well what ever works for you....I was just trying to take opinion and emotion out of the equation as it tends to distort fact. Did you ride all boards the exact same amount in the exact same conditions?
The Gerry you refer to at Mambo is a demo board and is open to novice paddlers with not the best (rail saving) technique.
Here are some facts. My taky chipped, it was tufflite, I learnt to paddle on this board and it copped a flogging. But you couldnt notice it that much because the paint and undercoat are similar colours. My mate has owned and surfed the crap out of PSH and Naish. Both have chipped about the same for him but it doesnt show up as much on the Naish because of the colours. Another mate has a PSH 9.8 this shows the few(he has ridden it bugger all) chips bad because it is aqua over white. Another mate has a Magic carpet which is heavily used and has the normal chips, it shows up more so again becasue of dark greay over white.
Re Gerry's doing it and not other Surftech Tufflite. I would find it hard to imagine a production company using a different brand and type of paint for one or two models in a very large range of same construction....Think economics, buying paint from one supplier, getting better price re volume, setting paint guns up etc the same to suit type and consistancy etc etc etc..... So that is to say ALL Surftech's would chip the same, good or bad.
Here is another spanner in the works, what about plane shape of the board? full nose, , pointy, wide, flat or full rocker, tail shape....all these variables play a role in how a board paddles including the likely hood, more or less, to hit the rails with the paddle.
My self im more likely to hit the rail in 1 foot slop onshore chop, than in 3-4 foot clean
I still hit my rails. I CHOOSE to use the all weather tape from bunnings on the board. AS IM NOT A PRO SURFER, SURFING VERTICAL, ALL TIME MOVES....the thin tape has no noticable effect on performance

cheers,
Serg