Hi Glass off,from a long history of riding longboards IMO it depends on a couple of things

How much rocker has the board got

and how many kegs you are

Do you surf from the tail

As Piros said

whats good for one may not be good for another

I find a 7 inch centre and small FCS outer fins work best for me

But iam 105 kegs surf off the tail and my boards have a three stage rocker!
I find a huge differance riding a board with either a 8/9/10 inch fin unless i am riding a single fin old school mal!
With the rocker,remember the more rocker the less contact the board has with the water IMO.
Tip loan 5/6/7/8/9/10 fins from anyone you can,a good quailty fin can cost upto 100 bucks!
Hope this is of some help

mac