Is this a good idea?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
SHEPPO3930
SHEPPO3930
WA
106 posts
WA, 106 posts
28 Feb 2005 12:01pm
G'day ppl,

i am after the brains of Kitehard (???) and anyone else who's an instructor (or very experienced). As you's might know, i am a n00b to the sport, and i have about 3hrs of "in water" experience...mostly involving falling off the board!

now the other day, in my first real session on the water, it was onshore, good wind, but being onshore made it hard to body drag and learn to water start. i found that i was being washed up on the beach faster than i could get on the board and launch.....simple solution you say, drag upwind more. Well i found that it was taking ages to do so i came up with a different method.

get the board under your upwind arm, and lay it on its side, then point it where u wanna go, and then act like u are body dragging, but using the board as a HUGE fin, much more efficient that your arm and body.

now this worked suprisingly well, and i could kite very close to the wind, almost like sailing a yacht (been doing that for years), then when i was far enuff out, i pointed downwind and started practicing the water start with my board.

i could get about 4 attempts in before i was on the beach, so it was much easier to re-attempt the water-start over and over in fast succession, getting the hang of it quicker i felt.

i know it isn't a propper substitute for the upwind body drag, and yes i can body drag upwind without the aid of the board, but it was really good to get upwind (away from the beach) so i could have some space to learn.

when i can water start and then hold an edge upwind, i will probably never use this method again. but for learners needing some upwind "space" on a direct onshore, this might help.

Any thought from the instructors/experienced kiters on here?
Surgeon
Surgeon
NSW
134 posts
NSW, 134 posts
28 Feb 2005 3:30pm
This is a Troll - right Your tryin to get people to respond to the fact that you're a dumb ass yeah! I'll take the bait Just remember that when you f*%# up and get dragged accross the land that I've got dibs on puttin your sorry Ar*# back together Have fun while you're alive kiting in onshore conditions - or get some lessons and check out where and in what conditions you should be in - Later
HungLong
HungLong
WA
859 posts
WA, 859 posts
28 Feb 2005 2:41pm
Surgeon, great way to get some advice across to a newby... no wonder we have image problem in our sport... TOOL!

Sheppo, what your doing is an important step for you and will serve you in many trying times to come... However, even thow surgeons delivery does not lend it self to constructive critism just plain critism , he is right... Dont go out and learn in onshore conditions, you realy are asking for trouble... My tip would be get a map of perth and plot the different type of wind directions that we experience,You mentioned your a seasoned sailer so should not have any problems finding a spot to learn on...
Surgeon
Surgeon
NSW
134 posts
NSW, 134 posts
28 Feb 2005 6:08pm
Settle down HungLong, my critism is constructive it clearly states 'go to an instructor and get some lessons' the image problem with the sport comes from tools without proper instruction rockin up at inappropriate locations endangering themselves and others. If your a dropkick and you do something dumb that's how it is - there is no point in candy coating a ** no matter what you do it's still a **... Kiting dead onshore is dumb period that's all there is to it OK
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
28 Feb 2005 3:40pm
Surgeon Hung Long is on the money mate... If youv'e nothin constructive to say then go back to your little lunch box where you are universally thought to be a legend.
T O O L
I spelt that S L O W L Y for you because as i know you don't bother to actually read the threads before launching into them T O O L - in case you missed it the 1st time
Surgeon
Surgeon
NSW
134 posts
NSW, 134 posts
28 Feb 2005 6:48pm
Oh GetFunky does that mean I'm off your Christmas card list??? I'd rather be a TOOL than a FOOL dude. I suppose you kite onshore as well is that wot your saying??? I note that your reply is the only non productive post on this thread surprise surprise!!! HungLongs message woz the same as mine just more eloquently put!

I can tell you don't like me aye?????
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
28 Feb 2005 4:08pm
Sorry Sheppo,
I allowed the inmates to distract me there for a mo.
Obviously HL put it a little more intelligently.
Simple equation:
1x day in westerlies = 1x f*%k up + mucho time out of water
Hmmm old Albert had a formulae for this too but I'm sure you can work it out too
I have only one full season under my belt and only get to go once a week max, so it is tempting to go out in westerlies (for WA)but just not worth the risk matee
good luck fellow noob hombre
PsYLoR
PsYLoR
QLD
927 posts
QLD, 927 posts
28 Feb 2005 10:28pm
I think what everyone is trying to say is.....
When learning its tempting to get out there every chance you get, sometimes you'll be stupid & go out in conditions that you shouldn't be in. IE directly offshore winds, directly onshore winds, gusty conditions, etc.
If you really want to get out there then your better off to find a SAFE place that will give you a side wind direction. You may have the ability to do what you were doing in your post, but the fact is that if anything goes wrong whilst doing that you've left yourself no option but to be dragged up the beach and into a hard object.

You don't get as much time in the water before your on the beach again and this means more time trying to get back out into deeper water to try again. You could of spent this wasted time driving that little bit further to a better spot.

With side winds, when you stuff up you will be dragged more or less parallel to the beach which is a lot safer.

As a beginner you just dont have the experience or kite control to handle onshore conditions, sooner or later you will stuff up, EVERYONE PAYS THEY'RE DUES at somestage. You will be thankful you decided to find a place with side winds to kite.

Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
28 Feb 2005 8:56pm
Hey Sheppo3930,

Wow, tough situation. Of course learning in onshore woinds is really dangerous, but then again, you didn't mention how far out you were body dragging. The IKO says a clear space of 0.5 km is safe and by this I think they mean you finish dragging at 0.5km and this space is used as a safety buffer should anything go wrong.

Then there is the other side of the coin. If the wind was cross on. I taught students everyday in Hawaii with on to cross on winds (between 45 and 60 degrees from side shore) and it is possible under controlled conditions. This is all well and nice when you have an instructor standing close by with radio comm, first aid and a plethora of techniques and safety gear to save you should the proverbial hit the fan.

As the others have said, it is best and safest to wait for better days or find better locations.

The method of using the board as a keel is great and really works a treat when done properly, you sound like you are doing well. Just be super safe, and test and practice your quick release pins. Nobody wants to see you hurt. Sometimes pushing the limits works for you and sometimes it doesn't through no fault of your own and if there is no safety buffer zone, the injuries can be extensive.

Just ask dangerous Dave of Sydney who no longer kites after learning toeside, he came to the beach so stoked he forgot a few simple rules and stopped 10m upwind of a heavy rock groyne at Dolls Point. A lull hit his kite, it luffed and then powered up lifting him and throwing him fully powered onto the rocks where he spiral compound fractured his femur from hip to knee.

That was nearly three years ago, He has had multiple ops since, and he still has pain walking and has not kited since that day. Don't become one of my anecdotes. Be safe!

Steady winds and Peace,

Darren Marshall

Hope this answers your query
Bo
Bo
WA
192 posts
Bo Bo
WA, 192 posts
28 Feb 2005 10:57pm
quote:
using the board as a keel...

I agree with the comments about the unsafe onshore wind he practised in, however I think using the board as a keel for going upwind is the main point he tried to make/asked about. I'm a noob too and I'm using this method constantly to go upwind. As soon as I lose ground, I bodydrag upwind edging the board with my arm an body. Works great and saves me doing the walk of shame that I see the other learners do.

Bo
HungLong
HungLong
WA
859 posts
WA, 859 posts
1 Mar 2005 9:30am
hey nothing wrong with the walk of shame BO... we all have done it...

it's character building...

regards browneee
SHEPPO3930
SHEPPO3930
WA
106 posts
WA, 106 posts
1 Mar 2005 2:24pm
yeah the wind was onshore, i chose that particular location as the wind is more steady when onshore, with the cross shore the headlands make the wind turbulate and i find it very hard to control the kite with it bouncing around in the messed-up air.

my main question was about using the board as a Keel, and not what conditions to kite in. but whilst this thread has turned into a "wind direction" lesson, lets continue....

the breeze on that particular day was about 70deg to the shore (90deg being direct onshore) so it wasnt fully onshore when i was learning, it was probably the best possibe direction for clean wind (makes flying the kite easier) and i would get washed onto the shore if i pulled the safety and couldnt re-launch the kite, saves trying to self rescue or swim in.

i was a good 200m+ out when i was practicing my water-starts, i thought that was enuff room for a deserted beach...apart from my other kiter friends upwind of me.

i have a 2004 Cabrinha c02 with Recon and i am VERY familier with its operation (used it a few times in practice), i also can activate the QR or the RECON within a second if i need to. i have no problem flying the kite, just a problem staying on the board...i will get it eventually!

so a question...what would you "experienced" kiters call safe wind (???) when:

a) direct on-shore gives the cleanest wind to fly the kite, but the most danger for being dragged into the shore and objects.

b) side-shore makes learning the board easy cause of the safety zone downwind of you, however turbulance from headlands at each end of the beach (50m high cliffs x 10 for wind turbulance gives a 500m high, by 500m long patch of "dirty" air downwind of the headlands) makes flying the kite unpredictable and hard as it luffs and gusts alot.

c) off-shore is just a NO NO!

Would you answer a cross-on-shore? Best of both worlds?? Cause thats what i thought would be best, and so did my mates (who kite). PLease correct me if i am wrong.

just a n00b after a straigh answer, not a flaming
Surgeon
Surgeon
NSW
134 posts
NSW, 134 posts
1 Mar 2005 6:01pm
Howdy Sheppo, side shore is safest, cross onshore is ok too just make sure you've got a buffer i.e. launch your kite and get off the land The trouble with the land is that when things go south - ** happens real quik, I think from memory, that none of the fatalities in Australia have had the QR's activated coz it went pear shaped so quik???. Air offers very little resistance as you get loftily dragged the kite will power up more and more and you'll be whacked into something before you know what has happened. In the water you present heaps more resistance so the kite tends to work its way to the edge of the window even if it's tea-bagging you. You need to be careful as well coz dunes, hills n other ** make the wind do strange things like rise straight up etc. So if you do get dragged towards any of these landmarks you may well find your self in the company of birds and planes.

As KH said dead onshore is OK as long as you've got a boat or something and you maintain a safe buffer to the beach.
stoff
stoff
WA
248 posts
WA, 248 posts
1 Mar 2005 8:05pm
Surgeon, missed the part in kitehards post about it being safer to kite in onshore conditions if you have a boat. You've lost me with that school of thought. Just another thing to hit i reckon.

Sheppo, i'd like to offer the following advice if you are going to kite in onshore and or winterery conditions.

1. Learn how to use your quick release with your eyes closed, back to front, upside down and combinations of the above, it will save your life.
2. I've used your suggestion of the board as a fin and find it is a good method to get yourself out far enough before you put the board on and dive the kite. Very useful for locations like pinnaroo and leighton where it gets too deep to stand.
3.Places like mullaloo and scabs you can sometimes walk out far enough to safely dive your kite without dragging yourself onto the beach. But a definate black run due to the surf, especially in winter, no beginners. Just watch how everyone gets going on the north side of the fishermans groine at woodies for an example.
4. Learn how to use your quick release. I know i've already mentioned it but i cant stress it enough. More than once, thinking i've had a large safety buffer i've launched myself into a jump only to end up on the beach or close to it. If this happens, dont panic, land the jump as normal but as soon as you hit ditch the kite. Most accidents will happen from panicking and overstearing the kite or thinking you can hold onto a luffing kite.
Onshore conditions are also when the wind is most likely to go from 15 to 30 knots(or higher) in the blink of an eye. Most winter kiters would have experienced this and its not fun trying to get on the beach safely in onshore conditions, on a 12m kite, with no assistance in 30+ conditions. This is when knowing how to operate your quick release safely and not being afraid to use it is invaluable.

Having said all that,i've also had some awesome days in onshore winter conditions, so far from anyone being afraid to go out, just be carefull and try and go out with fellow kiters. Have fun!

Also, if you dont like your quick release system, try another one. Personally i didn't like the one on my lifts but i like the north system. Simple and so easy to use in an emergency.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply