KA OK ?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Arnold
Arnold
46 posts
46 posts
11 Sep 2007 5:49pm
I am thinking of getting a KA Koncept sail for freeride/freerace, basically just bay blasting, are these sails ok for this, I have heard they are really just for racing and will not last very long when used for freeriding. Opinion appreciated from people actually using them please.
Stewie
Stewie
VIC
218 posts
VIC, 218 posts
11 Sep 2007 9:22pm
I had a Ka Koncept a couple of years ago, they are OK, but they are not the strongest freerace sails you can get. My current Naish stealth is made a little heavier and stronger and is nicer to use, but it is a full race sail.

Dont get me wrong, the Koncept is a very quick sail and nice to use, but there are other sails made by the bigger companies such as the NP V8, Ezzy Infinity, and North Daytona, which are nice freeride sails and made a little more heavy duty than Ka.

The bigger brands also seem to have a better resale


jp747
jp747
1553 posts
1553 posts
12 Sep 2007 9:52pm
hi stewie been using np sails and gaastra for the most part since they're the sail of choice here and easy to get at dirt cheap prices but not anymore..i inquired about ka sails and was told by andrew m. that there's no distributor up here..my question is why is not as durable? is the monofilm thinner or the luff sleeve easy to rip..etc.?am talking bout the koncept too...regards
Stewie
Stewie
VIC
218 posts
VIC, 218 posts
13 Sep 2007 12:02pm
Hi jp747

Luff sleeve on the Koncepts are quite thin, kind of made of a thick dacron like material, and the monofilm seems quite thin as well. Makes for a light sail, but they are made more like a prototype kind of construction, just have to be careful with them.
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14967 posts
QLD, 14967 posts
13 Sep 2007 1:01pm
the Koncept is built pretty light but so are lots of other "race" sails.

what i understand is that certain key areas have been look at to toughen them up.

i don't know if this is true but this is what i have read.

What's New !!!

Careful tweaking to further drive top end performance and control –
changes are top secret – all the major manufacturers are trying to figure this sail out!
Luff pocket changes to enhance camber rotation
New material selection incorporating new graduated Monofilm, Solid X-Ply and luff pocket material.
Added Kevlar leech strip and enhanced mini battens to assist high speed leech control
90 degree turn on downhaul pulley
Boom height slot modifications
New mast foot pad


www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=6009

frant
frant
VIC
1230 posts
VIC, 1230 posts
13 Sep 2007 1:36pm
Arnie, Why don't you look at the Koyote which is designed as a blasting sail. I have an 06 Koncept 6.6 which has been thrashed but a few bits of sticky back over some chafe on the luff sleeve and clear packing tape over creases in the monofilm before they become splits keeps the sail performing like new. (at least untill the 08 stock arrive.) I think that either the Koyote or Koncept should suit your needs.
mr love
mr love
VIC
2424 posts
VIC, 2424 posts
13 Sep 2007 1:52pm
Hi Gesalt , That sketch is pretty old and there has been some more upgrade's , but it,s pretty accurate . The bottom monofilm panel is now also 7 mil along with the top one for added durability , and the graphic is sublty different .
The mast pad is thicker than the old one to help protect those fragile speed boards and is also in a kevlar reinforced material to resist the boards non skid surface .
Also cam zippers are added , it,s so easy to rig now .
It now has PVC batten end protectors and a few other nice touches .
You guy,s can make up your own mind about the durability but I can't see that the sail is lacking anywhere in terms of specification .

And they are bloody fast !!

Regards Martin
sailquik
sailquik
VIC
6171 posts
VIC, 6171 posts
13 Sep 2007 3:58pm
From looking at the film thickness specs on many brands of sail it seems that the KA Koncept uses film that is at least as thick as other brands. The luff material in 03-06 models was a heavy Dacron type that was lighter in weight than some luff materials but comparable in strength. We found some were having issues with holes on the luff when rigging on hard surfaces like car parks so this year the luff material has changed to the more common type. It will add slightly to the weight I think but this seems to be what the market wants. One of the other reasons why the Koncept sails are lighter in overall weight than many other fast sails is that they are deliberately designed to 7 battens and 3 cams. We have found they still can have outstanding stability and give a lighter more responsive feel. And of course their speed credentials are well proven. Kind of a "have your cake and eat it too" situation. Lighter overall weight does not necessarily mean less strength! A sail can be physically heavier but still have a light handling feel and visa versa. The common feedback from Koncept users is that the sails have a light 'feeling' and are very stable which is what the designer is aiming for.
Arnold
Arnold
46 posts
46 posts
13 Sep 2007 5:32pm
Thanks for the advice guys.

I have done a bit of web research and I don't think the Koncept is for me, too much of a race/speed sail, I need something more durable as I can't afford to replace my sails every season.(I normally don't break out the monofilm repair tape in the first year thats for sure) I wanted to get on an Aussie product but I will leave the Koncept for the guys who are happy to sacrifice speed for durability.

I like the look of the North Daytona, or its replacement the new s-type, the North build quality has always been without question so perhaps that is a better option for me.
mr love
mr love
VIC
2424 posts
VIC, 2424 posts
13 Sep 2007 9:10pm
Hi Arnold , The question is , do you want cams ? If not , definitely consider the KA Koyote . I would never have considered a sail like this , but a month or so ago I was helping Andrew rig some Koncept and Koyote proto's, down at Beaumaris . I took the day off from work as the forecast was good .
The wind came up and I had my boards in the car but no sails . I grabed a Koyote 5.3 proto and zoomed up to Green Point . Man , what a great sail . Having seven carbon tube battens it was so stable , I thought I was on a Koncept , and fast too . I was passing people on full slalom gear .
It,s 100% Grid Xply , no durabilty issues with this one , Kevlar xply down the leech and luff .
I won,t bag out on no cam freeride /freerace sails again after having used this . It,s definitely worth considering .

Seeya Martin

frant
frant
VIC
1230 posts
VIC, 1230 posts
14 Sep 2007 9:33am
Arnold, KA or Severne for some Australian content at least.
Azz
Azz
VIC
44 posts
Azz Azz
VIC, 44 posts
14 Sep 2007 9:41am
Hey Arnold, I dont know about no-cam race sails. In bigger sizes the shape would float around the sail, it would be like the old windsurfer one design sail.

And using them, I reckon you would always be wishing there was at least 2 cams to hold some of the shape in the sail. I reckon a freerace/freeride sail should have at least a cam or two.
mathew
mathew
QLD
2172 posts
QLD, 2172 posts
14 Sep 2007 11:14am
quote:
Originally posted by Azz

I dont know about no-cam race sails. In bigger sizes the shape would float around the sail, it would be like the old windsurfer one design sail.

And using them, I reckon you would always be wishing there was at least 2 cams to hold some of the shape in the sail. I reckon a freerace/freeride sail should have at least a cam or two.



Azz, you do realise:
a) Arnold asked for a sail for "bay blasting".
b) The fastest no-cam sails are doing over 40 knots?

Race sails should probably have cams to lock the draft, but freeride sails should probably be more forgiving. A freeride sail is a good choice for most sailors in bay/choppy waters, whilst a more race orientated sail is less forgiving and tends to be harder to control in lumpy/jumpy conditions (unless your aim is for open-water speed).
Azz
Azz
VIC
44 posts
Azz Azz
VIC, 44 posts
14 Sep 2007 12:41pm
"Azz, you do realise:
a) Arnold asked for a sail for "bay blasting".
b) The fastest no-cam sails are doing over 40 knots?"


Sorry Arnold, I was just thinking about myself, as I like the locked in feel, but everyone is different. I just reckon if it is a big sail you are after, a cam or 2 makes a nicer feeling sail if you start to get over powered, yet still allows for a sail that is easy to rig and gybe. The North Sails X Type is a nice looking no-cam sail, but to me, not having a cam in a race/flatwater sail is like waking up, having a shower, putting on a nice suit, and then wearing a pair of old Dunlop Volleys, my point being, why go half way, you mose well just go all the way.

I have read a bit on no-cam sails. Hotsails dont make a cam sails, they love the no-cam idea. In bigger sizes, I see the draft moving all over the place when the wind picks up, and in smaller sizes a cam is going to help top speed and hold the draft in position better, so why would you want a no-cam sail, when 1 or 2 cams are only going to help, and it is not like a 1 or 2 cam sail is anything like a NP RS or any kind of full on race sail.

So I have actually changed my mind again, so I am not sorry Arnold. Dont get a no-cam sail. No Cam = No Good.
Stewie
Stewie
VIC
218 posts
VIC, 218 posts
14 Sep 2007 12:50pm
Arnold, I agree with AZZ.

No-cam sails will never be as nice feeling in different conditions as a sail with 2 cams. Most of us sail in winds that vary, and a cam sail feels better overall. My mate has a 2006 8m Severne no-cam sail, he likes it because it is light, but says that he wishes it had a cam, as he feels the draft move all over the place.
mr love
mr love
VIC
2424 posts
VIC, 2424 posts
14 Sep 2007 7:25pm
Seeing as you "spilt the beans" Gesalt and posted an early 08 Koncept sketch I thought I may as well post the final one .
Here it is , and this is what the 08 will be .

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=6050
Arnold
Arnold
46 posts
46 posts
14 Sep 2007 6:40pm
Thanks everyone but I like sails with cams because I have found all cam-less sails that I have owned to have the draft move around a lot. (including a KA that I owned a few years back). But everyone has their preference / experience, so whatever (there's a discussion about it on the Starboard forum at the moment that you can join if you want)
Though I did hear something about 'Leech flutter' with the Koncept, is this from over downhauling the sail and having a really floppy leach? (If so, I can't see that being good for the mono-film)
mr love
mr love
VIC
2424 posts
VIC, 2424 posts
14 Sep 2007 9:52pm
Hi Arnold , I was of pretty much the same opinion about no cam freerace sails . I have had a couple of Retro,s and a Severne NCX that were very good sails but just didn't have the stability at the top end . The 08 Koyote I tried was definitely far more locked in . Granted it was a 5.3 and I can't vouch for the larger sizes , but the carbon tube battens make a huge difference . The much stiffer tail sections on the battens really prevent the draft from moving back too far ,the downside being the sail probably loses some bottem end .
But if you want cams ,then cool .It was just a suggestion.
Regards Martin
jp747
jp747
1553 posts
1553 posts
14 Sep 2007 10:26pm
stewie thanks for the info on the koncept..i think all race sails should be light however for the average sailor who'd like to make it last at least 2yrs. should be looking to more thicker monofilm and tougher luff material..rigging and derrigging does take it's toll..is the koncept a "slide in the mast, downhaul a bit, outhaul a lot and pop the cambers in?" cuz' if it is it should last not creasing the monofilm...regards
sailquik
sailquik
VIC
6171 posts
VIC, 6171 posts
15 Sep 2007 1:54am
quote:
Originally posted by jp747

stewie thanks for the info on the koncept..i think all race sails should be light however for the average sailor who'd like to make it last at least 2yrs. should be looking to more thicker monofilm and tougher luff material..rigging and derrigging does take it's toll..is the koncept a "slide in the mast, downhaul a bit, outhaul a lot and pop the cambers in?" cuz' if it is it should last not creasing the monofilm...regards



Hi Jp747.

Check the specs of the '08 Koncept that Mr Love posted. I would be very surprised if any other race type sails had monofilm thicker than the Koncept and the luff material is tuff and reinforced around the cam areas.

Rigging method for the '07 was as you describe above. At least the larger sizes in '08 will rig the same way.
sailquik
sailquik
VIC
6171 posts
VIC, 6171 posts
15 Sep 2007 2:00am
quote:
Originally posted by sailquik

quote:
Originally posted by jp747

stewie thanks for the info on the koncept..i think all race sails should be light however for the average sailor who'd like to make it last at least 2yrs. should be looking to more thicker monofilm and tougher luff material..rigging and derrigging does take it's toll..is the koncept a "slide in the mast, downhaul a bit, outhaul a lot and pop the cambers in?" cuz' if it is it should last not creasing the monofilm...regards



Hi Jp747.

Check the specs of the '08 Koncept that Mr Love posted. I would be very surprised if any other race type sails had monofilm thicker than the Koncept and the luff material is tuff and reinforced around the cam areas.

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=6050

Rigging method for the '07 was as you describe above. At least the larger sizes in '08 will rig the same way.


yoyo
yoyo
WA
1646 posts
WA, 1646 posts
15 Sep 2007 1:02am
The 2008 have a nice shape. Pity about the lack of colour, they look kind of washed out on the water and hard to see from a distance, a bit like the grey 2006 Koncepts. The colour scheme seems a direct ripoff from the Lorch graphics of last year... I see Martin has just got himself a couple of those.
mikey100
mikey100
QLD
1109 posts
QLD, 1109 posts
15 Sep 2007 7:52am
Got an "07 5m Koncept- great sail. Like an F1 car compared to your family wagon, if you are after peak performance, the trade off is durability. Look after it and the increased performance is worth it. I am sure there are still 20 yr old Windsurfer One Design sails being used, but the performance???
mr love
mr love
VIC
2424 posts
VIC, 2424 posts
15 Sep 2007 10:00am
Hey Yoyo , Rip off is a bit steep !!!!

Lorch is KA,s European distributor and sell alot of KA Sails . It would be totally negligent of me as a Designer to ignore a major customer . Of course one of the colour schemes had to be compatible with their board range . However , the Koncept also comes in Orange and Blue ,which will match other major brands of board.
The wave sails are available in Red,Orange,Blue and Fluro yellow schemes , some with Metalex , so there,s something for everybody .
You have obviously seen Chris's sails which are early proto's . The graphics have changed a bit .
The idea behind the Koncept graphic was to represent the sail for what it is , a simple ,highly efficient ,no Bulls..t performer . Not a fashion accessory .
yoyo
yoyo
WA
1646 posts
WA, 1646 posts
15 Sep 2007 12:06pm
"... also comes in Orange and Blue "

Glad to read that but I still think a bit more colour would have been nice like some of the 2007 sails.

I see you have also gone all teutonic and restrained with stylized thin-lined colour stripes on the other ranges in 2008 as well.

I can see they would go well with Lorch. It was my first thought when I saw them... well almost :-))

Just letting you know that at least one guy would like a bit more colour.
mr love
mr love
VIC
2424 posts
VIC, 2424 posts
15 Sep 2007 2:16pm
Noted .
I have been designing stuff for long enough to know it is impossible to keep everybody happy . Some like restrained , some like loud .

It,s worth noting that one of the key priorities for 08 was to keep the weight done , therefore we tried to keep "aplied graphics" to a bare minimum . Performance was the no.1 objective .

I have had alot of comments when I have been using the 08 Kult and Kaos proto,s about how good they look !!!
As I said , you can't make everybody happy , what one person loves another will hate . Thats what makes design such a challenging profession .

Seeya Martin
ejmack
ejmack
VIC
1308 posts
VIC, 1308 posts
15 Sep 2007 4:35pm
The new 08 designs look really nice, much nicer than the 07 models IMO.

yoyo
yoyo
WA
1646 posts
WA, 1646 posts
15 Sep 2007 6:09pm
"..what one person loves another will hate . Thats what makes design such a challenging profession ."

not to mention sometimes photo/sketch and in-the-flesh impressions can be quite different or in our case in the shop at point of sail or 200m from the beach which may stimulate you to check one out in the shop etc etc........
mr love
mr love
VIC
2424 posts
VIC, 2424 posts
15 Sep 2007 11:10pm
I,m listening Yoyo , All critism is welcomed , you never stop learning .

jp747
jp747
1553 posts
1553 posts
15 Sep 2007 9:15pm
hi andy/sailquick, didn't know mr.love designed the ka sail..it's a wonderfull sail i would definitely would like to try one out if only there was a distributor here..if you say the rigging process is slide and pop then thin or thick monofilm would not be an issue..a friend told me the trend of sails now is the slide and pop to i guess make rigging easier..really don't know if thats true?!?but certainly makes it a lot lot easier..also regarding battens? i guess this one is for mr. love, why would maui sails put 9 battens on a 5.9? am puzzled it'll lock the shape hard but a 7battened one would do just as fine...regards
sailquik
sailquik
VIC
6171 posts
VIC, 6171 posts
15 Sep 2007 11:30pm
Hi JP747.

Mr Love is the Graphical Design Wizz who has done all the good work to make the KA sails look so great. The Aero and structural design is by Andrew McDougall, the owner of KA Sails Australia.

With the 2006 Koncept we had a different rigging proceedure becasue of the way the boom cut out was designed. With these sails we slid the mast up the sleeve putting the cam s on as we went. Easy to do if you have something on the ground to rest the mast base against. I have never noticed any issues with the Monofilm creasing abnormally with these sails and I an still using them to test the newer sails against so some have been rigged many, many times and used hard. There was some discussion about reverting to this boom cutout configuration for the smallest speed Koncepts in 2008 because of the very aerodynamic way you can make the cutout. I am not sure if this has been adopted or not but I rather hope it has. The larger sizes are certainly as per 2007 in the boom cutout and rigging procedure.

There will be plenty of Koncepts on the beach at Sandy Point this year during speed events in October, November and January. Demos usually available for a taste. :-)

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply