What Happened????

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
sebol
sebol
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
26 Feb 2010 10:29am
So we get classified as Highly dangerous activity by the Joondalup council who decides to enforce a ban and park us in restricted areas and not a word from WAKSA?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Am i missing something?????
Did you guys represent us, are you challenging the decision???
This will be closely scrutinised by other councils and surely WAKSA is doing something???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Even if you do, the lack of communication to your members is very poor.
I respect that you are volonteers but if you decide to represent all the kiters then you should do just that.
Hope to hear some sort of comment soon or you can kiss good bye to my future membership.
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
26 Feb 2010 11:14am
Good question.....
Enjoy the good ole' days while they last....
As far as an opinion on the thread..... Err, this one's a doozy.
GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
26 Feb 2010 7:46pm
Do you mean this: www.inmycommunity.com.au/
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
26 Feb 2010 5:22pm
As I said............
enjoy the good ole' days...... This will set a precident all over Australia. And again thanks to all those safety conscious, proactive wankers who over the past years saw this coming, and knew the lasaiz-fare attitude was doomed to failure......

What is WAKSA's/AKSA's public comment/opinion on the proposal, as isn't this exactly the type of scenario that is in the charter?



JOONDALUP Council has voted to release for six weeks of public comment a draft beach management plan outlining restrictions on kite surfing and changes to animal exercise areas.
The plan was developed in response to complaints and petitions about competing recreational activities, car park access, vandalism, antisocial behaviour and the condition of coastal paths.

It aims to provide an “umbrella” management framework to help the City manage and develop its coast from Burns Beach to Marmion.

“In recognising that many organisations, groups and individuals may be affected by the City’s position on beach management, development of the draft plan involved some preliminary consultation with a number of stakeholders and beach user groups,” Mayor Troy Pickard said.

The plan identified three focus areas – infrastructure, management and development – with 32 issue statements suggesting actions to resolve or manage concerns.

Under the plan, restrictions would apply to “highly conflicting” water and beach-based activities, such as animal exercising, kite surfing, water skiing and freestyle jet skiing, with designated areas and exclusion zones set out.

Kite surfing restrictions would apply at beach launching and landing areas at North Mullaloo south of West View Boulevard to Korella Street and at Pinnaroo Point north and south of the John Wilkie Tarn Access Path.

Kite surfing exclusion zones would extend north, south and west of Mullaloo and Sorrento surf lifesaving clubs, while animal exercising would be limited to an area north of the Ern Halliday camp site underpass.

Water skiing would be restricted to an area designated by the Department of Transport and freestyle jet skiing would be banned within 200m of the coast and in the water skiing area.

Cr Trona Young commended the City for its “forward thinking” on the plan, which is the first to be considered by a local government council.

Mayor Pickard said the consultation period was a wonderful opportunity to engage the community on a range of issues that would provoke a range of responses.

“The draft plan identifies factors likely to have an impact on the public’s enjoyment of beaches, the preservation of the coastal environment and lastly, on the maintenance of paths, parks and community buildings, which are the City’s responsibility,” he said.

“Kite surfing and the animal exercise areas are two issues that have generated the most community interest in the past and the City is expecting significant community feedback on the options proposed in the draft plan to deal with these matters.”
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
26 Feb 2010 8:10pm
dave...... said...


What is WAKSA's/AKSA's public comment/opinion on the proposal, as isn't this exactly the type of scenario that is in the charter?


WAKSA is working on this flat out. Public comment will be made as soon as a clear position and plan of action is determined. Just because they haven't said anything yet doesn't mean they're ignoring it.
lemming
lemming
WA
75 posts
WA, 75 posts
26 Feb 2010 7:19pm
WAKSA and Mullaloo Kiters User Group have been proactive into feeding into this process. The council from all of our input have come up with this proposal which is not aligned with our suggestions, however it does still allow kitesurfing on Mullaloo Beach. What you are probably not aware of is that there is a huge number of local residents who want kitesurfing banned completely and are actively campaigning people to feed into the consultation process. You may argue that the scenario laid out in the beach management plan is far from ideal, but in relation to a complete ban (which is a very real possibility) this is a reasonable compromise in my personal opinion, especially given Mullaloo is the 3rd busiest beaches in Perth.

Lots more information about how you can help the cause to maintain kiting on Mullaloo will be available shortly.

Regards
Dave
Mullaloo Kiters User Group
Bigwavedave
Bigwavedave
QLD
2057 posts
QLD, 2057 posts
26 Feb 2010 9:23pm
Hey Sebol,

You were very quick to be on the offensive to WAKSA on Seabreeze.

Just a couple of questions:

Did you actually contact WAKSA at their email address?

Did you offer any help?

Sometimes it's better to take 3 deep breaths, count to ten, and then deal with an issue in a better way. (I really don't think they care if one member doesn't pay his $65)

It is very disheartening for a volunteer in any organisation to have your work publicly questioned or criticised in a forum with no way to respond. It undermines any desire to continue donate time and effort to your chosen sport.

Just an observation.. maybe it's nicer to take a different approach. Before going off half-cocked, show a little consideration for those who bust their arses to keep this sport relatively unrestricted.






sebol
sebol
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
26 Feb 2010 8:28pm
No I have not contacted WAKSA and no I did not offer any help.

I am simply deeply troubled that our suposedly representative body has not bothered to come out with any plan of action or at least a simple reply.

Maybe a blank e-mail to all members advising of the findings or maybe some sort of a draft proposal to the council??????

Nothing, blank, nada, niente ,zilch

We are talking about our right to enjoy our favorite sport here, wake up.

I live and kite in Scarb and only occasionaly kites at Mullaloo or Pinnaroo so I am not even a local, I can see however how this decision will have long bearing implications for the future of kiting in any metropole and I am deeply concerned that those bans will prevent my children from sharing my passion.

If you do require some assistance however, I am definately willing to participate to the best of my capabilities.

But you must be right, I am just an agro being with deep rooted personal issues.
Sorry for expressing my concern and I hope that you enjoy living in your cave until you get kicked out for CO2 damage to the rock structures.

Peace brother
Bigwavedave
Bigwavedave
QLD
2057 posts
QLD, 2057 posts
26 Feb 2010 10:49pm
You are right to be concerned but I'm sure that more is being done by WAKSA than you think.

I wasn't criticising you. Just reminding you that seabreeze general forum is not the place to vent or be negative about hard working volunteers.

They have a website and seabreeze has a separate forum for WAKSA questions that one of the volunteers monitors.

Just trying to keep things positive. Expressing concerns in a negative way only results in the volunteers quitting. Then you in the west are up sh1t creek.

Peace to you too
Longers
Longers
WA
54 posts
WA, 54 posts
26 Feb 2010 8:55pm
take it easy guys and get with the program - this is serious. we need to work together and support each other - sebol and big wave dave; seems you guys are totally on the same page. There must be some kiters out there who have some experience in local govt law and/or planning processes. we should all be offering to help and put together a coherent rersponse from kiters - the NSW body was really helpful when the issue of mandatory flotation devices was raised and if you guys work together I'm sure you can come up with a similar response. Contact the councillors directly - meet with them - get a handle on whats pressing their buttons and formulate a strategy that appeases them and protects our rights etc etc - will be watching closely
spot1
spot1
WA
1588 posts
WA, 1588 posts
26 Feb 2010 9:36pm
well done dave keep up the good work if i can help with somthing just pm me
sebol
sebol
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
26 Feb 2010 9:55pm
Seebreeze is by far the largest medium related to kite surfing and if there is any way to raise your voice and express an opinion, I don't see why due to political correctness, I should purposefully avoid the one place where I may be heard???

No agro, mate, I appreciate your concern and as stated above, I was very impressed with the pdf I read in regards to flotation devices in NSW.

I am however concerned at the lack of reaction in WA.
Seing the amount of kites doing the downwinder from floreat to Scarb on the week end, we could surely get our voice heard if we pulled together.
And the one organisation that has the means to coordinate this action is WAKSA so I will await full of optimism.
lemming
lemming
WA
75 posts
WA, 75 posts
27 Feb 2010 12:11am
Sebol,

Please pm me with you phone number and I will call you over the weekend. Mullaloo Kiters and WAKSA have both been working on this issue ever since the council meeting last year proposing a ban. Yes there has been a lull of activiity whilst we awaited the release of the beach management plan, and now it has been released we need all WA kiters to actively get involved to help prevent a total ban of kitesurfing on Mullaloo. I know I can speak for all Mullaz kiter and WAKSA when I say that any assistance you can provide would be more than welcomed. With Kitestock last weekend, the timing of this plan was not ideal and that may be why it appears that nothing is happening. We will be holding a meeting at some point (TBC) this week which I hope you can attend, and then there is a public consultation meeting on the 10th March at Mullaloo Surf Lifesaving Club which I also hope you can attend as we need as many people as possible to show up.

Cheers
Dave
Mullaloo Kiters User Group
sebol
sebol
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
27 Feb 2010 1:13am
Sweet, I hope all the Scarbs kiters will tag along.
richswing
richswing
WA
724 posts
WA, 724 posts
28 Feb 2010 3:13pm
Well, I think we should do a peaceful march/rally if this ban goes through and show these people the numbers that they could be affecting - much more than the jetskiers would ever be and try to overturn the ruling.

VIVA Kitesurfing, VIVA freedom of speach and suppress the chains of suppression.

If this doesn't work, we can go Toi Toiing and smashup everything - it works in some countires.

But I am being serious, we have to fight this before it sets the presedence for everywhere else.

Peace
Rich
ApatheticEnd
ApatheticEnd
WA
995 posts
WA, 995 posts
28 Feb 2010 3:36pm
How about we work on prevening a ban first.

If it does pass though, how about rigging 100 kites and just leaving them on the beach on a saturday in protest. Or better yet, 100 kites on the water.
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
28 Feb 2010 4:41pm
GreenPat said...

dave...... said...


What is WAKSA's/AKSA's public comment/opinion on the proposal, as isn't this exactly the type of scenario that is in the charter?


WAKSA is working on this flat out. Public comment will be made as soon as a clear position and plan of action is determined. Just because they haven't said anything yet doesn't mean they're ignoring it.


Obviously WAKSA is working on this flat out that is why I asked the question.......... 5 weeks to go....
RayQ
RayQ
WA
638 posts
WA, 638 posts
28 Feb 2010 5:33pm
sebol said...

So we get classified as Highly dangerous activity by the Joondalup council who decides to enforce a ban and park us in restricted areas and not a word from WAKSA?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Am i missing something?????
Did you guys represent us, are you challenging the decision???
This will be closely scrutinised by other councils and surely WAKSA is doing something???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Even if you do, the lack of communication to your members is very poor.
I respect that you are volonteers but if you decide to represent all the kiters then you should do just that.
Hope to hear some sort of comment soon or you can kiss good bye to my future membership.


Good questions, WAKSA has been working on the Mullaloo issue for a while. Unfortunately the opposing group has a lot of destructive energy, this will take all the help kiters can offer to this cause, but it will have to be a concerted effort, so save your breath, you may need it.
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
28 Feb 2010 7:43pm
sebol said...

So we get classified as Highly dangerous activity by the Joondalup council who decides to enforce a ban and park us in restricted areas and not a word from WAKSA?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Am i missing something?????
Did you guys represent us, are you challenging the decision???
This will be closely scrutinised by other councils and surely WAKSA is doing something???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
Even if you do, the lack of communication to your members is very poor.
I respect that you are volonteers but if you decide to represent all the kiters then you should do just that.
Hope to hear some sort of comment soon or you can kiss good bye to my future membership.


This is his WHOLE quote.... thank god finally for the green thumbs.....So far WAKSA has said nothing on THE Australian kitesurfing forum. No finger pointing at anyone. Legitimate questions were asked by a member on the 26th Feb,probably knowing that WAKSA and Darren Marshall have been on this from day one.

This will set a precident for many councils. Many AKSA/WAKSA members are interested and would like some information. Remember: Are jestskis a pain in the arse to other water users...............we certainly are (the 2%ers)....

So what, designated kite beaches.....(woodies, pinaroo,sfety bay?) our favourite wave spot in perth is 200m upwind of one of the most crowded swimming beaches in Australia..............

If kitesurfing is to survive in WA and Perth, we have many issues, beginners with no lessons or not independent, visiting tourists who kite in a different environment and in a different way ( thats why their beaches are banned), and the indifference to locals stopping a f#@k-up from happening in the first place.

Let's all keep the beaches open.................

Andrash
Andrash
WA
637 posts
WA, 637 posts
28 Feb 2010 9:28pm
....hey WAKSA comitee, would you tell us what exactly we (plain kiters) can do to prevent **** hit the fan....it sounds serious, and we knew for years it was going to come....but now it is the time for actions....
...avalanche starts from a snow ball...I see it getting into motion...
...let us know what we can do.....and I'll do it...
BTW it is not a local issue of Mullaloo.....I've never kited there....it is the snow ball...
gruezi
gruezi
WA
3464 posts
WA, 3464 posts
28 Feb 2010 9:36pm
Good discussion here.

I do believe that Councils do have reasonable people making decisions. Perhaps this action is a bit shoot from the hip, hasn't been thought out enough and is reactive rather than reflective.

I feel this is a first draft and a fair and reasonable response will eventually come from Council.

However, it is up to us local kiters, especially non-WAKSA members to get involved. I'm for free beaches with imposed manners........mandatory WAKSA membership to kite in WA is the only way forward as long as WAKSA is true to what I believe should be in its Constitution, and that is that the organisation's only real mandate is to keep our beaches open to kiting.

This is certainly a hot topic on a hot week.

Old man out.
GreenPat
GreenPat
QLD
4107 posts
QLD, 4107 posts
1 Mar 2010 12:03am
OK guys, I know a lot of you are frustrated, but be patient. This is probably the biggest thing WAKSA has had to tackle since the Cottesloe restrictions were put in place, if not bigger, and it's pretty much entirely new crew since then.

At the moment WAKSA and MUGS are having in-depth discussions about an approach to take. By this time tomorrow there should be a clear plan laid down, at which time a public statement can be made. The reason nothing has been said yet, and I am saying this under my personal login, is that WAKSA is taking this very seriously, and are making absolutely sure all the ducks are in a row before making public statements.

Remember, this is a public forum, and people opposed to kitesurfing are reading it as well as us.

Once WAKSA and MUGS have a position and a plan laid out you can expect a meeting for the wider kitesurfing community to be announced, for probably later this week. This can only happen once the entire committee has agreed on what to do, as this is, as you know, a very serious issue.

Please be patient, your questions will all be answered soon.
Andrash
Andrash
WA
637 posts
WA, 637 posts
28 Feb 2010 10:14pm
Bigwavedave said...

Post your questions here

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=62842


WAKSA read and address WAKSA issues from there.


..no, Dave, this issue is beyond any thread....I believe WAKSA committee is monitoring this thread anyway...the point is that we may be able to give some support...representing our commitment if necessary.......I don't think it matters what you thing is the most appropriate forum or thread at the moment, this issue will effect the whole kitesurfing community....
Bigwavedave
Bigwavedave
QLD
2057 posts
QLD, 2057 posts
1 Mar 2010 12:32am
I disagree. You have a local problem with one local authority.

This part of Seabreeze is a national forum. The WAKSA forum area is designed for WA issues. Kitesurfing is a high visibility sport in WA maybe. Here on the east coast we do not have the same crowding issues nor the same friction between beach users. (except in a couple of high vis areas like St Kilda and Byron)



If we keep making loud noises about restrictions and bans on the national forum, then non-kiting readers of this forum (councils, govt regulators etc) will think the issue is bigger than it is.

Sometimes we think we are far more noticed than what we really are....

Better to keep under the radar than make one local council's issues into a national one.

Just one humble opinion.
Andrash
Andrash
WA
637 posts
WA, 637 posts
28 Feb 2010 11:11pm
Bigwavedave said...

I disagree. You have a local problem with one local authority.

This part of Seabreeze is a national forum. The WAKSA forum area is designed for WA issues. Kitesurfing is a high visibility sport in WA maybe. Here on the east coast we do not have the same crowding issues nor the same friction between beach users. (except in a couple of high vis areas like St Kilda and Byron)



If we keep making loud noises about restrictions and bans on the national forum, then non-kiting readers of this forum (councils, govt regulators etc) will think the issue is bigger than it is.

Sometimes we think we are far more noticed than what we really are....

Better to keep under the radar than make one local council's issues into a national one.

Just one humble opinion.


..no, again, no Dave, your opinion does not feel humble....and what you hear happening here in far wild West OZ has been happening in Europe and the US for years..........so just be alert and watchful on that (so you say) peaceful east coast........and let us post our posts wherever we want to.... the decision in Joondalup will effect the whole kitesurfing community even if you think differently.....
peace to you mate
GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
1 Mar 2010 8:25pm
Even if this isn't your home beach this is a problem as it sets a nasty precedent.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came...
herbyburger
herbyburger
WA
303 posts
WA, 303 posts
2 Mar 2010 12:02am
calm down maties, winter is nearly here and most of the summer fun crowd will soon be out of the picture, then head down to your local and see who,s around... wont be much.... the odd kitesurfer will make the dull, bland winter horizon look quite appealing and refreshing.. enjoy...
lemming
lemming
WA
75 posts
WA, 75 posts
2 Mar 2010 4:12pm
Mullaloo Kiters User Group and WAKSA had a meeting last night. There is no additional news which we can print on a public forum, however rest assured we are working on our approach to the beach management plan.

Please bear with us, but know that lots of people are working on this issue - just because we are not able to post full details on the forums, does not mean the issue is being forgotten. I can assure you it is not!

WAKSA members will get additional information in the next few days.

Dave
Mullaloo Kiters User Group
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
2 Mar 2010 4:51pm
lemming said...

Mullaloo Kiters User Group and WAKSA had a meeting last night.

Dave
Mullaloo Kiters User Group


Hey Dave, would it be possible to give me a heads up on the next meeting?, I also have an interest in the outcome of all of this and would like to contribute in any way I can.

Cheers,

KH
lemming
lemming
WA
75 posts
WA, 75 posts
2 Mar 2010 8:55pm
Kitehard said...

lemming said...

Mullaloo Kiters User Group and WAKSA had a meeting last night.

Dave
Mullaloo Kiters User Group


Hey Dave, would it be possible to give me a heads up on the next meeting?, I also have an interest in the outcome of all of this and would like to contribute in any way I can.

Cheers,

KH


Hi Darren,

I did send you an email to what I thought was your address, giving details of the meeting etc. I don't think it bounced but perhaps I did have the address incorrect. If you PM me your mobile (and email), I am happy to call and give you a quick synopsis of the meeting yesterday.

I will ensure you are kept in the loop for any future meetings

Cheers
Dave
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply