Grumpy Old Men......... revisited

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Sparx
Sparx
VIC
734 posts
VIC, 734 posts
3 Aug 2012 2:30pm
Given the data thats starting to appear on other threads I reckon its time for a grumpy update.
As you would recall in the original thread a few of us were lamenting the lack of divisions in State and National Titles and the apparent lack of direction from the sports administrators with regard to redressing this supposed imbalance. Rather than sit around and grizzle Ockanui and myself started stirring the pot round the traps to see what the state of play was and in fact could be. Ock started by going all out to attract sponsors and in fact organisational support for Over 50s divisions in the upcoming summer racing series in Vicco. From what I gather he has been successfull beyond expectations and this division will now be embedded in the SUP racing calendar.
Both Ock and myself also went on a fact finding mission to collect data with regards the age composition of the major SUP clubs around the country. Thank you so much to all those who responded with data and a big thanks to Casso for getting the ball rolling north of the border. Thus far the data states conclusively that the predominant age division in all clubs surveyed is the Over Forties. Probably of more interest is the fact that the age group with the second largest number of participants is the Over Fifties. If we are to take the data at face value and assume that the surveyed clubs represent a microcosm of the SUP scene nationally, then Surfing Australia should at least re consider the emphasis they place on particular divisions. Obviously we dont want to undermine the Open division, which is after all the sport showcase, or hinder the development of a viable junior division, the sports future. What we do want is due recognition of the majority of participants in this awesome sport/passtime/lifestyle.
Where to from here? I'm tapping this out during my lunch break at work so don't have time to access any of the aforementioned data. I will be happy to do that tonight when I get home. I hope Ock chimes in cos I know he has some great stuff tucked up his wizards sleeve. Can I say in closing that all of our data has been forwarded to the Victorian rep for the upcoming conference to take place in conjunction with the Nationals at Port Mac. I believe through his hard work the Over Fifties issue is already a tabled agenda item. Nice one Woody! However it would be pretty lame if the Victorians were the only ones banging this particular drum, so if you are passionate about this particular issue, get on to your State SUP Rep and make sure he or she is on the same page. If you cant find out who that is, get straight on to the admin of Surfing Australia or your state branch.
Anyway, gotta bail and get some lunch into me otherwise I,m likely to get even more grumpy!!
Cheers
Sparx
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
3 Aug 2012 3:29pm
Sparx said...

However it would be pretty lame if the Victorians were the only ones banging this particular drum, so if you are passionate about this particular issue, get on to your State SUP Rep and make sure he or she is on the same page. If you cant find out who that is, get straight on to the admin of Surfing Australia or your state branch.



The national forum comprises Surfing Australia representatives and internationally recognised SUP competitors, alongside state reps. These state reps are:

Mark Temple (South Australia), Troy Pease (Queensland), Elyse Comerford (New South Wales), Neil Thompson (Western Australia) and Paul Harrington (Victoria)
Casso
Casso
NSW
3785 posts
NSW, 3785 posts
3 Aug 2012 5:59pm
Nice one Sparxy - keep on it.
surf4fun
surf4fun
WA
1313 posts
WA, 1313 posts
3 Aug 2012 4:27pm
And given there are more than likely more beginners out there than experienced paddlers should we be including them as well? Just because there are more of you doesn't mean we should bow down to you.

So yes while I agree the divisions need to be revisited I don't think it is something that you need to get on your soapbox and tell the world (seabreeze world). You have already got it tabled at the forum, so rather than getting on here and continuing the grumpiness, why not let everyone know the good news and promote it in a positive light.

At the end of the day we had to start somewhere and that was open and 40+ but it is due to people like you and Ock, who have put in what sounds like a lot of work and effort to shine a light on the true state of play, which allows for changes to be made to reflect the true SUP demographic.
Sparx
Sparx
VIC
734 posts
VIC, 734 posts
3 Aug 2012 6:46pm
Maaaaate!
I dont want anyone bowing down to anyone, least of all me! As you said there are probably a pot load of beginners out there, I just dont see them competing at the National Titles. This way however, we identify where the numbers are and as well as opening up new divisions, it paves the way for junior development programs, bringing up the number of women participants and being generally more inclusive all round. As for grumpy, thats the brush we got tarred with last time, those who know us will attest to the fact that we are far from grumpy, as a matter of fact at the moment I am exceedingly happy!
All good
Cheers
Sparx
HumanCartoon
HumanCartoon
VIC
2098 posts
VIC, 2098 posts
3 Aug 2012 6:52pm
surf4fun said...

And given there are more than likely more beginners out there than experienced paddlers should we be including them as well?


Why not? Everyone was a beginner once. Inclusiveness is good. Beginners are where the growth is, let's not lose sight of that...

surf4fun said...


So yes while I agree the divisions need to be revisited I don't think it is something that you need to get on your soapbox and tell the world (seabreeze world). You have already got it tabled at the forum, so rather than getting on here and continuing the grumpiness, why not let everyone know the good news and promote it in a positive light.



Most of the audience for this is here. Besides, seemed to me Sparx wasn't all that grumpy today.

(With any luck, you might get to be a GOF...one day .)



surf4fun said...

At the end of the day we had to start somewhere and that was open and 40+ but it is due to people like you and Ock, who have put in what sounds like a lot of work and effort to shine a light on the true state of play, which allows for changes to be made to reflect the true SUP demographic.


Yep. Two thumbs up Sparx and Ock.
standupper
standupper
387 posts
387 posts
3 Aug 2012 4:59pm
Well done sparx, great to see someone being pro-active for the sport and backing themselves enough to make a difference. Cheers
goatman
goatman
NSW
2151 posts
NSW, 2151 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:02pm
Yeah well done Sparx and Ock, catch ya in a couple of weeks, sans rain hopefully
Sparx
Sparx
VIC
734 posts
VIC, 734 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:17pm
Sheesh
On a completely differnt note, now I am extremely grumpy.
Got an email from Surfing Vic telling me I had picked up the mythical last slot in the Over Forties of the SUP Surf Division....instant happy!! Then they send me another email, sorry Surfing Aus have just got back to us and they made a mistake.... youre out..... apparently there is a surfer from NSW who is ranked higher than you are and he's in. How does that work? NSW now have three reps in the Over Forties, I finished second by .25 from a field of twelve and this bloke is presumably copping a berth for finishing what?...from a field of fourteen! How do the Queenslanders feel about that?
Not happy in fact extremely grumpy!
Cheers(actully, no cheers)
Sparx
Casso
Casso
NSW
3785 posts
NSW, 3785 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:32pm
Sparx said...

Sheesh
On a completely differnt note, now I am extremely grumpy.
Got an email from Surfing Vic telling me I had picked up the mythical last slot in the Over Forties of the SUP Surf Division....instant happy!! Then they send me another email, sorry Surfing Aus have just got back to us and youre out..... apparently there is a surfer from NSW who is ranked higher than you are and he's in. How does that work? NSW now have three reps in the Over Forties, I finnished second by .25 from a field of twelve and this bloke is presumably copping a berth for finishing what?...from a field of fourteen!
Not happy in fact extremely grumpy!
Cheers(actully, no cheers)
Sparx

Cwoor - that's a bit rough.
PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:39pm
Casso said...

Cwoor - that's a bit rough.




I feel just a little sympathy for the Over 40s NSW surfer who has just received the good news only to learn he is going to be confronted by two very grumpy old men from Victoria when he gets to Port Macquarie.
surf4fun
surf4fun
WA
1313 posts
WA, 1313 posts
3 Aug 2012 5:43pm
HumanCartoon said...

surf4fun said...

And given there are more than likely more beginners out there than experienced paddlers should we be including them as well?


Why not? Everyone was a beginner once. Inclusiveness is good. Beginners are where the growth is, let's not lose sight of that...

Isn't the purpose of the Australian Titles to find out who the best in Australia is? While I agree 100% we have to support the beginners the Australian titles isn't the place for them. And I know I was the one who mentioned them being there but I was simply making a point of just because there are a lot of one age group/division doesn't mean they need to be included everywhere.

I think it is great What Sparx and Ock have done however at this point in time what suits and represents Vic paddlers may not be indicative across the country, although by the sounds of their research they are definitely on the right track.
surf4fun
surf4fun
WA
1313 posts
WA, 1313 posts
3 Aug 2012 5:44pm
Sparx said...

Sheesh
On a completely differnt note, now I am extremely grumpy.
Got an email from Surfing Vic telling me I had picked up the mythical last slot in the Over Forties of the SUP Surf Division....instant happy!! Then they send me another email, sorry Surfing Aus have just got back to us and youre out..... apparently there is a surfer from NSW who is ranked higher than you are and he's in. How does that work? NSW now have three reps in the Over Forties, I finnished second by .25 from a field of twelve and this bloke is presumably copping a berth for finishing what?...from a field of fourteen!
Not happy in fact extremely grumpy!
Cheers(actully, no cheers)
Sparx


That's a bit harsh.
Sparx
Sparx
VIC
734 posts
VIC, 734 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:49pm
Casso
Tell me it's Goaty and I will STFU. He probably deserves it as much as anyone. I guess I'm just p...ed at the way it went down. Been chasing that spot since Feb and to get told youre in and then youre out all between four and five tonight just sux. Anyway beers are going down a treat and the scotch beckons.
Soon to be cheers
Sparx
ockanui
ockanui
VIC
1321 posts
VIC, 1321 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:52pm
From little things big things grow... a little conversation with Sparx a couple of months ago.... thanks for all the emails from Suppers around Australia who have been very supportive in this initiative to have an over 50's category included in all events be it local,State or at National level. Thanks also to SASupcrew, Goochi, Tonyleitch, Malibujet, Casso, Bass Sup, Sup Vic for supplying the age demographics of their respective Sup clubs.

What is apparent from those figures is that there are sufficient numbers of over 50's in order to support the initiative, and thanks to Pt Woody for putting the concept on the agenda at the Surfing Australian Forum at Port Mack in a couple of weeks.

This whole Sup scene in Australia is 100% positive and supportive of the inclusion of all of us embracing Stand up paddle boarding without discrimination of age or even ability, that said, it is important that this is about inclusion of all and that it will not be at the exclusion of others.

Without preempting decisions from those event organizers in Victoria, over 50's, 'Masters' will be a category in this seasons events, starting with the Peninsula Paddle event August 11.

An email of support from Kissa who will also include an over 40's and over 50's in his Ocean series is also to be congratulated.

With 20-35% of suppers over 50 and again probably those figures again in over 40's there are alot of older suppers in the marketplace supporting the retailers so it would be short sighted if the support was not in kind.

On a tangent, but having had email contact with Dave Kalama, he also is supportive of the initiative, being 48 years old, the over 50's its closer than you think! although coming second to a kid some 25 years+ younger is no mean feat.

So as a wrap up we are all getting older, although some may be denial, :-), with the Sports growth it just makes logical sense that there will be an expansion of the age categories and with careful planning, a smooth transition of event management will see an expansion in numbers attracted to such events, thus giving direction and raising the bar on our fitness and ability of those Supping in Australia, a win/win situation.....MJ


PTWoody
PTWoody
VIC
3982 posts
VIC, 3982 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:58pm
surf4fun said...

I think it is great What Sparx and Ock have done however at this point in time what suits and represents Vic paddlers may not be indicative across the country, although by the sounds of their research they are definitely on the right track.




Certainly the point of discussion in a national forum will be to determine the best outcome across the board for the interests of the sport going forward. This is true of this particular issue along with a number of others. Having said that, there will inevitably be differences in needs from state to state, and in that instance, I dare say we may end up with some solutions that serve needs locally rather than enforcing a cookie cutter solution upon all states and clubs.
PTSUP
PTSUP
QLD
218 posts
QLD, 218 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:59pm

At 52 , I don't mind going in with the o'40s or opens in the Surfing..As you see in Masters life saving once the o'50s are catered for, to be fair and equitable to all ,you must make age categories available for all through to over 70's.





















Sparx
Sparx
VIC
734 posts
VIC, 734 posts
3 Aug 2012 8:20pm
Great stuff MJ
Loving your work.
Thanks so much for carrying the lions share of this project and being a worthy partner in crime. Sorry for the slight derail, gotta focus on the positives. One would hope this sort of stuff wont be an issue in the future, you make the final, you get a day out in the windy city and a shot at the brass ring.
And as for over seventies....why not!! If there's four of them that want a crack, that sounds like a division to me.
Cheers
Sparx
HumanCartoon
HumanCartoon
VIC
2098 posts
VIC, 2098 posts
3 Aug 2012 9:02pm
surf4fun said...

HumanCartoon said...

surf4fun said...

And given there are more than likely more beginners out there than experienced paddlers should we be including them as well?


Why not? Everyone was a beginner once. Inclusiveness is good. Beginners are where the growth is, let's not lose sight of that...

Isn't the purpose of the Australian Titles to find out who the best in Australia is?


I meant in the broader competition agenda of the sport, not the National titles. Just as the 0 50's agenda is growing support, locally we've been exploring beginner/fun divisions at local and club-level events. Juniors too.
Just as the O50's agenda is also about promoting that division at local/club events, not just the high-level competitions (that's in Sparx's first paragraph).
62mac
62mac
WA
24860 posts
WA, 24860 posts
3 Aug 2012 7:13pm
Its the only way to go and well done for making an effect for change to the better for SUP.Have a good look at most good longboard comps,there is so much interest in the age divisions its not funny.
SASUPCrew
SASUPCrew
SA
106 posts
SA, 106 posts
3 Aug 2012 8:43pm
Well done Sparx & Ockanui on the inititive & having this tabled at the nationals. We are extremely lucky to have a national body that has so far been very receptive to the ideas our state representatives put forward & to be so pro active for such a new sport. Looking forward to the outcome!
chrispychru
chrispychru
QLD
7932 posts
QLD, 7932 posts
3 Aug 2012 9:15pm
bravo sparx and ock. i love people who get shiz done....bravo again boys
Casso
Casso
NSW
3785 posts
NSW, 3785 posts
3 Aug 2012 10:17pm
Sparx said...

Casso
Tell me it's Goaty and I will STFU. He probably deserves it as much as anyone. I guess I'm just p...ed at the way it went down. Been chasing that spot since Feb and to get told youre in and then youre out all between four and five tonight just sux. Anyway beers are going down a treat and the scotch beckons.
Soon to be cheers
Sparx

Dunno who it is. Drink up!
NNSUP
NNSUP
NSW
1263 posts
NSW, 1263 posts
3 Aug 2012 11:36pm
Bring on the Over 50s.!!!!!
Then I don't need to race Casso, Kissa and Sammy P.
Seriously, thanks to Sparx and Ockanui for bringing this to light and pushing this through at the Nationals.
NN
matt18
matt18
VIC
534 posts
VIC, 534 posts
4 Aug 2012 9:34am
Well done mj and sparx and all involved
roggoodwin
roggoodwin
WA
232 posts
WA, 232 posts
4 Aug 2012 8:50am
Sparx said...

Sheesh
On a completely differnt note, now I am extremely grumpy.
Got an email from Surfing Vic telling me I had picked up the mythical last slot in the Over Forties of the SUP Surf Division....instant happy!! Then they send me another email, sorry Surfing Aus have just got back to us and they made a mistake.... youre out..... apparently there is a surfer from NSW who is ranked higher than you are and he's in. How does that work? NSW now have three reps in the Over Forties, I finished second by .25 from a field of twelve and this bloke is presumably copping a berth for finishing what?...from a field of fourteen! How do the Queenslanders feel about that?
Not happy in fact extremely grumpy!
Cheers(actully, no cheers)
Sparx


I agree WA only has one surf rep allocated, (for the over 40's) I think to be fair each State should be allocated a certain number of spots (ie 2 each or preferably 4) and make a contest out of it. It would increase participation in the state rounds if people new they had a better chance of making the nationals. It would be nice to see the SUP nationals extended to a 4 day comp instead of cramming everything in over 2 days. After all it is the fastest growing water sport in the world. (apparently).


malibujet
malibujet
QLD
59 posts
QLD, 59 posts
4 Aug 2012 10:56am
Well done guys.
Now to throw in a couple of other points.
1. What about an O 60's division.
2. At the recent Coast of Origin on the Sunshine Coast a couple of weeks ago there was some discussion re divisions for board lengths. This came about because the judging is based on shortboard style surfing. This is great for the younger guys with a shortboard background but from those of us elder gents from a more traditional longboard background we are behind the eight ball right from the start. There was discussion re a 9'+ and a 9'- categories. No reason anyone couldn't enter both if they wanted to as long as boards comply. This evens the playing field for everyone.
Your thoughts?

dtm
dtm
NSW
1610 posts
dtm dtm
NSW, 1610 posts
4 Aug 2012 11:17am
Sparx said...

Sheesh
On a completely differnt note, now I am extremely grumpy.
Got an email from Surfing Vic telling me I had picked up the mythical last slot in the Over Forties of the SUP Surf Division....instant happy!! Then they send me another email, sorry Surfing Aus have just got back to us and they made a mistake.... youre out..... apparently there is a surfer from NSW who is ranked higher than you are and he's in. How does that work? NSW now have three reps in the Over Forties, I finished second by .25 from a field of twelve and this bloke is presumably copping a berth for finishing what?...from a field of fourteen! How do the Queenslanders feel about that?
Not happy in fact extremely grumpy!
Cheers(actully, no cheers)
Sparx


Hey feel ya pain big fella surfing nsw gave out 2 wildcards for people who could not attend the qualifier state titles as we're away or overseas etc.. Chased it up with hope only to get told they gave it to Casso who got to compete in the event and got his chance but got knocked out? Yeah grumpy young man here haha ... Still gunna come up though so see you up there !! Hey at least you get to compete and not just watch!!
goatman
goatman
NSW
2151 posts
NSW, 2151 posts
4 Aug 2012 12:05pm
Casso said...

Sparx said...

Casso
Tell me it's Goaty and I will STFU. He probably deserves it as much as anyone. I guess I'm just p...ed at the way it went down. Been chasing that spot since Feb and to get told youre in and then youre out all between four and five tonight just sux. Anyway beers are going down a treat and the scotch beckons.
Soon to be cheers
Sparx

Dunno who it is. Drink up!


Not me as far as I know, probably Mick Davies.
Sparx
Sparx
VIC
734 posts
VIC, 734 posts
4 Aug 2012 2:03pm
Ahhhhhhh
Nice and mellow now, just had a little splash over Phillsway and ran into Leroy. Good to catch up and have a yack.
Mick Davis rips, saw him last year and he is a bloody impressive unit......however, where did he place in the Over Forties at the States this year? Why is NSW given a third slot when the States with only one are screaming out for more? If it comes down to ratios ie how many competed at each State Title in each division then someone has still screwed up. For an extra heat of Over Forties NSW scores three entries as opposed to Victorias one!! Anyway.....what ever, as you said Dan, I still get to compete and I still get ten days away from work and I get to catch up with lots of quality crew. Livin the dream!!!
Hey Malibujet! Great ideas, make sure you get in touch with your State rep and push it at the Nationals Conference. As I said before, if there is a heats worth, lets call it a division! As for long board SUP divisions I reckon thats a cracker of an idea. While I love the short board stuff it would be great to see some cross stepping and drop kneeing masters strut their stuff at the Nationals.
"All in good time Grasshopper"
Cheers
Sparx
dtm
dtm
NSW
1610 posts
dtm dtm
NSW, 1610 posts
4 Aug 2012 2:43pm
Nsw get extra slot as we are clearly the best state enough said
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply