Hello Sirgallivant, Sorry to get your hackles up, but just to clarify my position. I carry 3 x EBIRBs. One (MT403G) inside the life raft, one (MT403G) attached in the companion way and the smaller unit (MT401G) I have on me at all times. What I was suggesting (actually wrote) was to buy a new unit and keep the old unit as well. Which would give me 3 x factory sealed units and 1 possible spare that I could keep replacing batteries (if needed) till help arrived. Now if you add this to the fact most of my sailing is done solo, there shouldn't be problem with the crew.
And just what do you do when the battery runs out on your EPIRB and help hasn't arrived yet. Poodle's suggestion gave me a glimmer of hope. Think of it this way. Its like having an emergency rudder on you boat for when the main one fails or a backup GPS plotter, or a back up Auto Pilot or spare sheet ropes, spare spark plugs for the outboard. Why shouldn't we all have a backup plan for the EPIRB if it fails before help arrives.
For me, an EPIRB is the absolute last resort and activating it would only be done after exhausting all other avenues. I don't believe other people should endanger their lives to come to my aid. Just read "Fatal Storm". What the rescue crews did during that operation was too much to ask of anyone. You make your own bed, so you should be prepared to lie in it.
If having a backup plan is Criminal, then guilt as charged.