Reddo said..
Thanks everyone. I'm startling to think that the 9'5 striker is the go or maybe even the 10 ft. I should have made it clear that the board will only be surfed by her 25% of the time, the rest of the time it'll be my board for flat water. Longer always feels better on the flat to me.
Owning more boards is another option but that doesn't seem to be getting much traction!
I guess the best scenario will be to trial the 9'5 (I'll give you a tingle shortly Rod) and compare to the 10 ft.
One other question, how does the 10 ft destroyer compare to the 10 ft striker? It appears totally different to the other destroyers with its straight lines and lower volume, I can imagine it would be a joy on the flat water but any good for someone to learn to surf?
Longer is always better in flat water - true. But not in a surf shape. 14x25 U-boat will be amazing on flat water. 10x31 Striker will be a barge in surf for your wife and a frustrating board for you in flat water.
Destroyer is an amazing board in surf when sized properly - around 1.2 Guild factor. It is a waste of money in flat water. Even a 10' Destroyer - if you can get one. 10' Destroyer is a high performance longboard Surf SUP. It is not a flat water board. It would be sacrilege to use it in flat water.
If you are looking for a JL board that will be OK in surf and OK in flat water get Hanalei. You cannot get a board that will be great in both.
I have a Destroyer (8'5) and Hanalei (10'8) and surfed 8'11 and 9'5 Strikers. I am 240 pounds. If I had to choose one board for 75% flat water and 25% percent surf I would keep Hanalei - no question. If I had to choose one board for 75% surf and 25% flat it would be a Striker. I would never choose a destroyer for anything but 100% surf.
I would love to get a 10' Destroyer - virtually impossible in US. If I got one I would have never dishonored it in flat water :)