12ft 6' vs 14ft

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Scotty88
Scotty88
4214 posts
4214 posts
13 Jun 2011 7:48pm
Tell me the pros & cons of let's say a DC12"6 & DC14" or any make. Why would you train on one or both ?
Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
14 Jun 2011 1:49pm
How many paragraphs will Lacey write on this one !

Here's my 2 cents on where is seems to be heading....

Various race organisers have various classes to race within.... It seems to have settled into 3 classes;
- 12'6 or under
- 14' or under
- and Unlimited, or over 14 foot.

12'6 seems to be the BoP Standard Class (Battle of The Paddle style event, often in and out through some waves) Get forward, and the nose is often cutting through the water, and get back, and you can surf off the tail a bit...

14'0 is turning into a class for pure flat water distance. Flatter rockers, and the nose cutting through the water.

Of course there is also 14 foot Down Wind Class, with more rocker.

Unlimited is the preference for Elite (Extra) Long Distance Events. Such as Hawaiian Inter-Island Crossings, and long distance Down Wind. Of course, 14's can perform well in this arena too.

That's a bit of an overview anyway.


--------------

Lacey is a good person to answer your specific question. But the short answer is probably;
- depends which races you are planning on entering.... and / or - depends which you prefer to paddle regularly

Scotty, I think you said you are up in the 100 kegs range ? 14 should be a faster board for you.

Also, keep in mind that DC (and others) do 14' Down Winders, and 14' Flat Water Racers..... eg, Naish Javalin (14' flat water), and Naish Glide (14' DW). These two Naish boards have surprisingly similar "templates" but vastly different rockers and rails!

For me, I quite enjoy my Naish 17 on a regular basis. Covers me for distance touring, down wind, and flat water, and even little knee high peelers that are barely surfable on anything else. When the waves move into thigh high+, I'll be on "surf" equipment of some kind !


Scotty88
Scotty88
4214 posts
4214 posts
14 Jun 2011 11:52am
Scotty88 said...

Tell me the pros & cons of let's say a DC12"6 & DC14" or any make. Why would you train on one or both ?


Ok, so I will word my post another way.
I will be looking to upgrade to a race board in the near future and would appreciate advice on weather to purchase a 12"6 or a 14ft. I won't mention any brands, shapers,etc. Just looking for advice. After 178 reads of my post and no replies, I assume I have offended a few over-sensitive people by mentioning DC. Trust me when I say I have no agenda as i was only using the forementioned brand as an example as i know they do both sizes. I have found this website very useful as I am new to the sport. Don't let me down now.
Scotty88
Scotty88
4214 posts
4214 posts
14 Jun 2011 11:55am
Cheers Simondo for the response. Bloody iPad froze up and sent after your post. Appreciate the feedback
PeterP
PeterP
873 posts
873 posts
14 Jun 2011 2:43pm
Get a 14' - it's faster. I don't fully understand the argument that you would buy a shorter board to fit into a class that is slower? Or that it is easier to carry around, come on, like 1.5 ft extra is going to make a difference? Pricewise they are the same. A 14 also levels out the field so the bigger guys have a chance.

The 12'6 limit in BOP is an unfortunate rule which has created growth of a class that essentially is not required.

I think it would be much better for industry if we had 14' and Open - it's simpler and makes more sense imho.

Keen to hear other views
faito anto
faito anto
VIC
181 posts
VIC, 181 posts
14 Jun 2011 6:31pm
Hi PeterP,

I see where you're coming from, but as a lightweight rider (circa 70kg) who also happens to currently live in a location with limited storage space, I find 12'6 to be a good length.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
14 Jun 2011 6:48pm
My view? The race organisers have got it exactly right. 12'6" boards are awesome (just look at Jacko's GoPro thread and tell me I'm wrong) and there is enough distinction between them and the open class to make separate classes worthwhile. It's the 14' class that's pointless in my opinion. Don't get me wrong, I love my 14' board for having fun on a downwinder. But I would never bother to race a 14' board. They are mostly so sluggish and slow with too much rocker - no good for flat water and outgunned in a downwind situation by the 16' - 18' boards. Of course there are exceptions - the Javelin and the 14' Ace among others. But do we really want to see any of these boards in a BOP style surf race? That's where the 12'6" boards come into their own.

However for the OP, if you are over 100 kegs as someone hinted, you will most likely not be competitive on a 12'6" board. Not sure what sort of races you are thinking of entering, but as Simondo says, maybe consider open class and get yourself a 17' Glide, a DC or a SIC.
CMC
CMC
QLD
3954 posts
CMC CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:02pm
I kind of disagree regarding the 14' being pointless. The latest 14's by DC, Fanatic and Lahui Kai are ultra fast in the flat and the ocean. They have IMO made specialized boards like the Javelin and 14' Glide redundant. If you want one board that you can surf, paddle in the flat and in the ocean a 14' is the one you want. 12'6 are great in the surf and that's what they are designed for but the 14' is the best length for all round.
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:15pm
PTWoody said...

My view? The race organisers have got it exactly right. 12'6" boards are awesome (just look at Jacko's GoPro thread and tell me I'm wrong) and there is enough distinction between them and the open class to make separate classes worthwhile. It's the 14' class that's pointless in my opinion. Don't get me wrong, I love my 14' board for having fun on a downwinder. But I would never bother to race a 14' board. They are mostly so sluggish and slow with too much rocker - no good for flat water and outgunned in a downwind situation by the 16' - 18' boards. Of course there are exceptions - the Javelin and the 14' Ace among others. But do we really want to see any of these boards in a BOP style surf race? That's where the 12'6" boards come into their own.

However for the OP, if you are over 100 kegs as someone hinted, you will most likely not be competitive on a 12'6" board. Not sure what sort of races you are thinking of entering, but as Simondo says, maybe consider open class and get yourself a 17' Glide, a DC or a SIC.


better tell that to andy and kelly who beat all comers flatwater/ botany bay and ocean/excel respectively on 14' ers

seriously, boards over 14' in australia will be like the dinosuars in the not to distance future. our swells aren't hawaiian. not much point having a board for a once in a blue moon epic day.
my 15'3 is more than enough imo
cheers

cheers
aspaceman
aspaceman
VIC
48 posts
VIC, 48 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:19pm
PTWoody said...

12'6" boards are awesome


If you're a whippet
Gassa
Gassa
QLD
272 posts
QLD, 272 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:20pm
so true i have both 12/6 30.5" wide excellent in surf and a 14 and i weigh in around 100kg the new style 14,s are an allround board flat, ocean and with speed for the larger sized people[yes i love my fanatics]
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:31pm
CMC said...

I kind of disagree regarding the 14' being pointless. The latest 14's by DC, Fanatic and Lahui Kai are ultra fast in the flat and the ocean. They have IMO made specialized boards like the Javelin and 14' Glide redundant. If you want one board that you can surf, paddle in the flat and in the ocean a 14' is the one you want. 12'6 are great in the surf and that's what they are designed for but the 14' is the best length for all round.


I'm trying to bite my tongue but what the hell is the point of racing on a standup anyway, knowing just about any water craft is going to be faster OK, so I get on a 14 foot "race board" at St. Kilda and head of into the distance. Within 5 minutes I'm going to be hauled in by a 20 year old riding a Starboard Whopper. It's the paddler not the boat and if you really want to go fast, paddle a ski or a k1. I must be missing something here but the stand up forum has become more and more the "racing forum". That's ok but lets face facts here, most posters on this forum are between 30 and 50 years old and we all know that any half fit 20 year old with a mild cigarette habit and a decent technique will whip our asses, so what's the point. Added to this we are paddling the worlds slowest watercraft(I think my old 3 man Canadian canoe would be faster). SO......
Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:38pm
CMC said...

I kind of disagree regarding the 14' being pointless. The latest 14's by DC, Fanatic and Lahui Kai are ultra fast in the flat and the ocean. They have IMO made specialized boards like the Javelin and 14' Glide redundant. If you want one board that you can surf, paddle in the flat and in the ocean a 14' is the one you want. 12'6 are great in the surf and that's what they are designed for but the 14' is the best length for all round.


I tend to agree CMC. 14 is a great length for an all-rounder. And yes, there does seems to be a few good all-rounders popping up.

Lets make a 14'0 to 15'3 class for Lacey.
aspaceman
aspaceman
VIC
48 posts
VIC, 48 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:43pm
log man said...
...lets face facts here, most posters on this forum are between 30 and 50 years old and we all know that any half fit 20 year old with a mild cigarette habit and a decent technique will whip our asses...SO......



Shhhhh...
Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2097 posts
QLD, 2097 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:46pm
Gassa said...

so true i have both 12/6 30.5" wide excellent in surf and a 14 and i weigh in around 100kg the new style 14,s are an allround board flat, ocean and with speed for the larger sized people[yes i love my fanatics]

G'day Gassa
How many litres is your 12'6'' + you're a 100kg is that muscle or you a fat f##K
I'm getting a custom 12'6'' by 27'' wide 6' 1/2 thick at 170 litres I'm 89kg off da beer 95kg on da beer I love Fiji Bitter 12 beers a day never goes astray.
Getting the SUP made for Namotu Island Fiji very BIG SUP EVENT in Fiji for November 12th - 19th just waiting on one major Fiji sponsor to give the nob. Before I can promote this SUP event in Australia and Dave Kalama will be promoting it in Hawaii.

Me personaly I'm not into 12'6 or 14ft SUPs I'd rather surf my shortboard
Give me my 17ft f16 or my 17'6'' Bullet when the wind is up for a Downwind paddle or my 18'6'' f18 for no wind Downwind paddle all 3 SUP's are Built for Speed.
DW

CMC
CMC
QLD
3954 posts
CMC CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:53pm
Simple answer log man: because you may go faster on a surf ski than SUP but there will still be someone faster. It's all relative.
Downwinder
Downwinder
QLD
2097 posts
QLD, 2097 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:01pm
CMC said...

Simple answer log man: because you may go faster on a surf ski than SUP but there will still be someone faster. It's all relative.

G'day CMC
Downwind SUPing is for a surfer to do something when the surf is s##t
(surfing the trough)
a surf ski is for the SLSC member to train on
me personaly I'd rather stand in the trough than sit in it. But I couldn't paddle a surf ski to save myself (Help Me Please Mr Wizard)

laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:12pm
log man said...

CMC said...

I kind of disagree regarding the 14' being pointless. The latest 14's by DC, Fanatic and Lahui Kai are ultra fast in the flat and the ocean. They have IMO made specialized boards like the Javelin and 14' Glide redundant. If you want one board that you can surf, paddle in the flat and in the ocean a 14' is the one you want. 12'6 are great in the surf and that's what they are designed for but the 14' is the best length for all round.


I'm trying to bite my tongue but what the hell is the point of racing on a standup anyway, knowing just about any water craft is going to be faster OK, so I get on a 14 foot "race board" at St. Kilda and head of into the distance. Within 5 minutes I'm going to be hauled in by a 20 year old riding a Starboard Whopper. It's the paddler not the boat and if you really want to go fast, paddle a ski or a k1. I must be missing something here but the stand up forum has become more and more the "racing forum". That's ok but lets face facts here, most posters on this forum are between 30 and 50 years old and we all know that any half fit 20 year old with a mild cigarette habit and a decent technique will whip our asses, so what's the point. Added to this we are paddling the worlds slowest watercraft(I think my old 3 man Canadian canoe would be faster). SO......


dw ings biggest problem is the perception you've got to race -crap

most other craft go faster for sure, BUT WE GET TO STANDUP AND SURF THE OCEAN.

THATS THE DIFFERENCE.

i've got something to do in the ocean on most days instead of leaning on the beach fence looking a bad surf
cheers

Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:22pm
laceys lane said...



i've got something to do in the ocean on most days instead of leaning on the beach fence looking a bad surf
cheers




Bingo! Exactly!
Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:24pm
Downwinder said...


G'day CMC
Downwind SUPing is for a surfer to do something when the surf is s##t
(surfing the trough)




Exactly !

------

On a different note, that reminds me of Zackery's Disease. Your face looks exZachery the same as you bum ! (Not you Downwinder!)
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:41pm
Simondo said...

CMC said...

I kind of disagree regarding the 14' being pointless. The latest 14's by DC, Fanatic and Lahui Kai are ultra fast in the flat and the ocean. They have IMO made specialized boards like the Javelin and 14' Glide redundant. If you want one board that you can surf, paddle in the flat and in the ocean a 14' is the one you want. 12'6 are great in the surf and that's what they are designed for but the 14' is the best length for all round.


I tend to agree CMC. 14 is a great length for an all-rounder. And yes, there does seems to be a few good all-rounders popping up.

Lets make a 14'0 to 15'3 class for Lacey.


Not sure about Lacey's 15'3 but I reckon the K15 would absolutely smash any 14' in flat water.
Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:45pm
Depends on how many turns are in the course PT ! But yes, it's a pretty quick SUP.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:46pm
laceys lane said...

dw ings biggest problem is the perception you've got to race -crap

most other craft go faster for sure, BUT WE GET TO STANDUP AND SURF THE OCEAN.

THATS THE DIFFERENCE.





Damn straight. Jonathan made a point on the Zone a couple weeks back about the fastest DW board not necessarily being the most fun. I know I've taken my flat water race boards on weak DW runs and got no runners at all but still beat the other guys home. They went looking for runners and had a blast. That's when I learned that being first home in a DW run is not necessarily a good thing.
laceys lane
laceys lane
QLD
19804 posts
QLD, 19804 posts
14 Jun 2011 8:53pm
PTWoody said...

Simondo said...

CMC said...

I kind of disagree regarding the 14' being pointless. The latest 14's by DC, Fanatic and Lahui Kai are ultra fast in the flat and the ocean. They have IMO made specialized boards like the Javelin and 14' Glide redundant. If you want one board that you can surf, paddle in the flat and in the ocean a 14' is the one you want. 12'6 are great in the surf and that's what they are designed for but the 14' is the best length for all round.


I tend to agree CMC. 14 is a great length for an all-rounder. And yes, there does seems to be a few good all-rounders popping up.

Lets make a 14'0 to 15'3 class for Lacey.


Not sure about Lacey's 15'3 but I reckon the K15 would absolutely smash any 14' in flat water.


probably gets down to who's on what i would say.

jacko is pretty dam quick on a jav.

andy beat everybody, including some very big boards on this



its about 24.5 " wide. with chines in there, you are probably standing on about 22" in width
cheers
Scotty88
Scotty88
4214 posts
4214 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:08pm
Great feedback guys.
At 125kg (and heading south) & 6"2 I am top heavy and would find the 12"6 boards too tippy.
My paddling is flat water as not to many downwinders available around Sydney's east (correct me if I'm wrong).
Re: Simondo's post. If the Jav is for flat water & the Glide for DW, then what makes the 17" an all rounder ????
I would love a regular Downwinder as iit looks a whole lot of fun.
Gassa
Gassa
QLD
272 posts
QLD, 272 posts
14 Jun 2011 9:12pm
this is all bull s--t scotty 88 just trial a few boards and find one that u like AND JUST ENJOY IT eveyone to there own IM 6'5" and love my fanatic 12'6" the white version
Gassa
Gassa
QLD
272 posts
QLD, 272 posts
14 Jun 2011 9:17pm
Downwinder said...

Gassa said...

so true i have both 12/6 30.5" wide excellent in surf and a 14 and i weigh in around 100kg the new style 14,s are an allround board flat, ocean and with speed for the larger sized people[yes i love my fanatics]

G'day Gassa
How many litres is your 12'6'' + you're a 100kg is that muscle or you a fat f##K
I'm getting a custom 12'6'' by 27'' wide 6' 1/2 thick at 170 litres I'm 89kg off da beer 95kg on da beer I love Fiji Bitter 12 beers a day never goes astray.
Getting the SUP made for Namotu Island Fiji very BIG SUP EVENT in Fiji for November 12th - 19th just waiting on one major Fiji sponsor to give the nob. Before I can promote this SUP event in Australia and Dave Kalama will be promoting it in Hawaii.

Me personaly I'm not into 12'6 or 14ft SUPs I'd rather surf my shortboard
Give me my 17ft f16 or my 17'6'' Bullet when the wind is up for a Downwind paddle or my 18'6'' f18 for no wind Downwind paddle all 3 SUP's are Built for Speed.
DW




lol muscle now use to be 127kg till i got off my mals and started serious supin plus im 6'5" just enjoying life now 254 ltr fanatic fly
Simondo
Simondo
VIC
8025 posts
VIC, 8025 posts
14 Jun 2011 9:19pm
Scotty,

Technically, the Glide 17 is a Down Wind Board. But it is very stable, and is a really good Open Water Ocean Tourer, and enclosed water tourer. It has really soft round rails up the front, and a rudder, so it is actually quite controllable paddling at 45 degrees into the wind. Most boards hate that angle. It's competent in flat water too (quite quick). But other boards are quicker on the flats.

But as they say... some boards might be all-rounders but masters of none.

Scotty88
Scotty88
4214 posts
4214 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:19pm
Gassa said...

this is all bull s--t scotty 88 just trial a few boards and find one that u like AND JUST ENJOY IT eveyone to there own


Cheers Gassa.
I always keep an open mind about all posts. Still good feedback though.
The question now is 14" or 17" or somewhere in between ?
Got me knackered.
Have you ever walked into a huge video hire shop and become overwhelmed by the huge selection and then walk out with nothing ? Note: back when video shops were popular.
Rosscoe
Rosscoe
VIC
505 posts
VIC, 505 posts
14 Jun 2011 9:22pm
Hey Logman, not sure what point you are trying to make. You can always buy a jetski.

I also can't agree with you about a 20 yo on a Wopper - in downwind or flat conditions they would be left miles behind.
Makaha
Makaha
1145 posts
1145 posts
14 Jun 2011 7:29pm
Simondo said...

laceys lane said...



i've got something to do in the ocean on most days instead of leaning on the beach fence looking a bad surf
cheers




Bingo! Exactly!

Bingo or House who cares how much is the prize money,I so want a fanatic 1206
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply