Both excellent boards IMO.
I'm thinking the Naish will be slightly better dealing with side winds and side chop..
and the Starboard might be slightly better on the flatter water..
The Jav having deck pad all the way back is much better for DWing .. but you can also add deck grip to the Allstar.
I'm also thinking the Naish shape will be slightly more forgiving and the Statboard a little more technical.
You need to demo both and see what you have a gut feel as to what's best for you.. or toss a coin..