Hi slab
I've been on the Style Lord since last September and loving it - it's pretty much my do everything board - small waves carries speed and loose off the tail - larger stuff it holds in well (I'm about 78kgs).
The other nice things is it's prefect size for the wife to do some beginner paddling on

Disclaimer:
Haven't compared to boards you mentioned
and
I'm connected to a seller of SMIK - nalusurf.com.au in Torquay who have the full range of SMIKs for demo