Snap Tomooh - 85kg, 6'1" with a long history of surfing (only 30 years though!) and also paddling a racing ski. Starting Sup-ing about a year ago when I picked up a PSH 12ft gun (28 7/8s wide). First time out the one sided paddling felt really awkward - like I was zig-zagging all over the place. Second time out was into 6 ft heavy beach break with lots of chop inshore - very little joy on any front. Since then I have had some great sessions on flat water and in the surf, from 2ft to 6ft, and I have gotten used to the one sided paddling. So much so that I haven't taken out long board or short board at all!
Last weekend I paddled 15kms mostly flat water, then surfed a fantastic 3-4ft right hander for another 2 hrs. I don't have a lot to compare it with but having put in a bit of time to get my feet, the PSH 12 ft gun is an excellent all-round board that surfs really well. There were times during the 15kms where I still thought a two sided paddle would be more efficient and easier to use, but here is my take on why one-sided survives, especially for surfing:
- it's easier to push down with top hand when it is on top of one-sided paddle shaft, than it would be holding a mid-part of longer two-sided paddle;
- when surfing, you spend more time with one foot in front of the other (especially when accelerating into a wave) which makes off-side paddling very awkward;
- once you get used to the one-sided, apathy takes over and you don't think about it anymore.
If you want to have a look at how the paddle can be used while surfing - check out this clip on youtube
Stick with it - the rewards are worth it.