Is this kite really this good?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
bennie
bennie
ACT
1258 posts
ACT, 1258 posts
20 Apr 2007 7:05pm
I have been reading about the Flysurfer P3 and it sounds like an outstanding kite. It would seem to have almost everything that I am looking for in a kite, Huge wind range(20 knots), huge boosts,exellent upwind ability, fast turning,huge depower, super easy water relaunch and self launch and landings,and because its a foil it packs up really small and lite. No pumping. Great for travelling.

But this could be all marketing hype. So I want to know from anyone who has ridden one, is this kite all its cracked up to be?

Also how does its performance compare to industry leading LEI's such as the north rebel and the switcthbade, Ion 2 ect. It would be great to hear from people that have experience on both LEI's and foils.

I am seriously thiinking about switching to foils. I never thought I would say that!

Bennie
cwamit
cwamit
WA
1194 posts
WA, 1194 posts
20 Apr 2007 5:33pm
I have a 5 meter pulse... sorry no pycho3, the wind range are way off the mark - 15 knots is not going to get you out as stated on the flysurfer charts and other web sites - 28 knots and it starts to become useful.. 30 to 40 and its fun. I also have a 10 meter rebel for comparison of a lei.

Haven’t used the pulse enough to give you a complete comparison... but it’s better than someone that sells them or only fly's foils or hasn’t flown a foil at all.

Launches really easy, self landing can be harder than my 5th line rebel because it’s so light it doesn’t want to land in high winds... even with the backstalling method. It comes with a 5th line setup which personally for me doesn’t install the most confidence to use for fear of tangles.

You need to be more careful when packing up a foil than with a normal bridle inflatable because of the complex bridles. I have only ever had one major tangle and wasn’t that long with sorting out. About 15 mins.

I think you really need to just buy one and then use it enough to appreciate it because it’s different from the lei. You shouldn’t be taken back though just because it’s not a mainstream kite design. It’s probably more to do with kite companies - profits - patents and a whole lot of other factors not related to actual performance. (I have nothing to base that on except lei hype)

Psycho is more aimed at the wake style market I think. Were pulse is freestyle and wave ridding which is my discipline.


I may get a 7 meter yet as a teaching kite because it’s less liable to fall apart when mistreated by students. (Note: not an instructor yet )



tobes
tobes
NSW
1000 posts
NSW, 1000 posts
20 Apr 2007 7:59pm
I've used the 13m P3, and own a 10m Pulse and 10 and 17 Speeds.
The points that I think might be exaggerations are
- the stated windrange, which is really from flatwater with a "door" to scarily powered.
- turning speed. Better than the older Flysurfers, but not the same as a tube kite.
- the depower is not really as much as a bow kite
Everything else is pretty much right.
"huge boosts,exellent upwind ability, super easy water relaunch and self launch and landings,and because its a foil it packs up really small and lite. No pumping. Great for travelling."
Add to that durable and cheap to repair...
If I was travelling light, a 10m P3 would be my weapon of choice. 12 - 25? knots with a kite that packs up not much bigger than a pump.
You're lucky enough to be in WA where Ian Young can let you demo one.
user
user
WA
1140 posts
WA, 1140 posts
20 Apr 2007 6:22pm
Nah,load of cobblers matey !

If you get one of them foil thingies you will be the odd one out !

Not to mention if you drop the bugah,it will probably get waterlogged.
crash
crash
WA
22 posts
WA, 22 posts
20 Apr 2007 8:51pm
nahh user hasn't flown a flysurfer. Tobes comments are right on the mark. Depower on the speed2 fully drops all power from the kite if you get yourself in a sticky situation
joespencer
joespencer
QLD
167 posts
QLD, 167 posts
21 Apr 2007 8:46am
hey tobes, does a 10 metre foil have the same power as a 10 m LEi, or do yo get a size smaller in foil than you normally would for a pumped kite ? e.g 10 m pulse =12 m rebel in traction??
robbo1111
robbo1111
NSW
656 posts
NSW, 656 posts
21 Apr 2007 9:12am
quote:
hey tobes, does a 10 metre foil have the same power as a 10 m LEi, or do yo get a size smaller in foil than you normally would for a pumped kite ? e.g 10 m pulse =12 m rebel in traction??


My 13m P3 has similar bottom end to a 16m Switchblade - that is that both can get going in about 10 knots, as was the case last weekend when me and the Cab were the only two able to stay on the water.

With my recently departed 10m Pulse it would be similar to 10-12m bow just slower turning.
tobes
tobes
NSW
1000 posts
NSW, 1000 posts
21 Apr 2007 10:20am
Yeah, it's basically about projected area, the foils are flat, the bows are pretty flat, the c's arent.
A 10m Flysurfer = 11-12m Bow = 13-15m C
joespencer
joespencer
QLD
167 posts
QLD, 167 posts
21 Apr 2007 11:30am
for a light wind option i have the 16 m SB2 cabrinha, but in gusty light conditions 10-15 knots-the kiting is very difficult with the delivery of the power- i find it hard to maintain any momentum with edge- 88 kgs with a 140 x46 board- i wondered if a large foil (-13-17 m flysurfer) would be less prone to the light wind lulls in between the gusts- the cab tends to fly out of the window, and then stall backwards, unless it is kept closer in by constant turns.
ianyoung
ianyoung
WA
649 posts
WA, 649 posts
21 Apr 2007 10:48am
bennie, come see for yourself - more than happy to give any competant kiter a test fly. Call me 0414 716 812 to make a time & place. I have lessons booked @ Peli Pt Sat & Sun arvo if you want to come down before or after.

Like all manufacturers the wind ranges published are from min upwind on average size board to almost being lofted. Having said that I have had safe fun on FlySurfer 10m Pulse, Psycho3 and Speed2's from 10-30 knots.

user, I've always found that it's always better to not say anything at all than to remove any doubt that you don't know what you're talking about - water relaunching has always been one of FlySurfer foils strengths.
joespencer
joespencer
QLD
167 posts
QLD, 167 posts
21 Apr 2007 3:11pm
does anyone know who would demo's flysurfers on the gold coast?
bennie
bennie
ACT
1258 posts
ACT, 1258 posts
21 Apr 2007 5:38pm
Thanks Ian, but I actually live on the central coast of NSW now. Do you know where I might be able to demo one in this area or Sydney?

I realize the the advertised wind range is the absolute maximum. I was thinking that with a P3 10m that 10-14knots would be on my surfboard 15-25 knots on my flx 132 and 25-30 knots on a high wind board around 120cm, would this be correct. Also I weigh 80kgs.

I am interested in a good all rounder kite that is solid for surfing and general freeriding. I also like kites that turn fast. Does this sound like the P3 or would the Pulse or speed2 suit my needs better?

One more Q, as I have only ever used LEI kites. One of my concerns about having a foil is that if for some reason I cannot relaunch, the kite will eventually sink. Is this true? and if so approx how long will it float for ? will I have enough time to be able to wind up my lines and get to the kite so I can get it back to shore ? It would really suck to lose a 2k kite!.
lovey
lovey
NSW
177 posts
NSW, 177 posts
22 Apr 2007 11:46am
I'm a die hard LEI fan, currently riding north rhinos, so i got nothing to gain by saying this -

DO NOT be worried about water relaunches with the foils - i've seen tobes drop his foil in the waves enough times, and never once seen anything that came close to a difficult relaunch. If anything he gets relaunched quicker than i can, although that's probably got more to do with my incompetance than anything.

As for it sinking...when you have a look at the construction, you'll see that the chambers self close when it hits the water...i'm sure tobes will have a better explanation for how it works...but they do stay afloat.

The only issue i think you'll have with the kite is all the ** you''ll cop for flying a doona - all you'd need is a board leash and a nappy harness to complete the look
tobes
tobes
NSW
1000 posts
NSW, 1000 posts
22 Apr 2007 12:04pm
Oh I've sunk em, but you've really got to try...
How's the aftermath lovey? Doesn't look like we'll get that southerly today...bummer.
ianyoung
ianyoung
WA
649 posts
WA, 649 posts
22 Apr 2007 10:14am
bennie, Tobes lives in Moruya and is such a cool guy if ask him nicely I wouldn't be surprised if he'd give you a test fly. Else keep hassling Steve @ Kitepower - he sold a few FlySurfer Warriors years ago - if there's enough demand in Sydney I'm sure he'll get demos & stock in again.

As far as kite selection: coming from a LEI you may not even notice the differences between the Pulse, Psycho3 and Speed2 to start with. I personally like the way the Speed2 flies the best but it is a high AR wing and not as stable as the other two. The Pulse has more depower and is easiest to flip over. The PS3 is the best all-rounder.

I've had a few beginners put a lot of water inside their kite by walking/swimming dragging their back through the water (this is easily prevented) you but I have NEVER heard of anyone sinking a FlySurfer.

As lovely said if you get one you will have to get used to being sledged by people who have never flown a FlySurfer ... but I've always thought that performance is more important than image and people who try to put others down for being different are just demonstrating their own flaws - unfortunately that's one of the main reason the planet is in such a mess.
tobes
tobes
NSW
1000 posts
NSW, 1000 posts
22 Apr 2007 1:09pm
I'm always happy to let anyone that knows what they're doing have a fly....

I bought my Flysurfers without a demo, based on reviews on the web, look at foilzone.com...and found the kites pretty much delivered as promised.

When I say sunk, I mean either eaten up by a big wave (pulse), or the Speed1 liked to take on water if it was leading edge down and a wave caught it. This happened once in an underpowered surf session. In either situation most LEI's would have been in trouble too.

Hey lovey, it's mostly the crossbow guys with the nappy harnesses and board leashes! Gives me a good idea though, we should have a retro session, we all bring our oldest worst gear and ride that, I've got a ballbreaking seat harness, a huge old TT and one of the first flysurfers, a Speedair....what do you reckon?
robbo1111
robbo1111
NSW
656 posts
NSW, 656 posts
22 Apr 2007 2:02pm
quote:
Do you know where I might be able to demo one in this area or Sydney?



Bennie, I usually kite at Brighton, on the bay. I have a 13m P3 and have just ordered an 8m. I'm happy to give you a demo but with summer over it's not so easy as my old bones don't like winter sailing anymore. Next time you're in Sydney i'll be happy to show you one in the flesh.
crowling
crowling
WA
10 posts
WA, 10 posts
22 Apr 2007 4:52pm
I have personally sunk a 5 metre maniac, but it took 20 minutes. Main issue with complicated bridle is occasionally if you put the kite down completely depowered the tip can twist inside the outer bridle (my 9.3 warrior did this too once, but i was close enough to shore to swim in and drag it in). If the twist is big enough, it will not relaunch (smaller kite, more of an issue).

The speed1 does this too, ask Jeremy who had the starboard 30 cm twisted yesterday after a crash following a jump. Jeremy was able to untwist his by pulling on the line when it was relaunched (took about 15 minutes though and it was not particularly directional during this time).

So saying, I am impressed with the speed 10 metre, and would expect all 3 of the fs machines to be well made, durable and fun.

Back in the warrior days the depower was like a C (not real good, especially if the front lines stretched), but I understand the new kites are better. I would be surprised if they were as good as say the cab bows and gk sonics for depower, but they relaunch even quicker. There was a tendency without the depower however to end up downwind a way from your board. I understand this is not the case with the pulse, and I could relaunch the speed without taking the board off the 10-12 knot day I tried Jeremy's. I was warmed up from a long walk back up the beach. How does the psycho3 compare Ian, I cannot find a good description of this on the net?

For speedair should I read mastair?
lovey
lovey
NSW
177 posts
NSW, 177 posts
22 Apr 2007 8:45pm
yeah, aftermath was sweet...still got 4 cartons of beer left, so you obviously didn't apply yourselves enough.

I'm all for the retro seesion...got a 14m 02 toro and a "wedgie-o-matic" fusion seat. Add a two piece dive suit, flouro zinc and an original pair of oakley frogskins and we're in business...

And that call about the bows is completely uncalled for...you'll start a turf war with that kind of comment
ianyoung
ianyoung
WA
649 posts
WA, 649 posts
22 Apr 2007 7:38pm
Chris/ Jeremy read http://members.iinet.net.au/~ianyoung/FS_tips.html for the technique on how to avoid wing-tip tangles and getting them out much quicker by reversing it down onto it's TE or in worst cases deliberatey crash the kite LE down then flipping it over - also read self-rescue, much better than dragging a kite through the water.

Speedair was the model before the Mastair in 2001. 7m Mastair was pretty unstable but had the power of 9.3 Warrior/10m current models.

The Psycho3 is more stable than the Speed2 but will tend to stall in light winds if fully sheeted in whereas the Speed2 just seems to accelerate when you sheet in. The PS3 also kiteloops (hooked or unhooked) really sweet - don't know if Lou Wainman ever pulled off that new trick though www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=20089 foilzone.com has some revues but why not call me to arrange a test flight and see for yourself?
crowling
crowling
WA
10 posts
WA, 10 posts
23 Apr 2007 9:27am
Hi Ian

The issue is if it will not relaunch, you cannot pull it towards you and untangling is nigh on impossible without letting one end go. Also flipping a challenge if it can't fly.

Swimming in a kite ok if you are near enough beach, but I chose life/safety from the reef at Pinnaroo. Kites/boards pretty cheap all things considered.

Jeremy not a beginner anymore, he has had experience with twisted foils (another brand, so as not to ignite anything) and I doubt he had enough control to do anything much different, I will have a word with him Tuesday and get him to post his opinion firsthand.

Is there some way we can practice the untangle/self rescue with a bowtie? Can we reproduce/prevent this event? Due to the wonderful easy relaunch, getting experience in alternative styles of launch would be difficult. I do not recall in 2 years of using them ever having to use the back lines to relaunch and only recall this tangle happening 2 or 3 times.

ianyoung
ianyoung
WA
649 posts
WA, 649 posts
23 Apr 2007 9:53am
I don't know how to deliberately bow-tie a kite but you could go down to Peli Pt or Melville where you can touch the bottom and get a mate to bow-tie it for you then practice the techniques.

You should NEVER pull a foil towards you - always go along the lines to the kite. If you can't relaunch it for any reason the next option is a self rescue as per my tips page.

I'd be happy to run a free clinic for Perth FlySurfer users and any others interested?
bennie
bennie
ACT
1258 posts
ACT, 1258 posts
23 Apr 2007 4:43pm
Tobes and robbo thanks for the offer of a demo, its very generous of you. But how is this, today I was having a session at my local and a guy that I have never seen before turned up with a 10m psycho 3. I didnt get to try it, but I am going to try it next week wind permitting. Turns out he is new to the area. How weird is that! I think thats called the law of attraction.

Ian thanks for the info. It is great having people like yourself to answer my questions.

Bennie
jeremy
jeremy
WA
202 posts
WA, 202 posts
23 Apr 2007 10:04pm
Ian ..If you ran a clinic for Flysurfers i would be interested. If you like i could video the specific manouveres you talk about in your website tips. You could then use them as downloadable videos from your website.

Despite my bridal tangle the other day i'm still very positive about flysurfers. The Speed 1 has allowed me to use a lower wind range previously unkitable for me .
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply