I'm not commenting on any shop, I am commenting on the process involved.
If the board is damaged, the board is damaged!
You either offer a discount and the client leaves knowing he paid less and accepts the damaged as it is or sell him a new board. Often someone is happy to have a board with a few chips or shop soiled for less $$$
If someone questions the damage and takes the board and has buyers remorse later, so shall you sow, so shall ye reap.
Remember one person tells 5 people who tell 5 people who eventually post on Seabreeze PMSL.
Phill.


