6m sail (freeride)

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Chef
Chef
VIC
111 posts
VIC, 111 posts
18 Aug 2007 10:29pm
getting a new sail for fathers day(apparently gray and green tape arent the go)but which sail?
I liked the ezzy infinity,severne or tushinghum storm but as wifey is paying she wants a more experianced opinion wtf
she got a price on a north natural (never had anything to do with north are they much chop)noticed loft gets a good run in the forum how would the 5.8 freeride go with 127lt aero in 15 plus knots(im a big lad)any thoughts would be great
ps if you read this jordo, just finished a 13.5 hr shift and back 7am sunday morning BE A SPARKY this chefing sucks
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
18 Aug 2007 10:23pm
Bugger if I know Chef, but I have a 6.6 Ezzy Infinity which I'm real happy with. Nearly 3 years old now and still good as gold
I'm 80kg, and use it with a 100L board between 12 & 25 odd knots 99% of the time, can't be happier.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23685 posts
WA, 23685 posts
18 Aug 2007 10:45pm
Simmer Crossover....... massive range, wavesail construction and not mast-specific

Chef
Chef
VIC
111 posts
VIC, 111 posts
19 Aug 2007 8:02am
cheers for the replys.Just did a search in the forum for "which sail is the best"(how many times can the same question be asked)
Mark ,never heard of simmer sails(fairly new to sport)can you get them through Perth ,dont think ive seen them at melbourne stores
FletcHuz
FletcHuz
VIC
300 posts
VIC, 300 posts
19 Aug 2007 11:11am
I'm selling a 6m tushingham storm. It's in great condition. Also selling a 5.25m that's the same. Could buy both for the price of a new North! They are awesome sails, lots of x-ply so they are really durable. Great for freeride, freestyle and can take them in the waves to.

Check out the sails at this add on seabreeze - www.seabreeze.com.au/Members/Classifieds/Gear/JP-Australia-Freeride-270-270-cm-90-litres.aspx?id=HRh-

I have them in Melbourne now - give me a call on 0437984702 if you want to check them out.
DavMen
DavMen
NSW
1510 posts
NSW, 1510 posts
19 Aug 2007 12:11pm
I like your idea of the ezzy infinity (owner of a couple) sail nice and tough great sails too! Maybe a better match with the aero would be a ezzy freeride?

my 2 cents worth on a rainy sinday morn.
prokiterUK
prokiterUK
136 posts
136 posts
19 Aug 2007 10:52am
You should have a look at the MauiSails 2008 Switch 6.0 or Loco 6.0. Both are really great sails. It all depends if you want to go fast. If so the 6.0 Switch will be the way forward.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23685 posts
WA, 23685 posts
19 Aug 2007 10:52am
quote:
Originally posted by Chef

Mark ,never heard of simmer sails(fairly new to sport)can you get them through Perth ,dont think ive seen them at melbourne stores



Yeah if u r talking new, SOS in Fremantle are the Oz importers and the main retailer. John 08 9430 7050 he'll sort you out if you do want one
Auswind
Auswind
WA
398 posts
WA, 398 posts
19 Aug 2007 12:31pm
Just thought i'd put in a good word for the Severne S2 - which consistently gets top reviews. Also consider the NCx - although the S2 has a more wavey cross over

The S2 takes many of the concepts from Severne’s much loved S1 (like standard mast sizing –430- and super efficient shaping) and transfers them into a freeride / larger wavesail / freestyle all rounder

Here are some excerpts from windsurf UK

Ride And Handling

The S2 has been a delight to use over the years and the 2007 model is no exception being a FANTASTIC performing sail that was liked by all who used it.
Light and compact in the hands it has a surprising amount of bottom end power. It physically accelerates in the hands when hit by a gust, remaining impressively stable and balanced. The speed off the wind was EXCEPTIONAL , the sail’s balance and composure encouraging the rider to really put the hammer down. Is is a very well engineered and attractive looking sail whose performance undoubtedly made it one of the test teams favourites.

Light Handling , fast , efficient and impressive wind range. The S2 is a STUNNING ALL ROUND CONTENDER and comes very highly reccomendedby us for high wind blasting through to bump and jump sailing in coastal conditions



There are some great deals on thse brand new at the moment - check auswind's national windsports sale page!
Chef
Chef
VIC
111 posts
VIC, 111 posts
19 Aug 2007 2:37pm
davmen i thought the infinity was ezzys freeride or maybe i just liked a serious amout of x ply
thanks all for the input ,now to sit back and see which way the better half goes
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
19 Aug 2007 8:24pm
Severns are mast specific. And Severn wont release the spec for their mast curve.
DavMen
DavMen
NSW
1510 posts
NSW, 1510 posts
19 Aug 2007 9:26pm
quote:
Originally posted by Chef

davmen i thought the infinity was ezzys freeride or maybe i just liked a serious amout of x ply
thanks all for the input ,now to sit back and see which way the better half goes



No David Ezzy has developed a freeride (no cam) specific sail (the infinity has 2-cams) It has all the usual Ezzy stuff including the spectra x-film (x-ply) tough as nails.
http://www.ezzy.com/sails/freeride07.cfm




Chef
Chef
VIC
111 posts
VIC, 111 posts
20 Aug 2007 12:31am
cheers people,got home from work this arvo and i was told i am the new owner of a 6.2 north natural,should be here in 2 days(thanks RPS)
goes to prove you cant change ladies mind (unless she wants to)
thanks everyone for there input and if you see a 45plus guy on the swan with a brand spanking black jeep,(and 120jp)kick him in the arse he my bro
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
20 Aug 2007 1:02am
quote:
Originally posted by Chef

cheers people,got home from work this arvo and i was told i am the new owner of a 6.2 north natural,should be here in 2 days(thanks RPS)
goes to prove you cant change ladies mind (unless she wants to)
thanks everyone for there input and if you see a 45plus guy on the swan with a brand spanking black jeep,(and 120jp)kick him in the arse he my bro



you only left my house 5mins ago.........you shouldn't drink if you get abusive, Chef!!!

Besides, that sail cost you a 'lost-bet' with your 'good-lady' that will probably cost you more than the sum of the sail.....(I'll leave that to the reader's imagination!!)
Chef
Chef
VIC
111 posts
VIC, 111 posts
20 Aug 2007 1:10am
first, no good lady here
second,dont tell the world i was at your house(you now a chefs reputation darlin)
Ben Severne
Ben Severne
WA
194 posts
WA, 194 posts
20 Aug 2007 10:51am
Hi NotWal,

What do you mean by;
'Severnes are mast specific. And Severne wont release the spec for their mast curve.'?

ALL sails are ALWAYS designed for a specific mast curve.

Our mast curve is what is usually termed Constant Curve. Similar curves to Fiberspar, Powerex, MauiSails, Gaastra, Simmer, etc, etc...
The main difference is that the standard way to measure the bend curve is at 3 stations - one in the middle, and then one at the top and one at the bottom. We don't feel this is accurate enough, as the distance between these stations is quite long. So we use 7 stations along the masts' length. And then we can control the bend curve at ALL these points.
Basically you just end up with a smoother curve.

So when you compare a bend curve from 3 stations it'd look something like;
64% / 25 / 75%

Our bend curve is expressed;
41% / 60% / 81% / 25 / 88% / 77% / 51%

Complicated, and more info than most people need. Our sails are not more mast specific than most (except our S-1 which only fits on a RDM).

Sorry for the essay. Just trying to clarify that point on the masts.
DL
DL
WA
659 posts
DL DL
WA, 659 posts
20 Aug 2007 11:13am
Chef, I have a North Natural 6.2m and it rules. It's my favourite sail. Extremely stable, pumps well and has quite a good wind range.

It took me a while to get the light-wind tuning sorted though.

For light winds, the recommended downhaul setting is perfect (as indicated by the marks on the top panel). However, the suggested minimum outhaul is +1cm. I find a HUGE benefit in power and pumping from using neutral outhaul, or even a little bit of negative.

Enjoy your sail!
Wet Willy
Wet Willy
TAS
2317 posts
TAS, 2317 posts
20 Aug 2007 1:18pm
Ezzy! But not the Infinity - go for the 2007 No-Cam Freeride. Deep draft, loads of power, really good wind range, draft well forward for stability, totally bomb-proof construction - and, most importantly, it comes in a range of really funky colour schemes. Go Ezzy!! Go Ezzy!! I know a lot of people who swear by them.
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
20 Aug 2007 2:10pm
Thanks for that Ben.

Your website used to (and may still) imply that Severn masts were the only things to use, and when I emailed your guys to ask what the curve was I was told you don't release that information. That was reason enough for me to stay away from your sails.

Its nice to see a change of policy (if that's the case) because your sails get good reviews.

When you say your masts are Constant Curve similar to Fiberspar, Powerex, MauiSails, Gaastra, Simmer, that's not a lot of help because the curves of these different brands vary quite a bit.

Doing a simple interpolation from the numbers you posted it seems you have what is commonly termed a 12% bend. Is this typical for all your masts? I expect the skinnies would be more like 10% no?
Ben Severne
Ben Severne
WA
194 posts
WA, 194 posts
20 Aug 2007 12:44pm
Hi NotWal,

Our masts will work better in our sails than any other masts. Mainly due to that being the mast that every prototype is developed on, and adjusted for.
The idea is that if someone buys one of our sails, and then needs to buy a mast, the best option is to get use one of our masts as well to get the best performance. If they already have an existing mast from another manufacturer, our sails would still work, but not to the same level. Same as buying any sail from any brand.

There's been no change in policy. The origional policy of building sails that fit a lot of widely available masts still stands.

The bend curves of all the Fiberspar, Powerex, etc are all different. But they are all working along similar principles which is enough to get our sails to work. (Or any other sail.) The main thing is that the sails DON'T work so well on Neil Pryde, North, or any of the flex-top masts.

All our masts are so-called Constant Curve, except our Formula masts. These are much stiffer in the mid section, and are more of a Flex-Top design.
The RDM's are very similar to all our curves.
I can't give you a % difference between our top number and bottom number as I just don't measure the masts at those points.

We do a lot of work on masts - I go to factory at least once a year to work on new technology, and we continually build prototype masts to test. Masts DO make a huge difference, and it is an area where there is a lot of room for improvement. We just got back from the Canaries where we tested a lot of 370 and 340 RDM's, and differences some of them made were much bigger than the differences we see in changing the sail shape a lot of the time.

Again, sorry for the essay!
Chef
Chef
VIC
111 posts
VIC, 111 posts
20 Aug 2007 2:54pm
thanks for the reply DL, sail should be tuesday,nice to hear good things about the natural as it was not my first choice ,but then as th saying goes never look a gift horse in the mouth
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
20 Aug 2007 1:04pm
I have to say, having different curves for the different brands of mast available is a total, utter, uncontestable cock-up.

About a year ago, I went into my local windsurfing shop, and bought a nice shiny new sail (North Ice). I was told that it would work with my Pryde mast.

It didn't.

I vowed on the spot never to make that mistake again.

Now I'm at the stage where I'm willing to buy a quiver, but not having tried many sail brands, I'm looking at which manufacturer can produce a sail that works in a "standard" mast. It seems to me that if a sail manufacturer RESPECTS the consumer's dollar, then they will try to help the consumer make the best choice. Having mast-specific sails isn't respecting the consumer, to my mind.

Let's talk about computers for a little bit. When USB was first introduced, it was introduced as a "standard". A RFC was published, a set of guidelines were created, and then if you wanted to put the "USB" badge on your computer, it had to conform to the standard. Not Apple's standard, or Dell's, or Gateway's, or Microsoft's, it was a brand-independant standard.

Why can't this happen with masts? Why can't someone say "OK, we're going to publish a 'constant curve' standard, and create a little logo for it, and if you buy a mast and a sail from different manufacturers that both have that funky little logo on them then they will work perfectly"? Consumers don't like being locked into choices. They like to be able to shop around, and buy the best deal they can... and feel happy that they have shopped around. Not being forced into buying their sails and masts from the same manufacturer, and therefore being locked into the one brand of sail/mast for the rest of their windsurfing career! That is just being completely rude and greedy on the part of the manufacturer.

If a manufacturer could demonstrate that their sails are completely standard, then I'd buy their quiver today. Unfortunately, I can't
FletcHuz
FletcHuz
VIC
300 posts
VIC, 300 posts
20 Aug 2007 5:32pm
Nebbian - Your comment that mast specific sails isn't respecting the consumer is a little unfair! If a sail manufacturer comes up with an aerodynamic design that works better than other sails but required a different flex mast then I wouldn't want to be denied that just because all masts in the past are designed to a specific standard.

I don't disagree with your idea of tagging gear that works with a constant curve mast though - perhaps there just needs to be a curve characteristic added to mast and sail specifications instead of just a stiffness and a length - I think some manufacturers do this already.

The real key is to do your research before you buy and let your money talk - manufacturers will stop making something if no one buys it - but if it's better then chances are people WILL buy it, then you just need to make sure you buy stuff that is compatible (which is where the industry is at today). I think a rig is one integrated part of a windsurfer - the mast and sail should be thought of together and not bought in isolation of each other!
ka72
ka72
QLD
585 posts
QLD, 585 posts
20 Aug 2007 6:24pm
Nebbian I agree with you. I am looking at a new mast and some sails and am confused as to what to buy. It would be great if they were all standard and you didn't have to worry about what brand mast you have to what brand sails you might be using.

I am also concerned about the recommended mast compared to the compatible mast that sail manufacturers have in there specifications. I would like to keep things simple and have just one mast and three sails, (which I have done in the past)but it seems like some manufacturers recommend three different sized (length and mcs) mast to be able to rig a quiver of 3 sails correctly! As well as not wanting to drag a heap of gear to the beach I cant justify the expense.

Lfish
Lfish
402 posts
402 posts
20 Aug 2007 5:18pm
Nebs, your dead right,we have seen many insances where the consumer get's dudded where there is no standard. You should be able to mix'n match where stiffness and curve have a standard to comply with, the manufactures want you to buy all their bits, buy a sail and you have to buy a mast to go with it if you want performance that they claim (I for one certainly can't afford that).
My ravings won't do any good but the current stiffness ratings are only part of the story, there should be some curve rating along with it. You can only hope!
DavMen
DavMen
NSW
1510 posts
NSW, 1510 posts
20 Aug 2007 8:15pm
I'm with Nebs too. At least for freeride and wave sails - do what you like for the Formula stuff - but joe average shouldn't have to put up with this FORCED senario.

DavMen
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
20 Aug 2007 9:37pm
Spot on Nebs.
The "constant curve" label is next to meaningless.
Small differences in curve make an appreciable difference in performance. What do you do if you want to tweak your mast curve? You have to measure the bastard. This is not impossible but its certainly not convenient. All the manufacturers have to do is agree to tell us what the curve is, and use a common standard for specifying the curve.

We have already a simple and reasonably definitive (IMO) standard in the IMCS + quarter points deflection test.

decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
20 Aug 2007 8:23pm
quote:
Originally posted by NotWal

What do you do if you want to tweak your mast curve?



What do you mean by this notwal, how do you tweak mast curve?
Add a bit more carbon at the soft spots?
Does anybody do that?
I've tried stiffening up the middle of an old NP mast so it'd work on my sails, seemed to help, but it was all trial and error.

I also agree with Nebs, there should be a better standard that actually means something
X-man
X-man
WA
325 posts
WA, 325 posts
20 Aug 2007 8:54pm
About the mast/sail combinations, I had a neilpryde NR 2001 and the recommended mast for it (neilpryde of course), it was sweet as! Now i got a tushignham mast with a mauisails Legend... not the same but hey it still works fine!
To come beck to the topic, north, Ezzy and Simmer all seem to have excellent constructions and perform well, have a look at some magazine reviews if you find some.. Usually I dont really care cause all sails of the same program from different brands perform very well at this point..After all ur looking at freeriding.. What I do is pick the one i find best looking .
Happy sailing
P.C_simpson
P.C_simpson
WA
1492 posts
WA, 1492 posts
22 Aug 2007 9:27am
Sailworks Retro 6.5m or 7m, don't think a 6m would be big enough..
TelecomGreg
TelecomGreg
QLD
94 posts
QLD, 94 posts
22 Aug 2007 2:38pm
Well said Nebs
Ezzy is the only manufacturer who states "any mast made in the last 10 yrs will work in our sails.
I recently had to choose between a new Ezzy sail to go with my ezzy RDM mast or a new mast to go with my 07 5.7 KA Kaos.
I chose a new ezzy 5.8 SE and now have a near new KA to sell.
the KA is a good sail and I don't expect KA to develop and test their proto's with other masts, so the answer IS like you said
AN INDUSTRY STANDARD whether it made in the USA or Italy
Calling them "constant curve" is just a name to call it something!
Very happy with my new ezzy! and won't be changing again until they change "constant curve" to USB standard.


TelecomGreg
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply