Problem changing P-lines on Slingshot REV2 kite

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
AlexB65
AlexB65
1 posts
1 posts
17 Jun 2011 10:42pm
Hello all,


I know the subject has already been adressed but I cannot continue the other topic cause it's too old..

I have used P-lines on my REV2 9m, I ordered new ones from Slingshot and received 197cm long ones which is ok length according to specs.
When I check on my kite, the old ones are only about 160cm long ! It's seems to be a very big difference. It's a second hand kite so i wonder if first owner changed it to shorter ones...

Any one can with REV experience tell me if putting the new ones could make the kite fly very differently ? Is it possible the P lines shrank about 40 cm ?
I am a bit scared to put the new ones I don't whant to have troubles on next session...

Thanks a lot for your help !
woodys
woodys
WA
218 posts
WA, 218 posts
18 Jun 2011 12:16am
AlexB65 said...

Hello all,

Any one can with REV experience tell me if putting the new ones could make the kite fly very differently ?
Is it possible the P lines shrank about 40 cm ?



Replacement P lines certainly will make a huge difference if the old ones are 40cm shorter.
P lines do reduce in length when they wear through the pulley rather than - as common sense would tell you - stretch.
I havent seen any 40cm shorter - that sounds extreme but up to 20 cm is common.

It may be the case that a previous owner got it wrong by matching new lines to the same length as the original (shortened) worn ones. If they have shortened again that could explain the drastic difference.
But if you have checked the specs on the SS website and they say 197 then you are pretty safe.

If you would like to do an extra check ring me at the shop tomorrow (bw 10 & 4) and I'll measure up another new set of matching P lines. Cant be wrong if all three come up with 197.
radman4
radman4
678 posts
678 posts
18 Jun 2011 7:19am
Rev 2 p-lines come in the following sizes,

7m 167.5
9m 197
11m 213
13m 233
15m 252.5

Sounds to me like someone has previously fitted a set of 7m lines to your 9m kite,so be carefull as they may have altered the rest of the setup to accomodate the 7m set,if the kite was flying properly before then it may pay to order a new set of 7m P-lines to replace yours,alternatively you might have to replace the whole bridal.
TOAD
TOAD
NSW
305 posts
NSW, 305 posts
18 Jun 2011 12:50pm
Might be time to replace your pulleys too . Get em' from "Whitworths boat and Leisure"
Robbo2099
Robbo2099
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
18 Jun 2011 11:47am
Yeah mate, they shorten pretty quickly too. After three months of only occasional use my REV2 P-lines shrank by 25cm. I've recently just replaced them with some dyneema lines (a bit of a trick involved to create the loops on the end, but easy once you know how) I haven't measured them yet to see if it will shrink less than the factory standard lines.

It makes a BIG difference in how the kite flies. You won't believe how different.

Make sure you use the right length lines -- for the same size kites the P-lines are different lengths between REV and REV2. Andy Regan had a good solution--he always sent me REV1 lines for my REV2, that were slightly longer, so you could put a figure of 8 knot in the line and it would shorten to the right length, then once it shrank, you took the knot out and could get more use out of it before you had to replace it. Thanks Andy, RIP mate.

Rob
ok
ok
NSW
1089 posts
ok ok
NSW, 1089 posts
18 Jun 2011 4:25pm
get new pulleys as well and make sure there not the **** standard ones and that they are bigger and the wheel on the pully is flat instead of the tight U shape.
Jedibrad
Jedibrad
NSW
527 posts
NSW, 527 posts
18 Jun 2011 5:25pm
With the old 'shrunk' lines the kite will waft or slide when you initiate a turn, then jerk thru the rest of the turn. Very smooth turning with the new lines.
puppetonastring
puppetonastring
WA
3619 posts
WA, 3619 posts
18 Jun 2011 4:14pm
Radmans advice is sound.
If someone has replaced 7M for 9M (or any other DIY job) (and thats a real possibility as 40cm shorter is way more than you could expect) then you want to be sure that replacing with the right lines trims the kite correctly.
If other homebaked 'things' have been done to accomodate shorter P lines you never know what you may be dealing with.

Take it in to any Slingshot shop for a check over - if you can.
If not measure each individual bridle line (all of them) and check with original specs.

And ditto to Robbo. Andy was a goldmine of great stuff like that. Lest we forget such a tragic loss.
BennyB12
BennyB12
QLD
918 posts
QLD, 918 posts
19 Jun 2011 12:19pm
Def change your pulleys. the red and white plastic ones chip with age and destroy your lines.I got stainless pulleys on mine and so far no probs. I had exactly the same prob, had the lines and pulleys replaced and now she flys as smooth as silk. Gotta love those rev 2,s, hands down the best kite ive ever flown.
djdojo
djdojo
VIC
1614 posts
VIC, 1614 posts
19 Jun 2011 4:05pm
Does anyone have an explanation of how a line under tension gets shorter?

It doesn't bother me, as I ride pulley-free kites, I'm just curious how it works.
GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
19 Jun 2011 7:08pm
^^^ clearly the scientific science of the situation makes it shorter!

(translation - great question, but I have no idea!)

Generally old ropes get monger not shorter due to fibres within the rope breaking, but the only three reasons I can think of that make a rope shorter are:

- The heat generated as the rope runs though the pulley shrinks the fibres
- The rope is getting twisted as it runs through the pulley
- a gnome comes and shortens the rope after each session [}:)]

I reckon it's the last one
ok
ok
NSW
1089 posts
ok ok
NSW, 1089 posts
19 Jun 2011 9:38pm
middle one galah
Mikedobee
Mikedobee
NSW
331 posts
NSW, 331 posts
19 Jun 2011 10:42pm
Hi all,

Now that is a big "aha moment" for me.

I bought a second hand kite (Rev 2 - 11 metres) and the pulley lines looked awful, therefore I called the local shop and bought them.

When I measured them, they were about 10-15 cm longer, thinking that they got it wrong. Now it makes perfect sense. And probably that's why the guys from the beach told me my kite looks like it lacks adjustment.

Thanks for bringing this up, AlexB65
Cheers
woodys
woodys
WA
218 posts
WA, 218 posts
20 Jun 2011 1:12am
Ur not an orphan there mikedobee.
Everyone comes in with 'P' lines that they have 'stretched' and needing new 'shorter' ones.
Definitely a bit of a mind-**** but thats the truth of it. Its not stretching thats the problem its the wear through the pulley.
Ive tried pulling some of the worn line apart to work out exactly what is happening to make it shrink. I am still left 'guessing' but I think its due to the lay of the original weaving of the chord loosening as if frays and twists through the pulley; all of which contributes to making it thicker. The looser, more frayed & twisted it becomes the fatter & shorter it gets.
Still doesnt follow logic of a line under tension - but its a fact.
Maybe a rope expert could enlighten us further?
RU there rumplestilsken?

- look out now for 'shorter fatter' lines from the 's - inevitable but always entertaining
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
20 Jun 2011 10:11am
woodys said...

Ur not an orphan there mikedobee.
Everyone comes in with 'P' lines that they have 'stretched' and needing new 'shorter' ones.
Definitely a bit of a mind-**** but thats the truth of it. Its not stretching thats the problem its the wear through the pulley.
Ive tried pulling some of the worn line apart to work out exactly what is happening to make it shrink. I am still left 'guessing' but I think its due to the lay of the original weaving of the chord loosening as if frays and twists through the pulley; all of which contributes to making it thicker. The looser, more frayed & twisted it becomes the fatter & shorter it gets.
Still doesnt follow logic of a line under tension - but its a fact.
Maybe a rope expert could enlighten us further?
RU there rumplestilsken?

- look out now for 'shorter fatter' lines from the 's - inevitable but always entertaining


The shortening happens because of the twists, its quite obvious when you look at it in the early stages of it happening. As it twists and gets thicker, it gets more worn and becomes thinner again which is why its not as noticeable as it becomes more worn. I had the same confusion, so I started tracking it after I put new p-lines on, you could see the twists after the first couple of sessions. Replacing the pulley's does help a little as the kite gets older though so if people are having issues with the lines shortening quite quickly, replace the pulleys and it should extend the life of the lines.
radman4
radman4
678 posts
678 posts
20 Jun 2011 9:26am
I'd be tempted to get some Dynema to replace the existing lines and make up my own if i was using these kites,its obviously a problem with the outer and inner core seperating and twisting,so a line with no core is prob gonna work way better,my kites have no core in the pulley lines and stay the same length all the time,seems far mor logical than continually replacing them.
TOAD
TOAD
NSW
305 posts
NSW, 305 posts
20 Jun 2011 11:53am
Not sure how true this is but, I was told once that as the pulley wears, the edges become sharp .It then cuts and pulls tiny pieces of thred through the line actually pulling the line shorter ???
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
20 Jun 2011 12:59pm
TOAD said...

Not sure how true this is but, I was told once that as the pulley wears, the edges become sharp .It then cuts and pulls tiny pieces of thred through the line actually pulling the line shorter ???


Not sure about that. I've actually seen the lines early on and from what I can see its primarily twist related. I.e. get a piece of string and twist it and you'll see it getting shorter the more you twist it. I am not discounting the sharp edges on the pulleys, but i think that affects the physical wear on the outer coating of the line than the shortening.
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
21 Jun 2011 6:34pm
+1 on twisting. twist a piece of rope and it shortens (occam's razor).run a piece of rope through a pulley at an accute angle with tension and it twists. P-lines are braided on a diagonal. the bit of rope that touches the pulley flattens out and due to the diagonal weave makes it want to twist. Revs do destroy pulley lines as their bridle was shorter than other kites of their time. But they were less likely to catch a tip and deathloop. If you want some ideas on some permanent fixes, check out a BWS Noise.
sebol
sebol
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
21 Jun 2011 11:52pm
It would have to be an awesome kite!!!!

Can anyone explain why you would purchase a rev when there is obviously a manufacturing fault if you need to replace lines.

I am sure that other kites will have stretching lines (seen it on a star kite and a cab) but it does not appear to be so conssistent. I won't get into the shrinking line theory!

Maybe I should try one one day.
yeehar
yeehar
101 posts
101 posts
22 Jun 2011 12:18am
For gods sake people learn to splice or at least tie knots.
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
22 Jun 2011 6:46pm
I once did a temp fix for a guy using a front slingshot line that was a spare for an emergency. He was stoked when he came back from his trip to get his P-lines. No twisting and the lines were hardly worn. I dont know the issues with regard to snapping with no warning but it certainly worked very well for a temp job.
Robbo2099
Robbo2099
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
23 Jun 2011 10:11am
yeehar said...

For gods sake people learn to splice or at least tie knots.



Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply