If that screw has got wet it has probably shrunk.
Just kidding.. Eat some Wheaties and with the board upside down get our left hand palm against the leading edge at the base of the fin.. and right hand palm on the rear of the fin near the tip.. and push.. You migh find that the fin will push into the box just a fraction and let the screw pick up the plate.. Good luck and don't cut your hand..

DJ