizontal.

Obviously there's the apparent wind to consider, but I'd imagine even with that factored in, you'll still get a lot more force as the kite moves through the power zone.
jan
jan
WA
1119 posts
jan jan
WA, 1119 posts
19 Oct 2006 6:50pm
shrug... the dynamics are not trivial

i feel about as much pull upwards in a well timed jump as i feel pull laterally when i loop the kite hard.

when im overpowered i tend to DIVE my kite into the power zone and drive it to the edge of the window rather than raise it upwards and be pulled off my edge.

ive only ever seen people blowing lines in jumps rather than throwing the kite through power zone (*that ive seen*)
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply