HumanCartoon said..
User ShireSUP
That would be Uber ShireSUP to you Sir Cartoon

And yes, true I have actually progressed through all of the Fusions, until they released a super small one(i think they brought it out fearing i might by another brand.......) so I am well placed to comment. As your luck would have it, my partner has a 10'6 Allaround and having paddled and surf it more than once or twice am quite well placed to comment there.
But without know your dimensions its only a guess. So based on your criteria or mostly FW and the occasional little surf in places i have no idea what the surf is like, i would pick the All Around over the Fusion. The smaller you get in Fusion the less fun it is to paddle the distance, unless of course you are small yourself, then why would you buy a Fusion then........so my guess as above is the All Around but i wouldn't get anything but the 10'6 anything else is too all around like the Fusion is too surf.
Good luck with your decision