What setup for 12knt planning?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:29pm
What would be an ideal setup for 12knot planning for a lightweight (65kg)? (Besides formula gear )
rosey
rosey
NSW
575 posts
NSW, 575 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:38pm
8.5 sailworks retro, starboard carve 133(around there)....
Waiting4wind
Waiting4wind
NSW
1871 posts
NSW, 1871 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:59pm
Falcon 111, V8 7.5m with adjustable outhaul, I'm 8okg. I'm not sure what time you got out last Saturday, it was pretty light between 5 -15, mostly around 8-12. I had quite a bit of planning time, however it does need good pumping and other technique. Moreover with efficient gear you can get quite good speed as soon as you get planning.
AUS154 Chris
AUS154 Chris
QLD
217 posts
QLD, 217 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:12pm
Hi Harrow, I'm the same weight and I agree 8.5 is the size you want. Not sure of your experience or favorite discipline, but I prefer cambers, and if you're using a wide, floaty board, and it is light wind anyway, you can't get into too much trouble with cams. You want a board with some decent width - between 68 - 80cm, and a racy type fin - fairly straight and not a lot of rake. As for what type of board , well I would say a modern lightweight slalom, but I dunno what you like or how hard on the gear you are. So you also must look at construction. Don't get an ultra lightweight racing machine if you regularly crash, because you will destroy it.
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:13pm
Hi Harrow with your weight I don't believe you need bigger than 7.0
and 103 litre board maybe a Exocet scross.Im 83Kg and I plain in 10-12 knots on a 120 litre Scross and 7.0m Sail. But like Waiting4wind said is does take a certain technique.
ta Vando
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:26pm
go the isonic 125 and an 8.5 sail. make sure you get a sail that rigs on a 460 to keep the cost down. i think you already got a 460?
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:33pm
mmm 8.5 on a 460 mast not sure about that Gestalt.


Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
21 Mar 2006 10:50pm
hi vando,

should check out the north range. bigger sails fit 460 masts with the extender.

can use the extender on any sails. plus a lightweihgt should be able to use a slightly softer mast in a big sail in lightwinds and not fell to hard done by. not perfect but will work.

are you coming to vici point saturday arvo. about 3pm or so???
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
21 Mar 2006 11:06pm
Yer Gestalt prob right about a lighter sailer using a softer mast.
I suppose from my experience the sail would feel too soft but im 85kgs.

Vicky point Sat yer that sounds good if that wind holds up that long.
Had a blast late today at Manly.


junior freestyle
junior freestyle
QLD
546 posts
QLD, 546 posts
21 Mar 2006 11:28pm
geeze u are all goin to big i have 85 and a 5.9 that will easy get me going in 12 knots
AUS154 Chris
AUS154 Chris
QLD
217 posts
QLD, 217 posts
22 Mar 2006 11:29am
Hey Junior, you need a 9.8!!
ka43
ka43
NSW
3105 posts
NSW, 3105 posts
22 Mar 2006 2:16pm
Im 90 and I used my Falcon 111 and 8.5 Neutron last sat at Botany with Des. Had some good runs until boom decided it wanted to go somewhere else. At your weight Harrow you should be able to get away with a 7.0 or 7.5. Dont forget fin size makes a difference too.
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
22 Mar 2006 3:58pm
Harrow, given your current range you should look at something bigger than your current 105. I have ridden vando's scross and think if you were to get an scross 120 and 7.5 you should be planing in 8 knots. Be warned you would be topping out in 16knots but light wind gear is exactly that,you could possibly extend the range of the board a fair bit in a pinch with smaller fins. Given the extra volume you could pracitce tacks/helitacks and happily schlog along also. People should think a little more before suggesting dedicated boards such as isonic, falcon etc.
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
22 Mar 2006 5:56pm
quote:
Originally posted by mkseven

Harrow, given your current range you should look at something bigger than your current 105. I have ridden vando's scross and think if you were to get an scross 120 and 7.5 you should be planing in 8 knots. Be warned you would be topping out in 16knots but light wind gear is exactly that,you could possibly extend the range of the board a fair bit in a pinch with smaller fins. Given the extra volume you could pracitce tacks/helitacks and happily schlog along also. People should think a little more before suggesting dedicated boards such as isonic, falcon etc.

Aaaauuuuggghhhhhhh, I thought having a new board and two sails was a big deal. Then I went to two boards and three sails. Now I can't believe I'm considering heading to three boards, five sails, and two or three masts. And all within the space of a couple of months.

Still, with job, family, etc. there are only limited opportunities to get out, and it is frustrating if it doesn't coincide with good wind as the opportunity is just wasted. I can definitely see the value in being able to get out any time. Seems to be a lot of this 8-12 SE stuff at Sydney Airport.
crem
crem
WA
18 posts
WA, 18 posts
22 Mar 2006 3:17pm
Hi Harrow,

We are big fans of the Starboard 105 2003 with an 8.5 KA 2005 Formula sail and nothing over a 32cm fin around here. We had one of the crew take his up to 33.9 knots a couple of weeks ago at Sandy in a bit of wind but they excel in the light stuff as well. The sail is incredibly light and the board goes through lulls like nothing else and can be picked up pretty cheap. I had a guy trade in his Carve 133 recently for one and he hasn't looked back.

Check out http://www.cremaster.com.au/images/hypering.htm
grumplestiltskin
grumplestiltskin
WA
2331 posts
WA, 2331 posts
22 Mar 2006 3:51pm
what if you are fat bastard like me (100kg).

what size board for those 12-15 knot days????
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
22 Mar 2006 6:48pm
you'd be like me,

i use a 2005 KA 8.5m formula and a 95cm formula maxim board.
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
22 Mar 2006 5:31pm
quote:
Originally posted by ka43Dont forget fin size makes a difference too.



What difference does fin size make? Does a bigger fin make things easier in light winds? What if you're not spinning out, will going up a fin size make a difference? Does a bigger fin mean you can point upwind better when shlogging?

So much to learn...

Also planing isn't everything you know. I see many people out at the train sitting on their chairs when the wind is below 15 knots, there is a small core of people like me who go out regardless and practice freestyle moves (for me this means tacking and gybing but they do rig 360's and helitacks and other weird moves). I find going out on the water more rewarding than sitting on my tush but I guess I'm just not hardcore enough...
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
22 Mar 2006 8:50pm
crem,

Sounds promising. Either way I'll try the larger sail on my present board, with a larger fin if possible. Third board has to be last resort.
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
22 Mar 2006 8:02pm
Harrow- did you get the 78? if so you could consider just 2 boards say a scross 120 (yes i am pretty damn impressed by them)and the 78, given your weight you should be able to change to the small one pretty early. You could go huge with sails but my limit is 9m (going down to 8.5m max with my next set of sails). Above 8.5 sails become a different beast and imo arent really suited to boards under 80cm wide. Dont fall into the trap of going too many boards, you never get the most out of any of them. If you are a general freeride sailor 2 boards is plenty.

nebbian- no easy answers regarding fins, too many variables other than length ie chord width, foil width/aspect, fin area, rake, board width, footstrap position, sail size, sail draft and mast foot position. Basically the answer to your questions is a bigger fin generally provides more lift which assists you to get planing earlier and exploit the power from the rig. It will also assist you to point upwind better and can provide a slower stall speed. However it may make you slower and give you a good working out lifting the board or killing your legs, in particular your ankles (this is reduced alot with wider boards). My 52cm fin on the hypersonic probably only has an effective wind range of 6 knots.
crem
crem
WA
18 posts
WA, 18 posts
22 Mar 2006 6:32pm
Larger fins will certainly help you get on to the plane but are slower when you get there. Where we sail we have relatively flat water and so we rarely go above 32 even with 8.5s but if you have heaps of chop you will have to go up in size. While they won't get on to plane any earlier than the Carve, the Hypers are great in building apparent wind so once you are planing you are usually there until you gybe. Actually one of the tricks to light wind sailing is to be sure you gybe in the gusts.

The main thing is to learn how to get the board going in light wind. Be prepared to lose a little to gain a lot. Feet in the centre of the board foward of the footstraps while heading off the wind then coming back with little hops works for me.

It is interesting to see most of the guys who are topping the GPS speed sailing ladder are 35 plus. Often they learnt in the early days on plastic fins and US boxes that would break out if you put too much pressure on them. Tony Wynhoven who is topping the 2006 ladder uses a 22cm on his 6.6 sail. As a consequence they are skilled at getting small fins working so technique is pretty important. I am 94 kg and can still plane when all the kites call it a day and find I get more enjoyment on a Hyper under 15 knots than I do a kite.

Good luck.
vando
vando
QLD
3419 posts
QLD, 3419 posts
22 Mar 2006 9:21pm
quote:
It is interesting to see most of the guys who are topping the GPS speed sailing ladder are 35 plus


Ha thats my prob crem just have too wait a few more years.
so what's your excuse then.
ka43
ka43
NSW
3105 posts
NSW, 3105 posts
23 Mar 2006 10:33am
Hey Nebbian. I should of qualified my statement. I use a 44 cm fin in my falcon 111 on a 8.5 and 7.5 too. It gives you extra lift like MKseven said. It gives you something to push against so you can use the power of a bigger sail to unstick the board from the water. Once the wind gets to a certain strength a bigger fin will not make you faster as it just gives too much lift. I usually go down to a 40 or 38 on my 7.5 and 38 to 34 on a 6.6. We sail in varied water states
( chop, swell and waves) so unlike Crem you tend to use bigger fins.
Just more stuff to buy :-) Greeny will like that part!!
BTW, whats with this chair business at the Goldy??
Ive seen it mentioned quite a few times.
crem
crem
WA
18 posts
WA, 18 posts
24 Mar 2006 11:53pm
Hey vando,

It's because I'm not getting fat like the others as I get older :) and I refuse to wear a weight jacket althought am thinking camel pack might be okay.

If it is aging you are after just do a few trips with the tonster, it will get the grey hairs sprouting pretty damn quick.
Harrow
Harrow
NSW
4521 posts
NSW, 4521 posts
26 Mar 2006 9:05pm
quote:
Originally posted by crem

Hey vando,

It's because I'm not getting fat like the others as I get older :) and I refuse to wear a weight jacket althought am thinking camel pack might be okay.

If it is aging you are after just do a few trips with the tonster, it will get the grey hairs sprouting pretty damn quick.

Weight jacket ??? Is there such a thing
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12885 posts
WA, 12885 posts
26 Mar 2006 8:30pm
Sure is, but you have to fairly serious about winning to wear one.
So Harrow, how's the water in the board going????
Moffla
Moffla
NSW
25 posts
NSW, 25 posts
2 May 2006 3:21pm
So a 6.6 on a 32 fin should be fine?!?
84kg.. board is Screamer II 103l.
AUS154 Chris
AUS154 Chris
QLD
217 posts
QLD, 217 posts
2 May 2006 3:54pm
...or a 34.
nebbian
nebbian
WA
6277 posts
WA, 6277 posts
2 May 2006 2:12pm
Hi Moffla,

I'm 80kg and with a 31cm fin and a 5.7 on a mistral 104litre it takes a good 15 knots to get planing, but with a 37cm fin I can get planing in 13. Well maybe those numbers are a bit out but I know I can get planing in a couple less knots with the same gear apart from a bigger fin. A 6.6 sail would lower the knots needed somewhat, but I would really recommend going bigger than 32 to lower the planing threshold.

Specs between you and me are roughly the same, so I'd expect similar performance. One thing is that if you learn on a smaller fin when you move up you'll have an advantage, as you're used to trying really hard to get the damn board onto the plane
snides8
snides8
WA
1731 posts
WA, 1731 posts
2 May 2006 6:09pm
harrow- out today,7.6 sail 100ltr board (63cm wide)40cm fin -70kg, wind 12-16knots planing 95% t.o.w
Gestalt
Gestalt
QLD
14968 posts
QLD, 14968 posts
2 May 2006 8:49pm
quote:
Originally posted by Harrow

quote:
Originally posted by mkseven

Harrow, given your current range you should look at something bigger than your current 105. I have ridden vando's scross and think if you were to get an scross 120 and 7.5 you should be planing in 8 knots. Be warned you would be topping out in 16knots but light wind gear is exactly that,you could possibly extend the range of the board a fair bit in a pinch with smaller fins. Given the extra volume you could pracitce tacks/helitacks and happily schlog along also. People should think a little more before suggesting dedicated boards such as isonic, falcon etc.

Aaaauuuuggghhhhhhh, I thought having a new board and two sails was a big deal. Then I went to two boards and three sails. Now I can't believe I'm considering heading to three boards, five sails, and two or three masts. And all within the space of a couple of months.

Still, with job, family, etc. there are only limited opportunities to get out, and it is frustrating if it doesn't coincide with good wind as the opportunity is just wasted. I can definitely see the value in being able to get out any time. Seems to be a lot of this 8-12 SE stuff at Sydney Airport.



harrow, if you are looking for min gear with max time on the water don't be to quick to write off formula. i am in exactly the same boat.
i have an 8.5 KA Formula that i use with the 95cm maxim and 70cm fin
plus a 6.4 i use with a 95 lt fish wave board. so 2 masts and 2 booms, 2 sails and 2 boards. (i have a 5.7 as well but only use it if it gets over 22 knots)this means no mater what the wind strength i can be on the water.
went on monday with the family. was 10 knots and i was totally lit up on the formula. (i mean fully powered and cranking) so were the other 2 guys out. one on a starboard formula with an 8.5 and another (vando) on his scross 120lt with a 7.5, we were all blasting.

i had rigged fairly flat, but with a bagged out 8.5 i can get the formula planing in 8 knots and i weigh 98kg. formula boards are a blast to sail, upwind, downwind, across the wind and maximise time on the water. when the wind goes over 15knots hop on the small board.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply