Forums > Stand Up Paddle General

The definitive solution to fins and foils whistling/humming: The "Donaldson trailing edge"

Reply
Created by colas Two weeks ago, 26 Jun 2020
colas
3921 posts
26 Jun 2020 8:56PM
Thumbs Up

At last, I have found a good video explaining how to suppress the vibration of fins and foils (aka the Von Karman effect), and giving the name of this technique : the Donaldson trailing edge, described in 1956 by ... Donaldson

Up to now, I had only seen the diagrams for symmetrical foils but this video goes into the details and show that you must sand the inner face of asymmetrical foil (flat one), not the curved one.

Thanks to Mario Legenstein from Levitaz for the video:




You can google "Donaldson trailing edge" to find many detailed references. For instance these images show the alternating vortexs creating the vibrations on a blunt edge on the left, and how the Donaldson edge locks the vortex in place on the right:

Seajuice
NSW, 622 posts
1 Jul 2020 11:21AM
Thumbs Up

Thanks Colas. Good to know how to sand the trailing edges properly.
At the moment I'm happy with the whistle or should I say scream or high pitched whistle when doing a ton of speed. But this is usually only when taking the drop down head high or bigger waves. It eases off to nothing after levelling off & riding the swell. So it's not annoying to me & is a good indicator to know when I'm in the high speed band.
But I definitely would sand off the edges as described if my foil whistled whilst riding after the drop because I love that quiet serenity it's the best after making the take off.
It's a bit like getting fired out of a cannon. You get the big boom! And then it's just plain sailing after that.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle General


"The definitive solution to fins and foils whistling/humming: The "Donaldson trailing edge"" started by colas