Life Jackets!

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
bubs
bubs
SA
924 posts
SA, 924 posts
14 Jan 2007 3:43pm
Hi everyone,

I was sailing around Goolwa in SA over new years and the Water police came up and told me off for not waring a life jacket. Many people have told me different things and even the man at the sailing club said that i didn't. One of the water police apparently even told a lady that she didn't need one.

Different guys around say it is or isn't but one peoson told me they really only pick you up over new years and christmas which are the busy weekends.

If windsurfers need them i don't see why surfers don't. They are usually in deeper and more dangerous waters than us anyway.

I always though that a windsurfer was not classed as a yahgt and they wern't needed.

I hate waring them so i just wanted to find out the exact law. Do you have to be waring a life jacket while windsurfing?

cheers
bubs
Wineman
Wineman
NSW
1412 posts
NSW, 1412 posts
14 Jan 2007 5:47pm

Bugger!

From Waterways:
Sailboards/Kite Surfers

Exempted from carrying safety equipment when within 400m of the nearest shore. if the sailboarder or kite surfer is not within 400m of the nearest shore, he/she must wear a lifejacket type 2 or 3.

Now I'll have to go & get a GPS so I know when I'm 400m from shore - & chuck a U-ey.
kato
kato
VIC
3530 posts
VIC, 3530 posts
14 Jan 2007 6:29pm
In Victoria we were trying to get the law changed to "No life jacket needed within 400m of shore". I don,t know if it was successful. To me wearing life jackets is very dangerous and stupid.Crashing your board at 35k+ or jumping ,the last place you what to be is on top of the water so your board can drill you.You carn,t swim fast enough with a life jacket on to catch a blown away board.Much easier to spot a person and board from the air than a person.You can drown in a type 2 life jacket if unconcuss.Much better to wear a helmet instead,stops sunburnt heads too. Just my 2 cents worth
rosey
rosey
NSW
575 posts
NSW, 575 posts
14 Jan 2007 6:39pm
are you a complete and utter ****wit?
wearing lifejackets is very stupid and dangerous?
mate you can drown in a ****ing cup of water.
so you would prefer to get ****ed up and sink rather than having a chance of stayin alive all due to a lifejacket.
if your lifejacket actually fits you swimming is hardly impaired.
if you are jumping in 35knots your board will get blown away from you so ****all chance of it landing on you.
you are prob one of thos dicks who thinks 15knots is 35 and think your a hard **** coz your still on your 6m sail you gimp.
i honestly dont care whether people wear them or not, but making dumass remarks like that leaves you with 0 credibility and looking like a dikweed
easty
easty
TAS
2213 posts
TAS, 2213 posts
14 Jan 2007 6:54pm
used to use my good snug fitting (neil pryde)pfd when learning to waterstart - makes it heaps easier to keep your head above the chop when learning to fly the sail. still put it on sometimes in winter, when the windchill makes it about 0 degrees down in tassie - definately keeps me a bit warmer. and if i'm going cruising way offshore, what the heck, throw it on for a bit of extra insurance. i don't wear it often, but when i do i hardly notice it. (but i don't think it should be law - should be up to individual discretion).
Pugwash
Pugwash
WA
7733 posts
WA, 7733 posts
14 Jan 2007 5:17pm
quote:
Originally posted by rosey

are you a complete and utter ****wit?
wearing lifejackets is very stupid and dangerous?
mate you can drown in a ****ing cup of water.
so you would prefer to get ****ed up and sink rather than having a chance of stayin alive all due to a lifejacket.
if your lifejacket actually fits you swimming is hardly impaired.
if you are jumping in 35knots your board will get blown away from you so ****all chance of it landing on you.
you are prob one of thos dicks who thinks 15knots is 35 and think your a hard **** coz your still on your 6m sail you gimp.
i honestly dont care whether people wear them or not, but making dumass remarks like that leaves you with 0 credibility and looking like a dikweed



Ease up Tiger... Read Kato's post again. Didn't see a mention of WIND speed in there anywhere...

Pugs
rosey
rosey
NSW
575 posts
NSW, 575 posts
14 Jan 2007 8:30pm
if you are doing 35 knots there would be at least 35 knots..
snides8
snides8
WA
1731 posts
WA, 1731 posts
14 Jan 2007 6:49pm
got myself 1 of the pryde float vests last year to help offsett some lead i was wearing for speed sailing and can honestly say it is actually a pleasure to use even when iam not carrying weight, the advantages being- nice and stream line,added boyancy for waterstarting or swimming,some protection from impact to the front and back (should have been wearing it in november when i cracked some ribs!!)and this particular model although not pfd 1 or 2 is excepted for races here in wa. it also has pockets for spare bits and pieces like flares and gps etc and comes with a(removable) camel pac thingo on the back as well to quench the thirst. i dont know how it would go if you use a waist harness but with a seat harness no probs and still small enough to give full flexibility while sailing.
i personally dont see to many disadvantages to wearing 1 like this if you are sailing slalom or speed, waves and freestyle are obviously a nother story.
CJW
CJW
NSW
1731 posts
CJW CJW
NSW, 1731 posts
14 Jan 2007 9:00pm
Personally I don't use one because I use a waist harness and sail 95% of the time in the waves, rarely more than 100M offshore. If there was a flotation device that was non intrusive that you could wear I would but such a thing doesn't exist. If like the previous poster you are wearing weight, water or lead (f*@#@g dangerous) you really should wear one or if you get knocked out you're on a one way ticket to Davey Jones' locker.
bubs
bubs
SA
924 posts
SA, 924 posts
14 Jan 2007 9:33pm
It i deffently easier for water starting except at Goolwa where i got dun, other than about 20m of channel, it's like knee to waist deep. Plus when i sailed around at the barrage there was about 20cm of water.

I and another guy that sails with me, thinks that if you are sailing in water that is that shallow, a life jacket is actually more dangerous (and annoying). When i fall off still hooked in, i quite often end up underneith the sail. I have to un hook and get out as soon as i can holding my breath in just shallow water, which makes it harder. If i was to be waring a life jacket, this process would be much harder and longer, making it much more dangerous and even worse if i start to pannic. Floating up would make it hard to un hook and hard to get under the boom or upwards to the top of the sail.

I personally think at Goolwa in the Murray where there next to no water, a life jacket is the worst idea possible. They are uncomfortable and can be more dangerous. Mabey off a beach wheree you cant ever stand up they would be very useful for water starting, but for shallow water theres absolutely no point.

I still cannot work out why we have to ware them and surfers don't though. They are in deeper and more dangerous waters anyway.

bubs

mathew
mathew
QLD
2172 posts
QLD, 2172 posts
15 Jan 2007 10:29am
quote:
Originally posted by kato

... wearing life jackets is very dangerous and stupid.Crashing your board at 35k+ or jumping ,the last place you what to be is on top of the water so your board can drill you.You carn,t swim fast enough with a life jacket on to catch a blown away board.



As someone that hangs out at Sandy Point regularly enough, I can tell you that most guys there where impact vests with some bouyancy in them for a few reasons:

a) when you hit the rig at 40knots it is painful , some impact protection is a good thing,

b) when you crash sometimes you get concussed, even for a second - even with a helmet, 40-to-0 in one second is hard on your body.

I also use extra bouyancy when sailing race boards as the sails are very big and they easily fill with water making waterstarting quite hard.

That said I would agree that for wavesailing, you shouldn't wear any bouyancy.
kato
kato
VIC
3530 posts
VIC, 3530 posts
15 Jan 2007 7:05pm
Dear rosey
sorry you couldn,t read my post.I,m a speedsailer and even you can do 35ks in 20kt wind easy. Ps I was talking about the "safety" of life jackets
md74
md74
QLD
1064 posts
QLD, 1064 posts
15 Jan 2007 6:13pm
we need air bag deployed life vests in our waist harness's!
bubs
bubs
SA
924 posts
SA, 924 posts
15 Jan 2007 7:09pm
I think we need the water police to let us make our own decission on what we think is safe and our own preference on wether we think we need a life jacket or not. Some people like them and some don't, so there shouldn't be any law against it.

Yet i still am not exactly of the law in SA. Is it law to ware a life jacket and if so, why don't surfers need them?

bubs
gazza
gazza
WA
647 posts
WA, 647 posts
15 Jan 2007 7:48pm
quote:
Yet i still am not exactly of the law in SA. Is it law to ware a life jacket and if so, why don't surfers need them?


cause you can't duck dive with a life jacket on duh





Gidget
Gidget
NSW
104 posts
NSW, 104 posts
15 Jan 2007 10:27pm
quote:
Originally posted by bubs


Yet i still am not exactly of the law in SA. Is it law to ware a life jacket and if so, why don't surfers need them?

bubs



Aha! Knew I would find it if I looked hard enough! If you thought "Borat" was outrageous/funny, then read this little gem from the Marine Safety Equipment section of the Government of South Australia Department for Transport, Engergy and Infrastructure website at www.sa.gov.au/topics/driving-and-transport

quote:
Exemptions

The safety equipment requirements apply to the majority of boats. However, certain types of boat are either partially or totally exempt from these requirements. Some of the more common exemptions are summarised below.

Canoes, kayaks, sailboards and similar small, unpowered boats must have for each occupant

* PFD that complies with Australian Standards and worn at all times
* suitable bailer (unless the hull is permanently enclosed)
* waterproof torch or lantern while being operated during the hours of darkness.



It would appear from my reading of it, in terms of the law in South Aus at least, "surfboards" don't come under the definition of "boats" whereas "sailboards" do!
That's law for you!
bubs
bubs
SA
924 posts
SA, 924 posts
15 Jan 2007 10:11pm
Most of the sailing i do is in waters where i can stand up. This makes a life jacket completely pointless and annoying. An as i have said before in this topic, in some cases of very shallow waters, they can be more dangerous for different reasons.

Surfers are in much deeper and more dangerous waters.

bubs
divaldo
divaldo
SA
2879 posts
SA, 2879 posts
15 Jan 2007 10:40pm
Goolwa lake is pretty murky Bubs, how do you know where you can stand up and where you cant? I think you are pretty unlucky to have been pulled up by authorities, but the law is there for a reason. Like seat belts really, some people dont like wearing them but in some (most)cases they can save your life in an accident.
Gidget
Gidget
NSW
104 posts
NSW, 104 posts
15 Jan 2007 11:48pm
quote:
Originally posted by bubs


If windsurfers need them i don't see why surfers don't. They are usually in deeper and more dangerous waters than us anyway.



I found this quote from Professor Brian Fitzgerald (from the Law of the Surf Forum) which sort of sums it up:
quote:

The objective of the Law of the Surf Forum was to promote the universally accepted lore of surfing recognised by the surfing community so that surfing remains free of government regulative intervention and preserves the Free Spirit of Surfing.

As a surfer, the last thing I would like to see is the surf being colonised or taken over by lawyers - surfing would lose its soul. We surf to get away from the confines of everyday life: to get wet, have fun and feel free.



I think he is right and the same attitude should persist for windsurfers!
bubs
bubs
SA
924 posts
SA, 924 posts
15 Jan 2007 11:50pm
divaldo:
I have been sailing at goolwa since i was 6 and have never really worn a life jacket. After going there for this long i know within 10 or so metres where the channels are (two of them. one near hindmarsh island and one about 15m from beach launching from the aquacaff. Each about 20m wide.)

Around at the barrage where i usually sail, until you reach about 50m from hindmarsh island, it is knee deep or less in all places. This is why i find a life jacket very annoying and i personally hate getting stuck under my sail where i cannot breath.

When i have been sailing there for so long and know where to sail to avoid these channels, i don't think i need some person in a boat telling to ware a life jacket in waist deep water. I think windsurfers should be treated exactly like surfers and should be left to make their own decission. However i think they would help in water where you can never stand up. Goolwa is one of the safest places to sail because if you do get in trouble you always drift to shore.

One guy who snapped his boom a couple hundred metres from shore and walked back the whole way around at the barrage. This is why i find life jackets unneccesary.

Bubs

P.S: Are kitesurfers treated the same as windsurfers. Do they have to ware a life jacket?

jack1574
jack1574
TAS
12 posts
TAS, 12 posts
16 Jan 2007 1:23am
I wear an AS1512 PFD1 which is about the highest you get. Its so small I don't even notice it anymore.

looks like this :

www.mozu.com/login?returnUrl=%2flogin%2fto%3fscopetype%3dTenant%26scopeid%3d27878%26redirecturl%3d%252fapparel%252fapparel_details.php%253fitem%253d845%2526category%253driding%2526group%253d7%2526subgroup%253d%26postbackurl%3dhttp%253a%252f%252fwww.yamaha-motor.ca%252fauth%252fpants%26showdev%3dFalse?1.2005.6.0

mine is the manual version, wouldn't want it going off prematurely :)
divaldo
divaldo
SA
2879 posts
SA, 2879 posts
16 Jan 2007 10:48am
quote:
Originally posted by jack1574

I wear an AS1512 PFD1 which is about the highest you get. Its so small I don't even notice it anymore.

looks like this :

www.mozu.com/login?returnUrl=%2flogin%2fto%3fscopetype%3dTenant%26scopeid%3d27878%26redirecturl%3d%252fapparel%252fapparel_details.php%253fitem%253d845%2526category%253driding%2526group%253d7%2526subgroup%253d%26postbackurl%3dhttp%253a%252f%252fwww.yamaha-motor.ca%252fauth%252fpants%26showdev%3dFalse?1.2005.6.0

mine is the manual version, wouldn't want it going off prematurely :)



These are a good idea....
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply