forbidden from riding

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
stnkygoat
stnkygoat
NSW
230 posts
NSW, 230 posts
20 Oct 2005 1:27pm
Went to beach yesterday afternoon - Nobby's (Newcastle), and got told by the lifeguard (who made a special trip up the beach on his motorbike) that we were not allowed to kite because the waves were too big. he said we could wait until they went off duty in (about 20 mins later) and then we could go. He was very nice about it, but I just wondered if they can actually stop you.

The kiting, by the way, was pretty benign.
eightfootplus
eightfootplus
NSW
298 posts
NSW, 298 posts
20 Oct 2005 1:47pm
Was the beach closed?

Probably more like with 20 minutes to go, he didnt really feel like getting wet, probably heaps of stormwater poolution as well.

any clubbies out there to correct me? other wise I'll ask at nippers this weekend
Spacemonkey!
Spacemonkey!
SA
2288 posts
SA, 2288 posts
20 Oct 2005 4:50pm
waves are too big don't go out whilst i can save you, go out when i knock off and ur on ur own.

Shoulda just gone out wats he gonna do to bring u in.
stnkygoat
stnkygoat
NSW
230 posts
NSW, 230 posts
20 Oct 2005 5:30pm
No I don't remember seeing a closed sign yesterday - there was one today (thurs) saying no swimming due to current. There were people in the water yesterday, swimming down in front of the surf club

Macca Wollongong
Macca Wollongong
NSW
295 posts
NSW, 295 posts
20 Oct 2005 5:49pm
i think this is strange, your not using the public service of the lifesavers, so he shouldnt tell you if you can and cant go out. Correct me if im wrong.
Hammerhead
Hammerhead
NSW
118 posts
NSW, 118 posts
20 Oct 2005 7:02pm
The lifeguard was most likely saying that to cover his own butt.
If you went out and got into trouble, the question would be asked to him why he didn't do anything to stop you in the first place, it's on his shoulders at that stage. If you went out against his instructions and things went pear shaped it's your fault, he has done his duty of care and can't be sued.

All Newcastle Beaches were closed yesterday, look for the single red flag on the beach.
stnkygoat
stnkygoat
NSW
230 posts
NSW, 230 posts
20 Oct 2005 11:04pm
quote:
Originally posted by Hammerhead

The lifeguard was most likely saying that to cover his own butt.
If you went out and got into trouble, the question would be asked to him why he didn't do anything to stop you in the first place, it's on his shoulders at that stage. If you went out against his instructions and things went pear shaped it's your fault, he has done his duty of care and can't be sued.

All Newcastle Beaches were closed yesterday, look for the single red flag on the beach.



Yep I figured it was liability issue, but I thought it was odd that they would just tell you that the beach was closed, and you could not go out. I thought they might just say that if you go out they cannot rescue you.

There were also a whole heap of surfers out that day further up the beach.

Question though: if you do get in trouble and it is too rough for the jetski or boat rescue what happens? (Apart from drowning) Who pays for the chopper?
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply