The final verdict on Fallshaw Wheels

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
3 Jun 2009 4:32pm
Hi there Seabreeze members and future fellow landsailers. Im from Adelaide and together with a sailing buddy of mine, constructing a pair of Lake Lefroy's.

Construction has yet to commence, hopefully we will get both chassis built over this coming long weekend. I have to praise the simple design of the Lefroy Mini, and I must admit I am a little daunted by the layover steering but It should be too complex (using standard bicycle necktube/headset/bearings instead of the washer/bushing arrangement).

Anyway, to the point of my subject. Its clear that Fallshaw are the wheels of choice, however I'm quite confused in the depth of the topic. More specifically, confusion about the use of commonly avaliable bearings.

So is anybody able to provide me with a specific Fallshaw part number for the complete correct wheel with appropriate bearings (x3)that I need to build our yachts.

Also, where are South Aussies buying these wheels from? Is there a shop in Adelaide that carries these in stock?

A price would be helpfull too to know if im getting ripped off!

Bear in mind we dont have intentions of racing (except each other) so top performance isnt really an issue.

Man am I going on and on here, but Ive looked at the wheels avaliable in Hong Kong Hardware (pooraka) and found plastic 4x8 units that seem to accept 2" bearings, however the bearing housing is the same dimension through the wheel, the whole wheel would slide off the bearings under side load if im thinking correctly...


Thanks in advance for my stack of stupid questions!

Look forward to getting these things out and under sail.

Regards, Glenn.
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
3 Jun 2009 6:33pm
Hi Glenn,
Im also from Adelaide and if you need any help give me a yell via a Private Message
I recently bought 3 fallshaw wheels from

Adelaide Merchandising
8297 8444
9 Grove Ave. Marleston
(about 5 mins from the city down Richmond Rd.)

I think the are about $55 each with the standard deep grove bearings (which I prefer to use but some others don't). Better bearings are avaliable at most bearing suppliers as they are a common size.

Don't touch other types of wheels as they won't last or perform properly and you would soon need to replace them, (waste of money)

Welcome to the forum.....

Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
3 Jun 2009 5:07pm
Hi Glenn
Just bought some Fallshaw wheels for my mini this week here in Nz
The part number for the wheels is 8x250 PWB10
these come with ! inch deep groove bearings which you are best to throw away and get the housings which accept 20mm high speed bearings part no n6204
Two of these per wheel and 2 of 6204 bearings
You can get these with rubber seals part no 6204 2rs which are contact seal type
which have more friction but seal better or non contact type seals 6204 zz
less friction but probably wont last as long
The housings and bearings just push in very easy no problem
Prices here in NZ dollars
wheel $20.44 n6204 housing $1.29 62042rs bearings $2.85
Hope this helps and welcome to the forum
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
3 Jun 2009 5:12pm
Thanks for the quick replies Gizmo and Hiko, very informative. That should be pretty much all the infomation I need than..

Gizmo, ive seen your praise for 'wobbly' wheels over the forum, and I don't see an issue with that. Sorts out any minor alignment quirks

Not sure your machine is like but are the standard bearings up to constant side forces introduced by wheel camber?

Is there a part number on your wheels at all? Hopefully I can call them up and have some wheels quick smart.


Of course Fallshaw would be the best (and most expensive) option but is it unwise to use cheaper wheel for the front? I will be using the Lefroy fork as per plans, but with twin fork legs for a bit of extra strength, plus keeping the wheel captive.


The steering your guys use reminds me of the Cannondale Lefty fork, very strong indeed, but slightly worrying and you wont see me riding one

This is the wheel catalouge from Adelaide Merchandising, admerch.com.au/product-category/plastics/ Their W008/W009 wheels look quite appealing for a front runner. Any experiences?

Of course ive yet to see any of these wheels in person so I'll try and call in there tomorrow (just down the road!!)

Thanks for the speedy help guys! (I just wish I could afford to buy the wheels sooner!!)


1 other thing you can help me out with, As we are building the chassis this weekend, what diamater axles to these wheels take?

This is going to be a case of building a complete land yacht, ready to sail, without wheels - until funds permit

A nice shed ornament, a pair of mystery machines to most
Regards, Glenn.
hills
hills
SA
1622 posts
SA, 1622 posts
3 Jun 2009 7:05pm
G'day Glenn, good to see more South Aussies on here, you'll have to come out sailing with Gizmo and me (once Gizmo pulls his finger out ) plus the other South Aussies on here!

I'm pretty sure they need a 1" axle, but let Giz or Hiko confirm that before you buy.

If you do want to upgrade the bearings I got them from Gardner Bearings. part number EE9-2RS-JAP. 2"Outside Diam. x 1"Inside Diam. I think they were about $13 each from memory.

Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
3 Jun 2009 7:07pm
I think the model number of the wheel is 400x8KNO-PWB10

Now axles.. it depends that bearings you want to run?
As i mentioned im running the standard bearings with a 1" axle, im using a 1" steel tube with a 2mm wall thickness and using an "R" pin to hold them on.
Others have used soild axles of 1", 20mm, 5/8" etc some with pins and some with nylock nuts its up to you.
And Hillsy I would have more time to build yachts if i didn't have to go to work on the footy / soccer.
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
3 Jun 2009 5:41pm
Yes I think I will go with 1" Rod axles with pins.

Keep it simple for the first builds i think :)

Not sure if building 2 at the same time is a good idea or not but we'll soon see :)

Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
3 Jun 2009 5:45pm
The 400x8 kno is the knobbly tyre there is also a diamond pattern tyre
400x8 dmd and a ribbed one 400x 8 rib
The wheel is 8x250 PWB 10 on my invoice I bought the tyres and tubes seperately
elsewhere
The standard wheel has the 1 inch deep groove bearings if you want to fit 1 inch
precision bearings they are quite expensive the metric 20mm 6204 bearings are much cheaper like about six times cheaper! [Much more common]
Building two yachts at a time will be much less than twice as much work I think
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
3 Jun 2009 7:26pm
Just measured the wheel it is definitally 400mm dia. of the outside to outside of the tyre.



The only tyre I could find that size is the (knobly one which comes with it) when i wear that one out i will be going for the ribbed ones.
Hiko i think you might have been charged for the smaller wheel which is cheaper (lucky you)
Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
3 Jun 2009 6:00pm
Yes Giz I did wonder about that it does seem cheap doesnt it
The bearings were a good price too!
My wheels are definetly 400 mm dia the tyres are 480/400 x8
the 480 and 400 refers to the width I believe 4.8 inches and 4.00 inches
It gets confusing doesnt it ?
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
3 Jun 2009 6:05pm
Hiko, I think that might be the better option, and then either fit some ribbed tyres or some knobs planed down to slicks.


I have a 5m carbon mast + sailboard sail/boom that was given to me from a family friend, my mate is trying to source a similar setup from his connections.

I will also be exploring other sources for frame materials. I know somebody on here used a 'recycled' street sign. Other options are of course Fence post as listed in the plans, and Im inclined to think exhaust shops.

A while back I went to my nearest exhaust shop (exhaust technology on goodwood road) and purchased all the materials to fab the exhaust myself.

From what I recall, 2.5" mild steel had a about a 1.8-2mm wall and was very cheap (less than $10 a meter)

Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
3 Jun 2009 6:08pm
I have used 52x2 exhaust tube for my mini spine yet to try it out tho
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
3 Jun 2009 6:11pm
Hiko said...

The 400x8 kno is the knobbly tyre there is also a diamond pattern tyre
400x8 dmd and a ribbed one 400x 8 rib
The wheel is 8x250 PWB 10 on my invoice I bought the tyres and tubes seperately
elsewhere
The standard wheel has the 1 inch deep groove bearings if you want to fit 1 inch
precision bearings they are quite expensive the metric 20mm 6204 bearings are much cheaper like about six times cheaper! [Much more common]
Building two yachts at a time will be much less than twice as much work I think


Ok so It would be better to build the rear end with 20mm axles and swap out the bearings then. Is there any advantage over using threaded axles/locknuts to drilled stock with a pin?

Hiko
Hiko
1229 posts
1229 posts
3 Jun 2009 6:16pm
Plenty of people use the pin seems to be OK and makes taking the wheels off easy for transport
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
3 Jun 2009 6:33pm
okay sorry one more question hopefully before i dissapear into the shed for a week

do you see anything wrong with using a typical bicycle headset/races and necktube on the front of the main beam? Just about everyone seems to just use a combination of steel and plastic washers, seems primitive.

welding on a sacrificed headtube, and building the fork onto a threaded steerer is much simpler, probably more efficient and easier to obtain bits for ( a complete new headset with races, bearings, headset is about $10)

Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
3 Jun 2009 8:15pm
Try your local steel store and get a bit of tube the same / similar size of a bike head stem it would be easier than trying to mod a bike frame.
What you want to do is exactly the same as the "Sandpiper" yachts used, and that worked fine despite a different fork angles. We bought the headstem parts at Kmart or BigW
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
3 Jun 2009 8:44pm
Ribbed tyres from Mullins wheels,25-47 cheviot rd salisbury5108
If you have an alternative wheel that takes a 2" OD deep groove bearing, the fallshaw housing to convert to a 6204( 20mmID) bearing will fit, the part no is 6204HOUSING
isnt it typical , the kiwis can just buy the rim only , we have to have that stupid knobbly tyre
the reason I chose a 20mm axle is that I have broken the smaller sizes-15,16,5/8,17mm. the next size up is 25mm which gets too heavy . a 20mm mild steel bolt or just rod is strong enough even for a CL 5, no machining required.
If you are building a 30 degree layover steering head from a bicycle fork and sailing on rougher ground/sand, it will regularly chew out the bearings , and can seize during use
The reason that I use a solid 20mm shaft in the steering is that I have broken /bent every tube set up I tried. the mild steel 20mm shaft has outlasted everything else. it is also nice thick steel and easy to get a big heavy deep weld into
I am still waiting for a test of the exhaust tubing, I"m not holding my breath, as the tubing is designed for easy bending. if your building a full length chassis, ie mini "explorer" I would not recommend it, and would hunt harder for the galtube "fencepost" steel.
Enjoy your building , please take photos and put the finished yachts in the landyacht register, welcome aboard.
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
3 Jun 2009 10:29pm
Good information here, perhaps I will persue the steering construction as per plans.

Where do you purchase said plastic washers? And I assume these do wear rather rapidly...


Perhaps I should rename this thread to Idiots guide to the simplest landyacht ever...

And sorry to keep clogging your forum up with garbage, but is there anything wrong with running a traditional bicycle front end as mentioned for the sandpiper?

I know it isnt as pretty, but Im thinking for a first built it might help just to get our head around things to keep things as simple as possible. I have several bikes lying around to donor...



Looks like alot less headache if you ask me (but what do I know )
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
4 Jun 2009 1:49am
gsand said...

Where do you purchase said plastic washers?

You don't buy them. You cut them out of an ice crean container lid with a pair of scissors.

And I assume these do wear rather rapidly...

Wrong assuption, They last a long time.


And sorry to keep clogging your forum up with garbage,

No apology needed or wanted. No garbage coming from you.

but is there anything wrong with running a traditional bicycle front end as mentioned for the sandpiper?

Give it a burl Curl. Off the shelf or out of the dump is great. Tell us what happens.

keep things as simple as possible.

Way to go.

I have several bikes lying around to donor...

That is handy and cheap.


but what do I know

Maybe more than us.


Welcome to the forum mate. Join in the fun. Cheers Cisco

kiwi307
kiwi307
488 posts
488 posts
4 Jun 2009 6:12am
Hiko said...

Hi Glenn
Just bought some Fallshaw wheels for my mini this week here in Nz
The part number for the wheels is 8x250 PWB10
these come with ! inch deep groove bearings which you are best to throw away and get the housings which accept 20mm high speed bearings part no n6204
Two of these per wheel and 2 of 6204 bearings
You can get these with rubber seals part no 6204 2rs which are contact seal type
which have more friction but seal better or non contact type seals 6204 zz
less friction but probably wont last as long
The housings and bearings just push in very easy no problem
Prices here in NZ dollars
wheel $20.44 n6204 housing $1.29 62042rs bearings $2.85
Hope this helps and welcome to the forum

Hi Hiko, where did you get the wheels?

hills
hills
SA
1622 posts
SA, 1622 posts
4 Jun 2009 9:09am
Gsand, take a look at Pirrad's landyacht at the end of the landyacht register, he's used a bike front end and it looks great and from his video it sails great too. Go for it!!
iand
iand
QLD
243 posts
QLD, 243 posts
4 Jun 2009 11:44am
uses push bike steering bearing and front forks-45 degree layover. I'll be changing this to polyurethane (easier to pull apart for transport, sand in the bearing a thing of the past, just to name 2 advantages)


uses push bike front forks and polyurethane bushes (I felt with the extra give in polyurethane it would work better than something like acetal)


as landyacht said use solid 20mm this is what happens to 21mm/2.5mm tube with 30 degree layover

kiwi307
kiwi307
488 posts
488 posts
4 Jun 2009 10:53am
Hi guys, it seems there is an "issue" with these rollovers somewhere.
I have only ever used 12mm or 15mm solid and never had one bend on a Class 5.
I don't quite understand why a 20 by 2.5mm tube would bend, this is stronger than the rear axle tubes!!
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
4 Jun 2009 10:54am
Layover steering looks real neat and makes the yacht look real sleek, However what are the advantages over traditional type steering with about 70 degrees?
kiwi307
kiwi307
488 posts
488 posts
4 Jun 2009 11:04am
gsand said...

Layover steering looks real neat and makes the yacht look real sleek, However what are the advantages over traditional type steering with about 70 degrees?


The major advantage is that it steers better, ie more likely to be true to where you point it.
Also allows the chassis to be lower at the front (less windage), less load on the wheel. you don't "turn" a wheelbarrow, you lean it over, this is sort of where it came from. Likewise you don't turn a bike so much as a lean.
Disadvantages; More complex to make well, easy to stuff up! the axis of the pivot MUST meet the tyre contact patch, ie no lead, no trail. If it does not you get some "interesting" behaviour. in the early experimentation it seemed the yachts were out of balance (CofE in relation Cof R) but a bit of experimenting showed it was steering geometry as mentioned above. A clue when you have it correct is if the yacht tracks perfectly straight when you push it.
iand
iand
QLD
243 posts
QLD, 243 posts
4 Jun 2009 2:25pm
"I don't quite understand why a 20 by 2.5mm tube would bend, this is stronger than the rear axle tubes"?
Answer- you would need to see the rocks the learner pilot was hitting, plus- 30 by 2.0mm sq (rear axle tubes) is a lot stronger than 21 by 2.5mm rnd
Regards the lay over steering - even pushbike steering has it, just not to the same degree.
advantages also include- not being as twitchy at speed (it's even noticeable going from 45 degrees to 30 degrees), less side stress in turns on tyre/rim- which allows you to run a pushbike wheel if you wish and give it a hard time
"A clue when you have it correct is if the yacht tracks perfectly straight when you push it"- another is if the front end lifts or lows when you turn the steering (it's only a small amount so a block of wood under the tube and turn to see if the gap changes)
kiwi307
kiwi307
488 posts
488 posts
4 Jun 2009 3:57pm
Bending of tubes?
The stub axles on the rear, if Pauls plans are followed are 20mm (or 25 for the low speed bearings) and at right angles to the direction of travel.
The front shaft should not be carrying very much weight at all static, Paul gives a suggestion for this front weight too, and this load path is basically in the perpendicular to the wheel, ie along the shaft. I would have thought that even hitting rocks would have damaged the wheel before bending the pivot shaft?
The load to bend a bit of tube like this over such a localised area is huge!
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
4 Jun 2009 5:57pm
The "Sandpiper" had steering problems and they were....
The front wheel had a VERY light down force, and slid around on soft surfaces.
The wheel skipped a bit when turned sharply.
With the jib and high winds it was almost inpossible to turn without letting the jib off.
If similar steering to a sandpiper was used on a LLMini all the angles would need to be rejigged as the front would rise, the mast rake would then need to change, the seat and steering angle would all be different making it a TOTALLY different yacht (and I don't think for the better)
The LLMini plans work and work VERY well!!! stick with them
landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
4 Jun 2009 8:04pm
Basically its a weight over the front end thing. you need that bit extra weight over the front wheel. If you go from downwind to upwind with a lot of speed and little weight on the front wheel you can simply flip over backwards, Nappy rush is JUST on the edge of not doing that. all the front ends Ive bent have been on rough Euro style beaches , or walyungup gravel soI designed the front so it wont break. that then becomes one less thing to worry about. with 20mm solid , concrete kerbs in little carparks are no longer of concern
its great to see some of the failures getting reported, as we can all learn from each little experiment
gsand
gsand
19 posts
19 posts
4 Jun 2009 10:00pm
Thanks to all that have helped out here.

Its settled, I will be building exactly to the plan, commencing construction this weekend.

My yacht however will be a tad heavier than the normal :P

Consider it ballast I got given some of the required tube for the main beam however slightly thicker at 3.6mm wall

Once ive got the chassis sorted out I'll move on to the sail and rigging... another topic ive not much idea about!!!

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply