BOM Forecasts

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
7 posts
7 Aug 2007 2:21pm
I was looking on the BOM website at the forecast and spotted a line I hadn't seen before:

'Please Be Aware
Wind gusts can be 40 percent stronger than the averages given here, and maximum wave may be up to twice the height.'

...twice the height?!

http://www.bom.gov.au/cgi-bin/wrap_fwo.pl?IDW11400.html

mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
7 Aug 2007 4:32pm
Even the BOM has to cover themselves against liability, the line has always been there though.
DavMen
DavMen
NSW
1510 posts
NSW, 1510 posts
7 Aug 2007 4:33pm
I think this is to cover their backsides, especially after that tragic Syd-Hobart race, and to bring attention that the elements are very variable.

You always here about people being washed off rocks and boats over turned by that 'freak' waves. Fact is it's really not that freaky!

Sailor beware

DavMen
Revhead
Revhead
ACT
372 posts
ACT, 372 posts
7 Aug 2007 5:37pm
Same reason why they kept saying "chance of rain" during the drought... juuuuuuust in case.
grandfromage
grandfromage
WA
344 posts
WA, 344 posts
7 Aug 2007 4:38pm
Can you name the truck with four wheel drive,
smells like a steak and seats thirty-five..

Canyonero! Canyonero!

Well, it goes real slow with the hammer down,
It's the country-fried truck endorsed by a clown!

Canyonero! (Yah!) Canyonero!

12 yards long, 2 lanes wide,
65 tonnes of American Pride!

Canyonero! Canyonero!

Top of the line in utility sports,
Unexplained fires are a matter for the courts!

Canyonero! Canyonero! (Yah!)

She blinds everybody with her super high beams,
She's a squirrel crushing, deer smacking, driving machine!

Canyonero!-oh woah, Canyonero! (Yah!)

Drive Canyonero!

Woah Canyonero!

Woah!

Warning, The Federal Highway comission has ruled the
Canyonero unsafe for highway or city driving.

Same deal with the BOM.

laurie
laurie
QLD
3902 posts
QLD, 3902 posts
7 Aug 2007 7:45pm
Did you know that we (as a species) really only got a handle on the weather as a system in the last 100 years?

For thousands of years mankind generally didn't understand too well how it all tied together.

Consider the technologies available now: Satellites which provide a top down view, wireless communications, weather balloons, free roaming swell buoys, modern computer communications to share global readings in realtime, and increasing computer power to process all the data in under an hour.

Amazing inventions that have enabled forecasting to evolve beyond the basics of looking at a barometer and cloud watching!

When you consider the often sparse information available to generate the forecasts, it's amazing the forecasts are as accurate as they are!

Sometimes the forecasts miss, but I always reckon it's the weather that got it wrong - the forecast was spot when it was issued!
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4169 posts
WA, 4169 posts
7 Aug 2007 5:55pm
Well I think the BOM does a pretty good job. After all what else are we going to base a 2hr 40 min drive to Gerroa on other than information on the BOM website? The hit rate on a good noreaster is pretty good, better than 95% I'd say. OK we also miss a few good ones but at least you don't waste a drive.

The 40% warning came in after the infamous Hobart race. Up until then they'd forecast the average wind, assuming sailors knew about gusts. There was a storm warning issued prior to that race - a storm goes up to an average wind of 56 knots before it is called a severe storm. If one boat's anemometer on a pitching mast top measured one 90 knot gust - can't really blame the forecast.

grandfromage
grandfromage
WA
344 posts
WA, 344 posts
7 Aug 2007 6:07pm
just in case, i wasnt saying the bom was rubbish, i was agreeing that they were saying that variations in conditions are probable. in fact i am using the bom to forecast when to carry out a job where atmospheric temperature is critical, and have found their forecasts to be very good in comparison to a data logger i have installed in the area reading atmospheric temperature where the job is to be carried out.
Little Jon
Little Jon
NSW
2115 posts
NSW, 2115 posts
7 Aug 2007 9:34pm
I've found the BOM forecasts to be exceptionally crap. So many times they say it's 20 to 30 knots and I get to the beach and it's more like 2 to 3 knots.

Apart from the storms that beached the pasha bulka there has been bugger all wind on weekend the last 2 months which is really bugging me as I can't get my new gear out.
Wineman
Wineman
NSW
1412 posts
NSW, 1412 posts
7 Aug 2007 10:56pm
quote:
Originally posted by laurie

Did you know that we (as a species) really only got a handle on the weather as a system in the last 100 years?

For thousands of years mankind generally didn't understand too well how it all tied together.

Consider the technologies available now: Satellites which provide a top down view, wireless communications, weather balloons, free roaming swell buoys, modern computer communications to share global readings in realtime, and increasing computer power to process all the data in under an hour.

Amazing inventions that have enabled forecasting to evolve beyond the basics of looking at a barometer and cloud watching!

When you consider the often sparse information available to generate the forecasts, it's amazing the forecasts are as accurate as they are!

Sometimes the forecasts miss, but I always reckon it's the weather that got it wrong - the forecast was spot when it was issued!



Hey Loz
good to see you getting into the "serious" forum issues....

given the above, please explain why, before the drought broke here in Sydney, the gum tree in my front yard dropped the most amazing number of gumnuts, ever, & we have been here 18 years.

ALL THAT TECHNOLOGY...& NATURE STILL BEATS US

it knows...& it's not telin' us
laurie
laurie
QLD
3902 posts
QLD, 3902 posts
8 Aug 2007 12:03pm
quote:

given the above, please explain why, before the drought broke here in Sydney, the gum tree in my front yard dropped the most amazing number of gumnuts, ever, & we have been here 18 years.



Maybe they were just sick of hanging around with nothing to do?

Also interesting is that some researchers have found that the ionosphere (85Km+ in the sky) can predict earthquakes up to 6 days in advance?! The ionosphere is the one that deflects radio waves and was used to transmit radio signals. Folks noticed that the radio signals went haywire and then there was an earthquake a few days later.

Back to (bad) forecasting...

Rubbish in Rubbish out. All forecasts can only be calculated from available data. Offshore data comes from free wandering buoys, planes, boats, weather balloons and of course the trusty live readings. On any given day, there can be more or less of these inputs which will in turn affect the quality of the forecast.

Don't forget that weather is 3d. To forecast, you need obs vertically , not just at the surface. So, no matter how clever the forecasting gets, one of the biggest obstacles can be the lack of "real data" to kick off the calcs with...

MikeyS
MikeyS
VIC
1509 posts
VIC, 1509 posts
8 Aug 2007 5:20pm
What cheezes me off is the way forecasts are taken as gospel. "The weather tomorrow WILL be such-and-such". What the bureau dudes are really giving is a "based on all the available data we predict that the most likely weather events will be...." I suspect the element of probability is lost on many people, and I can't remember the Australian media ever reporting probabilities. I think I have heard US weather reports saying things like "the chance of rain/snow/hail is about 60%" or something like that. But no, we all seem to want to be told what the weather will be.
Sure, I get pissed-off when the predictions are wrong, and they aren't as accurate as my preferred "H.O.W." method (Head out window), but they do at least give you a better idea of what's over the horizon.
easty
easty
TAS
2213 posts
TAS, 2213 posts
8 Aug 2007 8:53pm
Well, I don't care if BOM have exaggerated tomorrow's forecast a bit, after all 40 - 50 knots might be a tad windy for my 4.2
7 posts
8 Aug 2007 11:03pm
I actually wasn't meaning to be critical when I posted my original comment...I actually quite like their optimism!
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply