Advice about sail sizes

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
B0z
B0z
NSW
22 posts
B0z B0z
NSW, 22 posts
7 Feb 2007 9:30pm
I'm looking at buying a wave sail (just starting out on the waves after a few years on flat water) and have been given contradictory advice on the sail size I should buy. Hoping I can get some help.

I weigh 80 - 85kg, am just over 6 foot tall and currently have a 2004 Goya/Fanatic 85L FreeWave board. Our local break blows 15 - 20 knots on average. Of course there's bigger and smaller days but I'm working on averages here!

I've looked at a few of the guys sails and they seem to be running anything from 5.0 to 5.8 range but confusing matters is the size of the boards these guys are riding and their actual body weights.

The guy at the local sail shop told me to get a 5.2 to 5.4, definately no bigger than 5.5 as I don't want to sink the board. One of the sailors I spoke to suggested a 5.7 - 5.8 and reckons the 5.2 to 5.4 would be too small for my body weight.

Anyone got any ideas?


nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
7 Feb 2007 7:36pm
Hi Boz,

I'm about your weight range, and always use a 5.7 with a 105 litre board in that wind range. If you're riding onshore slop like me you need all the push you can get

If someone offered me an 85 litre board with a 5.2 on an 18 knot day I'd tactfully decline the offer and rig up my 5.7
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
7 Feb 2007 8:38pm
I'm 67kg and can plane with a 5.2 and 85l wave board from about 15kts.
20knts I can use a 4.7 with a heavily rockered 75l board.

So for you I think 5.2 would do at 20kts, but a 5.7 at 15kts with an 85l board I suspect would be marginal. I'm not familar with your boards planning charecteristics freewave probably planes earlier than pure wave.

So what size sails have you been using on flat water?
elmo
elmo
WA
8894 posts
WA, 8894 posts
7 Feb 2007 8:46pm
I'll keep out of this one as I use the "Tim the toolman" approach of Brute force and ignorance
mineral1
mineral1
WA
4564 posts
WA, 4564 posts
7 Feb 2007 8:51pm
Elmo, we Knowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

Mineral
Big Al
Big Al
WA
265 posts
WA, 265 posts
9 Feb 2007 2:46pm
I'm 85kg's & 6' 4", I use an 84L board & a 5.3m is the main sail I use. Anything over 18kt's & you can't go wrong with this size. Perhaps look at a sail in this size range that is quoted as a "Power Wave" saile e.g. Pryde Search or Alpha, Naish Force, Severne Blade, Noth Duke. These sails feel very powerful for their size compared to others which are designed more for 65kg whippets.

AB.....
Troppo
Troppo
WA
887 posts
WA, 887 posts
9 Feb 2007 6:19pm
I'm 6'5 and 83 kegs. I use 74l hardcore wave and 84 litre wave cult and have 2 sails both KA kaos's 5m and 5.7m.

I use them on both boards depending on the condtions. I can pump the 5m with 84litre on to the plane if its a constant 15knots... no good if its gusty.

The 5.7 wont sink the board..thats crap i can uphaul on the 84litre. Even had a 6m freeride sail on it so dont worry bout 5.7 being too big.

maybe an in between size. or if your going to buy 2 then 5m and 5.7m would be my reccomendation.

go the KA's
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23685 posts
WA, 23685 posts
9 Feb 2007 6:25pm
quote:
Originally posted by Troppo

I'm 6'5 and 83 kegs.


I'm about 83 KEGS also...... so use substantially more sail in 15-20kn than most of the posters here............

The ladies don't seem to realise that a keg is better than a sixpack
Nato
Nato
QLD
16 posts
QLD, 16 posts
11 Feb 2007 12:43am
Boz,

I'd agree with your mate who's saying the 5.7 - 5.8 is the go.
I'm 82kg, use a 92 evo and gold coast averages 15 - 20knots. I have a 5.3 which hardly ever gets used and a 5.8 which is used almost all the time. I'm fairly novice in the waves too.

The guy at the shop may be thinking of pure wavesailing (think maui WA) where it is common to dredge out underpowered and wavesail back in. A smaller sail may be a little less cumbersome when wave riding, but when you are starting out, it is a hell of a lot easier to be well powered when heading out - you can pop or jump over the incoming whitewater rather than getting mowed down.

Good luck with it.
drjukka
drjukka
QLD
258 posts
QLD, 258 posts
11 Feb 2007 1:11am
Guys,

I can't speak for wave sailing.

However-
7.0 13 up to 22 knots.
6.0 15 up to 29 knots]
5.7 17 up to 36knots
4.7 22 up to 43 knots

After that I give up!!!

I'm of the Elmo school of thought on brute force!!

Modern sails have great dynamic wind range depending on how they are rigged. Consequently I RIG BIG and am rarely disappointed!


-j
Zed
Zed
WA
1274 posts
Zed Zed
WA, 1274 posts
11 Feb 2007 5:47am
quote:
Originally posted by drjukka



5.7 17 up to 36knots
4.7 22 up to 43 knots

-j




Well not sure about that for a sail/wind range! But the reasons why you get conflicting advice is that board volume/sail size vs body weight/wind strength there isn't really a hard and fast rule. I weigh 80kgs and when I'm out there'll be guys on 4.0's right up to 5.7's. It can depend on how powerful your sail is, how modern your board is, how good you are. With a modern sail you can sail in a much bigger wind range by downhauling it a lot more than you used to be able to. Not sure what the guy at sailing shop means when he says "no bigger than 5.5 or u will sink the board".. but for 80 - 85kg, 85l and 15 - 20kts, you need a 5.7 end of story. If it blows up to 22 you can downhaul the mother.
AusMoz
AusMoz
QLD
1514 posts
QLD, 1514 posts
11 Feb 2007 8:39am
boz !

your asking a question that can never be answered fully ! since the evolution of windsurfing many years ago !

only you can take advice and answer your own question !

EXPERIMENT !!!!
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
11 Feb 2007 9:42pm
My guess would be 5.8. Thats probably at the upper limit for an 85 litre board in the waves. In the waves its common to use a bit less than what you would use in the same wind on flat water. Its just easier. But its a balance. It's got to be big enough to get you up wind. Be conservative and just suck it and see.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply