Cat 2 - Help!

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
topknot
topknot
NSW
6 posts
NSW, 6 posts
12 Jun 2011 6:34pm
Hi all; I am planning to enter the Pittwater to Coffs Harbour race this year in my Carter33 sailing yacht. However, the Cat2 classification throws up some things I am not familiar with.

Specifically, entry requires the following:
Verification of stability
Stability declaration (where applicable)
Verification of construction
and (all marked 'If Applicable') an:
ICR
ORC or
One Design Certificate

Can anyone advise what these are and how I would go about getting them done? Is it just through a shipwright?

Also - with the HF radio requirement - does it need to have DSC or is a good certified second hand unit going to be ok? (With selcall etc).

All of the other requirements are pretty straightforward in terms of crew certification levels, HF radio etc etc.

Advice will be appreciated!

Poodle
Poodle
WA
868 posts
WA, 868 posts
12 Jun 2011 5:16pm
Hey Topknot,

You probably need the "SSS Base Value" for stability. Internet search? Any other Carter 33 on the IRC data base? Manufacturer / designer...??

IRC & ORC are two rating (handicap) systems - Probably not compulsory. We are big fans of IRC.

I doubt you need DSC on your HF - Although it is handy, it is not widely supported here on the West Coast. HF unit does need licence, and someone must hold the radio licence.

I assume you have gone through all the myriad regulations in the Blue Book (RRS)...??

I hope this helps a bit ;-)

Poods
topknot
topknot
NSW
6 posts
NSW, 6 posts
12 Jun 2011 7:53pm
Hi - thanks that is useful. Do you know who does these ratings (eg construction etc)? Or do I just find it on the internet somewhere.

I assumed (probably quite safely) that because it is boat related it will cost $$$ somewhere!

Thanks for advice on HF. That's good re DSC; I think I've tracked down a second hand set on that basis!

Does anyone else know the answers to my other questions (above)?
Jethrow
Jethrow
NSW
1282 posts
NSW, 1282 posts
12 Jun 2011 8:51pm
You will need to obtain an IRC certificate to get the stability index. NSWYA will do this. I don't think you can get the numbers from an old IOR cetificate which is what the boat probably has. There may be an IRC certificate for a Carter somewhere though. Where abouts are you? there is help availabe but easier if we know your location. The construction requirements could be harder though as the boat was constructed before the scantling requirements were in effect. I have no doubt the boat is strong enough to comply but having the little peice of paper might be harder. I'm not entirely sure but I think the HF requirement has been eased too...
topknot
topknot
NSW
6 posts
NSW, 6 posts
12 Jun 2011 8:59pm
Hi jethrow I'm moored in kogarah bay (back of botany bay)

Glad helps available! I should ring yachting NSW re the certificate then? Or someone else?

Poodle
Poodle
WA
868 posts
WA, 868 posts
14 Jun 2011 9:43am
Hey Topknot - How'd you get on with this...???
topknot
topknot
NSW
6 posts
NSW, 6 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:08pm
Hi - i've been told now that I dont' need to worry about IOR/IRC measurements etc unless I want to really compete against Wild Oats X - which will be hard in a carter - even if the iron genny was on!

Apparently they just allocate a PHS rating?

DO you know if that is true?

Another question while I am here - who would prepare a constuction worthiness certificate and who would prepare a stability and downflooding analysis?
Poodle
Poodle
WA
868 posts
WA, 868 posts
15 Jun 2011 9:40am
Correct - IRC & ORC are two measurment based rating systems (not a handicap) - Based on length, weight, sail area, hull shape, etc. Not mandatory, but necessary if you are a keen competitotr. PHS (Performance Handicap System??) is more locally based, and will use basic measuments (length, disp, sail area, etc), and then that will be adjusted in a range for your peformance & the type of race. You should get a PHS handicap for the race from the organising authority.

I'm not familiar with the Carter 33. Is it based on the old IOR 3/4 type of design...?? I used to own a UFO34 (similar to an S&S34) - very seaworthy boats. Was the Carter a local design? When were they built?? Has anyone ever had one certified to Cat 2 or cat 3 before? If you know the name of other Carter 33's, do some Google searches of race results to see if you can find another that has been certified.

Have you spoken with Yachting Australia? I assume you are affiliated with YA via your club, so put those fees to good use and see if they have any Carter 33's on record that have achieved cat 2

Failing all the above, you can get a Naval Artichoke to do the stablity & design reviews, but like you noted, that will be quite a few $$$

I trust this helps a bit

Poods

topknot
topknot
NSW
6 posts
NSW, 6 posts
15 Jun 2011 9:38pm
Hi poodle thanks that's very useful.

The Carter was a very popular race boat in ior times. Theyve done Hobart's fastnets etc so can achieve the rating I'd think. Got a good reputation though no longer the fast boats they used to be!

Supposedly similar to s&s. I considered a UFO but liked the aft cockpit cc lay out for privacy on longer trips. Not that I ever get time!!

Designed by dick Carter in the us. Built in Greece Poland south America and by passage yachts here in aus. Mine is the centre cockpit version and I love it. Link to an aft cockpit version below for sale
sundancemarine.com.au/brokerage-boat-sales/

sundancemarine.com.au/brokerage-boat-sales/
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7757 posts
NSW, 7757 posts
15 Jun 2011 10:35pm
Poodle said...

Correct - IRC & ORC are two measurment based rating systems (not a handicap) - Based on length, weight, sail area, hull shape, etc. Not mandatory, but necessary if you are a keen competitotr. PHS (Performance Handicap System??) is more locally based, and will use basic measuments (length, disp, sail area, etc), and then that will be adjusted in a range for your peformance & the type of race. You should get a PHS handicap for the race from the organising authority.

I'm not familiar with the Carter 33. Is it based on the old IOR 3/4 type of design...?? I used to own a UFO34 (similar to an S&S34) - very seaworthy boats. Was the Carter a local design? When were they built?? Has anyone ever had one certified to Cat 2 or cat 3 before? If you know the name of other Carter 33's, do some Google searches of race results to see if you can find another that has been certified.

Have you spoken with Yachting Australia? I assume you are affiliated with YA via your club, so put those fees to good use and see if they have any Carter 33's on record that have achieved cat 2

Failing all the above, you can get a Naval Artichoke to do the stablity & design reviews, but like you noted, that will be quite a few $$$

I trust this helps a bit

Poods




Probably more Carter 33's sailed in Hobart races that SS34's in the seventies. I'm fairly confident they are not the same as the 3/4 tonner but plenty of info should be on www.boatdesign.net/forums/ The Australian versions with the aft cockpit had a more race oriented layout than the European version by Olympic built in Greece. Nice boats apparently, more stable downwind than an SS34.
topknot
topknot
NSW
6 posts
NSW, 6 posts
16 Jun 2011 12:02am
Whoops I meant aft cabin and centre cockpit! Yes its a lovely boat and great to sail. I had a top hat before so it's much faster and so much room by comparison. And a hot shower and head you can fit in.

Tried to post a pic but doesn't like my iPad!

Thanks for the advice guys.

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply