Which Kite

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
sincs
sincs
4 posts
4 posts
10 Oct 2006 12:15am
I'm just new to Kitesurfing and I'm looking to get set up and its been suggested to me that I buy a "bow" kite as opposed to a "C" kite. I was just wondering what you all thought as I have been told that the "bow" style is the safer and seems to be the way all the kite manufacturers are heading. I'm looking at probably a Cabrinha Switchblade II 14m is this a good option.. Thanks for any help
Sincs
cwamit
cwamit
WA
1194 posts
WA, 1194 posts
10 Oct 2006 7:06am
Dude, last year was same as you are now - was just getting into the sport, had my lesson went to shop after a second hand and was shown the bow kites, didn’t hear anything about them previously – didn’t even know they existed (never been to the seabreeze forums) told about depower and the wind range so instead of getting a c I bought the switchblade1 9 meter, is a fantastic kite to learn on although the new sb2 is considered a totally new design reports so far say its well behaved like the previous one but with improvements and benefits.

Never had face plants or birds nests in the lines, actually didn’t have any inversions during my learning stage but now in waves inversions can and do happen, but also now I am going out in 25 plus knots wave riding with the best of them just one season down the track. You will progress fast on any depowerable kite just a matter of picking which one you want. As for size you must be a big boy or have fairly light winds as a 14 is a fairly large kite, if your 75 to 85 kilos look to go for a twelve, under 75 and you could get a 10 (I think they make one that size too) as 8 might be a bit too small. What are your average winds speeds where you are, and what size kites do the local crew (your weight) fly 80 percent of the time as 06 or earliar c kites then take two meters off for a bow and thats your kite.

I dont own a shop, get deals or am mates with anyone that does, but I do like cabrinha gear even if it seems pricey its got the little things that are important to me on their kites.
JB
JB
NSW
2232 posts
JB JB
NSW, 2232 posts
10 Oct 2006 9:56am
Sincs,

I suggest you try to demo as many kites/brand/styles as possible, take in as much information as possible. then sit down and work out what works for you! It is good to read up on others experience but I wouldn't make it a major factor in choosing a kite, you'll know what works for your self when you use it!

Hope your kite hunting goes well.

regards,

JB
cwamit
cwamit
WA
1194 posts
WA, 1194 posts
10 Oct 2006 8:07am
riding demo's is fine of you can get on a board and at least go up and back with competency, but rather hard to choose what’s good till you can do that let alone whats suitable, after saying that its a good point to make, if your able to ride - demo demo demo!!!
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
10 Oct 2006 9:28am
go cwamit!

spent a season on a C kite to learn and after 1 season I was ****, gusty winds pissed me off was still doing the walk of shame and was sick of getting slammed by variable, gusty winds on the river.

Whatever you get, buy a very new C which claims it has 80% depower of a bow or a Bow. Reason: Safety,more time on the water, bigger wind range, faster learning.
To choose a size: go to your local beaches that youll be kiting, look what guys your size are riding and note the wind strength, and ask, ask, ask
Kitehard
Kitehard
WA
2782 posts
WA, 2782 posts
10 Oct 2006 9:41am
Hi Guys,

Pretty hard to demo gear before you know what you are doing. Get a couple of lessons and look for a Hybrid style kite, avoid the bows. You will have less problems and learn faster on a Hybrid kite ("C" kite with a bridle for depower range).

The Hybrids have the best of both worlds and none of the nasty habits of either.The Airush Flow SLE, the Cabrinha SB2 etc is the way to go for learning. sincs Unless you are a heavy boy, you wont need a 14m Hybrid, they have the bottom end of a 16m, thats a big kite!

Good winds,

kitecrazzzy
kitecrazzzy
WA
2184 posts
WA, 2184 posts
10 Oct 2006 11:48am
different styles of kites exist but most brands have a beginner style kite.
first season you will trash it about. look for something cheap, or if ya loaded just go buy yourself a new vegus or something.
learner suited kites are just kites that fly themselves like the airush pilot. a pilot would suit a first season kiter perfectly, i had one for a while only because it was big and cheap (second hand) and progressed alot because you didnt have to worry about it when trying stuff. not that good for boosting though.
bows require a lot of rider input (not my words, the words of a bow flyer)
sincs
sincs
4 posts
4 posts
10 Oct 2006 12:44pm
Thanks guys all helpful info I actually have a Flow 15.5 that a mate has lent me to try with the option to buy it along with a 165 LF board. And just so you know I am a big boy 105kgs so I reckon a bigger kite is required. Thanks for the info very usefull
Sincs
TomClift
TomClift
NSW
50 posts
NSW, 50 posts
10 Oct 2006 5:01pm
I personally recommend the new Griffin kite by Monkey.

Everyone that has ridden them, and there's a few now who have on the Northern Beaches and in the South, rates them very favourably.

I was out at Long Reef on a 12 with the wind at 30 knots, then on the 9 when North Head read 43 knots. All I can say is that it was as windy as all hell, the jumps were insane, as was the depower. Photos at www.kitesurfing.com.au. It was a day great for bow kites...

The 12 also gets me going in 13 knots.

It's a one kite quiver basically...(if you miss the 43 knot days)

The 12 Griffin is selling for around $1000 new. So why pay double, especially when the reviews are as good and if not better than many of the leading brands? So my answer for which kite - is the Griffin.

And by the way, I've always been a Naish and North rider...

No doubt this email will get trolled because people don't like to know they pay double for theirs...Or they'll think ive got other motives...But the proofs out there - try it out! I think its great that there is finally a great performing kite have become affordable to most...

Tom
simonsays
simonsays
WA
63 posts
WA, 63 posts
16 Oct 2006 1:12pm
Fair play Tom, but in reality you use a kite for 1 season only or make a decision to keep it forever due to the bad re-sell value. Go Monkey kite and you loose 90% of the second hand buyers market and therefor get just about nothing back. Brands like Cabrinha, North etc keep re-sell value better than most and you are far more likely to sell for less of a loss. This way you can keep up with the latest and spend overall less to upgrade to the next years model..

Cheers!
Uncle Rico
Uncle Rico
NSW
200 posts
NSW, 200 posts
16 Oct 2006 4:09pm
hang on.

get a $1800 brand name kite and sell it for $700 a year later.

loose $1100

get a $1000 kite and sell it a year later for say $300.

loose about $ 700

how is buying brand name cheaper?




simonsays
simonsays
WA
63 posts
WA, 63 posts
16 Oct 2006 2:21pm
hang on, more like buy a good brand name kite for $1800 and sell it a season later (six months) for $1400, in good condition... but I think you missed the point, you will sit on a lesser brand name trying to sell it for much longer than a more popular brand name..
paul.j
paul.j
QLD
3381 posts
QLD, 3381 posts
16 Oct 2006 4:23pm
more like
$1800 brand name sell a year later for between $1000 and $1350

pay $1100 and get well any thing you can.

if you can get a good brand name kite a year later for $700 well done
Andrew
Andrew
WA
148 posts
WA, 148 posts
16 Oct 2006 3:49pm
here they go again... battle of brands!

adding fuel to the fire, why not a Peter Lynn... no bladders means they don't wear out like the bows or C's so lasts heaps of seasons... hence dont need to update next year and worry about depreciation at all!

and dont understand what the fuss is about... I (like heaps of others) learnt on a 2 line kite without ANY depower.... so just goes to show that learning on a 4 line (no matter how old or the design)really is NOT a big deal... I suggest you ignor the ego's and brand bull****

i say good on monkey kites.... awesome value for money!!! great quality etc... name brand means nothing... go for performance and value for money.

ps I have no affiliation with PL or Monkey
simonsays
simonsays
WA
63 posts
WA, 63 posts
17 Oct 2006 10:02am
Andrew, I agree with your note on a PL kite, although I have never flown PL kites, but the safety is very good as far as I know, but I have to dis-agree with you on the OLD "C" shape 4 line kites.. They are extremely dangerous compared to the new kites out on market today. I learn't on "C" shape kites a good few years ago and against my initial feeling towards bow kites, I bought myself one this year to cope with the extreme gusty conditions that we had over winter and I'm sorry to say, I am hooked. 100% more safe and to any newby there simply should not be another choice in kites. This does not mean they are fool proof, but definately less chance of ending up in hospital due to great depower, etc
NSW, 4382 posts
18 Oct 2006 8:33am
We have to avoid the BS and brand pimps, and Cinosaur lovers
I sell and use most brands on the market, have done for a long time now.

PL kites, lots of advantages over inflatables, like no punctures, longer lasting (generally), auto zenith, stable, etc
Disadvantages, pretty much the same safety as a C kite, only way to stop the pull is release to one line. Auto zenith was a feature that the designer wanted so that he could launch his kite catamarans single handed. Its a design feature that assists when getting on a board for sure, but the latest versions do it less. Very stable, but auto zenith makes the kite steer up slightly or a lot depending on the model and where it is in the sky. Its a feature thats easy to live with for the majority of riders. Relaunch can be tricky, gets easier with practice, and the kite is harder to crash in the first place.
+ make excellent land traction kites, whereas inflatos dont!

C shaped kites, are the dinosaurs of kiting, their time is coming to an end, many brands are not even making them anymore.
Certain riders who have gotten "good" using them do not want to
re-learn their trick list on bows or high depower kites. These people tend to slag them off as gay at every opportunity, some children like to play on the freeway, thats life!

Bows, hmmm, some brands are trying sound as if their kite is a C type others are promoting bow type and still others are promoting kite bisexuality.

I think we can call all the BOWS, HYBRIDS, AND SLE'S, high depower kites. Some that are claimed to be hybrids are bows and vice versa, some claim to be pure c and are really high depower SLE, etc, etc.

The key feature that the vast majority of new kiters and seasoned vets want is drop the bar 95% depower!! There have been a lot of versions of high depower kites that still retain a lot of power when the bar is dropped, these are bad for the sport, because they are being promoted as if they have the 95% depower feature.

I watched a rider yesterday crash badly after a mistimed unhooked attempt at something, he pendulumed right under the 10M Cab SB2 and it fell out of the sky, lines completely loose. Kite landed on the water, almost level with the kiter!!
It rolled around as it blew/drifted downwind of the rider, through its lines, inside out (inverted), then sort of wine glassed (half inverted/half right way out) for a bit, rider just kept jiggling and working the lines, and eventually after approx 4-5 mins the kite relaunched, but with twists in the lines because it had rollled through itself twice.
Rider dragged to the beach, put the kite down on the beach on a tip, held the centre lines where they join the trim strap and make a V with one hand, then unhooked his safety, and unhooked, and passed the bar through the lines to get rid of the twists. He did all this before anyone could offer assistance!
Bows with the full rainBOW bridle are super stable and depower 95% when only the front lines are tensioned.

The latest 07 bows based on the Legainoux patent and refined continuosly by Bruno (who then releases that info periodically to the licence holders), are the safest of the new high depower kites in my experience and observations.

None of the new high depower kites can match the fully bridled bows for relaunch either, if there is at least 5-6 knots of wind even a 17M contra will relaunch easily with no swimming, from the usual LE down and downwind of the rider position.

This is all from my personal experience over the last 15 years of observing power kiting and kite surfing developments. I sell all the main brands, there are good things about all of the brands we carry, but I personally prefer the proper bows, and I think they suit the majority of riders more than any other kite style, and they are a more sustainable, safer, kite for the future of the sport.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve McCormack

Mr float
Mr float
NSW
3452 posts
NSW, 3452 posts
18 Oct 2006 11:48am
I might add a little bit to Steve's last post .
I have 11 years traction kite experience .I have been snowkiting for 10 years .One of the things that I was looking for for our crappy gusty and dangerous high winds (and rocks everywhere with "I want to hurt you" all over them ) was a kite that was very stable and has heaps of depower in and emergency without having to pull the QR that had heaps of range and sweetspot.A nice additional feature would be that it was water suitable as well (so I didn't have to have another quiver of kites for the few days that I went snowkiting)
3 years ago the venom came along.in my experience the venom has enough depower when I sheet out or let go of the bar on a venom 2 13 m if I get hit by a mega gust(say from 15 kt ave to 30 kt gust frikkin scary all the same and would prefer it not to happen) in the mountains (and on the water )and has heaps more than an LEI C shaped kite and preceded Sle/bows in this reagrd .
I also ride waroos and have flown most of the current crop of SLE,s bows (whatever) .Waroos and othe SLE kites when you let go of the bar completely depower and crash and yes have some more depower than the venom in this situation .HOWEVER as an experienced rider and instructor I strongly advise that newbies stick to smooth winds less than 20 kt ave (preferable seabreezes ) rather than nuking gusty and thermally winds coming across land and possibly a short stretch of water .Why ?
I have now grabbed 2 people that have been out on SLE/bow kites in gusty strong winds with the belief that they are safe to have the kite depower lots crash roll and then have some kind of crap or jam happen with catastophic uncontrollable kite stuff happening.One guy was moments from being smashed onto rocks and dumped on a very busy road in Melbourne and was extremely traumatic for everone .Fortunately about 5 guys were able to jump on him and stop him and a brave soul gabbed the kitelooping kite in its brief moment on the water

Perhaps the best advice I could give is find a school /shop that has a good reputation with local riders for ongoing teaching and kite selection advice .Kites safety/depower etc has improved immeasurably but can still deliver nasty surprises good training and advice and experience are still invaluable and are very helpful in dealing with these nasty surprises .
I'll never forget the day my powered hang gliding instructor turned the motor off unexpectedly on our 95 % "the motor won't die on you mid flight" aircraft and I had to draw upon all my flight skills to safely land in an unfamiliar paddock

Cheers

Lach
MKC
MKC
NSW
9 posts
MKC MKC
NSW, 9 posts
18 Oct 2006 12:23pm
Hi Guys

I've been kite boarding for going on eight years and have tried or owned most types and brands in that time. At present I'm using Best Waroos (bow kite) and Peter Lynn Vennom II's depending on what I'm doing or how I feel. All the new kites are pretty good so trying a few to find what suits you is a must.

I think the Bow kites definitely are the best for depower and they tend to relaunch well too, BUT when they fully depower they tend to start to fall out of the sky and its very easy to lose control which can create a whole lot of other problems (luckily they relaunch well).

The Peter Lynn "twin skin" style kite also depowers well and if you let the handle go the kite tends to end up at the zenith depowered so you can easily get re-composed. Its for that reason I like to use it to try new tricks. They are a great all round kite and users tend to have a quick learning curve.

Regard
Morgs
justdoit
justdoit
QLD
65 posts
QLD, 65 posts
18 Oct 2006 1:56pm
quote:
Originally posted by Kitepower Australia

We have to avoid the BS and brand pimps, and Cinosaur lovers
I sell and use most brands on the market, have done for a long time now.
Yes, which ever brand you think you will make the most out of that year, king pimp.

C shaped kites, are the dinosaurs of kiting, their time is coming to an end, many brands are not even making them anymore.
Certain riders who have gotten "good" using them do not want to
re-learn their trick list on bows or high depower kites. These people tend to slag them off as gay at every opportunity, some children like to play on the freeway, thats life!

What a steaming pile of doodoo!! So what your saying is that all "c" riders are morons? They stopped developing them 2 years ago?
Many brands don't make them any more and which brands might they be? Surely not the brands you sell.



The key feature that the vast majority of new kiters and seasoned vets want is drop the bar 95% depower!! There have been a lot of versions of high depower kites that still retain a lot of power when the bar is dropped, these are bad for the sport, because they are being promoted as if they have the 95% depower feature. Wrong.


The latest 07 bows based on the Legainoux patent and refined continuosly by Bruno (who then releases that info periodically to the licence holders), are the safest of the new high depower kites in my experience and observations. Safer than a 5th line that only connects to the kite with one line, I think not.

None of the new high depower kites can match the fully bridled bows for relaunch either. Another untruth

This is all from my personal experience over the last 15 years of observing power kiting and kite surfing developments. I sell all the main brands, there are good things about all of the brands we carry, but I personally prefer the proper bows, and I think they suit the majority of riders more than any other kite style, and they are a more sustainable, safer, kite for the future of the sport.

Thats just it, your opinions are your opinions. Nothing personal but it doesn't mean you are correct.



mahadev
mahadev
NSW
46 posts
NSW, 46 posts
18 Oct 2006 10:16pm
Hi Sincs

You have pretty much answered your own questions, if you are turned on to the switchblade go for it they are a very good-quality kite.

I have known Steve since he first got started in kites and I agree with almost everything he has said. The only thing that I disagree with is the statement.
(Disadvantages, pretty much the same safety as a C kite, only way to stop the pull is release to one line.) Referring to Peter Lynn venoms.
The venom II without any doubt has double the wind range of any inflatable C kite. Therefore more safety, For instance today I was using my 13 in upto 32 knots, I also use the same kite down to a bottom end of 16 knots. I could be chugging along in a little bit less, but at 16 knots I am enjoying the kite. Today at 30 knots I didn't feel unsafe in any way. There was a visiting kiter from Sydney who was out on a 7 m Yaga, when I assisted him landing the kite, he said he was getting absolutely smashed. So I think it is very easy to say that the venom has a much wider wind range than conventional Tube kites which in turn translates to safety.
Ha Steve maybe you should come up to Coffs for a holiday and have a go at the new hyper venom, it's been over a year since our adventure into the wilderness, you know there's always somewhere to crash up here.

Bob Dawson
NSW, 4382 posts
19 Oct 2006 9:03am
G'day Bob

You've known me a while for sure, but not since I got involved in kites, I had been hard at it for a couple of years before you walked into that tiny shop we started Kitepower from in Geelong.

I stand by what I said - "Disadvantages, pretty much the same safety as a C kite, only way to stop the pull is release to one line"

You know what I said is true.

What you are mistakenly saying is that your ability to get a big wind range from a tweaked V2 is something to do with stopping the pull.

Its the pull and lift that kills and maims, when the rider drops the bar on a bow style kite like the Switchblade2 the PULL STOPS.

I'm not advocating people ride outside their ability or a sensible wind range for a given kite size (see manufacturers wesbites).
My stance on kite safety is well known.

Bow kites have an inherent safety feature that C's and arc style kite do not have.

The rider of a c or arc style kite must first realise that the sh1t is about to hit the fan and then have the presence of mind to actually pull or push some sort of release (all kite are different grrrr!).

With a bow they just let go!!

Big difference.

And I will take a holiday soon I think, I would love to catch up with you, but I will be bringing a couple of bow kites, and my favourite Benson.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve
dave......
dave......
WA
2119 posts
WA, 2119 posts
19 Oct 2006 8:55am
Steve Do you know if anyones been killed on a bow kite yet?...........enough said.

Had my new X-Bow2 fully invert yesterday in super gusty winds whilst doing a miss-timed transition jump.
It was flying upside down, pulled on 1 outside line kite spun around and I was leading edge down ready for a relaunch.
I was next to a guy with a C with 5th line with his kite in the water....Even with my supposed Kitemare I was up and going before he could relaunch.
Inversions rarely happen but are safe,and easy to rectify if you know what your doing. If you dont have a play, pull on an outside line now and then and youll work out whats going on pretty quickly. Never give up and swim in. Its safer to fix in the water

mahadev
mahadev
NSW
46 posts
NSW, 46 posts
19 Oct 2006 4:25pm
Ha Steve

If you read my post again you will see that at no stage did I compare the venom to a bow. All of my comparison was Venom to conventional
C kites.

Look forward seeing you.

Bob Dawson

bolgo
bolgo
WA
912 posts
WA, 912 posts
19 Oct 2006 3:01pm
having tried bows and sle's
dont enjoy the heavy bar pressure or ponderous turning or treacherous self launching experiences and have seen some pretty concerning stuff with tangled bridles caught on tips etc

tried torch3 yesterday(as an example of c kite now available vegas7 etc the same) light steering, agile all the depower and more that i would like, several redundant safety systems in use qr chicken loop, surefire spreader bar etc

its personal preference the way i see it, not gay v non gay or other lame arguements

each to their own,
NSW, 4382 posts
19 Oct 2006 5:23pm
Ha Bob

And all I said was that to depower a Venom 1 or 2, you still need to pull a chicken loop release and release to one line, via a safety leash. Same as a C kite.

I don't get what you found disagreeable about my post.

Venoms are great kites, C's are ok too (but I think they suck), I just wanted to wind up the cinosaur lovers.

There are no bad kites only bad kite flyers! :-)

Hopefully we can go for a kite soon!

Cya

Steve



quote:
Originally posted by mahadev

Ha Steve

If you read my post again you will see that at no stage did I compare the venom to a bow. All of my comparison was Venom to conventional
C kites.

Look forward seeing you.

Bob Dawson




waveslave
waveslave
WA
4263 posts
WA, 4263 posts
19 Oct 2006 7:32pm
quote:
Originally posted by Kitepower Australia

You know what I said is true.




Which kite ?
lol
This is a question only a fully certified kite-pimp can answer impartially.
hahaha
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
19 Oct 2006 8:33pm
A question.
If bow kites offer 100% depower why cant you fly a 16 comfortably in 40 knots?

PS I ride bows
NSW, 4382 posts
20 Oct 2006 7:42am
PR, I've never said that bows depower 100% by letting go of the bar.
I know they don't, but they do depower a lot I reckon around 90-95%, Ive been caught out in a squall on a 12M CB, wind got to low 30's (knots), then another rider took the kite off me and went and rode it for another 30 mins jumping to the moon!

I would not call hanging off a 16M SB, TD or CB (real bows) riding in 40 knots, and I really don't think it is possible.

No kite depowers 100%, it seems pointless to keep saying that. However even saying a kite depowers 90+% when the bar is not held could be misleading for some begginners, so kites should not be promoted that way.

We had customer come in with a bent sonic during the week, he got caugh out alone in fairly onshore conditions when the wind picked up to 25+ knots (said he had time to put it down, but thought he could survive the wind because he had sonic), he said the kite did not depower properly, but what we discovered (not the whole story) was that he kept trying to self land it using the pull a front line method, and got spanked every time he touched the bar to try. He was very lucky to survive uninjured.

Many other issues with this incident and user who is very inexperienced with kites, but who is or was slightly overconfident because of windsurfing experience (I thought we had seen the last of them).

It is the responsibility of the user to make sure that they use the kite in suitable locations and conditions, within their ability.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve
Andrew
Andrew
WA
148 posts
WA, 148 posts
20 Oct 2006 8:09am
steve.... did your mother used to tell you "you always have to have the last word"??

before the days of the bows... we all used to kite and have a heap of fun SAFELY So of course a learner now can grab a 4 line c kite cheap... and still go out and have a heap of fun. Presumably this learner will have had a lesson or two and know to go out in cross sure winds and NOT when it is gusty.

Sure the next generation in kites like bows & venoms can handle gusts with ease. And my venom handles a huge wind range as compared to my old C's. BUT OF COURSE PEOPLE ENTERING THE SPORT CAN GRAB A C KITE AND CAN HAVE A PILE OF FUN SAFELY!

As a retailer you are pushing the latest and greatest, and fair enough thats your job..... just like you used to with the C's not that long ago.

rgds
Andrew
NSW, 4382 posts
20 Oct 2006 12:32pm
Well you were going to get the last word and them Mum called from heaven, and said look out for Andrew he is sneaking up on you.

Of couse people have fun on C kites, people have fun on single line kids kites, sport kites, foil kites, bows, SLE's, Hybrids, Venoms, etc, etc, etc.
I don't like to use C kites anymore unless is is dead flat water, same goes for Venoms, mainly because of the strong steady pull, and the strain that puts on my knees.
Thats a personal opinion ok? Everything else I said was a wind up for the Cinosaur lovers, who always hang it on bows or high depower kite riders.

The best kite is the one YOU are having fun with, and we still stock C kites, but a few brands don't make any, anymore, ok?

Mum said I should shut up now.

Cya and

Goodwinds

Steve
RAL INN
RAL INN
SA
2898 posts
SA, 2898 posts
20 Oct 2006 5:11pm
I'm with your mum on that one
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply