Most stable wave sail?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
1 Sep 2007 6:44pm
Following on from a thread on the speed forum about control in the bumps...
Who makes the most stable wave sails? Does anyone make a wave sail that doesn't go backhanded and draggy when over-powered?
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
1 Sep 2007 8:54pm
It's using the wave sail outside it's brief... using a small size for handling. Being able to depower is best aspect of using a wavesail when it's choppy and windy.
wet dreams
wet dreams
NSW
29 posts
NSW, 29 posts
1 Sep 2007 9:17pm
Just to add a question to this topic....I have noticed some wave sails in the 5.3 sizes recommend the use of either a 400 or a 430 mast depending on the manufacturer. Would this make the sails feel different in stability depower or usability etc.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
1 Sep 2007 7:37pm
I'm exceptionally happy with my Avalon Sail Co wave sails, they're very stable, I'm 70kg and was using my 5.3 for blasting around before I had the use of a an ASco speed sail, the speed sail is more stable as you would expect. But I've been out in strong winds with my 5.3 and a friend who's 20kg heavier couldn't hang on to his 5.0, had to rig a 4.5, can't remember what his sails were.

Al McLeod
Al McLeod
VIC
633 posts
VIC, 633 posts
1 Sep 2007 9:56pm
ezzys are designed to be stable with the locked in draft. i dont particularly agree with it however but it could be due to rigging it on the wrong mast...
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
1 Sep 2007 8:12pm
Off topic, but Al tell your old man he missed a great day at Green Today, Ben went over.
jord070
jord070
WA
1109 posts
WA, 1109 posts
1 Sep 2007 8:30pm
well, i have 2 exelent sails, ones the hotsail deva, its a womans sail but it is buitiful handling, the other isnt a wave, but its a cross over, its the hotdsails superfreek, this is the best sail in the world, its shape is flat, so it depowers when you want it to, but it keeps the power in, but the thing about these two sails is that they need rdm's to take full advantage of its controlablity, if you want a full on wave, no monofilm, i have the 4.8 superfreek smack, another buitiful sail, but it hold a whole lot of grunt in it, and isnt as stable as these othertwo. but it still is much more controlable than alot of the other sails i have tried,
most of these sails i use over powerd everytime i use them, and they rock,
my conculsion for the best brand would have to b hotsails, but thats probally because my other branded sails are older, (2002 or 2003)
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
1 Sep 2007 11:14pm
i don't agree that ezzys are that good when overpowered. comparing the 5.3 SE wave i had to my 5.3 Kult there is no show. the kult handled winds up to 40 knots where the ezzy i used to have liked to slam me backwards into the water.

i also reckon (but haven't used one) that the NP alpha would probably come up trumps too. shape looks good.
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
1 Sep 2007 10:32pm
Hey Gestalt,

What year was the Ezzy?
the skipper
the skipper
QLD
90 posts
QLD, 90 posts
2 Sep 2007 1:27am
Well that could have been the year of the really loose leach.
There was also
The year of the distorted foot....or
The year of the loose foot and roach.

Hold on, what about the years of "if you downhaul it, everything goes floppy"

Bomb proof though if you can plane.

wa sog 30+ 4.5-
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
2 Sep 2007 9:38am
quote:
Originally posted by nebbian

Hey Gestalt,

What year was the Ezzy?



hi nebs,

i had a 2001 5.7 and 5.3 and a 2002 4.2
Al McLeod
Al McLeod
VIC
633 posts
VIC, 633 posts
2 Sep 2007 10:19am
ok firiebob. he wanted to go over but he had to work... wasnt very happy about it. and the ezzy that i used was a 2006 se wave.
curac
curac
WA
1160 posts
WA, 1160 posts
2 Sep 2007 8:42am
Out of sail's i have used. the Neilpryde Combat is probably the most stable. the centre of effort just doesn't move, i have a 4.5 and i have used that sail in 40knots and it's stable enough to still feel confident enough to try to go big in the jumps.

It's not the best sail. but it's the most stable i think
jord070
jord070
WA
1109 posts
WA, 1109 posts
2 Sep 2007 9:57am
quote:
Originally posted by curac

Out of sail's i have used. the Neilpryde Combat is probably the most stable. the centre of effort just doesn't move, i have a 4.5 and i have used that sail in 40knots and it's stable enough to still feel confident enough to try to go big in the jumps.

It's not the best sail. but it's the most stable i think


i dont agree so much with the combat, i have a older one 2002 i think, and when over powerd it is better than some sails, but worse than alot aswell, i can use the 5.0 combat is prety good winds, 25 knotts befor i change down to the smack (4.8) but if i had the choice i wouldnt go for one, thaT being said i have seen a few of the newer combats (07) and they do look very nice,especially when correctly powerd and riged etc. but when im out o0n my 4,8 and i see these guys on their 5.5 or 5.3 and they look like they'r doing the chicken dance on their boards, sheeting in sheating out, putting there left leg on the rail, putting the right leg, and well it doesnt look like much fun, untill they are planing that is, then they shoot past me at the speed of sound,
curac
curac
WA
1160 posts
WA, 1160 posts
2 Sep 2007 6:15pm
yeah i don't think they were out in 2002, i got an 06 4.5 it's pretty good, stable and strong,

it depends on what you like though as to if it's a good sail or not.

i think it is a good sail but i like other sail better. but for different things, the combat and those type of sail i find are good for jumping and smashing about, but for DTL i prefer something like the Zone or a Goya wave because they depower well in the bottom turn and don't slam back on with the power (unless you are totally over powerd) where as with combat style sails, (sails with fair bit of pre shape) i find that there is always power in the sail so it feels like you are going to get pulled over on the bottom turns, and some times you can have to much power on your cut back and end up sliding off the back of the wave.

but actually when you are totally over powered i would prefer the combat to the goya or zone for the cut back because the power stays in the front, where as with the zone of goya the centre of effore moves back more when you get over powered an you end up skipping out.

although saying all that i did sail severne blades for a couple bit 06 was the last model i had i think. and they really didn't suit me to well and i would put them in the same catagories as a combat, pre shape and all. the models i used had to much back hand for me.

I haven't tried and hot sails maui but i did have a hot rod mast and the quality was very good so i assume the rest of their products would be to the same level

I would think it pretty much works like this if the sail has pre shape in it.. is gonna be pretty stable, as to the centre of effort. but a sail with a flatter profile is better for DTL ridding

(not talking about this years sails. i haven't tried any yet)

Auswind
Auswind
WA
398 posts
WA, 398 posts
3 Sep 2007 2:52pm
Matty h here from Auswind

some interesting discussion going on here..

Just got back from the Severne distributors meeting. Interesting to note that Severne werent talking about onshore (full pre shape) vs sideshore (flatter profiles)in their design philospohy any more(in fact they never really have) The rational is that a wave sail should work in all conditions (nobody wants to have to own 2 sets of wave sails to cover all conditions)

The defining factor in their wave sail's design was rider geometry and style.

The Blade has a design suited to lower gemoetry where riders drive the rails through bottom and top turns (Scott Mckercher Style) - more suited to classic vert lip focused wavesailing .

whereas the Severne S1 was designed for riders who ride over the board more and have a more flicky and tricky style ( like Jaeger Stone) - more new school- suited to Goitres, and Freestyle like radical manoevoures in the Surf.

BOTH designs have a similar level of top end control.Any quality sail should have good top end control these days.

Another point of note was sail material development - it appears Severne is one of very few companies developing materials (especially laminates like E4, Metallex 2 , KS optic Xply) for use in sail making - a Severne sail can have up to 10 different types of material and laminates used to control shaping and reinforcing - whereas the max no competitors have is 4)- These new laminates allow Severne to control shaping, tension, reinforcment and UV stability in ways that havent been seen before in the Windsurfing game.

Severne are confident in calling the 2008 S1 the lightest and most high tech sail on the market today. It also features an "armoured frame" (the Aramid torsion frame) to protect the sail from the sort of radical impacts the S1 should be experiencing.

Leech
Leech
WA
1933 posts
WA, 1933 posts
3 Sep 2007 3:06pm
Matt, what you report lines up with a couple of old reviews I read recently in Windsurf mag. 4.7 S1 and Blade were both reviewed and similar comments were made:

Blade: "the centre of effort is concentrated low and forward in the draft, physically accelerating in the hands as it transfers its energy directly into the board."

S1: "The centre of effort is higher than in its sibling - the Blade, positioned around shoulder height and forward in the foil, which, coupled with the higher clew position, encourages the sailor into a more upright manoeuvre-oriented stance."

Reading between the lines in the reviews it seems that both sails have pre-shape in the draft, right?
REAL
REAL
14 posts
14 posts
3 Sep 2007 4:07pm
Gee I want to see Gestalt use a 5.3 in 40 knots what a load of crap.
jord070
jord070
WA
1109 posts
WA, 1109 posts
3 Sep 2007 4:18pm
quote:
Originally posted by REAL

Gee I want to see Gestalt use a 5.3 in 40 knots what a load of crap.


agreed
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
3 Sep 2007 7:05pm
quote:
Originally posted by REAL

Gee I want to see Gestalt use a 5.3 in 40 knots what a load of crap.



sorry to dissappoint REAL. it is all true. there were witnesses. HTFU
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
3 Sep 2007 7:13pm
I had a 6.5 out in 40+knot squall once......not bragging about it, had witnesses too (watch me swim to the nearest sheltered outcrop, holding the rig underwater, and wait 'till the storm passed).....nearly ended my windsurfing, and life.

There's alot to said for those with ability - (ie; Gestalt)......as opposed to those with stupidity - (ie; me)

Anyway, what was the topic about again???
mineral1
mineral1
WA
4564 posts
WA, 4564 posts
3 Sep 2007 5:18pm
quote:
Originally posted by Sailhack

I had a 6.5 out in 40+knot squall once......not bragging about it, had witnesses too (watch me swim to the nearest sheltered outcrop, holding the rig underwater, and wait 'till the storm passed).....nearly ended my windsurfing, and life.

There's alot to said for those with ability - (ie; Gestalt)......as opposed to those with stupidity - (ie; me)

Anyway, what was the topic about again???




Dunno, but your avator is sh1t hot
jord070
jord070
WA
1109 posts
WA, 1109 posts
3 Sep 2007 5:46pm
quote:
Originally posted by Gestalt

quote:
Originally posted by REAL

Gee I want to see Gestalt use a 5.3 in 40 knots what a load of crap.



sorry to dissappoint REAL. it is all true. there were witnesses. HTFU


really! wow. was it by choice or where you just out at the rong time
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
3 Sep 2007 6:18pm
What I want to know is did your 5.3 Kult get you planing in the same wind as your 5.3 Ezzy?
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
3 Sep 2007 8:42pm
I can't confirm Gestalt's 40knot prowess, but I can confirm the KA's aren't short of bottom end.

I'll freely admit my 5.3 kaos is a bloody handful in 40knots
WINDY MILLER
WINDY MILLER
WA
3183 posts
WA, 3183 posts
3 Sep 2007 10:05pm
quote:
Originally posted by mkseven

I can't confirm Gestalt's 40knot prowess, but I can confirm the KA's aren't short of bottom end.

I'll freely admit my 5.3 kaos is a bloody handful in 40knots




errrm maybe 40kts in the east isn't the same as here in the west or the average weight over there is 120kgs or i'm a total blouse
Haircut
Haircut
QLD
6491 posts
QLD, 6491 posts
4 Sep 2007 10:15am
don't forget we're talking SE Queensland 40knots here, which is really only 29.7knots anywhere else, and not to be confused with kiteboarding knots which is the equivalent to 23.9 knots

apparently this converion process also applies to gps units sold in SE Queensland

Auswind
Auswind
WA
398 posts
WA, 398 posts
4 Sep 2007 9:17am
any sail has pre shape built in to it

The Blades definitely seem to have a fuller draft although it is tuneable

The s1 seems to be a little flatter - but i may be wrong on this

often its where the foil peaks rather than how much that gives a sail its particular ride.

I can say that the S1 has alot more luff curve which- through mast bend and tension - transfers tension to the rest of the sail- So the S1 runs a higher skin tension than the blade. Luff curve is one of the major determinants of a sails feel, yet rarely gets mentioned. Also -use of softer dacron panels near the mast sleeve can deliver a softer feeling to a sail - i have noticed Severne doing this in smaller sizes to get away from that twitchy on off feleing that some small wavesails give in gusty conditions

on the knots issue - 2 kiteboarding knots equals one 1 windsurfing knot.

a 5.3 wavesail in 40 knots - i'm pretty sceptical about that one too.considering that most crew are blown off the water in around 25 knots on a 5.3 there may be some credibility issues here...
Poida
Poida
WA
1922 posts
WA, 1922 posts
4 Sep 2007 9:45am
if you were 200kg on a 92L wave board using a 5.3 you may be just powered up in 40knots?
i would of thought best to stay in the car at that type of wind or risk being blown away in the carpark!


Regarding stability I found the S1's really stable in fully powered and overpowered conditions
555
555
892 posts
555 555
892 posts
4 Sep 2007 10:43am
I think 5.3 in 40 knots is absolutely possible.. I got caught out in 34 knots (according to the local wave tower at the time) with a cambered 7m sail on a 152 litre techno and 46cm fin just this past weekend. I weigh 78kg.

Definitely a case of wrong place at the wrong time!

It was survival sailing at best, but definitely doable. A brilliant time to remember all those tips for trimming, stance, and going fast, and then doing the opposite of most of them. Too much speed upwind, and it's time for a backloop lesson.

A fellow sailor was caught out in the same weather on similar gear and went for a long drift while I parked my gear under a log on the beach and went to help.

There is no way that I wanted to crank on the power though - that would've been suicidal. Just enough back hand pressure to keep moving and prevent a stall, and no more. It's the first time I've ever had to waterstart a board that big in both straps!

It's not comfortable, easy or recommended, but it is possible!

Backhanded and draggy? Try a 7m North Tonic in 34 knots without any outhaul, and only slightly more downhaul.. No wonder he was drifting!
Leech
Leech
WA
1933 posts
WA, 1933 posts
4 Sep 2007 10:57am
I was watching a video clip yesterday of the Pritchards sailing 40 knot Kona winds. They rigged 3.7's.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply