Stupid fin question

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
3 May 2011 1:02am
So , The new 7'10 is in the shed drying and I'm thinking, I hate putting those stupid little round fin boxes in ,. So why can't I put in three standard old longboard fin boxes in instead. I went to the Shapers site and yep no problem with the boxes but getting fins that have a foil on them seems too hard. All I want to do is have three slidable fins with the rail fins that have a foil(flat on the inside), so they need to fit the standard fin box , This isn't the best description but anyway , help!!
milko
milko
NSW
604 posts
NSW, 604 posts
3 May 2011 2:20am
you can buy an adaptor that converts the long box to FCS/Futures.
Piros
Piros
QLD
7303 posts
QLD, 7303 posts
3 May 2011 9:10am
Rupert you may have a problem with the depth of the centre box on the side (don't know how thick your tail is) if you can get them in the FCS adaptor will work but be careful with them as they do drop fins , I drill and put a small pin right through the adaptor and fin.

I suggest put in 4 future boxes with a centre fin box for your best combo choice , my opinion the future boxes hold in much better than the FCS but if you are set on the FCS system use the Fusion box looks like the number 8 much better than the individual FCS plugs.

Rob
Casso
Casso
NSW
3785 posts
NSW, 3785 posts
3 May 2011 12:35pm
milko said...

you can buy an adaptor that converts the long box to FCS/Futures.

Really? I've seen the FCS converter but not a Futures one. I rang Futures a few months back and they didn't have one then.

Have you got/seen a Futures one Milko?
Casso
Casso
NSW
3785 posts
NSW, 3785 posts
3 May 2011 12:40pm
Piros said...

Rupert you may have a problem with the depth of the centre box on the side

Three longobard boxes will be pretty heavy too.

Piros said...

the FCS adaptor will work but be careful with them as they do drop fins , I drill and put a small pin right through the adaptor and fin.

Good idea Piros.
cRAZY Canuk
cRAZY Canuk
NSW
2528 posts
NSW, 2528 posts
3 May 2011 1:53pm
Check out probox fin systems: www.proboxhawaii.com

There what I've been using on my home made boards - dead simple to install all you need is a trim router and some contact glue (3M Super 77), good selection of cool fins (and normal ones), guys that work there are super helpfull.

The only bummer is that angles change a bit depending on concaves so if you want an exact angle theres a bit of fiddling around but you can get different cant angles so you can get it pretty close to were you want to be.
log man
log man
VIC
8289 posts
VIC, 8289 posts
3 May 2011 3:19pm
Thanks, chaps but I want to be able to move the whole fin assembly back and forward. I don't really know WHY I want to do this but I figure if I've got a centre fin that moves up and back say 6 inches in the fin box, why don't all fins do the same? And really those little circular fin boxes are very annoying to put in........ OK, so another stupid question, what would happen if I put an ordinary centre fin type fin on the rails . So what I mean is a fin that is foiled on both sides and not flat on the inside of the fin?.
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
3 May 2011 2:20pm
log man said...

OK, so another stupid question, what would happen if I put an ordinary centre fin type fin on the rails . So what I mean is a fin that is foiled on both sides and not flat on the inside of the fin?.


It wouldnt turn I wouldnt think, havnt tried it tho. CMC will know........
micksmith
micksmith
VIC
1701 posts
VIC, 1701 posts
3 May 2011 5:37pm
Its all about hydrodynamics, I tried similar thing on a short board some 25yrs back didn't work then and I doubt if it will work now. something about high and low pressure flow over the fin, just as like an aircraft wing is not symetrical or a sail. it needs that flow to get the drive so as not to stall or something like that. read up on hydrodynamics and angle of attack before you decide.
good luck.
be good to see pics whatever you decide
colas
colas
5388 posts
5388 posts
3 May 2011 4:13pm


I have bought a second-hand custom prototype with US boxes for rear quad positions. I use FCS adapters with FCS fins in them (the red ones).

The FCS adapters are not well designed mechanically: their screws push on the tabs at an awkward angle (they actually puh the fin out of the box), and they push on the tabs so they can induce breakage (I already broke one fin at the tabs in them). So maybe you want to glue them in the adapter or add pins/screws through them.

However, being able to change the positions of the fins is great to experiment (this was the goal of this prototype, to experiment fin positions for a future production board with just FCS plugs)

You can also try to find vintage twin fins (1980) in US box formats, but the foil will be often crude. Or windsurfing/kite fins, but they may be too stiff.
CMC
CMC
QLD
3954 posts
CMC CMC
QLD, 3954 posts
3 May 2011 6:56pm
micksmith said...

Its all about hydrodynamics, I tried similar thing on a short board some 25yrs back didn't work then and I doubt if it will work now. something about high and low pressure flow over the fin, just as like an aircraft wing is not symetrical or a sail. it needs that flow to get the drive so as not to stall or something like that. read up on hydrodynamics and angle of attack before you decide.
good luck.
be good to see pics whatever you decide



This is exactly why. Think of side fins like aeroplane wings. The difference is the lift is not vertical but outwards from the rail. This is the idea with cambered foils rather than flat inside edges as they create more lift for the size and also are more efficient.

If you put centre fins in there is much less lift or drive. They would not create much drag but no lift equals no drive and would not help you to turn much.

This is the same argument for quad rears. Center fins are more neutral, 80/20 are a bet each way and sides in the rear mean more drive from the rear.
doggie
doggie
WA
15849 posts
WA, 15849 posts
3 May 2011 5:02pm
CMC said...

micksmith said...

Its all about hydrodynamics, I tried similar thing on a short board some 25yrs back didn't work then and I doubt if it will work now. something about high and low pressure flow over the fin, just as like an aircraft wing is not symetrical or a sail. it needs that flow to get the drive so as not to stall or something like that. read up on hydrodynamics and angle of attack before you decide.
good luck.
be good to see pics whatever you decide



This is exactly why. Think of side fins like aeroplane wings. The difference is the lift is not vertical but outwards from the rail. This is the idea with cambered foils rather than flat inside edges as they create more lift for the size and also are more efficient.

If you put centre fins in there is much less lift or drive. They would not create much drag but no lift equals no drive and would not help you to turn much.

This is the same argument for quad rears. Center fins are more neutral, 80/20 are a bet each way and sides in the rear mean more drive from the rear.


My quad has gone so much better after I put in a set GQX rear fins with the 80/20 foil. Smaller fins with better drive.
Bazza
Bazza
TAS
24 posts
TAS, 24 posts
3 May 2011 10:31pm
I have www.4wfs.com/ on my custom kiteboard. Gives you a bit of micro adjustment forward and backward, as well as rotating and you can switch plugs for different angles.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply