Loft Sails?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
shi thouse
shi thouse
WA
1159 posts
WA, 1159 posts
15 Aug 2006 9:13am
Hoping to get some feedback on the Loft Wave Sails. Was having a look at their web site last night and checking out their 2006 and 2007 (yet to come out) range. Not only do they look like good sails, they are also fantastically priced. Last thing left to question is what their performance and durability is like?
winddude
winddude
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
15 Aug 2006 11:40am
sorry shi thouse but they are shi thouse - dont even bother. Buy a name brand youll be much happier and the sails will actually be worth something in a couple of years time.
Crash Landing
Crash Landing
NSW
1173 posts
NSW, 1173 posts
15 Aug 2006 1:55pm
Durability - can't say, only had mine for a month. Performance - excellent (although it was an O2), fast, stable, great leach twist.

I had a look at Harrows loft lip and it looked the business, tough, well designed and some good extra features - eg very padded mast sleeve.

Winddude - can you back up your strong opinion?
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
15 Aug 2006 2:45pm
From what i've seen durability is fine, they work well, are well thought out and look great. My one critism of the O2 was that it appears a little long in the boom for a given size.

You could always spend twice as much and get pryde and you'll get half as much back in a few years since they will fall apart before you're eyes... but I guess thats the benefit of getting a brand name.
Wim
Wim
QLD
23 posts
Wim Wim
QLD, 23 posts
15 Aug 2006 4:31pm
have a 5.7 m loft lip wave 2006 and happy with it. It rigs well and has a good wind range. Who cares about 2nd hand value if you buy cheap enough? Will definitely consider this sail again for replacement on my older sails.
winddude
winddude
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
15 Aug 2006 6:20pm
Have given them a go.Have had Pryde,Gaastra and North sails (and a few others)over the last few years and have always found them to be well balanced, well built and good resale.Lofts and others have a poor wind range, hard to rig for changing conditions (tune)and are not well balanced. The old " such and such brand falls apart" line is bollocks and is only spread by people who have a vested interest- if you cant attack a product on performance then attack it on something intangible like durability. In my experiance (actively windsurfing for 22 years) most sails are quite durable - the bigger the company the more important it is to fix any problems, the Prydes i have owned have been awesome(both wave & slalom).Resale on my sails has been good- I have often seen lesser brands not sell for any price.
Mike
aage
aage
WA
1 posts
WA, 1 posts
16 Aug 2006 9:00am
I have one 7,4 O2 (-03 or -04 model) and one 4,7 (-05 model). Durabillity is exceptional compared to any other sails I've had. NP in my experience has a particularly short life span (no vested interest what-so-ever, except getting my moneys worth). I've also had North and Gaastra over the last couple of years.

Winddude: "Lofts and others have a poor wind range, hard to rig for changing conditions (tune)and are not well balanced."
Have you tried them???
My experience would be the exact opposite. Very easy to rig with a great range.

By the way; how is durabillity intangible?? Few things more tangible than a long swim with a sail ripped to shreds...
racycoot
racycoot
WA
315 posts
WA, 315 posts
16 Aug 2006 9:26am
Stick with Ezzys, shi thouse, you cant go wrong!

Besides that, with the Ezzys from the last two years tuning is as easy as adjusting your outhaul. Yesterday I was sailing on the Swan in gusty gusty conditions. Wind dropped out, let out the outhaul and I was away. Squalls came through, reefed on the outhaul and I was away. I had my 5.2m sail working from 15knots to 35knots!
winddude
winddude
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
16 Aug 2006 10:10am
quote:
Originally posted by aage

I have one 7,4 O2 (-03 or -04 model) and one 4,7 (-05 model). Durabillity is exceptional compared to any other sails I've had. NP in my experience has a particularly short life span (no vested interest what-so-ever, except getting my moneys worth). I've also had North and Gaastra over the last couple of years.

Winddude: "Lofts and others have a poor wind range, hard to rig for changing conditions (tune)and are not well balanced."
Have you tried them???
My experience would be the exact opposite. Very easy to rig with a great range.

By the way; how is durabillity intangible?? Few things more tangible than a long swim with a sail ripped to shreds...




Yes have tried them - just giving my honest opinion.If your sail rips to shreds its usually something that causes it, all sails are basically made from the same materials, the same way and often in the same factory. What you pay for is research and development, testing and expertise.
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
16 Aug 2006 2:32pm
Cmon winddude, all sails are the same- at a base level it's like saying all glad wrap products are the same... they're not. Pryde's do have poor quality, gaastra tend to make their sails to a specification (often at the expense of durability)- the only major brand which has really always been there reliability wise is north. I was a pryde man through and through, owned other sails but always returned to pryde. Now they dont even get a look in, it'd be good if Neil or whoever the director is now read some of this stuff and decided to make it right.

I'm sure Monty who has practically been designing sails since the dawn of windsurfing is capable of making sails that are user friendly and have good performance and range. mmm Loft blades [}:)]
Crash Landing
Crash Landing
NSW
1173 posts
NSW, 1173 posts
16 Aug 2006 3:04pm
HAve a look at this link to see Montys background, seems to have worked for a few sail makers, has been at the forefront of sail design for over 20 years and has had sails claim the speed sailing record. I guess with that much experience, working for his own company, he's hardly going to launch sub standard products?

http://www.windsurfingsales.com.au/aboutsales/earlydays.php

It would be great if we could have a poll on here to see who thinks which brand makes bad/good equipment. I have read what seems like hundreds of posts saying Pryde make weak sails. Gaastra are mentioned as not being great either (longevity), I have heard lots of reports that Severne sails look the goods but don't last.

What i personally know from my own experience is that Ezzy make bullet proof sails, I can't fault North, Tushingham makes sails that last, I personally liked the feel of Arrows (and never had a problem with them) and my sailworks sails are still going strong and they're 6 years (and multiple wipeouts) old!

That is all based on my opinion gained from use and reading forums.
SurfConnect
SurfConnect
QLD
1674 posts
QLD, 1674 posts
16 Aug 2006 5:23pm
I had a 2006 7.4 n 5.7, very impressed with material and craftsmanship. Well made and designed to last. Priced very competitively too. Definitely worth considering if dont wanna pay higher price for more well known brands. My loyalty still lies with Pryde though
winddude
winddude
WA
92 posts
WA, 92 posts
16 Aug 2006 5:32pm
As i said, generally most sails have a similar level of build quality - especially from year to year.Every now and then a company can make a mistake-but you shouldnt tar and feather a brand name for ever because of it.The reason why you read more about pryde sails is that they own over 50% of the market worldwide.If a company outsells another 100 to 1 you will hear 100 times the comments both good and bad. I can also assure you that Neil himself is very aware of his product's strengths and weaknesses - he is one of the most astute businessman in the industry
SurfConnect
SurfConnect
QLD
1674 posts
QLD, 1674 posts
16 Aug 2006 9:05pm
But Pryde feels nothing like others, light weight yet responsive and stable especially the RS series. My fav are RS3s. RS4 on luv pockets gone too big lol!!!
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
16 Aug 2006 10:49pm
maybe i should start a new thread.
oh well,
in 1980 i got one of the first neil pryde 6.3 racing dacron sails.
they were the benchmark of shape and durability.
along with every other sailbrand they have swung between durability and performance, always with performance being the benchmark often to their detriment. north,gaastra always followed similar paths.
there are a lot of sail brands all of which are copies of those three market leaders and their offshoots: naish, ezzy.
use what you like but there is "nothing" like owning a new pryde kit.
or the other companies i have mentioned.
if you are on a budget and you feel a need to go to the direct seller market of cheap stuff,you will certainly still have a sh1tload of fun windsurfing. you will almost never be able to resell it, but hey it was cheapish.
i have been privileged to always have been able to have used the top gear over the last couple of decades but all newcomers stuff has always had a test too, if offered.
save your bucks i say and get the good stuff.
regards ian.

Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14965 posts
QLD, 14965 posts
17 Aug 2006 1:06am
Pryde is the only brand of gear that i have continuously seen falling apart. i myself steer clear of them because of that one point. Also i have north sails and naish sails that i can't sell second hand so i don't believe buying a major sail brand means protection in the long run.

lucky for me resale is not such a big item. i usually buy a sail and then sail it to death. normally 6 years. so the purchase price and quality are certainly very big items. if my sails fell apart after 3 or so years i would be very angry.

a quick search online will reveal that loft sails do very well in magazine tests. sometimes beating pryde for performance and always fighting for the top of the list with quality. they are also designed on rdm masts. seems to be a current trend...
hobie14t
hobie14t
QLD
259 posts
QLD, 259 posts
17 Aug 2006 8:53am
I just got the brochure from the guys at Windsurfing sails for the Gun and Loft brands, must say that both brands look fantastic and the effort looks equal to that of any other sail brands. I havent ever used a Loft of Gun sail so cant comment on them. However if you want to save $$ then why not give them a go? If you picking over the fact that they are such a small company and that the resale value isnt good and the durability isnt upto what larger brands is, then frankly if your a dam good sailor then pay that little extra and go for the bigger brands. However if your not a pro sailor, choosing between a Pryde or a Loft sounds like a big toss. Granted durability could be not so good on Loft but if your on a budget and perhaps not the best sailor out there, your still going to have a dam good bit of kit and for a dam good price! PS I sail with an Ezzy 6.6 and North 8.1, cant fault them!
sick_em_rex
sick_em_rex
NSW
1601 posts
NSW, 1601 posts
17 Aug 2006 9:27am
Hey Gestalt,
what are these Naish and North sails you have that you say you can't sell second hand????
RedDragon
RedDragon
QLD
122 posts
QLD, 122 posts
17 Aug 2006 9:29am
Dont buy these sails- support your local retailer,god knows they need all the help they can get.
FilthyAmatuer
FilthyAmatuer
WA
877 posts
WA, 877 posts
17 Aug 2006 7:44pm
I love them. I have a 5.2m 2006 loft lip wave. It is my favourite sail, riggs easy. Quite a large wind range. And handles fine on the waves. Better than any other sail I have owned. I have had my sail about 8 months and used it heaps and it still looks new.

I think it is poor that people slag off brands because they arent as well known or dont make as many sails. I think the smaller brands have more at stake if the make a crap product. Even the better manufacturers make **** sails from time to time.
marco0575
marco0575
NSW
58 posts
NSW, 58 posts
17 Aug 2006 9:46pm
Seems to be some strong opinions in this forum - each is of course equally valid.

I learned to sail in Italy, and am familar with Loft brand, as well as the mainstream.

Taking up windsurfing in Sydney, in summer 05/06, I brought a Loft O2 6.6. Superb balance, lightness, tunability, speed potential. Is it well built.... no its not, its very well built.

Others share my opinion.. see Windsurf Mag test http://www.loftsails.com/kam_pages/1/e/155.php







greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
17 Aug 2006 10:26pm
its funny that people who spend their working hours (half their life or more) doing diddly squat to do with windsurfing can comment on a sails durability/performance.
most similar construction sails with equal use, wear at similar rates.
a 2 year old looks used
a 4 year old looks stretchy and scratchy
a 6 year old you gotta be kidding you cant like that stretched piece of crap any more.
some guys wreck stuff in a month regardless of the brand, some rinse them in so much fresh water that they rot,some leave them in the boot or their car moist in the sun so they cook like cabbage.
and others leave them rigged all day in the sun while the spend time justifying to onlookers why they bought the daiwoo of sails instead of going sailing.
buy what you like, but a pryde,north,gaastra is a prestige vehicle and has some heritage.

if every company offered you free sails because you were really good.
which offer would you accept?

i know this will attract some beauties.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
17 Aug 2006 8:44pm
I'd stick to what I've got, Avalon Sail Co.
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
17 Aug 2006 10:49pm
i have no doubt they are good decrepit.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
17 Aug 2006 9:00pm
If you've heard of Phil (Bugs) Smith, you'll know why I love them!
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
17 Aug 2006 11:10pm
we should really start a new thread about favourite sail brands and why? good idea decrepit!
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
17 Aug 2006 9:13pm
you go first, perhaps I'll follow
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14965 posts
QLD, 14965 posts
18 Aug 2006 12:11am
i guess people comment on what they see at the beach or what happens to them when they windsurf. regardless of whether they work in the industry or not.

what's really behaind the bagging loft sails cop. i pressume it is more political than fact based.

if we were to support the local guys we would all sail KA, Severne and Stuart bell, and ride NXS and OES boards.
greenleader
greenleader
QLD
5283 posts
QLD, 5283 posts
18 Aug 2006 12:20am
there are more guys employed in australia making their living from distributing overseas brands as localish ones that are still manufactured overseas anyway. do you own an aussie t.v.?
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14965 posts
QLD, 14965 posts
18 Aug 2006 12:57am
sick-em-rex

my sails are listed here.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=19800

cheers.
Wim
Wim
QLD
23 posts
Wim Wim
QLD, 23 posts
21 Aug 2006 4:21pm
quote:
Originally posted by greenleader

its funny that people who spend their working hours (half their life or more) doing diddly squat to do with windsurfing can comment on a sails durability/performance.
most similar construction sails with equal use, wear at similar rates.
a 2 year old looks used
a 4 year old looks stretchy and scratchy
a 6 year old you gotta be kidding you cant like that stretched piece of crap any more.
some guys wreck stuff in a month regardless of the brand, some rinse them in so much fresh water that they rot,some leave them in the boot or their car moist in the sun so they cook like cabbage.
and others leave them rigged all day in the sun while the spend time justifying to onlookers why they bought the daiwoo of sails instead of going sailing.
buy what you like, but a pryde,north,gaastra is a prestige vehicle and has some heritage.

if every company offered you free sails because you were really good.
which offer would you accept?

i know this will attract some beauties.



Dear Greenleader,

I first bought 3 new prestige vehicles: One ripped in half after 6 months and the 2 others have at least 20 holes in them also within 6 months. (Anybody who knows me can confirm)

So, I bought 2 daiwoos (1 Loft and 1 Aerotech), both of whom sail great and still look like new.

So, I hope you don't mind I prefer to go sailing my daiwoos instead of sitting home patching up my prestige vehicles.

Best regards,

Wim
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply