2014 Naish Mana 9'5 @ 6'2 110kgs...?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
808-Obsession
808-Obsession
QLD
452 posts
QLD, 452 posts
19 Sep 2014 1:02pm
I know Mana's have been discussed constantly on here, but any opinions on a 2014 Naish Mana for a 6'2 110kg former (as in 20 years ago!) surfer, improving SUP'er wanting a bit of basic 'surfability' (too old and broken to be throwing it around!) in a board but also stable & buoyant enough for a guy my size to easily paddle in flat water and hanging around out the back waiting for the sets to come through? Too low in volume? Shape not stable enough? I know DJ has a version of it (Alana?) with same dimensions but I believe he's 15kgs+ lighter and a helluva lot more experienced! Am limited as to length I can get due to storage constraints - 9'10 is about as long as I can get, or I'd look at the 10' Mana or a Nalu...advice would be more than welcome please!
Stev0
Stev0
422 posts
422 posts
19 Sep 2014 11:31am
Dude, Looking at the specs of the 9'5 Mana the max rider weight is 95kg. I had a 9'5 Mana when I was starting out and it is super stable but I'm 85kg. You might want to look at the 9'6 X32 as max rider weight is 109Kg so that might suit you better? Both are 32" wide but I reckon the X32 is better at surfing than the Mana too.

www.naishsurfing.com/product/hokua-96-x-32-le/
808-Obsession
808-Obsession
QLD
452 posts
QLD, 452 posts
19 Sep 2014 1:45pm
Stev0 said...
Dude, Looking at the specs of the 9'5 Mana the max rider weight is 95kg. I had a 9'5 Mana when I was starting out and it is super stable but I'm 85kg. You might want to look at the 9'6 X32 as max rider weight is 109Kg so that might suit you better? Both are 32" wide but I reckon the X32 is better at surfing than the Mana too.

www.naishsurfing.com/product/hokua-96-x-32-le/


Thanks Stev0 - great suggestion, and I did think of the X32 but was thinking the pulled-in nose and tail might make it a little less stable than the Mana? Am also assuming the rocker would be more pronounced on the X32 so not quite as good in flat water? Point taken re. the recommended rider weight though. This fat bastard needs to shed some kegs!
DavidJohn
DavidJohn
VIC
17570 posts
VIC, 17570 posts
19 Sep 2014 1:47pm
Stev0 said..
Dude, Looking at the specs of the 9'5 Mana the max rider weight is 95kg. I had a 9'5 Mana when I was starting out and it is super stable but I'm 85kg. You might want to look at the 9'6 X32 as max rider weight is 109Kg so that might suit you better? Both are 32" wide but I reckon the X32 is better at surfing than the Mana too.

www.naishsurfing.com/product/hokua-96-x-32-le/


I agree the new 9'6" X32 Hokua would be defiantly worth checking out.. but my 9'1" Hokua is less less stable than my 9'5" Mana.. The Hokua seems chunkier in the rails but the nose is much more pointy with a lot more rocker.. Making it slightly tippier for me.. I'm guessing the Hokua will float you better but the Mana will still be more stable even with water washing over the deck.. I'm 6'4" and normally about 95kg but a little more with my winter coat on.. I'm thinking the 9'5" Mana will be the best option if your main priority is surfing performance but if you're after that extra float and stability along with better flat water paddling ease I'd say go for the bigger 10' Mana.. IMO if you're choosing between the slightly smaller option and the slightly bigger option I'd recommend going the slightly bigger option every time.
808-Obsession
808-Obsession
QLD
452 posts
QLD, 452 posts
19 Sep 2014 1:58pm
DavidJohn said...
Stev0 said..
Dude, Looking at the specs of the 9'5 Mana the max rider weight is 95kg. I had a 9'5 Mana when I was starting out and it is super stable but I'm 85kg. You might want to look at the 9'6 X32 as max rider weight is 109Kg so that might suit you better? Both are 32" wide but I reckon the X32 is better at surfing than the Mana too.

www.naishsurfing.com/product/hokua-96-x-32-le/


I agree the new 9'6" X32 Hokua would be defiantly worth checking out.. but my 9'1" Hokua is less less stable than my 9'5" Mana.. The Hokua seems chunkier in the rails but the nose is much more pointy with a lot more rocker.. Making it slightly tippier for me.. I'm guessing the Hokua will float you better but the Mana will still be more stable even with water washing over the deck.. I'm 6'4" and normally about 95kg but a little more with my winter coat on.. I'm thinking the 9'5" Mana will be the best option if your main priority is surfing performance but if you're after that extra float and stability along with better flat water paddling ease I'd say go for the bigger 10' Mana.. IMO if you're choosing between the slightly smaller option and the slightly bigger option I'd recommend going the slightly bigger option every time.


Thanks DJ - sage advice as always
Stev0
Stev0
422 posts
422 posts
19 Sep 2014 12:18pm
If you need the flat water option then the 10' Mana x33" is the one to go for. The x32 has a lot of rocker which is why it will surf better than the Mana but not as good cruising in the flat. Just make extra space in the garage to squeeze in a 10 footer?
supthecreek
supthecreek
2783 posts
2783 posts
19 Sep 2014 12:51pm
roscoe... you said you want easy paddling and standing out back.... didn't really want to throw it around.

I have had 2 9'5 mana's and really liked them both, I'm 104 kg.... and I agree with the others that the 9'5 would not be boarderline for you.

I think that a board you should consider is the Fanatic Allwave 9'10 x 33 at 191 liters.
Super stable, surfs well and very durable.
Not as good a wave performer as the 32LE, which looks awesome.... but it will paddle much straighter and have more comfort in rough water

Plus.... it will probably come in about $800 cheaper than the New Naish 9'6.

Just an option to look at....
808-Obsession
808-Obsession
QLD
452 posts
QLD, 452 posts
19 Sep 2014 3:10pm
supthecreek said...
roscoe... you said you want easy paddling and standing out back.... didn't really want to throw it around.

I have had 2 9'5 mana's and really liked them both, I'm 104 kg.... and I agree with the others that the 9'5 would not be boarderline for you.

I think that a board you should consider is the Fanatic Allwave 9'10 x 33 at 191 liters.
Super stable, surfs well and very durable.
Not as good a wave performer as the 32LE, which looks awesome.... but it will paddle much straighter and have more comfort in rough water

Plus.... it will probably come in about $800 cheaper than the New Naish 9'6.

Just an option to look at....


Thanks supthecreek - will check that out as well
CrustyD
CrustyD
SA
32 posts
SA, 32 posts
19 Sep 2014 7:22pm
Roscoe 1974. Mate just had a quick look around Sup sites re prices and surprised to see that the Mana was at times 200 to 300 dollars cheaper than the Fanatic. Just to add to your thought process.
808-Obsession
808-Obsession
QLD
452 posts
QLD, 452 posts
19 Sep 2014 10:32pm
CrustyD said...
Roscoe 1974. Mate just had a quick look around Sup sites re prices and surprised to see that the Mana was at times 200 to 300 dollars cheaper than the Fanatic. Just to add to your thought process.


Cheers for that Crusty. Yep I've noticed similar patterns. Not a huge amount of 9'10 Allwaves around that I can see either? Judging by the previous advice though, the Mana just might be that tad too small for me, and I physically can't manage to squeeze anything into the storage spot that's longer than 9'10 (and that'll be pushing it!). Rented a Naish Odysseus for a couple of days as was thinking about those, but found it just that bit TOO stable (ie. tough to turn etc.). Will keep an eye out for a demo on a 9'10 Allwave I think. Anyone know of a Dealer with a 9'10 to demo around the Brisbane/Sunny Coast/Goldie area?
Brenno
Brenno
QLD
909 posts
QLD, 909 posts
20 Sep 2014 3:48pm
Go the x32. I just traded my 9'10" hokua for a 9'1" x32 and it's a whole different beast for a big bloke. At 6'2" and 95ish kg, i was pleasantly suprised how stable it is and how well it surfs. By the way i was cast in to this world in '69, and i too am broken, but sup has brought me back to the waves and i don't intend to quit anytime soon!
Cobra
Cobra
9106 posts
9106 posts
21 Sep 2014 5:40pm
im 6'2" 105kg have been out to 109kg I've owned the 9'1" x32 2014 and the 9'6" x32 hokua 2015 and the naish 9'6" mana 2015.
if we are going to talk stability the mana ticks the box... next 9'6" then the 9'1" Hokua's….I've had all boards out in 20knt winds.
surf wise, nothing separating the Hokua's 9.6 and 9.1.but both perform way ahead of the mana.
i still own the Hokua's,i moved the mana on, but not because of stability.
Cobra
Cobra
9106 posts
9106 posts
21 Sep 2014 5:48pm
if you want comfort in the lineup ,go the 10' Mana..surfs well + you can dance and read the paper at the same time waiting for the sets.
Chapstar3000
Chapstar3000
NSW
9 posts
NSW, 9 posts
21 Sep 2014 8:09pm
Cobra said..
if you want comfort in the lineup ,go the 10' Mana..surfs well + you can dance and read the paper at the same time waiting for the sets.


Agree I'm 105 kg's and have surfed the 10' mana for a couple of years. Who cares about chucking it around that much anyway. They turn great and the 2015's seem more turntable (paddled one on flat yesterday) and you can get on the nose when the opportunity arises!!!
808-Obsession
808-Obsession
QLD
452 posts
QLD, 452 posts
21 Sep 2014 8:44pm
Cheers for the advice guys - very helpful all round. Would love the X32 but at this stage it's likely A) a bit out of my skill range, and B) quite a way outside my budget until they start making it into the 'used' scene.

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply