manicskier said...
But Choady, a nautical mile for a plane travelling at 30000 feet is further than a nautical mile for boat at sea level, isn't it... the earth is round yeah??? doesn't it just apply to the water, ie 'nautical'??
A nautical mile is still a nautical mile whether at 30,000ft or sea level. Perhaps your getting confused with indicated airspeed and True airspeed?
Even though the earth is round, its a massive sphere (not a perfect one), thats over 21,600nm round at the equator. At 30,000ft, your only about 9km, or 5nm above sea level, so this extra height is totally negligible when it comes to calculating the distance between two points at sea level or 30,000ft. A nautical mile is a nautical mile regardless of the height. But, you are correct in saying the distance between two points on the earth is slightly longer at 30,000ft, but its so small it makes no real difference.
So it certainly doesn't just apply to the water, it just originated with sea travel. Aviation use exactly the same method of nav that ships do. Whether boat or aeroplane, the shortest distance beween two points on the earths surface is a great circle, not a straight line due to curvature of the earth. This distance is measured in NM, and speed used is nautical miles per hour (knots).
Dawn Patrol said...
The nautical mile is 1852m and is used for scientfic purposes the define distance with precision is a distance of 1852m. And has NO GENERAL USE IN NAVIGATION.
The statement that a nautical mile has no general use in Navigation is absurd and naive.

To navigate accurately, you need an accurate direction, velocity, and distance or time. The velocity and distance are knots and nm respectively. As I mentioned previously, 1 nm is one minute of lattitude arc along a meridian. The NM for all intensive purposes is a sea mile too. The distance is exactly the same for both. Using a sextant, very accurate measurements of lattitude can be obtained from sun/star angles. This therefore directly equates to degrees and minutes of arc which are nm. All aircraft and ships use nm and knots to navigate by.
Unfortunately Sebol, who says "knots are useless outdated mesurements and we would be all much better off using km - Come on cave men, join the modern boat ."
We would have to devise a new way to pin point co-ordinates on the earths surface and travel between them !! I think Sebol - you need to be more open minded how and why things are the way they are, rather than have the whole world change to fit in with the speed your car moves at !!
This thread is getting like the Telstra commercial ' Why did they build the great wall of China dad? "
"Emporer Nasi Goreng build it to keep the rabbits out - Son"
That 15yr old looking for a way to carry gear on his bike will soon be at school discussing the finer points of nav with his mates saying you got to throw rope to measure wind speed, and that the nm has no use in navigation .
