Capsized Catamaran Manly boat harbour QLD

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
JAKE123
JAKE123
QLD
314 posts
QLD, 314 posts
9 Jan 2015 12:52am
Hi Guys,

I was sitting on the training wall with a couple of mates tonight and we saw the coastguard tow in a capsized cat.
The yacht looked to be about 30-35 feet long. She was being towed upside down and one hull was partially full of water as it was sitting low.

Has anyone heard anything?

Regards

Jake
brizzydave
brizzydave
406 posts
406 posts
8 Jan 2015 10:59pm
Fark! Joizes?? Might go down n have a squizz?
JAKE123
JAKE123
QLD
314 posts
QLD, 314 posts
9 Jan 2015 8:30pm
Yeah pretty crazy. It was only 15 - maybe 20 knot gusts that day.

Did you see anything dave?
Sectorsteve
Sectorsteve
QLD
2195 posts
QLD, 2195 posts
9 Jan 2015 8:39pm
Ouch
brizzydave
brizzydave
406 posts
406 posts
10 Jan 2015 7:01am
I haven't got off my lazy behind to go look to be honest. Sorry. A guy I know owns a business in one of the yards down there. I'll ask him.
DrRog
DrRog
NSW
608 posts
brizzydave
brizzydave
406 posts
406 posts
11 Jan 2015 8:30pm
They are a nasty business and Bad for your health, I say what......catamarans.
HG02
HG02
VIC
5814 posts
VIC, 5814 posts
12 Jan 2015 1:43am
You just to adjust your sail area according to the wind and be on the caution side. There reasonably safe. I can recall reading about Simpson cat in a really big storm off New Zealand many years ago. Really huge waves along with a mono the Simpson ended up with slight bridge deck crack the mono lost its mast both crews abandoned there boats and were taken on board I think a Navy ship. They were really big waves
The Bridge deck crack occurred after the crew abandoned the Cat and was later recovered by the owner
McNaughtical
McNaughtical
NSW
908 posts
NSW, 908 posts
13 Jan 2015 10:09pm
I'm glad I chose a mono
Bananabender
Bananabender
QLD
1610 posts
QLD, 1610 posts
13 Jan 2015 9:23pm
Makes one wonder if cats require very different skills . The one Dr Rog refers to is not the one Jake 123 refers
radar
radar
NSW
86 posts
NSW, 86 posts
13 Jan 2015 11:17pm
hey guys that cat is a racing cat with a oversize mast and oversize sail area for racing purposes only
not a well found cruising cat with a conservative size mast and sail area
I went sailing today on lake maquarie with a constant 25 knot south easterly with
full main and headsail with no problems at all ,highest speed attained was only
nine knots on a reach with no hint of capsize ,round up or any other nasty habbits
that the over canvased racing boats will have ,it seems that as soon as someone sees
a racing mutihull capsize all mutihulls are considered extreamly dangerous boats that
capsize all the time, far from the truth
well designed and built cruising catamarans have a very low risk of capsize due to the conservative
rig designed for the particular boat, just like any cruising monohull ,and then we all over load our boats
and the risk of capsize deminishes compleatly
if any of you guys want to sail a cruising catamaran on lake maquarie feel free to message me
just my 2 cents worth, cheers ray
HG02
HG02
VIC
5814 posts
VIC, 5814 posts
14 Jan 2015 12:17am
And how many other cats have over turned over the past 12 months thats you have heard of . This is the first I know of and as Radar said its a racer not a cruiser
scruzin
scruzin
SA
564 posts
SA, 564 posts
14 Jan 2015 9:04pm
HG02 said..
And how many other cats have over turned over the past 12 months thats you have heard of . This is the first I know of and as Radar said its a racer not a cruiser



Exactly!

Folks, please stop confusing racing mutihulls with their cruising counterparts. It is true that racing cats capsize quite often, but that is because they are hardly more than super-sized Hobie cats and regularly pushed beyond their limits. Cruising cats, on the other hand, are safe and stable, and routinely crossing the world's oceans.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply