2013 Naish Mana Air 11'6 vs Naish The One 12'6

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Raginbird
Raginbird
3 posts
3 posts
3 Sep 2013 8:16am
Hi there,

I'm pretty new to the sport and love it. I have a small apt and a small car, so I want an inflatable. After reading up on many ISUPs, I have narrowed it down to the two Naish models (11'6" Mana Air or The One 12'6"). I'm 6'2" 200lbs. Does anyone have any experience on these boards? I've read they are both very stable, but curious if the Mana Air is the better choice because it may be more versatile? I plan on using in ocean bays and lakes and am curious what would be best for a beginner to grow into. Thank you!
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
3 Sep 2013 10:54am
I've paddled both and I'd be choosing the One 12'6" unless you mostly want to be using it in the surf.

I'm about your height and weight..

I can see myself buying the Naish inflatable 12'6" one day because its so good.

DJ
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
3 Sep 2013 12:00pm
If the choice is between those two boards, I'd suspect that the Naish One could also be better in the surf. Just a better size and shape all round. Where are you located Raginbird? There are demos in Melbourne this weekend.
Raginbird
Raginbird
3 posts
3 posts
3 Sep 2013 10:07am
I live in San Diego, there are many sup shops around, but haven't seen these boards in the showroom. I think for what I will be doing, The One is the way to go. I'm sure anything will be better than the shorter and cheap rentals I've been using! Thank you both for your input!
tbwill
tbwill
1 posts
1 posts
3 Sep 2013 1:53pm
I own both boards, but my Mana is the 10'0" version. For flat water paddling definitely go with the 12'6" Naish One. The Mana was my first board and after two months I was looking for something a little faster. DJ's right, if you plan to be in the surf a lot the Mana has a lot more rocker, but for mostly flat water the Naish One is the way to go. After a couple of months with the Naish One, I'm now looking at a 12'6" or 14" Naish Glide, can't stop the fever

Tom
Aramathorn
Aramathorn
VIC
117 posts
VIC, 117 posts
4 Sep 2013 9:26pm
PTWoody said..

If the choice is between those two boards, I'd suspect that the Naish One could also be better in the surf. Just a better size and shape all round. Where are you located Raginbird? There are demos in Melbourne this weekend.




Hi PTWoody, I've sent you a PM, but will post here as well. Where are the demos in Melbourne this weekend?
waxer00
waxer00
37 posts
37 posts
4 Sep 2013 9:05pm
naish one is the best isup I have tested by far.stable ,quick and really light for it`s size;10kegs I think.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
4 Sep 2013 11:42pm
Aramathorn said..

PTWoody said..

If the choice is between those two boards, I'd suspect that the Naish One could also be better in the surf. Just a better size and shape all round. Where are you located Raginbird? There are demos in Melbourne this weekend.




Hi PTWoody, I've sent you a PM, but will post here as well. Where are the demos in Melbourne this weekend?



As per reply PM, demo at Sandridge Beach Port Melbourne on Saturday morning from 10.30am to 1pm.
Aramathorn
Aramathorn
VIC
117 posts
VIC, 117 posts
4 Sep 2013 11:43pm
thank you for letting me know. WIll have to see if I can get some time to come down and watch.
NeilInOz
NeilInOz
ACT
30 posts
ACT, 30 posts
6 Sep 2013 12:42am
Don't just watch, paddle! I had a go on the One and if I was living in an apartment I'd grab one. It was a while ago when I was uber-wobbly, and I thought it pretty good on flat stuff. I have the impression its sweet spot is 85kgs, 5'11" or thereabouts. Or smaller maybe. It certainly is light. But a rigid board for me felt better.
Raginbird
Raginbird
3 posts
3 posts
8 Sep 2013 1:09am
Update: Naish One was out of stock everywhere I looked around me, so I ended up going with the 12'6' Race by Red Paddle Company. Although I don't have much to compare to, as I am new to the sport, I couldn't be happier! Top notch quality, stable, and faster than any of the crappy rentals I've used (those were shorter also). I've only taken it out in lagoons, but will try the ocean soon enough. Thanks everyone!
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply