Wave Nationals Judging

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
LEWISS
LEWISS
NSW
335 posts
NSW, 335 posts
19 Jan 2007 8:15pm
I seriously think that it shouldnt matter if you're hooked in, unhooked, riding strapless or riding with straps of a surboard or kiteboard.

If you're ripping it up on a strapless board unhooked and someone is also ripping, but they're strapped and hooked, then STYLE should seriously be looked at. No point winning a comp if u looked like you were struggling but still doing the turns.

I personalyy think that the style of each rider should be considered.

Lewis
theultimategrinder
theultimategrinder
WA
17 posts
WA, 17 posts
19 Jan 2007 6:38pm
KiterDAN, I dont know if your trolling but either way take your hand off it.

If you think that when you are riding a wave on your surfboard that you are using only the power of the wave and none of the kite you are wrong. A kite wont be stable in the air unless there is some tension on the lines. Tension on the lines = pulling you along.

I agree with some of the other forum members in the sense that we are kitesurfers and that if we can do a move using both the power of the kite and the power of wave to make the move more powerful or more radical then why not.

On you other point DAN, if I do only one turn on a wave because it has closed out 10m from the shore (ie scabs) then I come in and turn around does that mean that I that I am not a "WAVEsailing".

In order for me to be a cool wavesailor should I follow my turn up with a "sick" foamclimb so that I can say that I did two moves on a wave.

If you want to ride a wave without using your kite just stick to surfing or buy a jet ski and do tow-ins. But remember if you do do tow-ins dont tow in any faster than you can paddle because then you are relying on the speed of the jet ski and you wont be classed as a "pure surfer".

Keep it real



ox
ox
WA
101 posts
ox ox
WA, 101 posts
19 Jan 2007 7:14pm
i think thats a pretty arrogant post dan, to assume that all twintip riders are reckless and heroes is to assume that all bow kite riders are amatuers...

And as i recall it, last year in esperance it was me riding a strapless surfboard and you on the twintip asking me what it was like... you converted pretty quickly i see.
Dont wanna get into a verbal belting though, i just think that what you are describing is very close to surfing itself, it is already defined as a sport. Lets push all areas of kiteboarding as see where we can develop it, rather than isolate wave riding to just one board type.
But heck im not even going in the damn comp, good luck and fun fun if you are, and well done to the organisers
kiterdan
kiterdan
WA
680 posts
WA, 680 posts
19 Jan 2007 9:34pm
A verbal sling match...good-o!

Yeah Ox, I have converted. I'm heading to esperance on the weekend so might see you out?

I said twintip riders were reckless?? I said a number of intermediates, not all...just some certain individuals. And that comment is only from what I've seen at brighton and what was relayed to me by some surfer mates who sometimes have to share the water with the cooler ones. Sorry if that came across as arrogant...it's just sort of tied into the boardsport acceptance issue but more importantly, might be a major access issue in the future.

UltimateGRINDER, don't take it so seriously mate. It's only my opinion...don't like it? Don't care. My hand will still be on it.
I agreed that there is room for a seperate category of wavesailing because there's obviously a division of opinions (and probaly always will be). And by the way, if the conditions are right, you can have minimal to no pull in the kite i.e. it momentarily luffs. Not that I ever said you HAVE to rely solely on the power of the wave...this is kitesurfing right? (I'm pretty sure I said that, too).
And just to dig myself into a nice big hole, no I wouldn't call that wavesailing!

Apologies if I come across as arrogant. I was only trying to relay info from what I've found from using surfboards if anyone was interested.

And I'll say it again for the illiterate ULTIMATEgrinder,
As long as your having fun, and your not hurting anyone or claiming it, you're a champ!

Cheers
DAN (with capitals)

By the way, stop hiding behind an alias forum name when you want to have a go at someone or something. Its kind of pathetic. Fun! but pathetic...
sir ROWDY
sir ROWDY
WA
5378 posts
WA, 5378 posts
19 Jan 2007 11:19pm
lol, this just shows how gay waveriding is.
BigDasa
BigDasa
WA
47 posts
WA, 47 posts
20 Jan 2007 4:06am
quote:
Originally posted by Kitepower Australia

Just curious about what people think about the way these sorts of wave only events should be judged?


Dear All my 2 cents, rounded up to 5 cents worth

Preface.
Kite wave riding is a new sport and the concept of overall flow, progression and style should be judged while riding a wave. When wave is gone or you are not riding it, your not being judged. Equipment choice should be limited to Whatever Kite + Whatever Board you want reall easy .

Here's a thought lets have a new sport called Freestyle Kite Wave Riding any board, any kite. SMS voting looser leaves at the end of each week [}:)]

Is it important to weight the judges scores to show whether a rider is strapped or unstrapped.
Do we get size, weight, height, heart rate, etc as well ? Seriously

Can riders on twin tips enter or even win this sort of event?
If you can ride wave on a log, you should be in ?

Is it important that judges have any knowledge of kiting or that judges know how to kite themselves?
Good judges are those who are consistent and turn up from my experience. Yes would be good if they know what we are doing.

If preference is towards unstrapped, should jumping be given any points at all?
I think this is splitting hairs, go back to over all impression. If you have too many rules, no one will bother. Or to put it another way

If you make too many rules they will leave !!!

Appologies to Field of Dreams "If you build it, they will come."


Are back/forward rolls/loops recognised and awarded points?
What about other tricks?
What about unhooked Vs hooked?

See above sounds like a previous rephrased. Physc. Major anyone

Any other important issues judges and organisers need to be aware of.?

How I see it.
Good wave riding is about the flow and critical sections. I've been kite wave riding for over 7 years and have used directional, mutant (strapped and unstrapped), twin tip and other boards.

At the momement I use an asymetrical twin tip on reef and beack breaks. I have the most fun on over head high reef breaks and I really enjoy my wave riding.

I feel I have flow, one turn into another and mostly in the cricial section of the wave.

I used to compete in Wave Ski [}:)] riding in another life (I can still hear surfers screaming, but no I knew the rules, shared the waves, even got respect at my local break back then).

I remember Wave Ski 1987 Nationals we had everyone from all over OZ at Margrets WA, few rules, lots of great people (mums, dads, uni students, tradies, blue colar, yupies all sorts) and lots of fun. After that too many rules, all got a bit too hard, debates over channels, fins, paddles, style

So don't let it happen to kite surfing.
NSW, 4382 posts
20 Jan 2007 10:40am
quote:
Originally posted by theultimategrinder


If you think that when you are riding a wave on your surfboard that you are using only the power of the wave and none of the kite you are wrong. A kite wont be stable in the air unless there is some tension on the lines. Tension on the lines = pulling you along.


TRUTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

quote:
Originally posted by theultimategrinder



I agree with some of the other forum members in the sense that we are kitesurfers and that if we can do a move using both the power of the kite and the power of wave to make the move more powerful or more radical then why not.


And if a person chooses to use a board with straps, to enhance the power of their moves even more, why should they be at a disadvantage to a person who chooses to be more "pure", less radical, and less powerful, and who utilises kitepower less ???????????????
I thought this sport was called KITEsurfing, not brownnoseingtosurfing
(no offence meant to the great sport of surfing and all soulsurfers)

quote:
Originally posted by theultimategrinder



If you want to ride a wave without using your kite just stick to surfing or buy a jet ski and do tow-ins. But remember if you do do tow-ins dont tow in any faster than you can paddle because then you are relying on the speed of the jet ski and you wont be classed as a "pure surfer".

Keep it real




Yep, keep it real, and keep it kitesurfing.

Cya and

Good winds amd waves

Steve
angie pangi
angie pangi
QLD
1782 posts
QLD, 1782 posts
20 Jan 2007 10:17am
yes kite surfing, use the kite to get you on the the wave and then just surf the wave that's kitesurfing.

Just a question but who would win a surfing comp if a guy went with straps and busted an air and then a guy went out without straps and did an air not as big who would win. for me the winner is the guy without straps because of the extra skill factor.

How do people want the sport to go if we end up wearing straps on our surfboards then expect it to go the same way as freestyle with double mobes of the lip and **** like that, if we follow the surfing path then style and technique has more to do with it.

Please don't get me wrong staps have there place if you have never surfed they are a great way to start out and get the feel for it.
paul
ox
ox
WA
101 posts
ox ox
WA, 101 posts
20 Jan 2007 10:19am
quote:
yes kite surfing, use the kite to get you on the the wave and then just surf the wave that's kitesurfing

No thats tow in. Try it its fun

i agree paul, two airs, the unstrapped gets my vote too. Does that mean you shouldnt be allowed to ride a strapped board? What about an underpowered carve on an unstrapped board against a perfectly timed air off the lip at the critical point of the wave on a strapped board? Surely this is progressing the sport more, or are we all about impressing the surfers?

quote:
5. Unstrapped riding will be rewarded as requiring higher skill.


why should unstrapped be automatically given extra points for doing 1 carve the same as a strapped rider? As i said previously, if the unstrapped does a move that warrents extra points, then give them, just dont assume they have a higher skill levels before the contest, keep it fair!

quote:
How do people want the sport to go if we end up wearing straps on our surfboards then expect it to go the same way as freestyle with double mobes of the lip and **** like that, if we follow the surfing path then style and technique has more to do with it.


I agree the surfing side is great, but this can be achieved using straps in certain conditions too, so why limit our boards, just let all boards be used, the most progressive style will be awarded and eventuate. Theres no need to force the sport a certain way. And no need to write off other styles just because you are worried that you may choose a strapless board to be cool and get beaten by someone chosing the right board for the conditions.

quote:
if you have never surfed they are a great way to start out and get the feel for it

Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha. Nice one

Ox
angie pangi
angie pangi
QLD
1782 posts
QLD, 1782 posts
20 Jan 2007 11:40am
If we wear straps way not just call it kiteboarding on a wave.

We do really need to sit down and sort out a proper judging criteria for wave riding to stop this same topic going around and around,then ever one knows where they stand before they go in to the comp. Might stop some of the bitching.
congo abrezio
congo abrezio
NT
285 posts
NT, 285 posts
20 Jan 2007 11:33am
should just use the kite to get on the wave then once ur on it ditch your kite and just surf it normally. then when u get back to shore go fetch ur kite and kite back out n do it again.
RayQ
RayQ
WA
638 posts
WA, 638 posts
20 Jan 2007 4:31pm
And these days we might all just be suckers or pawns.
The big pic. is that if kiting can be assimilated to surfing eg ( take your surfboard , which you allready own) , and just add a kite, you instantly have tapped into a hugh existing market.
We are closing in on the agenda.

Ray
NSW, 4382 posts
20 Jan 2007 6:56pm
quote:
Originally posted by angie pangi

yes kite surfing, use the kite to get you on the the wave and then just surf the wave that's kitesurfing.


No thats surfing or tow in surfing. If the kite is kept flying it is pulling you and you need to do things on the wave to keep the kite flying, that skill is definitely called KITE surfing.

G'day Paul, thanks for your input. These are my replies to what you have said.

quote:
Originally posted by angie pangi


Just a question but who would win a surfing comp if a guy went with straps and busted an air and then a guy went out without straps and did an air not as big who would win. for me the winner is the guy without straps because of the extra skill factor.


For me it would be the style, exhibited by each rider, and also the height, tweaks, etc, but according to the current judging rules the jump would need to take off from the critical section of the wave and be landed back on the same wave in a similar critcal section, otherwise it would not be scored. Thats the rules, which is fair enough.
The unstrapped rider has little chance of doing a biggish air, and landing it on the same wave, the strapped rider has a better chance and it would require a greater degree of synchronised kite and board handling skills to do it, and would probably not only pull it off but would score better and win.

quote:
Originally posted by angie pangi


How do people want the sport to go if we end up wearing straps on our surfboards then expect it to go the same way as freestyle with double mobes of the lip and **** like that, if we follow the surfing path then style and technique has more to do with it.


Hang on isn't a mobe stylish?
Isn't handle passing, expecially in the critical section of a wave face technique??
Surfing is surfing, I know it well, grew up surfing from the age of 7yo, loved it until leg ropes and the crowds.

Kitesurfing is kitesurfing, it has its own style, and technique, and should be allowed to develop without trying to make it appealing to surfers and the kite industry people trying to attract even more people into our already becoming overcrowded sport!


quote:
Originally posted by angie pangi


Please don't get me wrong staps have there place if you have never surfed they are a great way to start out and get the feel for it.
paul



Thats a pretty biased way of saying you value strapped riding less than unstrapped Paul. Would you go out in double overhead, perfectly peeling reef shoulder waves, but with occassionla close out sets, unstrapped?
Would you expect to be given a bias in a comp if you did, even though you did not attack the waves as much as a well syncronised (with powerful, aggressive, flowing, stylish combinations of kite and board movements) kitesurfer on a strapped board.??

If there are enough people to run a totally unstrapped only event do it, otherwise take out the judging bias and let all riders compete on a level playing field.

Its nonsense that it takes more skill to ride unstrapped, its more about unstrapped riders wanting to penalise strapped riders because they can't lose their board as much and can get more waves, isn't it?

Judges of kitesurfing events need to be kitesurfers, and should be chosen from the most experienced, proven, volunteers.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve

sir ROWDY
sir ROWDY
WA
5378 posts
WA, 5378 posts
20 Jan 2007 5:36pm
this is a load of sh#t!! the whole unstrapped/strapped business has got way out of hand, it should be scored on who has the most style and is ripping (in the pocket) the hardest the only time a strapped/unstrapped decision should come into play is if two people did an air of the same height and score then the unstrapped rider should win.
p.s. if you went out in a surfing comp strapped and did a rodeo clown (of course it will be in the pocket, this being the only variable needing to be taken into consideration when juxtapositioning it against kitesurfing) you will for sure beat someone else who has done just a normal air unstrapped.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
20 Jan 2007 9:40pm
quote:
Originally posted by RayQ

And these days we might all just be suckers or pawns.
The big pic. is that if kiting can be assimilated to surfing eg ( take your surfboard , which you allready own) , and just add a kite, you instantly have tapped into a hugh existing market.
We are closing in on the agenda.

Ray



RayQ shines some light onto the Industry's evil masterplan.
A cunning plan that is thinnly disguised as style-policing.
That twin-tips are gay in waves,
and that strapless surfboards are way more styley.

Don't be fooled by this fashion distraction.
The real agenda is the mega-expansion of the corporate kite empire.

Can surfers ever be convinced that windslop is cool ?
That's the debate.
It's really a hate debate....
Cause surfers generally hate wind.

Nevertheless, the Industry continues to beaver on, scheming, scheming.
And once surfers are convinced that windslop is very cool,
the surf market has been fully penetrated.
Success.
Billabong harnesses....
coming to a surf shop near you.
Keahi
Keahi
QLD
853 posts
QLD, 853 posts
20 Jan 2007 10:44pm
I agree with lewis and rowdy.
LEWISS
LEWISS
NSW
335 posts
NSW, 335 posts
21 Jan 2007 12:17am
ofcourse u do keahi!!!
LouD
LouD
WA
642 posts
WA, 642 posts
20 Jan 2007 11:50pm
Slave!!!!? -at last. Thought you had died!
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
21 Jan 2007 9:11am
So good to have you back Slave....right on, well said................where's my tee shirt?

Some kids start a kite clothing company, one would think that perhaps they could make something people would want to buy.............like a Waveslave tee shirt.
mahadev
mahadev
NSW
46 posts
NSW, 46 posts
21 Jan 2007 2:36pm
No doubt JB hit the nail on the head. Once the judging criteria is set then the equipment should not matter. Over a period of time the equipment that performs the best to the judging criteria will become the standard automatically. I am also a little sceptical that the industry maybe trying to drive the sport in a certain direction. After all we are a very minor sport and it is really our own industry that suppliers all of the sponsorship.
I know from my own personal experience of judging 4 world championships. The French, the American, the Japanese, and the Australian, and judging the all-American sport kite championships. As well as countless Australian national and state championships. You are never going to please everybody. But the one thing that is needed is an exact and clear cut criteria for the judging. And this information is passed on to the competitors well in advance. The rest will take care of itself

Cheers Bob Dawson
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
21 Jan 2007 12:53pm
Agreed mahadev.

My thought is let the crowd decide, best show on waves wins. Sometimes at comps. I have a feeling that the judges are too busy counting points and never see what the crowd really likes. My experience of being to kite comps. is limited though.

Having the crowd choose the rankings is coming I believe....if not already here. Scoring could be 50% what the judges like and 50% what the crowd likes.........crashes would cancel: judges score 0%...crowd score 100%
NSW, 4382 posts
21 Jan 2007 6:39pm
We may as well add judge biases or scores weighting for Bow/high depower kite or C kite use, line lengths and brand, wax type and thickness, how much bum crack your short show and what brand they are, etc!!!

And now the lines get blurred even more, that Predator surf straps are on the market (Sean Phillips the inventor just dropped off some stock).
Are they things straps or not?

I don't think so, they are so unique and specially designed evolved for KITEsurfing but it is bullsh1t that they probaly will be classed as straps and someone like Sean would be at a disadvantage if he uses them at the Nats - if he can be bothered to go.

There is no way you can attack a wave as hard or with an aggressive flowing style unless you use some sort of straps, let AKSA and the Wave NATIONALS organisers know!

Its the National KITEsurfing titles!
And the most experienced, kitesurfers only, volunteer judges should be judging IMO.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve
Blownaway
Blownaway
QLD
776 posts
QLD, 776 posts
21 Jan 2007 11:15pm
Just have no rules other than you have to go hard or go home, to much regulation = NO FUN

style is everything, keep it smooth an fast, strapped or unstrapped, whateva looks best wins !!
smegma
smegma
2 posts
2 posts
21 Jan 2007 11:18pm
Why would you score an unstrapped rider higher than a strapped rider it's just stupid!
the unstrapped rider has a natural advantage of bein able to move his feet freely on the board.
and the disadvantage of looking like a kook when he can't stay planted.
What is this misguided and pathetic eliteism that makes some believe there is an intrinsic value in riding unstrapped?
Eventually this whole issue will become totally irrelevant.
Why prolong the inevitable?
Happy
Happy
NSW
98 posts
NSW, 98 posts
22 Jan 2007 8:48pm
what is the advantage of riding unstrapped? its not like u ever move ur feet when on a wave.

to earn respect from surfers they dont want to see a lame attept of their sport they want something diffrent e.g. freestyle moves off the lip, widsurfing wouldnt have harf the credit they do now if it wasnt for the airs they do off the lip when their waveriding.


so why not see a double backmobe of the lip???
JEFFERSON
JEFFERSON
WA
72 posts
WA, 72 posts
23 Jan 2007 12:00am
The guys who are riding unstrapped are not making a pathetic attempt to be cool and trying to be like surfers. Most of them ARE surfers and just want to enjoy what is familiar to them. Whats the harm in that? Why all the angst towards them?

To compare strapless riding at this point is unreasonable. Not may guys have been at it for very long and as such this side of the sport is still in it's infancy.

Of course the kite surfing industry will generally not like the idea that you don't have to pay $1200 for a board. Just use an existing surfboard ($750 max.)... buy a second hand kite for $500 and you are kiting. There is no mark up in that.

Back to the point though, just judge what you see. Judging sports such as kiting will alweays be totally subjective. All contest organisers can do is attempt to get judges that are experienced enough at all types of riding to be able to judge as fairly as possible. If you can't accept that fact them don't go in comps.
waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
23 Jan 2007 1:09am
quote:
[i]Originally posted by JEFFERSON
Just use an existing surfboard ($750 max.)... buy a second hand kite for $500 and you are kiting.





It sounds simple, doesn't it ?

I'll buy a cheap kite and then use my ol trusty 6 footer,
and bingo,
I'm wavekiting.
But only simple for the truely gifted kitefreak.

The average surfer wanting to wavekite will need to take the standard route,
along the tricky learning curve of kitesurfing.
Welcome to the newbie zoo, brother.
Don't feed the animals.

The destination may be clear as NW crystal,
but the journey to wavekiting nirvana is littered with tangles and numerous dodge kiteboards.

But once the kitepath has been chosen,
the search becomes endless.

Kitesurf the wave,
don't surf the image.
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
23 Jan 2007 2:26am
helooooo, waveslave!?!?!?

have you turned into some kind of profetic monk?

kitesurfing is a good but subjective sport.


judging it is another matter, that it is hard to divide between "subjective, progressive"

aaargh! still no firm rules!
strapped
strapped
NSW
171 posts
NSW, 171 posts
23 Jan 2007 4:04pm
What a topic strapped or unstrapped most of us have tried both and then decided to settle on one style because it felt right. We all started kitesurfing in the beginning for the jumps and when I was riding my surfboard unstrapped I missed this aspect and the control going out through the whitewater but then when I rode strapped I missed stalling, carves and being able to reposition my feet to suit the wave. So now I have Predator surfstraps that allow me to do both. If I ride out with my feet in the straps, catch a wave move my back foot to the tail out of the strap, what class do I fit into?
JB
JB
NSW
2232 posts
JB JB
NSW, 2232 posts
23 Jan 2007 5:21pm
Wow, hasn't this thread blossomed! (BTW, I know I can't spell)

I think there is alot of people getting defensive and critical about aspects that don't really matter. Wave riding, or Wave kiting or what ever you wish to discribe it as, should be judged on the performance given, using the riders skill, knowladge and wave sence to produce the best ride they can! There shouldn't be any difference if the rider has long or short hair, 2 fins or 9, the moves will all look diferent! and thus be scored different, and this difference will be how that style,power and performance appealed to that perticular judge! Even with a large team of judges that have all had the same judging breifing will have different ideals of what is good and what is better!

If a kiter just uses the kite to get on the wave then just lets it fall out of the sky, their ride will look shyt! and their score will show that! I don't think you need to be a kiter to know that someone drowning trying to relaunch their kite isn't wave riding!

Now on the flip side, someone who uses enough kite power to make sure they are always hitting the lip well powered and with speed throwing buckes of water everywhere will look much more impressive and their score will show this too! but not because the judges were watching the kite go back and forth, but because the rider performance on the wave would show this extra power!

I like to look at kiteboarding as being a way of adding a 4th dimention to surfing, it allows us to have our own power sorce separate to the wave. I think it should be the way which we are able to conbine to too, capturing the better qualities of both in power and style that should make a perfect ride!

Anyway, what eva tickles your pickle! If your not smiling at the end of the day.... You're doing it wrong!!

JB
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply