"FIN" Selection Advice Needed. PLEASE

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Grasshopper
Grasshopper
NSW
58 posts
NSW, 58 posts
13 Feb 2006 9:03pm
G'day

I've been out of wave sailing for about 10 years (or any sailboarding) and have just bought a 89ltr wave board........and the question is WHAT FIN????

I had a custom board 8'6" Mad Dog and Never spun out (well I did but rarely) with a fin with a slot in the foil just behind the leading edge....

Now I sail on the new board with a so called wave fin and I'd be fighting spinout 60% of the time.. Slalom fin I'm ok, No spin out.

I hope its the fin and not my technique.

Seriously If my old fin fitted the board I'd use it.

Please Please help me with some advice as I have recently been in some really bad situations because of I think is a poor fin choice.

Please help

Cheers

Bruce
ju_724
ju_724
231 posts
231 posts
13 Feb 2006 7:19pm
what make and model of board did u get?

check the mcftrs web page and you should be able to get correct fin specs for your board,
Grasshopper
Grasshopper
NSW
58 posts
NSW, 58 posts
13 Feb 2006 10:24pm
Naish 8'7"
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
13 Feb 2006 7:59pm
Sail rigging has changed a lot in 10 years, modern sails need lots more downhaul. Somebody said on a recent thread the main reason for spin out is not enough downhaul. I think that's why modern wave fins have gone slotless, modern sails (rigged properly) don't have as much sideways force, (fullness of foil doesn't move back) it's mostly forward drive.
Saying that I have seen some very small and flexy wave fins around. You may have one too small and or flexi for your weight and sail size. I think these are more relevant than board design.
RAL INN
RAL INN
SA
2898 posts
SA, 2898 posts
13 Feb 2006 10:44pm
copied this from the www.finco.com.au site, hope John doesn't mind.

Spin out is problem experienced by every sailor at some time. The causes and solutions can be quite complex, but l will try and give some guidance. Spin out is easily recognisable because it feels as if your fin is broken and your board goes side ways in and uncontrollable manner. What is actually happening is the water flow detaches itself from the fin, causing cavition, ventilation or what ever you want to call it. The actual theory of this, l will leave up to the aeronautical experts. Spin out is nearly always caused by pilot error. Some of the situations that lead to spin out are as follows.

Low speed spinout .
This occurs when you are just getting onto the plain and the fin suddenly lets go. The water flow over the fin is not fast enough to generate enough lift to balance the large lateral forces that can be applied to the fin at this stage. The faster the fin moves through the water the more lift it generates and then more force can be applied to it. If the problem persists
A) Use a larger fin with greater lateral resistance.
B) Use a fin with a higher lift foil shape or one that works well at lower speeds. (See section on fin selection.)
C) Don't load up the fin until board speed has increased.
D) Sail more off the wind until the board speed increases.
E) Check rigging of sail.



High speed spinout.
This usually occurs suddenly and is caused by a rapid change in flow conditions over the fin. It most commonly occurs when the fin is operating at a angle of attack that is too high or in other terms you are pointing your board too high into the wind. In this situation the fin stalls because the water flow over the fin becomes detached. Unbalancing the fin or sudden changes in direction such as reaching off the back of a wave can also cause spinout. Once again this is usually pilot error. Whenever the board leaves the water it must be landed in a down wind situation where the board and fin are travelling in the same direction and your weight must be over the fin. This will maintain a smooth water flow over the fin surface. The same is true for wave jumping where the board must be turned down wind when landing. Whatever the cause of spinout it can be corrected by.

A) Having the correct fin for the conditions you are sailing in. It is no good trying to use an 11 inch speed fin when you are slalom sailing with a 6.0M sail. Generally if you are having problems try a bigger fin.
B) Having the correct rig balance. Sailing is a matter of balance. The rig, board, sailor, and fin must all be balanced correctly. Rigging is one of the first areas to consider. A sail not rigged correctly will exert too much side ways force and not enough forward motion. Plenty of downhall will help correct this. Mast position will change the center of effort of the sail which changes the whole balance of the board. A small change even half a inch can make a huge difference. Check board manufacturer specifications for correct positions. Boom height and harness lines will also effect rig balance as well the sailors stance. To avoid too much back foot pressure try to keep your body weight on the boom , this helps to keep the fin powered up. In conclusion if the balance is correct you can sail on the edge of control with minimal spinout.

Correcting spinout.
Place your weight over the center of the board , take your back foot out of the footstrap and push down on the leeward rail to reattach the water flow to the fin.

end quote.

best winds
Tony L
MikeyS
MikeyS
VIC
1509 posts
VIC, 1509 posts
13 Feb 2006 11:49pm
I seem to recall that slotted fins went out of vogue because of the high drag they created. Sure they might have been "sticky", as in they were good to keep laminar flow of water over the fin, but at the same time they were also "sticky" in terms of drag. Not such a problem in the waves I guess where speed isn't the main design priority. But I thought advanced fin design used better foiling, coupled with good technique and rigging to avoid spinout.
If it's the fin that came with the board, my guess is that it could be your technique and/or rigging. You can't expect to load up a wave fin the same way as a slalom fin or slotted fin. I know that in the past when I used to change from a slalom board/fin/sail to a wave board/fin/sail when the wind picked up, I'd still be trying to sail the wave board with the same heavy sideways back foot pressure style which lead to a lot of spin out. My tip is to "get the foils working" before you load them up, ie get some boardspeed downwind before you put too much pressure on the fin.
Or of course I may be wrong and you actually need to spend a truck-load on a new fin quiver. And perhaps the reason I can't do a forward is because my wetsuit is the wrong colour.
Cheers
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
14 Feb 2006 9:12am
To me that is kinda just a wave fin, if you are super powered up you will find that the fin has enough grip. So I would suggest a bigger fin, for use most of the time. You might find your previous board had a little more rail bite also helping things along.
Grasshopper
Grasshopper
NSW
58 posts
NSW, 58 posts
14 Feb 2006 6:32pm
I reckon ya right..........I'm gonna make a paper weight out of my fin and get a new one...The one I have seems to have way to much flex and the size seems to be a little small .. AND yes I am talking about the FIN
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
14 Feb 2006 5:37pm
Dont write it off yet, keep it for those big wind/smaller sail days or for when you hit the surf.
Grasshopper
Grasshopper
NSW
58 posts
NSW, 58 posts
14 Feb 2006 7:05pm
Maybe right.........I went through all the fin evolutions back in the late 80's untill I actually found a good design that suited me. Shame I have to go through the same again. I may be a little rusty at the moment but after going through the same problem many years ago I recon its a simple issue called the fin..
Struth I might put some straps on the old Mad Dog to have a go with the old fin.....just for memories.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply