It depends on (a) how serious you are about your SUPing, (b) your own physical make-up, (c) how far above the water your two boards (surf, race) make you stand.

If your surf SUP is quite large, and you paddle a dugout like the Ace, for instance, and you race quite seriously, then one paddle might be fine.

The only way is really to try and find out. You'll probably soon know if your surf paddle is too short for your race board because your back and legs will hurt.

If you do neither activity seriously then you can use an adjustable. Personally I wouldn't take an adjustable into any "serious" conditions, either race or surf. I've had too many let go at critical moments. But other people feel differently. So what you have to ask yourself is "do I feel lucky?" Well, do ya...? ;)

colas said...

I would recommend two fixed quality paddles. Adjustables are heavier and less durable (with time they will leak water, have some wobbles...).

I agree..

ChrisP3 said..
Those Gong paddles work out at about £215, that's pretty good value. I see they also offer some models that would be just over £160 including a specific surf and race paddle (looks like the race is out of stock though), I'd probably be looking at that sort of price for a decent used paddle. Can you point me to any reviews or additional information please Colas?

All the info is in the Gong forum:
The topic on the Gong Pro is www.gong-galaxy.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=69&t=4711
Most of the posts are in French, but you are welcome to post in english.

Basically if these paddles were sold in a shop, via a traditional importer + distributor route, they would sell for twice as much.

I would recommend the Gong Pro. They are a new generation in construction that is so impressive, with a blade shape so refined, that the shaper went now with only one model for everything, whereas he used to make up to 10 different paddle types before. The one you see with specific surf & race models are the old generation, heavier and with a less refined shape, but that are cheaper to produce and more impact resistant as not 100% carbon (for beginners, schools,...). The quality/price ratio of the Pro is definitely stunning.